Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to be shocked at universal credit amount?

513 replies

oddsocksmatchifsamethickness · 01/12/2022 07:26

I've just become a single mum of one, husband gone. So obviously I want to bring my earnings up. I'm self-employed and will be doing so. But I put in a calculation for UC to see if I could get help while I sought new contracts. I'm self-employed. I earned 1K this month and did the calculation and it says I will get another 650 a month from UC.

Can that be right? It seems a lot, it would take my income up to a wage of 28K/year, but I only work 20 hours a week.

Is this what people get?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
8
LakieLady · 01/12/2022 16:55

Screwcorona · 01/12/2022 12:00

It is that much...it's not very much to live on.

My bills are just over £1650 so I'd be driving nowhere and eating nothing 🙃 I suppose its based on average costs for low income families

I agree. I'm over pension age now, but if I wasn't and was made redundant or became too ill to work, I'd get £335 a month UC. I own my house, so no housing costs, and no kids.

That £335 barely covers my basic bills (energy, internet, tv licence, phone, insurance, water and the reduced rate of council tax - I'd have to pay 20% of the total, after the 25% discount for being a sole occupier). It would leave me about £120 a month to feed and clothe myself, and running a car would be out of the question. I wouldn't be able to afford to have the boiler serviced or anything else fixed or replaced.

I don't think the child element of £244 reflects the full cost of having a child, and unless the youngest was born before April 2017, claimants on benefits only get the child element for 2 kids (unless there's a multiple birth).

The biggest chunk of every UC claim I come across is the housing costs. Even council rents here are over £500 a month, private more than double that.

If there were enough council houses for everyone to have one, the "benefit bill" would go down by a significant amount, without people who need benefits to survive being any worse off.

WishingWell5 · 01/12/2022 16:53

@Closuretime I think people should claim for whatever they are entitled to. But in some cases, people are struggling whilst working. And I don't think that's right. Or they are missing out on help because they want to work more hours which takes them over some arbitrary cut off point... So then (understandably!) don't work those extra hours.

bringincrazyback · 01/12/2022 16:39

Pineconederby · 01/12/2022 08:27

I’ve never understood why when people split up, the state suddenly becomes responsible for subsidizing their lifestyle choices.

Because shit happens, and children shouldn't have to starve when it does.

LakieLady · 01/12/2022 16:15

PurpleyPineappley · 01/12/2022 11:41

Changed username so it's not outing, but UC seems to be astonishingly high in some cases - my single friend with a disabled child (the child has no expensive extra needs, they have a learning disability & get PIP because of it) is now receiving the equivalent the take home pay of a wage of £55k a year with her UC income plus their low paid part time work income. And yes, that figure is accurate before all the BUT HOW DO YOU KNOWWWWWW people jump on. I was specifically told the monthly payment amount.

My friend gets fucking shedloads in benefits. She's on ESA and in the support group because she has severe PTSD and other MH issues, her mid-teens son gets DLA because he has a raft of MH issues, so she gets the carer's premium, child tax credit + the disabled child element and she gets full housing benefit for her council flat.

But she'd far rather be well and working in the career she trained for, and have a child who's happy and sociable, and not to have been married to the cunt that's the cause of most of their problems.

She deserves (and needs) every damn penny she gets imo.

ironingboredrefusal · 01/12/2022 16:01

Pineconederby · 01/12/2022 08:27

I’ve never understood why when people split up, the state suddenly becomes responsible for subsidizing their lifestyle choices.

Because it's easier for the patriarchy to give token amounts of money to single mothers than make fathers pay a realistic amount for their children or to make them look after them 50% of the time.

LakieLady · 01/12/2022 15:57

Getoff · 01/12/2022 09:31

I've been looking at the "minimum income floor" for self-employed getting universal credit, and it looks like OP will be assumed to be getting £1441 a month froms self-employment, if she's 23 or older.

Maybe she's exempt for the first 12 months, but it doesn't look like it's a long-term option to get £1000 topped up to £1650?

The implementation of the "mif" was delayed for quite a while, but I can't recall if they've announced a date for its reinstatement yet.

(I should fucking remember, I deliver a training course on UC and self-employment, I'd better re-train myself before the next course!)

LakieLady · 01/12/2022 15:51

Icecreamandapplepie · 01/12/2022 09:07

I'm very grateful uc is there for those who need it. I don't think it's an obscene amount at all.

Is more obscene wages aren't higher...

Absolutely.

And it's obscene that for people renting, rents are exorbitant.

