Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To say no to elf on the shelf

156 replies

Illumicrateme · 01/12/2022 10:26

My DS is 5 and in Y1, this morning all the children were excited that their elves had visited them. I had previously told him that the elves were for children that miss behaved and the elves could report back to Santa. Now it looks like half his class have been miss behaving and I don't want him thinking he needs to be naughty tk get a elf🙈 I really don't want to begin elf on the shelf so I was hoping you lovely lot could help me come up with a better excuse before school pick up this afternoon 😬

OP posts:
shivbo2014 · 02/12/2022 07:27

I've done it a few times, not doing it this year. I just told my daughter that the elf goes to different children each year.

pepperminttaste · 02/12/2022 06:59

Well, I don't have the time or inclination for it at all but for the first time ever last night my youngest (8) asked if we could get one. In previous years she's just asked why we don't have one. We said a flat no and then OH jokingly said, 'Why don't you get a toy, get it to do stuff every single night and then tidy it all up the next day?' Oh she looked so disappointed. Anyway, when I went to bed she'd hidden her cuddly Mog behind our curtain rail for us.

I might compromise. Thinking maybe take her Olaf toy, leave a note saying 'Mum and Dad are elf grinches, I'm not here to spy, I'm only going to show up a few times because otherwise I'm a pain in the backside'.

Think her and her sister will see the funny side of that... Maybe!

MumToBe1980 · 02/12/2022 06:40

Do the kids actually believe the elf moves around? Or do parents tell their kids it's a toy that they move around? I feel like my 6 year old would see straight through this, which would probably start to make him question how real Santa is too.

Canuckduck · 02/12/2022 02:48

My kids asked for one when they were about 7 & 8 and I said no, it’s a toy and not something we’re doing. One of their classrooms had one.

I just didn’t / don’t have time in my day to think of fun / hilarious stunts. Some families I know are really creative with it. Good for them! It’s not for me. We’ve likewise never made a huge deal about Santa.

PickyEaters · 02/12/2022 00:55

@SleepingStandingUp thank you for the explanation. Well… people are always sayng they want kids to spend less time on their devices.

SleepingStandingUp · 02/12/2022 00:19

PickyEaters · 01/12/2022 19:00

I find it hard to believe that children of any school-going age would get so excited about a stuffed toy that they would talk about it at school, or even mention it to their friends.

What are they going to say?— "He was on top of the dishwasher this morning!". "Ooh, mine was behind the sofa!".

It's hardly gripping stuff.

I thought the elf was supposed to bring gifts hence the excitement.

Needless to say I don't do this and never have done.

This mornings walk to school with two friends aged 7.

A: tells B that the elves came this morning, explains about the note and tells their names. There's even a photo on Mom's phone.
B: tells A about his elf trying to steal Mom's coffee.
They both think this conversation is hysterical and riveting.
Tonight B sent A a photo because his elf's baby brothers showed up.
Tomorrow B will tell A all about the babies and what naughty things they did. A will tell B about whatever her elves got up to overnight.

I can only assume this conversational pattern is repeated in class. They talk about them as if they're real because even tho they kinda know he came fro ma shop, they believe in magic. And because 7 yo are weird.

Tonight B and I had Al Omg conversation about why the envelope had the same tape on as we did and B decided they'd travelled by themselves then taped themselves into an envelope, not sent by their Mom as previously assumed.

Trust me, parents wouldn't do it if kids rolled their eyes and ignored the damn thing.

PickyEaters · 01/12/2022 19:11

ladymarmiteee · 01/12/2022 19:04

I don't think you're the target audience to be honest...

furry muff

TheKeatingFive · 01/12/2022 19:06

I don't think you're the target audience to be honest

Quite 🤣

TheKeatingFive · 01/12/2022 19:06

What are they going to say?— "He was on top of the dishwasher this morning!". "Ooh, mine was behind the sofa!".

My 8 year old talks about the elf with his friends. Seems pretty exciting to them 🤷‍♀️

I thought the elf was supposed to bring gifts hence the excitement.

No. I mean you can do whatever you want with the elf, up to you, but this doesn't seem to be a common approach.

ladymarmiteee · 01/12/2022 19:04

PickyEaters · 01/12/2022 19:00

I find it hard to believe that children of any school-going age would get so excited about a stuffed toy that they would talk about it at school, or even mention it to their friends.

What are they going to say?— "He was on top of the dishwasher this morning!". "Ooh, mine was behind the sofa!".

It's hardly gripping stuff.

I thought the elf was supposed to bring gifts hence the excitement.

Needless to say I don't do this and never have done.

I don't think you're the target audience to be honest...

