Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

If you can’t make it work full time, go part time.

93 replies

Pineconederby · 01/12/2022 08:33

Teacher at DC’s school. Appears to have numerous childcare issues from what we’ve been told. Barely makes it through a week without being off for this or that, but tells the DC it’s because she needs to look after her little one.

AIBU to think that she should be supported to go part time, rather than trying to eke out a full time job, which she is very clearly not doing? Multiple complaints made by parents, school not particularly receptive. This is a new member of staff who started in September, supposedly full time, and has completed just two entire weeks in the classroom since then.

At the start, I was sympathetic. Now, not so much. It’s really started to affect DC’s attitude to school, they are left with the (not amazing) TA when the teacher isn’t in and seem to complete endless worksheets but not much else. At parents’ evening it was pretty clear she didn’t have a clue who DC was, or what their abilities were (made a glaringly obvious mistake and referenced a different child 😳). I know teachers tend to be sacred on here but really? Is this the standard that’s deemed acceptable these days?

OP posts:
AngelicPickles · 01/12/2022 10:12

Also, how do you know the TA is unqualified? At least half the TAs I've worked with have QTS.

Littlepaws18 · 01/12/2022 10:09

Rather than the teacher I would focus on the school system. So if a teacher is off a unqualified TA steps in? And this happens on a regular occurrence? They should have better measures in place to ensure the school is fully staffed. What is there cover policy? Also standard of work- endless worksheets on a regular occurrence isn't good practice- what is their cover work policy- surely it's the teacher's responsibility to set appropriately challenging work. (I am a teacher, I have to set work which mirrors what I would have taught to the same high quality)

I would pose these questions to the head.

The reason and fact she is off shouldn't be the focus- it's how they manage the absence that's the issue.

ChicCroissant · 01/12/2022 10:05

Pineconederby · 01/12/2022 08:47

@carefulcalculator - not teacher bashing. Could be any industry really. If you have a staff member who is repeatedly off for two/three days a week, but meant to be full time, at what time do you call time on someone being paid full time money for a part time job, family circumstances or not?

What makes you so sure she is being paid when she's off?

Goldenbear · 01/12/2022 10:03

Yes, where i work i was surprised that the cover teachers are not degree educated, we don't have TAs covering lessons though.

RaRaRaspoutine · 01/12/2022 10:02

The issue is with the school and lack of decent cover, NOT with the teacher who is probably dealing with a lot in their personal life. YABU. I had a flakey A-level English tutor who turned out to be suffering multiple complications from a miscarriage. Teachers are human beings.

maddening · 01/12/2022 10:01

think your argument is with the school- the teacher's issues are between her and her employer.

But your dc should receive proper education and the school are failing in that respect, how they address that with their staff is up to them.

Goldenbear · 01/12/2022 10:00

It is unfortunate but realistically there is no way they will address this with teacher shortages as they are.

AngelicPickles · 01/12/2022 09:55

123woop · 01/12/2022 09:50

This is very odd - I'm not sure why the school are seemingly accepting it. I had a teacher at school who was off frequently during my GCSEs as she had very severe PND. Whilst it's a private thing obviously, she explained it to parents and put concrete plans in place for when she wasn't able to be in with lesson plans planned a term in advance.

In the end she dropped to part time and we got a new teacher, but she handled in a very positive and professional way, as did the school.

How horribly invasive. Nowadays the school would sign her off with sickness/disability allowance as stipulated by discrimination law and certainly wouldn't be inviting prying pupils and parents to comment.

Your solution still doesn't change the fact there is NO SUPPLY for very good reason.

noblegiraffe · 01/12/2022 09:54

This is very odd - I'm not sure why the school are seemingly accepting it.

Try this thread www.mumsnet.com/talk/_chat/4685680-staffing-crisis-in-schools-teachersschool-staff-whats-your-school-like?

AlwaysLatte · 01/12/2022 09:53

Maybe it's another private matter that's keeping her off but they're using that as a public reason. Or maybe her nursery closed down or something? It seems unlikely that she would have started the job knowing she didn't have childcare covered.

123woop · 01/12/2022 09:50

This is very odd - I'm not sure why the school are seemingly accepting it. I had a teacher at school who was off frequently during my GCSEs as she had very severe PND. Whilst it's a private thing obviously, she explained it to parents and put concrete plans in place for when she wasn't able to be in with lesson plans planned a term in advance.

In the end she dropped to part time and we got a new teacher, but she handled in a very positive and professional way, as did the school.

AntlerRose · 01/12/2022 09:48

Pineconederby · 01/12/2022 09:11

@NoSquirrels - I imagine that’s part of the problem. They don’t have the budget to provide supply teachers so use TAs. But they’re not getting value for money from a (by reputation at least) experienced teacher who isn’t there half the time (for whatever reason).

The thing is the class teacher remains responsible for planning the learning and for pupil progress and attaintment, even if she doesnt come in. Supply is great but they do only deliver what the teacher has prepared generally if its ad hoc random supply, the same way as a TA.

So you cant really judge she is poor value if she has planned the learning in her absence.

This is a situation where tge HT coukd be rubbish at managing staff and school, but complaining wont change that

The ht could be averaged which is most likely, and she is doing everything by the book for the teacher and is happy the
TA covering a class is good enough compared to non existent expensive supply.

The Ht could be above average and not only is she supporting ateacher through a tricky patch, knowing it will end, she has personslly seen the planning, asked a parrallel class teacher to check in on the TA regularly and is closely monitoring progress and is confident it is the same as the parrellel class or previous year.

All scenarios look the same to a parent.

