Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

If you can’t make it work full time, go part time.

93 replies

Pineconederby · 01/12/2022 08:33

Teacher at DC’s school. Appears to have numerous childcare issues from what we’ve been told. Barely makes it through a week without being off for this or that, but tells the DC it’s because she needs to look after her little one.

AIBU to think that she should be supported to go part time, rather than trying to eke out a full time job, which she is very clearly not doing? Multiple complaints made by parents, school not particularly receptive. This is a new member of staff who started in September, supposedly full time, and has completed just two entire weeks in the classroom since then.

At the start, I was sympathetic. Now, not so much. It’s really started to affect DC’s attitude to school, they are left with the (not amazing) TA when the teacher isn’t in and seem to complete endless worksheets but not much else. At parents’ evening it was pretty clear she didn’t have a clue who DC was, or what their abilities were (made a glaringly obvious mistake and referenced a different child 😳). I know teachers tend to be sacred on here but really? Is this the standard that’s deemed acceptable these days?

OP posts:
Pineconederby · 01/12/2022 09:12

@Speedweed - thank you for understanding!

OP posts:
AngelicPickles · 01/12/2022 09:12

Again, not the teachers job that management aren't using adequate cover.
Possibly management's fault, certainly I have worked for schools who have baulked at using proper cover and instead used a ta, justifying it as a budget issue whilst paying senior leadership very well.
Likely because there is no budget for cover and people who could be doing cover have had enough at the appalling conditions of teaching and have quit for good so there's no pool to draw from.

This has been created by successive government decisions regarding education, not just the conservatives,but also labour putting in unnecessary hoops and impossible working conditions. It's been helped along by parents who treat teachers, who are educated people, as slaves not fit to human treatment. Add in that the same parents breed children whose absolute contempt for teachers make the one perk of the job deeply unappealing and it's no wonder we are where we are.

And the situation will get worse. Pay and conditions for teachers is going down not up and people are not training for it.

Oh and by the by, teachers are very rarely allowed any time off. I speak after years of threats and bullying to get me in no matter the cost. So if the teacher is off its extremely likely it's for a good reason.

And no, teachers shouldn't have to share their private information such as cancer, bereavement, serious illness with parents. They are human beings entitled to dignity.

HaudYerWheeshtYaWeeBellend · 01/12/2022 09:11

Only on MN will this be classed as teacher bashing.

it’s completely unacceptable that children’s education is suffering due to long term teacher absence no matter the circumstances.

Id personally be informing the governors in writing if this continued long term with no foreseeable plan in place.

Parents don’t need personal specifics however they do need communication on their children’s education and what plans have been out in place.

Pineconederby · 01/12/2022 09:11

@NoSquirrels - I imagine that’s part of the problem. They don’t have the budget to provide supply teachers so use TAs. But they’re not getting value for money from a (by reputation at least) experienced teacher who isn’t there half the time (for whatever reason).

OP posts:
healthadvice123 · 01/12/2022 09:11

@Pineconederby you call time depending on your work policy and the law and based on their circumstances , for example someone undergoing cancer treatment is protected by law
The school will not tell you the full reason the teacher is off as they can't
The school will know the issues and will either be planning to replace or if long term issue they will need to out alternative plans in place to cover

Speedweed · 01/12/2022 09:10

I'd speak to the head about it. Focus on your concerns about your child's attitude to school, rather than why the teacher is off.

Even if there is the most heartrending, tragic circumstances behind her absence, the head should put in place a consistent replacement provision, it shouldn't just be a shrug and oh well, sometimes life is difficult.

Pineconederby · 01/12/2022 09:09

@BonnesVacances - she goes part time and is able to actually make 2 or 3 days in the classroom. Another teacher does the other part of the week. The children know where they are, don’t get messed about, disappointed that yet again, Mrs X hasn’t shown up… If the teacher can’t cope with/facilitate a full time role, at what point should this be addressed?

OP posts:
NoSquirrels · 01/12/2022 09:07

Your issue is with the school arranging adequate teaching cover, not with the specific teacher or their issues.

