Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

ASD/ADHD Do not know what to do for best - medicate or carry on?

58 replies

antarctictoc · 30/11/2022 21:53

DC10 has a diagnosis - high functioning autism (unable to focus so not highly academic) and mild ADHD inattentive type without hyperactivity. He enjoys sport and the practical lessons.

He tolerates school - does not really like it and has some trouble making good friends but is friendly with a couple of boys. He has poor impulse control so sometimes behaves in a silly way (calling out in class or acting the clown). It's not very often but enough to alienate himself from a lot of his classmates.

He struggles academically - bright but his inability to focus means he rarely shows his true ability.

Psychiatrist wrote his report and ASD/ADHD diagnosis and we had a phone call to ask questions.

We asked about trialling medication to help with focus and came away feeling psych was against medicating - recommended reading up on methylphenidate which he referred to as amphetamine.

We have read and researched and see there are possible side effects but also worry we are not doing the right thing if we don't try it.

Our child is struggling with school work and socially. Much of the time seems stressed and anxious. Self confidence affected too. We have tried counselling, one to one tuition, extra support in school (sat at front of class, one to one help, lots of positive reinforcement) but feel his inability to focus is very much a hindrance in so many areas of his life.

Has anyone else struggled with this decision and felt psychiatrist was not supportive of medicating?

OP posts:
Hankunamatata · 30/11/2022 22:46

www.nhs.uk/conditions/attention-deficit-hyperactivity-disorder-adhd/treatment/
These are drugs but they also have brand names
Mehtyphenidate - ritalin, concerta, delmosart etc

Risslan · 30/11/2022 22:46
  • QB test
Risslan · 30/11/2022 22:44

I do think there's no harm in trying if you're willing. The first medication we were given was only supposed to last 6 hours so you could try at a weekend and keep a close eye on him in a familiar situation and see how it goes.

It's strange they're not supporting you in meds though. We felt very much pushed in that direction, in fact the school refused to refer for adhd when we said we weren't sure we'd medicate!

How was the adhd diagnosed? My DS had a QT test so we can genuinely see measurements of concentration compared to other kids and he was 99th percentile. I think many are diagnosed by questionnaires so really hard to tell how 'bad' they are.

antarctictoc · 30/11/2022 22:44

@Anothermother3 Yes, psychiatrist specialises in neurodevelopmental - and report mentions emotional regulation - concerned this will worsen with hormonal changes in puberty.

OP posts:
Hankunamatata · 30/11/2022 22:39

3 adhd dc, one with asd (possibly 2 but didn't see point in pursuing another dual diagnosis).
Medication all the way. My are all on methylphenidate.

Eldest went from bottom of his class to top of his class when he started at 7.

antarctictoc · 30/11/2022 22:38

thank you for sharing your experiences @Risslan . We're feeling wobbly about this decision because we feel unsupported by psychiatrist. Just a feeling we came away with after discussing. I am sure my feelings are playing into this too - but the reasons motivating us are DC is not enjoying life as he could or should if he was able to focus on his social interactions, learning, sports, everything really.

OP posts:
Anothermother3 · 30/11/2022 22:35

Apologies I wrote that like I talk (without commas).

Anothermother3 · 30/11/2022 22:35

I think at 10 if it’s impeding his ability to engage in academic work and relationships and your child is trying and has all the reasonable accommodations at school already it might be helpful to trial. Methylphenidate is the first line recommended treatment in children in terms of clinical guidelines and comes in different preparations but there are other stimulant and non stimulant options as well. Methylphenidate over time has done positive effects on emotional regulation in the context of adhd as well. Does your psychiatrist work in a neurodevelopmental service? Would a second opinion be helpful?

JustAnotherManicNameChange · 30/11/2022 22:34

I think you can try it. It doesn't mean he has to stay on them if they don't agree with him, or he has side effects, or simply hates the effect on him.

I know one child medicated for ADHD , it simply gave him the ability to focus ,apply himself and function. On the days he missed it , you could really tell mainly because he would become so easily frustrated by anything and everything which then meant no learning, negative social interactions with friends etc. and most of the day was spent trying to regulate himself.

antarctictoc · 30/11/2022 22:33

@anxiousweewill that sounds tough going, I'm sorry things didn't work out. My DC also has autism but our psychiatrist was clear there are no other medications just amphetamine. I feel a little bit lost now we have the report - no follow up offered by the psychiatrist but we asked for a phone call and had very top level conversation without any real discussion.

OP posts:
Risslan · 30/11/2022 22:32

You have pretty much described my DS there, asd diagnosed very young, adhd at 10.

He has no behavioural issues but huge trouble focusing and anxiety that they said medication would improve.

I went to the session held for parents of newly diagnosed kids and felt so alone in my thoughts. Isn't medicating for adhd social engineering? If there was a pill to cure autism would we be encouraged to use it? How is it different? Every other mum there was desperate for medication because their dc were in so much trouble at school and at risk of exclusion, I didn't feel able to ask my questions.

Anyway we didn't go down the medication route until the anxiety was really bad, and the side effects (depression, weight loss and lack of sleep) were awful and no improvement in focus. Psychologist just kept increasing the dose.

DS was the deciding factor in stopping the medication, he very much didn't want to take it which I believe is mainly down to his oppositional nature (asd) but also that he's been brought up being told that neuro diversity is a good thing and could not understand why this is different.

