Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Does the UK have a racism problem?

556 replies

JolllyBee · 30/11/2022 20:43

In just the last 24 hours alone we've had in the news:

Prince William’s godmother quits palace over comments to black charity boss

Meghan Markle had several 'disgusting' and credible threats to her life, Met cop reveals

Various people's census rants going viral and getting a scary amount of support

James McAvoy shocked by hometown racism in Glasgow after castmates abused on street

and a few days prior:

London Fire Brigade houses a toxic culture of bullying, racism and misogyny, inquiry finds

OP posts:
TruckerBarbie · 13/12/2022 10:22

MarieIVanArkleStinks · 13/12/2022 10:00

I don't agree. We are not born naturally hating people with a skin-colour that's different from ours, any more than a brunette is born naturally hating a blond person. It's a fallacy.

Racism is learned behaviour.

Yes, the UK is a racist country. Yes, so is the eastern seaboard of the US, particularly the southern states. I've only lived in those two countries so I'm unable to comment on any others with certainty (but certain forms of national behaviour, such as the treatment of first nation Australians by the colonial populace).

The excuse 'but other countries are worse' is not an excuse.

Yet if you put a red ant next to a black ant they attack each other.

I think animals are actually quite tribal tbh.

MarieIVanArkleStinks · 13/12/2022 10:00

Gluewhine · 30/11/2022 21:27

There is racism, same as everywhere. Racism is a natural element of being human (as is any ‘othering’ of people who are different to you - we are tribal). I don’t think you can aim to eliminate it or to dictate what people think. All you can do is pass and enforce anti-discrimination law/prosecute hate crime/ develop a culture of tolerance. I think in general compared to many other countries we do well on racism but obviously there’s always room for improvement.

I don't agree. We are not born naturally hating people with a skin-colour that's different from ours, any more than a brunette is born naturally hating a blond person. It's a fallacy.

Racism is learned behaviour.

Yes, the UK is a racist country. Yes, so is the eastern seaboard of the US, particularly the southern states. I've only lived in those two countries so I'm unable to comment on any others with certainty (but certain forms of national behaviour, such as the treatment of first nation Australians by the colonial populace).

The excuse 'but other countries are worse' is not an excuse.

phoenixrosehere · 13/12/2022 09:43

Mezmer · 12/12/2022 19:45

I just don’t believe that hating someone because they have a certain skin colour is as prevalent as believed. Most friction is because of cultural not racial differences. Institutions are set up to serve historical British hierarchy and are not purposefully hostile to different cultures, they are like it symptomatically. Maybe it’s important to realise that it works all ways. Cultures generally don’t tolerate different cultures very well. That’s different from racism where tribalism comes into force solely because someone looks different from you. There was nothing wrong with what Hussey said in those circumstances. NOT asking her where she was from could have been seen as rude, or ignoring her, or overlooking her evident desire to promote her African sentiments. To say it is is taking a hostile stance by failing to give someone the benefit of the doubt, which in this context came down to the fact that a person from one race or background is not allowed to say certain things to another. You can deconstruct anything you like and build it up again in a narrative that suits your cause. I agree there is racism but mainly it’s culture wars. You can’t change your race but you can choose your culture.

How many times does it have to be said.. it wasn’t the asking but LH not accepting the answer given. There was no reason for her to continue to ask. No one owes anyone their life story or background just because someone asks especially if you cannot accept the answer given.

That is not a hard concept to understand.

ReformedWaywardTeen · 13/12/2022 09:41

The point is that I firmly believe that she had a motive to discredit someone in or linked to the Royals. In doing so, she has invited scrutiny into her actions.

It's like anything else, you can't go on TV and not expect something dodgy to come out if there's something dodgy about you.

I said from the start I found it questionable why someone who has so vocally slated the Royals and accused them of DV against MM, would accept an invitation from them.

This charity, if you can call it that, has seemingly scammed hundreds of thousands from charities and government agencies. Apparently several are now speaking directly to the guy who posted it with a view to investigating huge fraud.

What upsets people is this charity has claimed money which could've been spent on genuine projects.

If you can still say "but what about" with regards Lady Hussey shows that yet again, discrimination is fine when it's against one group.

I would question if anyone has ever received help from Sistah Space other than the Headley family.

Ohlife2020 · 13/12/2022 09:05

ReformedWaywardTeen · 13/12/2022 06:58

For those who acted as cheerleader for Sistah Space after the Lady Hussey incident, you may wish to pop over to Twitter.

A twitter account (JustPikachoo) has gone into a huge deep dive on the woman involved, her family, and the quite interesting finances of the charity and it looks very much like she may regret all the publicity. The Charities Commission has been made aware along with Hackney council, the London Community Fund and Comic Relief and will no doubt have to launch an enquiry. And yes, the twitter account holder has a raft of evidence that was all in the public domain.

Seems the whole charity is little more than a questionable fraud.

