Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Does the UK have a racism problem?

556 replies

JolllyBee · 30/11/2022 20:43

In just the last 24 hours alone we've had in the news:

Prince William’s godmother quits palace over comments to black charity boss

Meghan Markle had several 'disgusting' and credible threats to her life, Met cop reveals

Various people's census rants going viral and getting a scary amount of support

James McAvoy shocked by hometown racism in Glasgow after castmates abused on street

and a few days prior:

London Fire Brigade houses a toxic culture of bullying, racism and misogyny, inquiry finds

OP posts:
Mardyface · 01/12/2022 16:56

TruckerBarbie · 01/12/2022 16:51

Well, yes I understand that. But Africa, for example, features prominently in the worst offenders for modern slavery with Africans still being the people most at risk of being enslaved. It's arguably a bit rich to be moaning about the transgressions committed by other nations several hundred years ago when your home territory is still one of the worst offenders.

I think you need to be a bit clearer about which group of people is 'moaning' and what you mean by 'home country' here for me to even enter into a discussion about it. Which actually I'm not going to because whatever else this line of argument may be, it's definitely whataboutery and so I don't think that stands as a valid argument.

JudgeJ · 01/12/2022 16:55

Just don't be racist. Why do you need to make a statement about it at all? If you have to say that you aren't racist it's usually to excuse something racist.

Love the stupidity of that last sentence, it's akin to my saying I am not a murderer, hence I must be a murderer.
Because this site does not allow honest discussion on this topic it's really a pointless thread, anyone whose views don't tick the self-determined boxes is 'racist', it's an extreme position that causes more harm than good.

Tillow4ever · 01/12/2022 16:53

SantaCarlaCalifornia · 01/12/2022 15:40

Is there a way that someone can say they're not racist without it being a signal that they're racist?

No need to say you aren’t racist at all. Just don’t be racist. If you have to tell people you aren’t, you are doing it to virtue signal. Or you are racist but you’re trying to defend something racist you just said or did.

TruckerBarbie · 01/12/2022 16:51

Mardyface · 01/12/2022 16:44

In addition when you're talking about slavery that happened hundreds of years ago you are also being ruled over by an aristocratic class whose family money was earned by selling other people. Surely you can understand that might be a bit galling if you are a person whose family was sold and the profits are still being used by people who think they have a God-given right to it? It should be galling to everyone even if it doesn't apply to you.

Well, yes I understand that. But Africa, for example, features prominently in the worst offenders for modern slavery with Africans still being the people most at risk of being enslaved. It's arguably a bit rich to be moaning about the transgressions committed by other nations several hundred years ago when your home territory is still one of the worst offenders.

Allthegoodnamesarechosen · 01/12/2022 16:51

Tooshytoshine · 30/11/2022 21:25

I married a child of an immigrant. She is a well respected doctor (as are her immigrant parents). We now have British children. Should they feel guilt for being children of immigrants or are they British enough for you (as the arbiter of all that is right and good in the world)?

Pretty confident there have been more than 1/2 a million immigrants over the millennia. I mean the Picts, the Anglo Saxons, vikings, not to mention the Romans...

500, O00 in ONE Year.

The other examples you choose : Vikings, Romans etc were all invaders and military conquerors ( except possibly the Picts, no one really knows about them since they were illiterate), so quite different from modern immigrants.

Mardyface · 01/12/2022 16:49

TruckerBarbie · 01/12/2022 16:46

If you're going to try and pretend that you've never heard people moaning about the BE then I'm not going to waste my time digging up examples. It's extremely common on here. Pretty sure there was mention in this very thread.

Of course I'm not suggesting people don't 'moan about' the British Empire. If you're talking about Mumsnet people are probably more interested in the BE rather than other ones because this is a British website?

TruckerBarbie · 01/12/2022 16:46

Mardyface · 01/12/2022 16:41

The British Empire gets demonised more than other empires by whom TruckerBarbie? Could it just be that you are in Britain so you notice?

If you're going to try and pretend that you've never heard people moaning about the BE then I'm not going to waste my time digging up examples. It's extremely common on here. Pretty sure there was mention in this very thread.

Mardyface · 01/12/2022 16:44

In addition when you're talking about slavery that happened hundreds of years ago you are also being ruled over by an aristocratic class whose family money was earned by selling other people. Surely you can understand that might be a bit galling if you are a person whose family was sold and the profits are still being used by people who think they have a God-given right to it? It should be galling to everyone even if it doesn't apply to you.

Mardyface · 01/12/2022 16:41

TruckerBarbie · 01/12/2022 16:31

I sometimes wonder why the British Empire gets demonised so much more than the Spanish Empire, Persian Empire, and all the many other empires that were comparable but just less successful - I've no doubt they'd have been happy to do the same as the BE had they been able.