The head was unprofessional to fob you off with the talking about this staff member’s childcare issues. They should have been talking to you on the basis of how they were providing adequate teaching cover.

If you think the TA cover is not acceptable, have THAT discussion.

healthadvice123 · 01/12/2022 09:07

@RambamThankyouMam but thats up to the school to decide not the parents
The school will have all the info , maybe her child has been hospitalised or something and the school need to be putting measures in for teachers absence
A parent doesn't decide what action is taken in the teacher

Pineconederby · 01/12/2022 09:07

I agree that the head/seniors should be managing this better. As @OKild09 says, when should that be? As a parent/service user/whatever - when is a line crossed and the situation simply not sustainable?

OP posts:
BonnesVacances · 01/12/2022 09:05

You're complaining about having a part time teacher but are saying she should go part time. I'm struggling to understand how your life will improve if she does what you're saying she should.Confused

Echo what PP are saying. If you think your DC's education is suffering, take it up with the head. But maybe try some compassion and understanding for others too.

OKild09 · 01/12/2022 09:03

Listen, OP has a right to question and be concerned about the quality of her child's education. I'd be surprised if a parent WASN'T concerned.

Now we don't know the teacher's issues and why she's been off work so much but at what point does it become too much?

I understand the education sector is on it's knees at the minute but surely if it continues then something has to be done?

Parker231 · 01/12/2022 09:03

Children get ill, childcare arrangements break down - it’s life. Let the school sort it out - they will be aware of the details.

Have you never been off work when your children were ill?

PorridgewithQuark · 01/12/2022 08:59

RambamThankyouMam · 01/12/2022 08:39

So we should just let people do whatever they like and not meet the clauses of their work contracts? What a bizarre attitude. She clearly isn't fit to be in the role, for whatever reason. Why should 30 kids' education suffer?

Parents aren't her employer though. It's the head teacher who has to assess whether or not she's unable to meet the clauses in her contract and how the school can both legally and empathetically address that. Obviously as service users parents can complain to the head and expect to be answered, though not with any confidential details.

It's hard to recruit teachers atm. so driving away a good teacher who is going through short term issues (such as a child of their own having recently started nursery and being ill a lot, as many are) would be a mistake.

DrinkFeckArseBrick · 01/12/2022 08:57

How would going part time actually help though?

If she works money- wed and her nursery aged child is ill on a tuesday and gets sent home, what is she supposed to do? She can easily swap her hours at work unless it's a job share with an extremely flexible other person with no childcare issues. She can't get the child to stay at nursery but keep them off Thursday friday instead. The only feasible alternative is for her to give up work which is pretty awful.

Most teachers I know get their partners to look after kids when they are ill but maybe she doesn't have that option. The school could be managing it better

Managinggenzoclock · 01/12/2022 08:57

obly the headteacher really knows the circumstances. What if the little one has cancer or is undergoing tests? It might be that there is no one else and they need the money. It’s rubbish for your child (and the class) but teachers are human too.
When I was a deputy head in charge of these things we had a situation with a teacher and a sick child. In the end I timetabled her for cover (which did impact PPA for other teachers if I couldn’t cover the cover) but at least meant the children had regular teaching, However that was ten years ago. Schools aren’t funded well enough for that anymore. The school are between a rock and a hard place, as (probably) is the teacher, as is your child. Ultimately this comes down to government funding.
Public services employ people not robots, so there needs to be sufficient slack in the system to cover sickness well. There just isn’t.
Protest, write to your MP and for Fs sake don’t vote Tory.

MaggieFS · 01/12/2022 08:57

FWIW: I don't think it's being well managed as I've already posted.

But I don't see this as a teacher bashing thread. However the OP's insinuation that the answer is to go PT is also rude and probably not the correct solution to whatever the problem is.

Anger should be directed at the head, crap as that sounds, it's their job to manage this sort of thing effectively.

