Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To effectively sue the nhs :/

184 replies

HarriwithanI · 01/12/2022 01:52

This is mega outing with my name and condition, If you know me please respect my privacy.
I work for the nhs but also been neglected massively.

after 10 days in the hospital I work in I lost all feeling from my hips down (couldn’t feel when I needed to wee or walk) was told it was my mental health and functional. Blue lighted to a specialist hospital turns out ecuda equida and basically I’m extremely lucky not to be paralysed.

WWYD? Feel so let down and when at a low emotionally and physically time everything was put down to weight and mental health when it was something that could’ve been/is seriously life changing. I don’t want it happen to anyone else

OP posts:
Guitarbar · 01/12/2022 08:14

HarriwithanI · 01/12/2022 08:11

Sorry i have named this wrong it should be complain NOT sue.
sorry I’m not replying individually.
just wanted to reply to some, yes was left 10 days no examination, in bed unable to move with a catheter being told I was big and needed to poo.

A million percent yes complain- as you say there should be lessons learnt from this (optimistic I know).

HarriwithanI · 01/12/2022 08:11

Sorry i have named this wrong it should be complain NOT sue.
sorry I’m not replying individually.
just wanted to reply to some, yes was left 10 days no examination, in bed unable to move with a catheter being told I was big and needed to poo.

OP posts:
PeloFondo · 01/12/2022 07:55

Medstudent12 · 01/12/2022 07:48

I agree with others that you might not be able to sue if you get full function.

But as a doctor I am shocked people are telling you that it’s fine. It’s not fine. You received substandard care. Delaying surgery can lead to permanent paralysis, all doctors in a specialties know this. It’s frequently taught at medical school. Even a psychiatrist knows!

ps psychiatrists know lots but obviously do less physical medicine now. I know minimal about mental health.

That ^^

I had CE, but I knew somehow I had it and told a&e and was operated on. It took them 5hrs to sort out the mess in my back and I was off work recovering for months
I never lost bladder or bowel control but I still have residual numbness and back pain and I was lucky!

BookwormButNoTime · 01/12/2022 07:55

There’s something very different between complaining and suing.

To sue you have to prove some sort of loss. This would be financial loss or a change to your physical health that affects your life. You then need to prove that this loss occurred because of negligence as opposed to you simply having CE. Many people suffer life changing illnesses and accidents but there are often no grounds to sue. It’s just a bit sh*t happens (please read to the end before flaming me!!)

To complain officially would mean that a thorough review should be completed regarding your case. The results of a complaint can also help you decide if you have grounds to sue.

I’ve been in your shoes. I had CE due to a tumour in my spine. I had been going to the doctors for 16 years about “niggles” in my back which were getting progressively worse. They were written off as back spasms or as a result of aches and pains after childbirth or even down to my age. It was only when I could barely walk that I got an MRI and 10 days later I was on the operating table. I am now absolutely fine.

I do ask myself how it went unnoticed for so many years though. There’s also the “why me?” question. It all just felt so unfair. Then I remind myself that what I went through was very rare. Yes it should have been picked up sooner but I wouldn’t say anyone was negligent. It was just a bit sh*t happens.

You are probably still rather out of it on the post op drugs you’ll take for the next few months. Let the dust settle. Get weaned off the meds and only then work out a plan of action.

Wishing you all the best for your recovery.

Medstudent12 · 01/12/2022 07:48

I agree with others that you might not be able to sue if you get full function.

But as a doctor I am shocked people are telling you that it’s fine. It’s not fine. You received substandard care. Delaying surgery can lead to permanent paralysis, all doctors in a specialties know this. It’s frequently taught at medical school. Even a psychiatrist knows!

ps psychiatrists know lots but obviously do less physical medicine now. I know minimal about mental health.

snowbellsxox · 01/12/2022 07:46

My first thought would be something along the spine impacting your nerves
MH? That would be my last thought! And I'm admin!

Medstudent12 · 01/12/2022 07:46

I’m a doctor (old account hence username) I rarely post. I am horrified!!!! Saddle numbness and urinary retention are “red flags” that I ask everyone. You needed an urgent mri. Vast majority of hospital do not have spinal surgeons but we can easily refer online or discuss via phone to hospitals that do.

Please speak to pals. This is awful, cauda equine should not be missed. This doctors involved need to learn from this incident.

IncessantNameChanger · 01/12/2022 07:44

I'm sure if it wasn't the nhs and stated funded you'd be getting different replies.

