Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Does the UK have a racism problem?

556 replies

JolllyBee · 30/11/2022 20:43

In just the last 24 hours alone we've had in the news:

Prince William’s godmother quits palace over comments to black charity boss

Meghan Markle had several 'disgusting' and credible threats to her life, Met cop reveals

Various people's census rants going viral and getting a scary amount of support

James McAvoy shocked by hometown racism in Glasgow after castmates abused on street

and a few days prior:

London Fire Brigade houses a toxic culture of bullying, racism and misogyny, inquiry finds

OP posts:
Simonjt · 10/12/2022 07:21

TruckerBarbie · 10/12/2022 03:39

Oh whatever.

Try working for an Indian company and you'll see some real racism. They're much more racist about Pakistanis than most whites would ever dare be.

But yeah, technically this is a pretty racist country when you add the non white racists to the white racists.

Never experienced any racism from anyone of Indian heritage, or while in India.

TruckerBarbie · 10/12/2022 03:39

Oh whatever.

Try working for an Indian company and you'll see some real racism. They're much more racist about Pakistanis than most whites would ever dare be.

But yeah, technically this is a pretty racist country when you add the non white racists to the white racists.

Dahliasandtea · 09/12/2022 05:59

I’ve been thinking about this thread and the bizarre nature of the question posed all night last night. And it’s just hit me now while it bothers me so much. The OP cited recent newspaper articles that point her to posing the question, innocently, as if she is shocked she hadn’t realised it before…

And I can’t stop thinking about newspaper articles,TV documentaries, TV news stories, that I have read and watched my whole life.
racism in housing, healthcare, education (school, university, post-grad), general workplace, the police force, academia, the armed forces, politics (at the highest level!) , movies, music industry, sports….

and I wonder what the HELL has the OP been doing in her life that she has to ask if MN thinks there is a racism problem in the UK. And it makes me so angry to scroll through these comments and it be reduced to ‘Lady Hussey is an old lady and doesn’t know any better, that’s how she talks’ and ‘I’m so scared of offending someone because everyone is so sensitive’. Or the best was ‘every country is racist’ and ‘non white people are racist too!’ Like al of this makes some kind of difference to the original question.

bloody shut up and grow a pair. Britain is a disgustingly racist place and just because you don’t see it in front of you on a daily basis, it doesn’t mean it’s not. What it probably means is that you’re wilfully blind! And don’t want to see it because it means you are in a a position of white supremacy and getting rid of racism means you have to give that up and you’re scared to.

ChristmasNoodles · 08/12/2022 21:03

To be honest i think what I find almost more upsetting than overt racism is the insistence that it's fine because the UK isn't the most racist country in the world. It feels as if people are saying that the status quo is good enough for people of colour. That we should be grateful that we are treated all right a lot of the time and making a fuss of when we aren't is ungrateful.

I think Lawrence Fox (and many on this thread who keep talking about how racism is worse elsewhere) is a bigger racist than Susan Hussey.

blueflagflyhigh · 08/12/2022 15:55

I think it does to be honest. I imagine it is better now than it used to be but that is not gd enough!

I also notice it in the older generation where I live. They say things they really shouldn't but aren't aware that it's racist. They would say it's just how they were brought up 🙄

It's pretty sad and I just I don't get it. I take a person as they are, no matter their race, sexual orientation etc, none of that matters.

phoenixrosehere · 08/12/2022 15:33

Ohlife2020 · 08/12/2022 15:16

There IS a problem of stereotype. Modern culture make people think others as a group shared common traits first thing when they know the background. People don't want to disclose where they are from, not because they are ashamed. Each is an individual, some just don't want to be labelled and stereotyped.

You are talking from a single minded thoughts, as if that's the only way should be done.

Exactly. I don’t mind discussing my background but when I don’t fit the stereotype that fits some people’s heads, it gets awkward or they make assumptions based on it and treat me differently or they want to lump all pocs with a certain skin tone into a monolith when our ethnic backgrounds are all different and we have completely different diets and traditions.

People here have pointed out how they don’t like being lumped as all English when they’re from Scotland, Wales, and Northern Ireland so why do some think pocs want it done to them.

phoenixrosehere · 08/12/2022 15:20

Kazzyhoward · 08/12/2022 12:25

There are different kinds of "racism".

Yes, in rural/regional areas, anyone who isn't "like the locals" can feel discriminated against, that's not always based on colour of your skin - there are numerous reports of Welsh white people being discriminatory against English white people for example. But that kind of discrimination is often simply because people are different, and in some close knit communities, any kind of "outsider" is viewed with suspicion, and I would hope that no actual harm is intended.