A single person renting a one-bedroomed flat here is now affected by the benefit cap. They get £257 pw, but the average rent for a one-bed place is £223 pw.

LakieLady · 01/12/2022 15:41

TortugaRumCakeQueen · 01/12/2022 08:04

You're obviously living somewhere very expensive! You can rent a flat (not studio) here for under £600.

An awful lot of people live in London and the SE, where rents and house prices are most expensive. I think it's over 18m now, so over 25% of the population.

I did a benefit calculation for a friend of a friend the other day. Her DH has just fucked off and left her with 3 kids, and she was frantic about how she was going to pay her rent on just her £40k salary.

She's entitled to just under £800 a month in UC, because rents here are so high. UC allow just under £1,200 a month for a 3-bed property in this area, but her actual rent is £1,600, so there's still a big gap between what they'll pay and how much rent costs here.

People moan about how much claimants get in benefits, but they don't realise that often a huge chunk of that goes straight to landlords.

Babyroobs · 01/12/2022 15:41

Henuinequest · 01/12/2022 10:49

'I’ve never understood why when people split up, the state suddenly becomes responsible for subsidizing their lifestyle choices.'

The state helps parents with kids so the children have a better chance at a successful life. Growing up in poverty limits all sorts of choices and experiences for children. As one of the richest nations on earth I'm not sure we should be begrudging our children food, shelter, healthcare and education.

They wouldn't be at risk of growing up in poverty if the non resident parent was forced to support them would they ? The fact is that all too often they get away with contributing very little and the state picks up the costs of that.

LakieLady · 01/12/2022 15:24

Suzi888 · 01/12/2022 07:32

Well it pays to work part time, but not full time. Unless your a high earner.
A work colleague has “split” with her partner and they both remain in the same house. She now gets uc.
He is a high earner.
Of course, they haven’t split up at all but “tough times” etc.

Your colleague is committing benefit fraud, @Suzi888. I work in welfare rights, and it is incredibly hard to convince DWP that you are separated from a partner when you are both living in the same property.

It's people like her that get genuine claimants a bad name and leads them to be treated like scroungers.

Closuretime · 01/12/2022 15:05

@WishingWell5 but if you have children you may have to claim UC yourself and then you can join OP too and "live the dream".

Seriously there's a bigger picture. Some people are listing figures but there's a £300 pound difference it's a lot of money each month. It's ridiculous that people are envying a rough estimate that OP has put.

WishingWell5 · 01/12/2022 14:42

@sleepingdragon it's not far off including student loan repayment and pension payments.

Livpool · 01/12/2022 14:35

sleepingdragon · 01/12/2022 07:30

How does £1650 a month add up to £28k a year??

I hate these goady threads

Exactly!

The faux naïveté

Wellward · 01/12/2022 14:33

If you think that is ' it pays not to work' you are living in a parallel universe and reading too much Daily Mail.

This. UC is fairly generous IF you are a working parent. This is to encourage parents to work and to ensure children can be fed, clothed and housed.

If your youngest child is over 3 and you don't work, UC is pitiful. You have to look for work and you will be sanctioned if you don't.

If you have no children and don't work, UC is frighteningly low. You are expected to look for work and will be sanctioned if you don't.

And children grow up fast. Once they leave full-time education, UC and child benefit stop. Then you're left to fend for yourself.

Of course, if you're disabled, you are eligible for more in benefits - as you absolutely should be. Anybody begrudging benefits to disabled adults or children is morally bankrupt.

vivainsomnia · 01/12/2022 14:31

I'll take every penny gladly, I've worked all my life and like the work I do but money for doing nothing is welcome. I paid in, and none of you truly care about us taking "your taxes" or you would be shouting from the rooftops about what MPs do
And that's fine but will you have the same cavalier attitude when your children have left home and you are no longer entitled to anything and you have to work your ass off to earn just enough to survive and then having to live on the state pension only. Maybe then you might regret your lack of investment and moan how little you have to live on. What you do now doesn't only gave an impact on your present situation but your future too.

palygold · 01/12/2022 14:27

So it was your post, Rincewind...

It's already been pointed out to you why it was inappropriate. More than once I believe.

RincewindsHat · 01/12/2022 14:24

palygold · 01/12/2022 14:20

I expected nothing less. Congrats on outing yourself as an idiot who's purely out to make nasty untrue comments about others for no good reason other than trying to make yourself feel better because you're having a bad day or bad life or whatever."

Calling out the ableist post you name changed to make?
She wasn't the only person to challenge your post @PurpleyPineappley

How was anything I said ableist? Give me an example. I can't see one.