Tinkerbyebye · 01/12/2022 08:55

carefulcalculator · 01/12/2022 08:41

Oh yet more teacher bashing Biscuit

Teachers don't easily get time off, so potentially it is something serious.

Rubbish. She will just phone up, say she can’t come in because of xxx and leave it to the school to sort. It’s not like the HT will drive to her home and collect here

op you have to hope that the school are sorting this, it is bad, whatever her circumstances are, to have only done two full weeks, however I also know it’s fair on impossible to discipline a teacher on absence unless you have a very strong HT

take the matter to the Governors

AngelicPickles · 01/12/2022 08:55

I got sick of demanding parents.

Parents up in arms when someone had to cover my class for two days when there was a chicken pox outbreak and I was in the first trimester.

Parents complaining when I covered the class of colleagues who had cancer, sepsis, one whose lungs were collapsing. Parents made aware of this and still complain.

I didn't go part time, we don't get paid enough to deal with this rubbish. I quit. Amazing, best decision I ever made. Never going back.

Three Rs and other teaching agencies beg me to do supply on a fairly regular basis. Perhaps op should train as a teacher and fill the void?

figmaofmyimagination · 01/12/2022 08:53

The Headteacher needs to make a better plan. What that is, behind the scenes, isn’t your business, but ultimately they are responsible for your children’s education.

Scarywaitingtime · 01/12/2022 08:52

I had a mega flakey form tutor in year 7. She had a breakdown one day in the classroom . Turns out her ex husband ( from an Arab country ) had kidnapped her two young kids and she was fighting to try and get them back. It was incredibly sad and we used to sit with her at lunch breaks and she’d read The hobbit to us and bring us home baked food . We almost became her substitute kids . It’s just made my cry a little thinking of her , she always looked thin and fragile and had dark rings round here eyes. I wonder if she ever saw them again or got them back .

MaggieFS · 01/12/2022 08:52

Pineconederby · 01/12/2022 08:45

Tried the head. They also referenced her having children and said that was why she was off. Clearly, if it’s for a sick child, I would be sympathetic on a personal level.

BUT - for my DC, and their classmates, how long are they expected to put up with a part time teacher, an inferior quality education? Shouldn’t the teacher, or the teacher and head, come up with a plan that is manageable and means the DC’s education doesn’t suffer?

I think it's a fair ask. Ignore the cause and reasons why which are non of your business, but ask the head that, given there will apparently be frequent absences, what is being done to manage them better and ensure the classes' education isn't compromised given it's already affecting attitudes.

If you don't get a decent answer, escalate to the governors.

It sounds shit all round but doesn't sound like it is being well managed.

carefulcalculator · 01/12/2022 08:51

Pineconederby · 01/12/2022 08:47

@carefulcalculator - not teacher bashing. Could be any industry really. If you have a staff member who is repeatedly off for two/three days a week, but meant to be full time, at what time do you call time on someone being paid full time money for a part time job, family circumstances or not?

I am starting to think you don't have a job. The questions you ask here are ridiculous.

It is November. This issue started in September. That is only two months ago.

In every workplace I have been in, a valuable member of staff would not be dismissed because some mardy customers (parents in this case) wanted them to be.

This is an anti-teacher thread - you clearly want teachers to have fewer employment rights. That is the only way to get what you want, which is for this teacher to be dismissed after only two months of what could be a serious family situation.

Biscuit
funtycucker · 01/12/2022 08:51

I love how in almost every other thread people complain that employers aren't family friendly and they are penalised if they have childcare issues so demand that companies be more flexible towards working mums, but as soon as a teacher is having the same issues it's tough shit and they are incapable of doing their job. Talk about double standards.

SnarkyBag · 01/12/2022 08:50

Who knows why she’s really off but to be honest I visit schools as part of my job and frankly they’re on their knees. It’s not a sustainable system or way of working so parents should brace themselves for more of what your experiencing IMO.

Education is going the same way the NHS and frankly rather than working excessively to paper over the cracks I think it’s time for teachers (and TA’s) to just stop going over and above and burning themselves out.

Swipe left for the next trending thread