The whole thread (it's long as it's fully proved) is here threadreaderapp.com/thread/1601735411860406274.html

Kind of cheeky, trying so hard to discredit the accuser by digging into what she does. The conversation between her and LH so far seemed genuine as no dispute on that. So what would it change even if the accuser has anything wrongdoing outside this conversation ? Isn't the subject of the debate is the conversation itself? What's the intention trying to deacrit the accusing side by something irrelevant to the subject itself???

It's like a domestic abuse victim is told she doesn't have the right to complain if she committed wrongdoings in her personal affair outside the household.

Why do you try so hard to defend LH?

stuntbubbles · 13/12/2022 07:50

I’m not reading that long rambling mess, which is suspect is only that long because its author has padded it out with thereafter and heretofore. Appears not to present any evidence or information til about tweet 8; it just reads like lunatic stream of consciousness.

ReformedWaywardTeen · 13/12/2022 06:58

TooBigForMyBoots · 12/12/2022 20:27

Lady SH's racism to Ngozi Fulani was very much intentional.

For those who acted as cheerleader for Sistah Space after the Lady Hussey incident, you may wish to pop over to Twitter.

A twitter account (JustPikachoo) has gone into a huge deep dive on the woman involved, her family, and the quite interesting finances of the charity and it looks very much like she may regret all the publicity. The Charities Commission has been made aware along with Hackney council, the London Community Fund and Comic Relief and will no doubt have to launch an enquiry. And yes, the twitter account holder has a raft of evidence that was all in the public domain.

Seems the whole charity is little more than a questionable fraud.

The whole thread (it's long as it's fully proved) is here threadreaderapp.com/thread/1601735411860406274.html

TooBigForMyBoots · 12/12/2022 20:27

Lady SH's racism to Ngozi Fulani was very much intentional.

Mezmer · 12/12/2022 19:45

I just don’t believe that hating someone because they have a certain skin colour is as prevalent as believed. Most friction is because of cultural not racial differences. Institutions are set up to serve historical British hierarchy and are not purposefully hostile to different cultures, they are like it symptomatically. Maybe it’s important to realise that it works all ways. Cultures generally don’t tolerate different cultures very well. That’s different from racism where tribalism comes into force solely because someone looks different from you. There was nothing wrong with what Hussey said in those circumstances. NOT asking her where she was from could have been seen as rude, or ignoring her, or overlooking her evident desire to promote her African sentiments. To say it is is taking a hostile stance by failing to give someone the benefit of the doubt, which in this context came down to the fact that a person from one race or background is not allowed to say certain things to another. You can deconstruct anything you like and build it up again in a narrative that suits your cause. I agree there is racism but mainly it’s culture wars. You can’t change your race but you can choose your culture.

Dahliasandtea · 12/12/2022 10:16

Mezmer · 11/12/2022 21:22

On the whole the majority of UK people are NOT racist and I find it incredibly insulting to insinuate that an entire nation is. There are of course fringes of dreadful racists and people who are gunning to stir up violence and hatred and these people drag the entire country downward. This small minority is making everyone completely paranoid so that innocent things are getting twisted in the wrong way to be sinister. Similarly racism from the minority is being used to drive forward agendas from other small and very vocal groups and this is being used against normal UK citizens of all races and backgrounds in a way that is toxic and divisive.

I think you need to make sure you make the distinction between individual racism and institutionalised racism. One skinhead waving a St. George’s Cross screaming p**i go home is an extreme case of individual racism and no I don’t think anyone would say that the UK is filled with people this. But the UK does have a real problem with individual and casual and probably unintentional racism….. (Lady Hussey gave us a good example…) and also institutionalised racism…. Which has been well documented.
reading works like White Fragility and How to be an Antiracist helps one understand how racism is embedded so deeply in society and the psyche of a nation that it’s hard to actually identify it. It’s so commonplace and so part of our daily lives and basic functioning that people can’t see it and when it’s highlighted cannot accept it.

phoenixrosehere · 12/12/2022 10:13

toffeecrisps · 12/12/2022 09:59

Who exactly said that everyone in the country is racist?

No one, but simply posing the question about racism specifically in the UK causes outrage when it’s not even said.

I believe that people CAN NOT be racist but say racist things without realising it (through upbringing, the way society phrases things, history, etc) but even saying that, it doesn’t take away the harm it does to those effected. Overtly, covertly, it still has an effect and some becomes so pervasive that certain things are simply accepted and causing harm to undeserved people.

toffeecrisps · 12/12/2022 09:59

Mezmer · 11/12/2022 21:22

On the whole the majority of UK people are NOT racist and I find it incredibly insulting to insinuate that an entire nation is. There are of course fringes of dreadful racists and people who are gunning to stir up violence and hatred and these people drag the entire country downward. This small minority is making everyone completely paranoid so that innocent things are getting twisted in the wrong way to be sinister. Similarly racism from the minority is being used to drive forward agendas from other small and very vocal groups and this is being used against normal UK citizens of all races and backgrounds in a way that is toxic and divisive.