PickyEaters · 01/12/2022 19:00

I find it hard to believe that children of any school-going age would get so excited about a stuffed toy that they would talk about it at school, or even mention it to their friends.

What are they going to say?— "He was on top of the dishwasher this morning!". "Ooh, mine was behind the sofa!".

It's hardly gripping stuff.

I thought the elf was supposed to bring gifts hence the excitement.

Needless to say I don't do this and never have done.

Illbeready · 01/12/2022 18:54

At the point of*

Illbeready · 01/12/2022 18:54

I hated doing it in the past but I'm not at the point of it takes me 2 mins an evening to set something up and it makes my daughter happy.

QueenBeex · 01/12/2022 18:54

We don't do elf or xmas eve boxes. He won't be the only one

Appleandoranges · 01/12/2022 18:52

To be honest think elf on the shelf is much better than Santa. It's not materialistic (apart from initial outlay for elves). And it's just fun and very playful, and makes the children happy for £0. I get it's annoying having to move them everyday though and think of things to do with them. And more pressure on stressed parents. But if I could, would replace Santa with the elves.

Lovetotravel123 · 01/12/2022 17:40

Tell him you don’t do it in your house. Instead, do a little St Nicholas basket on 5 December. Just needs to contain chocolate, gingerbread, nuts and satsumas. Then it is a nice surprise and just done on one day. It’s a European tradition.

NippyWoowoo · 01/12/2022 17:38

You think the cave man got dressed up and sat the cave kids in his knee every shortest night or thereabouts and gave them a new bone to play with?

Grin
Sunshineandflipflops · 01/12/2022 17:32

*saying, not dying!

Sunshineandflipflops · 01/12/2022 17:32

We were quite late to the elf on a shelf game as my kids are now 15 and 16 so we only had a few years of it before they were too old (although they’d still be up for it now if I was…which I’m not!). I’m glad I never have to do it again but they did love it.

we all have our own things. I bet a lot of the people dying they’d never do EOAS do Xmas eve boxes and/or matching PJ’s and both would be a solid no from me so do whatever works for you and your family.

Arewenearly · 01/12/2022 17:21

@Suedomin perhaps they didn't 🤷‍♀️ maybe they will or won't this year or next. I was only letting OP know what happened here.

Ylvamoon · 01/12/2022 17:05

Soo glad I missed out on the Elf thing!

Suedomin · 01/12/2022 16:50

You're not unreasonable to say no, but just realise your son might feel really left out when the other kids in the class are talking about their elves.

My GC age range 10 to 4 have never had an elf on a shelf and have never felt sad or left out because of it. It Some of their friends have them but many don't.

They have other traditions they follow and have a lot of fun in my the follow up to Christmas. Just not with an elf!

Suedomin · 01/12/2022 16:30

I don't like the idea of elf on a shelf and find them a bit creepy.Neither do. I like the idea that only 'nice' or 'good' children get gifts. And the idea of an elf spying on them to report back to Santa is just weird. All children misbehave sometimes and they shouldn't be bribed into always being nice. Besides it's not true anyway no parent is going to withhold their child's gifts because they have done something they think they shouldn't.
Also what about families that really can't afford to buy their child lots of gifts are they supposed to think they haven't got what they wanted because they haven't been nice?
I am sure your child won't be the only one without one.

ladymarmiteee · 01/12/2022 16:20

NerrSnerr · 01/12/2022 12:09

Each to their own and I respect that every family has their own traditions. I just don't get all the hatred on here! Some very grinch like mothers on mumsnet

I agree with this, we don't do a special December 1st breakfast or a Christmas Eve box but that doesn't mean those who do are wrong or somehow inferior.

Just live and let live and do what's right for you and your family. You can do that without judging or looking down at others.

This.

Everyone is entitled to do their own thing. But I often find those who don't do it are the ones who are passive aggressive and snipey about those that do. Weird.

Murasakispillowbook · 01/12/2022 15:23

TheKeatingFive · 01/12/2022 15:07

What I hate is the whole contrived / invented tradition aspect.

Every tradition was 'invented' at some point. Your Christmas will be full of contrived, invented traditions like trees, crackers, turkey, etc.

OP just say you aren't doing it, all houses do Christmas differently. No need to more than this or being snide about other people's kids.

Yeah this. Do your own things. I'm sure some people would think our family's rituals odd.

It only irks me when it comes to already stressed parents (usually mums from what I see) feeling pressure to keep up with a growing list of new essential Christmas traditions (North Pole Breakfast, I'm looking at you!) And lots more involved halloween, Easter etc. It's a lot to find money & energy for. If you're not as confident or comfortable just doing what you want.