In inner cities, the racism is often more explicit and overt and often linked to violence, and you have "black on black" racism which is also often common. Some of worst racism I've seen was from an Asian family towards Black Africans for example (culminating in one of the brothers being convicted and imprisoned!).

There's certainly no "one size fits all" answer that would deal with both types of discrimination, as a general "be nice" and open towards outsiders publicity/education campaign would probably work in rural areas who don't inheritently wish harm on anyone, but completely misses the target when trying to deal with inner city gangs or employers employing illegal immigrants in squalid conditions who know exactly what harm they're doing and simply don't care!

black on black" racism

It’s called same-race discrimination. It happens in all races. It boggles my mind why that term isn’t used more considering it is normal in all race groups, yet black on black is often said.

Ohlife2020 · 08/12/2022 15:16

Abracadabra12345 · 08/12/2022 13:52

If we meet someone of colour, my Turkish friend and another friend - also of colour _ openly ask where someone is from. I’m cringing - “you can’t ask that!” - but no one ever is offended and are proud to discuss their heritage, and why wouldn’t they be? Why act as if you are ashamed?

There IS a problem of stereotype. Modern culture make people think others as a group shared common traits first thing when they know the background. People don't want to disclose where they are from, not because they are ashamed. Each is an individual, some just don't want to be labelled and stereotyped.

You are talking from a single minded thoughts, as if that's the only way should be done.

Ohlife2020 · 08/12/2022 15:11

Kissmybaubles · 08/12/2022 14:16

“We live at outer London, can already feel the local white English mum's are less easy to get on with than people of the same profile from inner London.”

Maybe they are afraid of being accused as racist so think it’s wise to just keep to themselves 🫣

You are being ironic and I said they aren't racists, just not comfortable to talk to people from different background. What you said might be some people's thoughts (like yourself) but certainly not a concern of most of the English people.

ChristmasNoodles · 08/12/2022 15:03

Ritasueandbobtoo9 · 05/12/2022 21:13

If you have lived in other countries you will realise that other country are also racist.

If you have had stones thrown at you, had kids yell "pakis out", have had other weird stuff thrown at you (like take away food or cigarettes), been called a terrorist, told you should know your place because you are not from here, ETC...if all these things had happened to you, your family or friends or god forbid your children, do you really think it would be a consolation to think that other countries are racist too?

I live here. My family lives here. My children live here. Don't tell me to be grateful that I am only sometimes treated as a second class citizen because of the colour of my skin.

Kissmybaubles · 08/12/2022 14:16

“We live at outer London, can already feel the local white English mum's are less easy to get on with than people of the same profile from inner London.”

Maybe they are afraid of being accused as racist so think it’s wise to just keep to themselves 🫣

Kissmybaubles · 08/12/2022 14:14

Abracadabra12345 · 08/12/2022 13:52

If we meet someone of colour, my Turkish friend and another friend - also of colour _ openly ask where someone is from. I’m cringing - “you can’t ask that!” - but no one ever is offended and are proud to discuss their heritage, and why wouldn’t they be? Why act as if you are ashamed?

This 👏

being over sensitive and seeing racism in situations that are not racist are what makes communication even harder and will make ‘white’ people afraid to even talk to people of different heritage for fear of being Perceived racist 🙄

you can see example’s of that throughout this thread. People accidentally saying the wrong thing and instantly being jumped on for being ‘racist’. Ffs no wonder white people are avoiding people of other race… And then they are accused of racism again.

Come on now, most people are not racist🤦‍♀️

Abracadabra12345 · 08/12/2022 13:52

mamabear715 · 03/12/2022 11:57

Ok, my story, FWIW.. school meeting, asked a chinese lady where she was from - yes, just like Lady Susan. Sharp intake of breath from the rest of the (white, middle class) room. Lady wasn't bothered at all & told me her heritage, which happened to be where a family member grew up, and we had a lovely chat.

I didn't mean anything by it, am just naturally interested in people.. should I have held my tongue, & missed out on our conversation?
I hate the feeling that I have to watch everything I say. :-(
I love people, am genuinely interested & feel that if we all stay quiet for fear of causing offence, it's pretty isolating way to be. Am I wrong?

If we meet someone of colour, my Turkish friend and another friend - also of colour _ openly ask where someone is from. I’m cringing - “you can’t ask that!” - but no one ever is offended and are proud to discuss their heritage, and why wouldn’t they be? Why act as if you are ashamed?

Abracadabra12345 · 08/12/2022 13:37

ReformedWaywardTeen · 01/12/2022 06:38

It depends on what you consider racism.

