Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To say no to elf on the shelf

156 replies

Illumicrateme · 01/12/2022 10:26

My DS is 5 and in Y1, this morning all the children were excited that their elves had visited them. I had previously told him that the elves were for children that miss behaved and the elves could report back to Santa. Now it looks like half his class have been miss behaving and I don't want him thinking he needs to be naughty tk get a elf🙈 I really don't want to begin elf on the shelf so I was hoping you lovely lot could help me come up with a better excuse before school pick up this afternoon 😬

OP posts:
Snoopystick · 02/12/2022 14:40

We don’t do it and I temporarily unfollow all Facebook people who post all their bloody photos of it. Bah humbug!

LikeTearsInRain · 02/12/2022 13:20

YABU

in this modern day all children deserve elf on the shelf, Xmas eve box and all the good things. And they will all be comparing experiences at school, don’t want them to feel left out.

swirlypinky · 02/12/2022 12:52

What's more annoying than doing the elf thing?

Other people's bloody photos of the bloody things on social

Bore off zzzzzz

Tootsweets84 · 02/12/2022 11:16

I hate those creepy elves. We have Danish nisser. They're just sweet looking fabric elves. We leave out rice pudding for the a couple of times during December and they start appearing around the house and leave a small chocolate in the kids stockings every day (instead of those cardboard advent calendars). They don't play any tricks or make mess because they're nice elves. And to be honest my kids know it's all made up and just a bit of fun anyway

HairyToity · 02/12/2022 11:09

We relented and bought the elf. My kids love it. A highlight of Christmas. No regrets.

Comefromaway · 02/12/2022 11:05

Tell him that you have told Santa that you don't want an elf in your house spying on him because you buy the presents for Santa to deliver and you decide what your son gets, no-one else and as long as you know he has tried his best to be good then he will get his presents.

Thereisnolight · 02/12/2022 10:54

I’m not into crass commercialisation and plastic just for the sake of it (who is?) so I’m not going to go for “Christmas Eve box” instead of a movie and popcorn or “North Pole breakfast” instead of just breakfast.

But the elf, although a new tradition, is a good idea that children really really love. He lasts for years so is cheap and brings so much pleasure. Parents who say “I don’t have time”…whatcha doing with your time exactly luv? Are you a brain surgeon who works 6 out of every 7 days? My friend is, and they have an elf so get over yourselves with the no time excuse.

PeterRabbitHadACarrot · 02/12/2022 10:50

Are some parents actually expecting other parents not to tell their DC the elf isn't real incase they tell theirs?
Just tell your child you haven't bought and elf. If questioned why, just tell them you didn't want to do all the activities, the advent calender is enough.

pepperminttaste · 02/12/2022 10:44

ladymarmiteee · 02/12/2022 07:39

That's really sad.

Would it kill you to get one (they're about £2) and just move it around? You don't have to do all the big, messy, time consuming stunts.

😂 It's not sad.

TheKeatingFive · 02/12/2022 10:05

It’s a distasteful American tradition that normalizes bad behavior, commercialism, and continual surveillance.

Oh for gods sake 🙄

it's a small toy you move around the house. Do it/don't do it, but the outrage just silly.

No one I know does surveillance. It's actually one of the least commercial things about Christmas for us, after the initial outlay of 5 euro, 5 years ago, I've never spent a penny on it. Just a bit of harmless fun.

Ericaequites · 02/12/2022 09:43

It’s a distasteful American tradition that normalizes bad behavior, commercialism, and continual surveillance. Just say no.

neverbeenskiing · 02/12/2022 09:34

OP, I was adamant we weren't doing the sodding elf! I thought it was a nonsense and I was having none of it. Life is busy enough! DD had never mentioned it, so I thought I'd gotten away with it.
Then when she was in Year 1 she came home from school very quiet one day, I could tell something was up. Eventually told me that the Teacher had asked if anyone had an Elf arrive overnight and the only kids who didn't raise their hands were DD and a couple of kids who don't celebrate Christmas. They were then all sharing what their elves had gotten up to. Then the tears came, she didn't understand why santa hadn't sent an elf to visit her and did it mean we wouldn't be having Christmas? I felt terrible!! Really terrible. I didn't realise so many kids would have one, I had thought it would be about 50/50 split at the most.

I caved, obviously! The next day DD came home to find her Elf with a note explaining she'd gotten a bit lost on her way from the North Pole. She was overjoyed! She's 8 now and still loves the little fucker. Her younger Brother (4) has an Elf too and the pair of them are so excited to come downstairs and see what they've been up to even though we don't do anything elaborate with them. We don't link it to behaviour, or say the elves are "watching" them, it's just a nice thing.

Takes an extra 2-3 minutes in the evening at most. Worth it IMO.