Classic signs of a serious condition that needed a MRI but you told "it's all in your head?"

Being OK in the end wouldn't be OK with me either.

Meseekslookatme · 01/12/2022 07:39

Passthecheeseboard · 01/12/2022 05:09

You should totally sue , I would … how else are they going to learn? And it’s the best way to stop it happening again to someone else

Unfortunately this.
When my partner died, the only way I could get them to recognise it as avoidable and due to a series of "Never events" (funny how often they happen really 🤔) was to push for a full inquest and then instruct solicitors.
I didn't get any sort of apology, but found out through NHS workers I know that policy was changed so it wouldn't happen again.
The people saying "Well you're OK now aren't you?" We PAY for this shit show and we are not taken sseriously unless we go down the route of suing.
So I say go for it.
It's all done through insurance anyway. You aren't stealing from cancer patients.

IncompleteSenten · 01/12/2022 07:36

I would begin by wanting a discussion and explanation.

I'd also want an apology but you may as well ask for a rainbow farting unicorn because apologising would mean accepting responsibility.

I'd want to know what they plan to do differently in future to ensure other people are not dismissed like you were.

BirmaBrite · 01/12/2022 07:33

Hope your surgery was successful and you are recovering well Flowers

Your timeline is a little confusing, were you in hospital for 10 days because of pain in your back ? They dismissed this as MH related or due to weight but still kept you in ? Then on day 10 you developed the loss of sensation and were unable to walk and pass urine ? or were those symptoms present during the whole of the admission ?

MrsT84 · 01/12/2022 07:31

I have been through very similar recently. I had red flags 8 weeks before being listened to. First I was unable to move without excruciating pain - literally stranded on a dining chair in the middle of the lounge, yet advised by 111 to stay in bed as comfortable as I could. I am a breastfeeding mother and they prescribed tramadol and advised me not to feed baby for 8 hours after taking it! I got by with rotating ibuprofen and paracetamol and self referred to physio and called the GP. GP gave me an appointment 5 weeks later and I had to contact the breastfeeding support network for painkiller advice before they prescribed something suitable over the phone. I muddled by, looking after my young baby and older child until my physio appointment. She advised it was not nerve pain and I should build up my exercise, including cycling. By now I had regular bilateral sciatica and numbness. 2 weeks later I saw GP. He saw I couldn't lift my leg on the examining table so referred me to MSK. This should have been a serious red flag. 2 days later I couldn't move for pain. I had to call my mum to help me with baby, back to the dining chair as couldn't move. Home visit GP refused to come and told me to call 999. 999 raised priority of call due to red flags. Paramedics reluctantly drove me to the hospital where I stayed on ambulances for 5 hours before being seen by Doctor. Doctor prodded me a bit and gave me 2 paracetamol and said he would "mobilise me in 2 hours" and I was taken on a wheelchair to wait by myself in the a+e waiting area. Seen a couple of hours later by a different doctor who requested a urine retention test, which I was made to walk to the toilet and back in excruciating pain, and examination of back passage. I failed both these tests. Next seen by an orthopaedic doctor, who wanted to do the same tests but I said no, it had already been done. Advised I would be sent home and called back next day for MRI and told to go nil by mouth. I wasn't sent home (couldn't have got in the car anyway) and at 6am they opened the MRI for me. After the scan the radiologist told me not to walk, and it turned out I had a huge herniated disc pressing on my spinal cord. After 20 hours since ambulance arrived I was rushed into surgery for decompression, discectomy and microdiscectomy for cauda equina. I was so relieved to be listened to, and walking pain free the next day. Recovery has been hard, no lifting, bending or twisting for 12 weeks (with a baby at home!) but I am getting there slowly and seem to have no long term effects. I am still in two minds to complain but at the same time so grateful to have finally been heard.

Badgirlriri · 01/12/2022 07:26

You can tell from the language and terminology the American posters on here encouraging to sue!

Guitarbar · 01/12/2022 07:20

I would definitely report to PALS. Very unlikely to be successful in suing though unless you have long term implications which require you to pay to support yourself ie living aids due to it, or loss of earnings as you can no longer continue on your career path.

flamingogold · 01/12/2022 07:19

Itsjustlife0190 · 01/12/2022 07:14

Sorry but you wont be able to sue them, you wouldnt win with that argument as you havent lost anything and your health hasnt significantely suffered as a result. They DID diagnose you eventually and you had the surgery which i presume went well.