Nigel Farage is of course a massive and unashamed racist. As is anyone to do with or supportive of far right groups.

However, the Lady Hussey thing really doesn't sit comfortably with me as racism.

Here are two women, at the palace. One an older lady who comes from another era and a class system that many of us don't really understand the workings of.
The other, a woman who considers herself British, as she was born here so is quite correct to do so, but whose parents were immigrants to the country. She had already made quite inflammatory comments on the Royals regards Meghan (suggesting Meghan was the victim of Domestic violence by her in-laws).

Lady Hussey's generation speak very differently to us. I believe that when she said about where her people come from, to her "people" means family in general. Sadly people of that generation are most likely to unintentionally cause offence. Why did the woman not just say "I was born here but my parents are originally from x".

Looking at the way she handled it was to almost push the conversation into something she could complain about.

I also don't get the run to Twitter angle. Why not just raise it with the palace. And why, if you had already said of your belief that the Royal Family are guilty of domestic violence would you even accept an invite to attend the palace?

I've seen some nastier people use this to suggest she went with an axe to grind and went looking for trouble. If anything, she will probably experience far worse now because of the way she has brought this to the public attention, especially when some are already suggesting she is racist by only extending her domestic abuse charity to women from one specific community.

I think it's about language and some older folk of the same class as Lady Hussey speak very differently to the rest of our younger generations.

I also don't think that it helps that every day seems to bring another accusation of some sort. That filters the real cases down and means people are more likely to pass off genuine abuse as another snowflake engaging in cancel culture.

So yes, we do have racism. Yes there are some proper scumbags out there aided by Boris and co. Yes the football will probably see a rise in incidents.

But not everything is racist. Not every white person is secretly engaging in far right activities. Not everyone with an England flag up for the football is a card carrying far right supporter. Most of us are truly embarrassed about Farage, Hopkins and Robinson.

Thank you

Abracadabra12345 · 08/12/2022 13:32

BMW6 · 30/11/2022 21:20

Of course. There is no country in the entire world that doesn't have racism.

Not one.

Quite

808Kate1 · 08/12/2022 13:25

phoenixrosehere · 08/12/2022 06:26

No one has said that the entire of the UK is racist though nor should us being more tolerable than other countries be enough. That is not deserving of a pat on the back and everything is just fine.

I also don’t agree that having a non-white British PM for the first time is proof of how non-racist the UK can be after how many years? Was there really no one good enough who happened to be non-white in that time until now?

The fact is that it should be acknowledged that there are different elements of racism in the U.K. and that there are people effected by it through no fault of their own and it is more than just the overt but the casual versions said with a smile regardless of intent. They still have to live with, deal with it, and are harmed by it. We can do better and be better than we’re “more tolerable than other countries”.

Not talking about it, getting annoyed and upset instead of asking what can be done about it, what steps can be made shows how tolerable some really are.

Yes, agree with phoenixrosehere

And this silly argument that we can't be a racist country because we have an Asian prime minister reminds me of the people who claim the Royal Family absolutely can't be racist because we had a Queen over 200 years ago who was (apparently) mixed race.

Prettypissedoff88 · 08/12/2022 13:17

Do you really need to ask???? Genuinely do you need MN to answer that question.

of course there is a a racism problem in the UK. And I feel that if you need to ask that question, that kind of proves it. It means that no one is listening to the experiences of people of colour who are constantly telling white Britain that there is a serious problem with racism… casual and deliberate institutionalised racism.

Ohlife2020 · 08/12/2022 12:36

Kazzyhoward · 08/12/2022 12:29

@Ohlife2020

We live at outer London, can already feel the local white English mum's are less easy to get on with than people of the same profile from inner London.

That could also be that those Mum's are a bit more introverted, shy or reserved than the ones from the inner city? Certainly in our village school, which was mostly "white" mums, there were lots who weren't over-friendly even towards each other, with lots of them waiting around on their own rather than getting together for a gossip.

Over so many years, I have already let down any judgement.

Some are truly unfriendly and wouldn't bother to acknowledge your existence.
Some are only interested in people within their own circle (known each other prior to RC year).
Some are just uncomfortable to engage with people from very different background and don't see it a problem to avoid and stay in their own comfort zone.

Ive decided most of them aren't racist, just prefer to deal with what they know (like ordering the same food in pubs all the time) than having to step out of what they feel under control.

Kazzyhoward · 08/12/2022 12:29

@Ohlife2020

We live at outer London, can already feel the local white English mum's are less easy to get on with than people of the same profile from inner London.