Same with slavery. There are now almost 4x the number of slaves in the world than were traded over the whole 400 years of the African slave slave trade. Not one country in the top ten is a western country and Russia is the only majority white country.

All slavery is abhorrent but not all slavery is called out. In fact, the bulk of it is ignored in favour of focusing on what happened hundreds of years ago. It's odd.

The British Empire gets demonised more than other empires by whom TruckerBarbie? Could it just be that you are in Britain so you notice?

TruckerBarbie · 01/12/2022 16:31

I sometimes wonder why the British Empire gets demonised so much more than the Spanish Empire, Persian Empire, and all the many other empires that were comparable but just less successful - I've no doubt they'd have been happy to do the same as the BE had they been able.

Same with slavery. There are now almost 4x the number of slaves in the world than were traded over the whole 400 years of the African slave slave trade. Not one country in the top ten is a western country and Russia is the only majority white country.

All slavery is abhorrent but not all slavery is called out. In fact, the bulk of it is ignored in favour of focusing on what happened hundreds of years ago. It's odd.

feellikeanalien · 01/12/2022 16:16

phoenixrosehere · 01/12/2022 16:00

Don’t think anyone is saying that. Often many Brits on here seem to think as long as they’re not as bad as the States, they’re doing well when actually that’s a ridiculous thought process and makes too many ok with the level of racism because it seemingly not that bad as other countries.

I’ve lived in both the US and the UK for over a decade and the covert racism and the casualness of it in the UK is worse than what I’ve experienced and seen on top of the deniability that there is an issue to begin with. Also, summing it up as an effor to create division between black and white is even more ridiculous considering the many reports of racism in many sectors against anyone who doesn’t “look” British which seemingly means anyone who is not white.

My post was in reply to this one. For some reason the quote disappeared.

feellikeanalien · 01/12/2022 16:15

I'm not saying that having less racism than in other countries makes it ok. Racism is never acceptable. I also wasn't saying that speaking up about it is trying to cause division. Simply that some people manipulate the issue of racism to create division.

SantaCarlaCalifornia · 01/12/2022 16:11

WhoHasMovedMyBrain · 01/12/2022 15:50

Just don't be racist. Why do you need to make a statement about it at all? If you have to say that you aren't racist it's usually to excuse something racist.

I agree, that's why I side-eye anyone that makes pronouncements of being anti-racist.

santaslay · 01/12/2022 16:04

The UK is definitely still racist- but not just the UK. The world is racist

The UK is actually less racist than some countries ( looking at you Italy / Germany / USA etc)

phoenixrosehere · 01/12/2022 16:00

feellikeanalien · 01/12/2022 14:26

The UK does not have a much worse problem with racism than any other countries. I lived in southern Europe for 16 years and the racism towards black people was open and quite shocking.

I think though that there is a certain element in the UK who like to emphasise the racism here and I have a feeling that the intention behind that is to create division. You can see that it is starting to work.

There obviously is racism in the UK as in any country but I do have a feeling that the narrative of the UK being the most awful racist country in the world is being manipulated to create division between black and white.

Don’t think anyone is saying that. Often many Brits on here seem to think as long as they’re not as bad as the States, they’re doing well when actually that’s a ridiculous thought process and makes too many ok with the level of racism because it seemingly not that bad as other countries.

I’ve lived in both the US and the UK for over a decade and the covert racism and the casualness of it in the UK is worse than what I’ve experienced and seen on top of the deniability that there is an issue to begin with. Also, summing it up as an effor to create division between black and white is even more ridiculous considering the many reports of racism in many sectors against anyone who doesn’t “look” British which seemingly means anyone who is not white.

WhoHasMovedMyBrain · 01/12/2022 15:50

SantaCarlaCalifornia · 01/12/2022 15:40

Is there a way that someone can say they're not racist without it being a signal that they're racist?

Just don't be racist. Why do you need to make a statement about it at all? If you have to say that you aren't racist it's usually to excuse something racist.

WhoHasMovedMyBrain · 01/12/2022 15:48

feellikeanalien · 01/12/2022 14:26

The UK does not have a much worse problem with racism than any other countries. I lived in southern Europe for 16 years and the racism towards black people was open and quite shocking.

I think though that there is a certain element in the UK who like to emphasise the racism here and I have a feeling that the intention behind that is to create division. You can see that it is starting to work.

There obviously is racism in the UK as in any country but I do have a feeling that the narrative of the UK being the most awful racist country in the world is being manipulated to create division between black and white.

The UK is not the most racist country but it has racism. Enough to make me uncomfortable once in a while and enough to worry that my children will encounter it at some point.