We have just revisited the adhd nurse since he is really struggling in lessons, and feel far more listened to than previously. She's prescribed a different medication that she thinks will suit him better and wants regular detailed feedback to tailor the dose. I'm really hoping it'll help him, he's always been happy at school but is lately noticing how much harder he finds it than others and is getting a bit reluctant. It's too early to tell yet but we'll give it a go.

Anyway, those are my thoughts and I'm sure they don't help that much but just wanted to share so you can see both sides.

antarctictoc · 30/11/2022 22:29

Thank you @Thelonelychicken . I am convinced sweets like Haribos make him very reactive and stressed. However other sugar (chocolate, refined white carbs) seem to help. He craves sugar - I think he needs it to focus sometimes!

OP posts:
winewolfhowls · 30/11/2022 22:28

I just completed a free course on future learn about ADHD and it seemed to recommend medication, it had proper university professors and research papers included. Maybe have a look at it? It was called something like understanding ADHD.

anxiousweewill · 30/11/2022 22:28

My son has ADHD and autism. Very intelligent but extremely hyperactive.

We tried medication but his private doctor said children who have autism along with adhd are best off on a non stimulant. We tried atomoxetine for nearly a year.

It made him so angry and sad. Very irritable.

We all made the decision together for him to come off meds and it was the best thing we did. He's so much more happier.

I think it just is trial and error with these things. We focus on diet and other forms of therapy.

Thelonelychicken · 30/11/2022 22:26

There is a non stimulate adhd medication. My dd is medicated with a stimulate during the day then has a mon stimulate at night. She's on the maximum doses for her weight. But she does so much better on it than off it. We've been trying to find the right balance since she was 8. She's now 13 and has been on these meds for a year.

Her appetite did struggle hugely shes a tiny wee thing but not underweight anymore. I make up for it by feeding high calories meals she also has breaks during school holidays.

If one medication doesn't work try the others until you find the balance. Also I find lack of sleep makes symptoms much worse so make sure they are having enough sleep. (can be hard I know)

Food colourings set off dd too especially blue and the aspartame sweeteners. I can go find the medication names if anyone wants to know when I get up tomorrow.

antarctictoc · 30/11/2022 22:25

Not sure what else they could do at primary school to accommodate him after diagnosis. He is already having one to one sessions with counsellor for wellbeing, seated at the front, receives time and attention from teachers when he has lost focus or to help him stay on task, he gets lots of praise and encouragement. He does fidget with pencils etc but they don't seem to mind that.

OP posts:
paddler78 · 30/11/2022 22:21

And definitely share with school asap, my sons was managed really well in primary with limited medication but come secondary school unfortunately the things they use in primary to manage things (eg wobble cushions, fidget toys etc) mean they really stand out out secondary :(

antarctictoc · 30/11/2022 22:17

Thank you for all the replies. I recognise a lot of symptoms in myself too.

OP posts:
paddler78 · 30/11/2022 22:17

antarctictoc · 30/11/2022 22:12

Can I just ask, it is just methylphenidate that everyone is referring to as medication? We were told this was the only ADHD medication - but has different brand names.

There are other options but that is the most flexible and easy to adjust to

lollipoprainbow · 30/11/2022 22:17

My dd10 sounds very similar, hates school, very anxious and on edge and can't maintain friendships . I would love for her to trial some medication but I don't know how to go about it. I tried going down the cahms route but they don't want to know. The school have an educational psychologist that goes in once a week but senco have spoken to them and they don't feel she is eligible to see them despite my dd saying she wants to die on school mornings. Can I ask how you got a psychiatrist? Did you go private.

Hercisback · 30/11/2022 22:16

Share the diagnosis with school ASAP, please! It really does help us, especially if there are specific strategies that may support your child.

Medication is individual. I've taught students who thrived on it, and others who didn't. I'd trial it and see. If it doesn't work, nothing lost.

antarctictoc · 30/11/2022 22:12

Can I just ask, it is just methylphenidate that everyone is referring to as medication? We were told this was the only ADHD medication - but has different brand names.

OP posts:
Sidking · 30/11/2022 22:11

Sorry hit post!

As an adult female who was completely missed in childhood and is now struggling to get a diagnosis I would give my right hand to be properly diagnosed and medicated. IME and from talking to/reading accounts from other adults with ADHD it doesn't often get any easier as you get older (it certainly wasn't the case for me) without being medicated, or developing some serious coping/masking techniques, and the benefits of medication on MH outweigh the health risks of medication (which will be monitored).

I did read somewhere (can't remember where, probably just a link in a FB comment so don't take my word on it!) That medicating in childhood allows the brain to make better connections that are then with that person for life, and that medicated children are more likely to cope without meds in adulthood than ADHD adults who weren't medicated, because of these neuro pathways that the medication enabled them to make

antarctictoc · 30/11/2022 22:11

We had just about convinced ourselves that it was worth trying mediation but came away after call with psychiatrist feeling they do not agree. It was talked about as amphetamine - worrying and I don't fully understand how that would help?! Last resort type scenario.

While we have not yet shared diagnosis with school (still digesting and deciding next steps), school have been using lots of support and interventions for some time.

OP posts:
WHEREEL · 30/11/2022 22:08

I have ADHD. Medication has been life changing but the side effects can be awful. I now sweat a lot and whenever I’m stressed I’m unable to eat.