Who exactly said that everyone in the country is racist?

TooBigForMyBoots · 12/12/2022 00:51

Racism is definitely a problem for the UK. It's a problem wherever it exists. Because it is illogical, unjust and shit for the society that tolerates it.🤷‍♀️

Mezmer · 11/12/2022 21:22

On the whole the majority of UK people are NOT racist and I find it incredibly insulting to insinuate that an entire nation is. There are of course fringes of dreadful racists and people who are gunning to stir up violence and hatred and these people drag the entire country downward. This small minority is making everyone completely paranoid so that innocent things are getting twisted in the wrong way to be sinister. Similarly racism from the minority is being used to drive forward agendas from other small and very vocal groups and this is being used against normal UK citizens of all races and backgrounds in a way that is toxic and divisive.

Sausagenbacon · 10/12/2022 10:37

When I visited India,it was very noticeable what an enormous market for skin lightening creams there were.

SallyWD · 10/12/2022 10:27

TruckerBarbie · 10/12/2022 09:55

But you must know that Sikhs and Muslims don't always get along?

My DH and family are all Indian Hindus. My DH is not racist but I've heard dreadful racism from his wider family. They seem very anti-muslim and send us awful BNP type videos about the "Muslim problem" in the UK. They also look down on black people (of African heritage) and I've experienced racism as a white person in India. One of my DH's more enlightened cousins told me that India is the most racist country on earth! I'm please to report that the Indians I now in the UK are NOT like this.

Simonjt · 10/12/2022 10:22

TruckerBarbie · 10/12/2022 09:55

But you must know that Sikhs and Muslims don't always get along?

As a Sikh, who grew up in a multi-faith household with family friends etc on both faith sides, not really a huge issue. It isn’t a Sikh v Muslim thing, its an issue of control over land, it isn’t about religion. And obviously as us Sikhs and Muslims are humans, we don’t all get along, just as not all Sikhs get along with all other Sikhs.

MassiveSaladWithChristmasTrimmings · 10/12/2022 10:10

It depends on you define racism.

If it is now acceptable to call I'm a Celebrity racist because the first people voted out were black, then yes it is.

If it is now not acceptable to make a perfectly valid negative point about a black person because it is judged that racism must be the driving force behind it, then yes it is.

I don't think either of these examples are racist and yet they have been held up to be so.

So, it seems to me that the bar for racism is being set lower and lower and as it becomes more so then everyone will be accused of racism-there will be no way in which to avoid it.

A bit like many of the supporters/instigators behind the French Revolution or The Russian Revolution-eventually they were executed because it became easier and easier to find some way in which they had transgressed.

It matters because in the end-when everyone is accused or accuses themselves of racism (individuals or institutions)-no-one will pay any heed to these accusations. It is an unpalatable fact but this is already happening.

There are already cartoons and jokes going around using the Sacha Baron Cohen punchline, "Is it because I is black?"

I have heard this line from people in a private capacity who, in their public capacity, sing exactly the opposite line.

So no, in a real sense I don't think this is a racist country BUT if the bar for defining a racist continues to drop then it will be portrayed as such and there will be very very few who will never find themselves in breach of such a low bar.

TruckerBarbie · 10/12/2022 09:55

Simonjt · 10/12/2022 07:21

Never experienced any racism from anyone of Indian heritage, or while in India.

But you must know that Sikhs and Muslims don't always get along?

Simonjt · 10/12/2022 08:28

Sausagenbacon · 10/12/2022 08:07

Try working for an Indian company and you'll see some real racism. They're much more racist about Pakistanis than most whites would ever dare be.
This
Or try working in a factory alongside East Europeans. That's a eye opener.

Done exactly that, not a problem (weighing cooked pasta also gets very old very quickly).

Sausagenbacon · 10/12/2022 08:27

That's true

RocketIceLollie · 10/12/2022 08:25

The UK, and the world, has a problem of outrage obsessed social media and a media who like to create news rather than report news. Social media and the media in general just likes to create division today.

Sausagenbacon · 10/12/2022 08:21

As this is the nth thread on this, and they always go the same way I.e. any poster who disagrees with the OP is racist, what is the point of them? It seems to be the same posters (including me, I know) coming on again and again and nothing changing.
I suppose it's the replacement for the eternal Brexit boards.

Sausagenbacon · 10/12/2022 08:07

Try working for an Indian company and you'll see some real racism. They're much more racist about Pakistanis than most whites would ever dare be.
This
Or try working in a factory alongside East Europeans. That's a eye opener.

Prettypissedoff88 · 10/12/2022 07:36

‘Would ever dare be’

I think that says it’s all.

racism isn’t always an active choice. That’s why a country or a system becomes or remains racist. Obviously you have no concept of this.