That could also be that those Mum's are a bit more introverted, shy or reserved than the ones from the inner city? Certainly in our village school, which was mostly "white" mums, there were lots who weren't over-friendly even towards each other, with lots of them waiting around on their own rather than getting together for a gossip.

Kazzyhoward · 08/12/2022 12:25

Ohlife2020 · 08/12/2022 10:32

Sorry for your DH's experience. Got the feeling that outside London which is highly multinational, some inland area where people aren't exposed to multicultural, more of them tend to be less tolerant and more stereotypes can be going on than London in general.

We live at outer London, can already feel the local white English mum's are less easy to get on with than people of the same profile from inner London. Some can be quite outright rude, but have no problems to be chatty and friendly among themselves.

There are different kinds of "racism".

Yes, in rural/regional areas, anyone who isn't "like the locals" can feel discriminated against, that's not always based on colour of your skin - there are numerous reports of Welsh white people being discriminatory against English white people for example. But that kind of discrimination is often simply because people are different, and in some close knit communities, any kind of "outsider" is viewed with suspicion, and I would hope that no actual harm is intended.

In inner cities, the racism is often more explicit and overt and often linked to violence, and you have "black on black" racism which is also often common. Some of worst racism I've seen was from an Asian family towards Black Africans for example (culminating in one of the brothers being convicted and imprisoned!).

There's certainly no "one size fits all" answer that would deal with both types of discrimination, as a general "be nice" and open towards outsiders publicity/education campaign would probably work in rural areas who don't inheritently wish harm on anyone, but completely misses the target when trying to deal with inner city gangs or employers employing illegal immigrants in squalid conditions who know exactly what harm they're doing and simply don't care!

Ohlife2020 · 08/12/2022 10:32

CornedBeef451 · 08/12/2022 08:06

Yes of course there is racism here. A couple of weeks ago DH got asked if he'd just got off a boat. Considering we live in the midlands it didn't seem to be related to his travel choices.

Since Brexit he's also been shouted at to go back home, I've been asked if my DCs are mine, a friend has been told in the supermarket that she should be ashamed of having children with a black man and colleague's boyfriend was called a monkey at work.

Oh and a Chinese colleague has been shouted at and harassed in the street since the start of covid.

Sorry for your DH's experience. Got the feeling that outside London which is highly multinational, some inland area where people aren't exposed to multicultural, more of them tend to be less tolerant and more stereotypes can be going on than London in general.

We live at outer London, can already feel the local white English mum's are less easy to get on with than people of the same profile from inner London. Some can be quite outright rude, but have no problems to be chatty and friendly among themselves.

Ohlife2020 · 08/12/2022 10:23

phoenixrosehere · 08/12/2022 06:26

No one has said that the entire of the UK is racist though nor should us being more tolerable than other countries be enough. That is not deserving of a pat on the back and everything is just fine.

I also don’t agree that having a non-white British PM for the first time is proof of how non-racist the UK can be after how many years? Was there really no one good enough who happened to be non-white in that time until now?

The fact is that it should be acknowledged that there are different elements of racism in the U.K. and that there are people effected by it through no fault of their own and it is more than just the overt but the casual versions said with a smile regardless of intent. They still have to live with, deal with it, and are harmed by it. We can do better and be better than we’re “more tolerable than other countries”.

Not talking about it, getting annoyed and upset instead of asking what can be done about it, what steps can be made shows how tolerable some really are.

This!!! ❤@phoenixrosehere 👏

808Kate1 · 08/12/2022 09:39

Kissmybaubles · 08/12/2022 07:50

It’s unfair to say the UK has a racist problem. There are lots of good people in the UK who would be the first to call out racism when they see it

Unfair to who? People who call it out and the many people who are victims should just suck it up?

Could say that about any country regardless of their levels of racism

Marths · 08/12/2022 09:24

Kissmybaubles · 08/12/2022 07:50

It’s unfair to say the UK has a racist problem. There are lots of good people in the UK who would be the first to call out racism when they see it

Having good people does not preclude a place from having a racism problem.

CornedBeef451 · 08/12/2022 08:06

Yes of course there is racism here. A couple of weeks ago DH got asked if he'd just got off a boat. Considering we live in the midlands it didn't seem to be related to his travel choices.

Since Brexit he's also been shouted at to go back home, I've been asked if my DCs are mine, a friend has been told in the supermarket that she should be ashamed of having children with a black man and colleague's boyfriend was called a monkey at work.

Oh and a Chinese colleague has been shouted at and harassed in the street since the start of covid.