If you're referring to the fact I clearly stated the child was disabled, that's mentioned because it's relevant to the actual topic. Or maybe it's because I said the child doesn't have expensive additional needs - again, relevant because there are disabled children who have extensive and extremely expensive medical needs or otherwise, which is not the case here. Again, in no way ableist - simply relevant.

In case you missed it, the people 'challenging' my post were the ones saying the amount quoted was not possible, and others came along to demonstrate that it is very possible. Again, not ableist. Simply stating facts. I made no judgement calls on any of it, beyond expressing both my friend and I were surprised at how much UC she's now getting. Does that make the mother of the disabled child ableist too?

palygold · 01/12/2022 14:20

I expected nothing less. Congrats on outing yourself as an idiot who's purely out to make nasty untrue comments about others for no good reason other than trying to make yourself feel better because you're having a bad day or bad life or whatever."

Calling out the ableist post you name changed to make?
She wasn't the only person to challenge your post @PurpleyPineappley

ClaudineClare · 01/12/2022 14:17

PurpleyPineappley · 01/12/2022 14:15

I expected nothing less. Congrats on outing yourself as an idiot who's purely out to make nasty untrue comments about others for no good reason other than trying to make yourself feel better because you're having a bad day or bad life or whatever.

OK. Have a nice day yourself.

PurpleyPineappley · 01/12/2022 14:15

ClaudineClare · 01/12/2022 14:12

come back and apologise

Shan't.

I stand by what I said 💯 per cent.

I expected nothing less. Congrats on outing yourself as an idiot who's purely out to make nasty untrue comments about others for no good reason other than trying to make yourself feel better because you're having a bad day or bad life or whatever.

Closuretime · 01/12/2022 14:14

TheyreOnlyNoodlesMichael · 01/12/2022 14:05

Which parts? Because I live in the North so tell me where you can get a private 2 bed "much cheaper" please

My 2-bedroom lovely house in "the north" is £500 pcm. Private rent.

Can I ask where in the North you rent privately for a 2 bed private house? How long have you been renting it for? I'm asking this because private rents have definitely shot up in the West Yorkshire area.... since the pandemic.

I'm lucky and live in social housing but I have helped a friend house search and we don't live in well off areas. There's a lot of properties in poor condition and the private rents are definitely above £500 per month for a 2 bed. Your lucking more £700 per month and more.

CellophaneFlower · 01/12/2022 14:13

oddsocksmatchifsamethickness · 01/12/2022 12:58

This is exactly why I asked. I put this into a benefits calculator.

It told me I would receive 660 a month based on 400 rent and an income of 1K

I put in an income of 800 a month and it went down a bit. Those figures might be off.

My CT is 135/month
Rent 400/month

Income 800-1000/month

No childcare costs. I think the above includes child benefit also, £21/week.

I want to know what I will get so I can budget for the months ahead, my appointment is not until next week you see so that's why I am playing with benefits calculators. They did just give me £200 though as an advance on my first payment.

If you can indicate to me how much I will get that would be really helpful, thank you.

OP, if I'm understanding the minimum floor thing correctly, surely you just put that into the calculator as your earnings? I think a PP said it will be £1131 for you.

Remember to factor in those months where you say you may earn 800 though, as there wouldn't be any top up to cover this.

ClaudineClare · 01/12/2022 14:12

PurpleyPineappley · 01/12/2022 14:05

I didn't do either of those things. Jump down off your high horse, go look up what those terms you're throwing around actually mean, swallow your wounded pride and false sense of virtuosity at calling someone out on something you think they did (but didn't do) and come back and apologise.

Bet you won't do any of that though.

come back and apologise

Shan't.

I stand by what I said 💯 per cent.

Danikm151 · 01/12/2022 14:09

bloodyeverlastinghell · 01/12/2022 13:41

They're contributing more than if they didnt work and cost the state 50% more. Also childcare costs dont last forever and the amount claimed will be reduced possibly to less than 4k?

@bloodyeverlastinghell thank you.

some people really don’t understand. I said I was contributing not replacing like for like. Once childcare reduces(April hopefully) i’ll be getting around £200 per month UC so definitely paying more in than I get out.

StarManDan · 01/12/2022 14:08

ShimmeringShirts · 01/12/2022 13:57

Unless I’m spectacularly stupid, £1650x12=£19800??

But a £19,800 salary wouldn't be £1650 a month take home. The OP said equivalent salary....but also student loan coming out etc.