Managinggenzoclock · 01/12/2022 09:48

healthadvice123 · 01/12/2022 09:17

You obviously don't work or have no clue as how would part time work , if she works mon- weds and her child is ill on a mon and tues she still won't be in ?
You need to speak to the head and say your not happy with the TA cover etc , although ta cover happens a lot in schools

TA cover would have been extraordinarily rare 15 years ago when I qualified. It’s now common place and not just HLTAs who in theory (at least initially had training and weren’t supposed to do planning). In the school I work in (not for) they have a 20 year old doing all their PPA cover and ECT cover. They don’t even have A levels or any TA qualifications (yes I do know that for a fact because he told me). It’s ridiculous.
It’s budget.

noblegiraffe · 01/12/2022 09:45

No, this isn't a desirable or even acceptable education for your DC and you are right to be disappointed and concerned.

Please email your MP and let them know the situation, and how the absent teacher isn't being covered by a teacher but a TA, and they are doing worksheets.

In a normal education system, an absent teacher would be covered by a supply teacher who could follow the planning for the class (or do their own planning).

We are not in a normal education system, we are in a crisis situation. Parents need to complain to the government that it is unacceptable. Schools don't have the resources to fix this.

Rocksludge · 01/12/2022 09:39

God. Who would be a teacher?

jumperoozles · 01/12/2022 09:35

It’s none of your business whether she is full time or part time. You have no idea what’s going on in her personal life - why should she have to cut her pay long term when it may be a shorter term issue, you just don’t know do you.
what is your business is your child’s education. This can be provided by other people on her days away and not just her. Good cover should be provided - if you’re not happy with that then speak to the school about that side but leave the poor woman alone.

LadyWithLapdog · 01/12/2022 09:33

The issue is how the HT is managing this situation. I wouldn’t be happy either.

However, there is no money and no slack in the system. Not in education, in health, in any public or private, for that matter, service. So we’ll be putting up with shitter and shitter service. It’s a Tory thing. No doubt some daily wail saddos will get a boner out of this.

Luckycatt · 01/12/2022 09:33

Why should 30 kids' education suffer?

They shouldn't. But that's not the teacher's responsibility. It's the school's management that should ensure continuation of teaching if a staff member js absent. Teacher's are human and allowed to take time off work for various reasons. There's only so much emergency childcare they're allowed to take, so I imagine this would be for a very seriously ill child or bereavement as PPs have said.

Teadrinkingmumofone · 01/12/2022 09:26

Teadrinkingmumofone · 01/12/2022 09:24

@carefulcalculator you 'call time' as you put it, as per your company/industry/employment policies. I've had a month off work followed by a month reduced hours, followed by a month of increased WFH. It is what it is because of extenuating circumstances. As a PP said I wonder if you actually have any experience of how such things work.

Oops meant to tag @Pineconederby sorry @carefulcalculator !

JennyForeigner · 01/12/2022 09:25

I agree with everything in your post @AngelicPickles, but would also say that the no term absence policies have become unsustainable. They were only backed up by the threat of no progression or bad references.

Teachers have been pushed too far - so many have just stopped believing that they have a long term future in the classroom or even that their schools have much of a financial future, and so why wouldn't they stay home with illness? And that's leaving aside all of the pressures around childcare and other issues escalating so quickly.

The bonds have been broken, and it's hard to see how schools recover.

Teadrinkingmumofone · 01/12/2022 09:24

@carefulcalculator you 'call time' as you put it, as per your company/industry/employment policies. I've had a month off work followed by a month reduced hours, followed by a month of increased WFH. It is what it is because of extenuating circumstances. As a PP said I wonder if you actually have any experience of how such things work.

sqirrelfriends · 01/12/2022 09:23

This. It’s basically impossible.

healthadvice123 · 01/12/2022 09:17

You obviously don't work or have no clue as how would part time work , if she works mon- weds and her child is ill on a mon and tues she still won't be in ?
You need to speak to the head and say your not happy with the TA cover etc , although ta cover happens a lot in schools

Whatifiwereareindeer · 01/12/2022 09:17

Pineconederby · 01/12/2022 09:07

I agree that the head/seniors should be managing this better. As @OKild09 says, when should that be? As a parent/service user/whatever - when is a line crossed and the situation simply not sustainable?

Most children will have a shit year somewhere in their education- a teacher off long term sick, a teacher they can’t gel with, a teacher who breaks their leg on Sept 5th and comes back sometime in February having been covered by a dozen random adults over that time (yes, that was my DC)….. it’s awful but they just have to cope. Expecting an entirely smooth and trouble free education is just not realistic in the current climate. It’s been a couple of months.

The school will be doing what they can, but finding appropriate cover is hard both in terms of cost and a lack of supply teachers. Talk to the head, explain how your child is feeling/finding things, but don’t expect miracles. Do as much as you can at home yourself and encourage your child to be resilient.

You decide when the line is crossed/it’s not sustainable- but that choice is expressed by making a formal complaint via the head (not the governors, this isn’t a governor issue) or moving school. You have absolutely no power at all over the HT decisions around staff and how they are managed, or over how a class is covered.

NoSquirrels · 01/12/2022 09:14

Pineconederby · 01/12/2022 09:11

@NoSquirrels - I imagine that’s part of the problem. They don’t have the budget to provide supply teachers so use TAs. But they’re not getting value for money from a (by reputation at least) experienced teacher who isn’t there half the time (for whatever reason).

That may be true, but that is the only basis on which you can discuss this issue: the quality of education your child is receiving and (as a PP says) how the instability is affecting their attitude to learning.

If you start making suggestions about the teacher going part time or any other operational matter you are interfering and will get treated that way.

Frame your complaint in a way that will produce a better outcome.