Milkyway00 · 02/12/2022 09:32

We've never done it. Its pointless and a waste of time in my opinion. Each to their own!

ladymarmiteee · 02/12/2022 09:18

GETTINGLIKEMYMOTHER · 02/12/2022 08:50

Had this yesterday from dd with 3 young dcs 😂

This Hurrah For Gin sketch resurfaces every year and is just another 'I'm far too busy and important for the silly elf' message when in reality moving a stuffed elf takes all of 30 seconds.

teaandtoastwithmarmite · 02/12/2022 09:16

Also if we forget she will move it lol

teaandtoastwithmarmite · 02/12/2022 09:15

We do it. I managed to not do it until dd was 7 and said she wanted it. We got two though which actually makes it easier. It's pretty low effort though. For example. Last night one elf shut the other in daddy's guitar case and the legs were sticking out. She's 10 in feb so not sure how much longer we'll do it

GETTINGLIKEMYMOTHER · 02/12/2022 08:50

Had this yesterday from dd with 3 young dcs 😂

To say no to elf on the shelf
TheGoogleMum · 02/12/2022 08:48

Tell DC you don't want to invite fae creatures into the house, never trust the fae (perhaps there is an exception for the tooth fairy as its always a 1 night only visit)

TheKeatingFive · 02/12/2022 08:44

I admit I don't go in for the naughty stuff either. Our elf gets up to mischief, which usually involves hiding places or playing with the other toys.

TheKeatingFive · 02/12/2022 08:42

I don't get the apparent contradiction of the elf supposedly making sure the kids aren't being naughty in the run up to Christmas whilst demonstrating such misbehaviour themselves.

The elf riffs off two different long-standing Christmas narratives. The first being the 'lord of misrule' type stuff that they went in for several centuries ago. The rules of normal society are over turned, mischief making ensues. The second is the Santa naughty/nice list.

So yeah, there are contradictions in that. However I don't think many go in hard for the surveillance, so it's not really an issue. Christmas traditions are really known for their logic anyway - see the Santa myth.

NerrSnerr · 02/12/2022 08:17

DrinkReprehensibly · 02/12/2022 07:48

I don't have kids but I see several friends posting about the antics of their elves. The effort is insane.
I don't get the apparent contradiction of the elf supposedly making sure the kids aren't being naughty in the run up to Christmas whilst demonstrating such misbehaviour themselves. Are they not being a bad influence on the children? What does santa think about what the elves are doing? It seems confusing to me. Or is it just parents taking it further than the original concept was intended to?

If you read the thread many of us don't do the 'don't be naughty as the elves are watching you'. Ours just move around, aren't particularly naughty and I can't be arsed to clean stuff up so don't do messy things.

minisoksmakehardwork · 02/12/2022 07:53

We don't have it. Never have and dc just see it as a tradition others do that we don't, like we have ours and others don't.

That said, I did buy a teeny figurine on a spur of the moment this year (it was very cheap) to play with 'where's Wally' style. We are having fun hiding it in vague sight and seeing how long it takes to notice. The person who finds it, hides it somewhere different.

DrinkReprehensibly · 02/12/2022 07:48

I don't have kids but I see several friends posting about the antics of their elves. The effort is insane.
I don't get the apparent contradiction of the elf supposedly making sure the kids aren't being naughty in the run up to Christmas whilst demonstrating such misbehaviour themselves. Are they not being a bad influence on the children? What does santa think about what the elves are doing? It seems confusing to me. Or is it just parents taking it further than the original concept was intended to?

ladymarmiteee · 02/12/2022 07:39

pepperminttaste · 02/12/2022 06:59

Well, I don't have the time or inclination for it at all but for the first time ever last night my youngest (8) asked if we could get one. In previous years she's just asked why we don't have one. We said a flat no and then OH jokingly said, 'Why don't you get a toy, get it to do stuff every single night and then tidy it all up the next day?' Oh she looked so disappointed. Anyway, when I went to bed she'd hidden her cuddly Mog behind our curtain rail for us.

I might compromise. Thinking maybe take her Olaf toy, leave a note saying 'Mum and Dad are elf grinches, I'm not here to spy, I'm only going to show up a few times because otherwise I'm a pain in the backside'.

Think her and her sister will see the funny side of that... Maybe!

That's really sad.

Would it kill you to get one (they're about £2) and just move it around? You don't have to do all the big, messy, time consuming stunts.

Wishawisha · 02/12/2022 07:30

TheKeatingFive · 01/12/2022 15:07

What I hate is the whole contrived / invented tradition aspect.

Every tradition was 'invented' at some point. Your Christmas will be full of contrived, invented traditions like trees, crackers, turkey, etc.

OP just say you aren't doing it, all houses do Christmas differently. No need to more than this or being snide about other people's kids.

Ancient Celts decorating their houses with branches from evergreen trees and us now bringing in evergreen trees and decorating them with lights, like they’ve been doing in Germany for centuries, is not exactly the same as a box appearing on supermarket shelves out of the blue labelled “tradition” is it? (And as a PP mentioned, released by a marketing executive no less).

But people can obviously do what they want, no one is saying they can’t, but this thread is about someone who doesn’t want to do it and it’s fine surely if plenty of us (on a not liking / wanting to do Elf on the Shelf thread) also think it’s quite naff.

Swipe left for the next trending thread