Im sorry but i think your just trying whatever you can to rinse them but it wouldnt work in this case.

None of that is known at the moment. The op may well be absolutely fine now, but she wouldn't be able to bring a claim for some time until the long term prognosis is clear. However she may want to obtain and review the medical records in the meantime as they do go missing on occasion and sometimes have incorrect information recorded.

Itsjustlife0190 · 01/12/2022 07:14

Although i would make some serious complaints.

Itsjustlife0190 · 01/12/2022 07:14

Sorry but you wont be able to sue them, you wouldnt win with that argument as you havent lost anything and your health hasnt significantely suffered as a result. They DID diagnose you eventually and you had the surgery which i presume went well.

Im sorry but i think your just trying whatever you can to rinse them but it wouldnt work in this case.

ReedRite · 01/12/2022 07:11

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Ridiculous, rude, spiteful post.

piedbeauty · 01/12/2022 07:11

So you couldn't walk or wee for 10 days? Sorry, your timeline is confusing.

I agree that a debrief might be the most helpful thing for you now.

We don't have all the information - we only have what you have said, post-op, and I'm not sure that's enough to make a judgement.

Best wishes for your recovery.

DohaDragon · 01/12/2022 07:10

If you have been left with long term/permanent bowel/urinary problems due to a delay in surgery like a friend of mine then yes, sue. 5 years on she still can’t have a poo or wee.

if no long term issues then I’d just complain because I’d want the staff who missed it to be made aware for their future knowledge.

ReedRite · 01/12/2022 07:09

Deciding symptoms are likely a result of stress/mental health issues/‘functional’ should ONLY EVER be done once all relevant tests have been carried out to rule out a physical cause.

In this case there was a huge red flag that cauda equina could be a possibility and that you be had be left paralysed for life, OP.

You NEED to take this up with the hospital one way or the other. They have been negligent and probably discriminatory as well.

They need to learn from this to make sure they don’t put other patients in danger. What happens if they dismiss the next patient’s chest pains as ‘stress’ or ‘anxiety’ and the person is actually having a heart attack? Or somebody loses feeling and movement in an arm and leg and they immediately conclude it’s ‘functional’ without testing for stroke? And then the person misses the window for treatment which can limit damage from the stroke.

It’s scary that you can be in a hospital and have actual medical staff fail to consider serious physical conditions. They need to learn and change. This won’t happen if you don’t at least complain. And if you are left with ANY long-term damage they should compensate you for their incompetence.

I hope you recover well and completely.

Wrongsideofpennines · 01/12/2022 07:06

I think you would be fair to put a complaint in via PALS but if you are not suffering any long term effects then I don't think you would win a litigation case.

I also think it may be difficult to prove that their delay in treating you for it is the cause of any ongoing problems. Cauda Equina is serious and can result in long term problems even if treated immediately. The other thing would be did they highlight any risks to the surgery. Because they may argue that any injury was caused by this rather than the original problem.

Anotherguy · 01/12/2022 07:00

Blueotter22 · 01/12/2022 06:58

I’m sure you wouldn’t be saying shit happens, move on if you were misdiagnosed for 10 days for a condition that is treatable (within 24 hours usually). You then spend the rest of your life being unable to hold in a fart and never getting it up again.
Aye, shit happens move on.

she’s not taking money directly from the nhs when she sues, the doctors have insurance to practice.

but that isn’t the case for the op. Costs should be covered, profit shouldn’t be made, ever

Anotherguy · 01/12/2022 06:59

Blueotter22 · 01/12/2022 06:58

I’m sure you wouldn’t be saying shit happens, move on if you were misdiagnosed for 10 days for a condition that is treatable (within 24 hours usually). You then spend the rest of your life being unable to hold in a fart and never getting it up again.
Aye, shit happens move on.

she’s not taking money directly from the nhs when she sues, the doctors have insurance to practice.

The insurance does not fund compensation claims. Every penny comes out of the nhs budget so puts further strain on the nhs

Blueotter22 · 01/12/2022 06:58

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

I’m sure you wouldn’t be saying shit happens, move on if you were misdiagnosed for 10 days for a condition that is treatable (within 24 hours usually). You then spend the rest of your life being unable to hold in a fart and never getting it up again.
Aye, shit happens move on.

she’s not taking money directly from the nhs when she sues, the doctors have insurance to practice.

Swipe left for the next trending thread