Why should I accept any racism at all? Why should I agree that it's ok to be treated badly because of the colour of my skin once in a while? Why should I be grateful that there is just some racism and that it's not worse? That's not good enough.

I'll tell you something else. I have lived in a few countries. They all had racism and it's always unpleasant. However, in my experience other countries have more overt racism and the British are more subtle about it (like lady hussey).

SantaCarlaCalifornia · 01/12/2022 15:40

Tillow4ever · 01/12/2022 12:36

Further back on this thread, someone asked if racists would admit that are racist. Or if they know they are.

There are a number of posters on this thread that clearly demonstrate that they absolutely would not admit they are racist - far, far too many posts that are essentially "I'm not racist but..." Note to you all - if you ever think or say that, you are racist.

Sadly it seems so ingrained in them they will not listen to it being called out, hold their hands up and say something like "I'm sorry, I'll do better" and then actually work on themselves. Which means they genuinely don't think there's anything wrong with their behaviour or words.

To all those who have ever suffered racism, I'm truly sorry you've had to experience that and can only hope that one day this will be so few and far between, it will be considered a fringe view (I can't imagine we'll ever eradicate it completely).

Is there a way that someone can say they're not racist without it being a signal that they're racist?

JudgeJ · 01/12/2022 14:44

BippityBopper · 30/11/2022 21:04

Why ask the question? The answer is obvious.

As does every single country I've ever lived in, it's not unique to the UK, people are so naive!

PlinkPlonkFizz · 01/12/2022 14:43

Definitely it does, based on the Empire and a superiority complex. Not just skin colour racism either, there's the idea of those "Funny Irish people" and potatoes jokes which I heard in my family growing up.

1 million people starved to death in the mid 19th century and were scraping an existence based on eating potatoes, as a result of the legacy of the Penal Laws that forbade education and primogeniture, not innate ignorance. I couldn't believe it when I first read about the famine, it's definitely not taught in our schools. My eyes were opened by an Irish friend.

Bonnylassie · 01/12/2022 14:39

Squeezita · 01/12/2022 07:17

She could have just as I said say "I was born in Britain and based in Hackney, my parents are from..."

Yes OF COURSE! The black person is at fault for not submitting submissively to her interrogation. How dare she get uppity about being questioned by white aristocracy!

We are not puppets. We don’t have to answer your rude questions to satisfy your rude curiously.

As for the rest of your garbage about Ms Fulani accepting the invite - I think the police are institutionally racist but I still have to contact them when I need them. Just because we see the shit doesn’t mean we can always avoid it.

I was talking to my ten year mixed raced child about this and she said, but I would say I'm Scottish. Why would I say I'm Scottish, my parents are English, some of my grandparents come from England some from Jamaica. She can see I'm brown she doesn't need to know anything else about me.

feellikeanalien · 01/12/2022 14:26

The UK does not have a much worse problem with racism than any other countries. I lived in southern Europe for 16 years and the racism towards black people was open and quite shocking.

I think though that there is a certain element in the UK who like to emphasise the racism here and I have a feeling that the intention behind that is to create division. You can see that it is starting to work.

There obviously is racism in the UK as in any country but I do have a feeling that the narrative of the UK being the most awful racist country in the world is being manipulated to create division between black and white.

DailyMaui · 01/12/2022 14:01

That's really quite frightening! What decade was this? Britain is such a diverse place, people can have an entirely different experience of it depending on their postcode.

HI Pops - we moved in the late seventies. But the extreme views were still happening when I finally left in the late eighties. They used to Zeil Heil at QPR matches too... my granddad couldn't believe his eyes when he saw them do it. He'd fought actual Nazis and here were white English men and women saluting as Nazis. They hated everyone who wasn't "born and bred English."

What makes it worse as this estate was down the road from Ladbroke Grove. The whole area was so multicultural - it could have been a fantastic place to live. And we were in this little enclave of hate.

Peedoffo · 01/12/2022 13:51

I do think there's a subtle racism, like for instance the media , there's been a big hype for more diversity sadly it's just two ethnic groups. White and Black. I have not seen any east Asian heritage actors portrayed in the media or if they are they usually play a stereotype good at martial arts , sexy exotic or takeaway owners. It's sad there's no UK TV shows my DD can watch which have a person with her heritage. We watch a lot of stuff from abroad.

I think east Asians suffer from prejudice they are portrayed as "good" immigrants who don't complain , integrate but are completely invisible from media etc as a consequence. It would be nice for more east Asians to speak out about the lack of representation.

Juniperising · 01/12/2022 13:50

Obviously the UK has a race issue, if you white and are not practicing self flagellation and ashamed of your ansestry your racist now days, but its not racist to abuse white people its a one way street.

Win win 🙄