Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

For asking for my money back

61 replies

Moneyowed2021 · 30/11/2022 19:58

I should start with, this is mostly historical. But I’m trying to understand if I’ve done something wrong. Or if I should have done something wrong… (named changed because this is outing!)

so. I’ve been friends with A for almost 20 years. We have a small group of friends and even though we’re in different places in life we’ve always stayed fairly close.

Last year we all went on holiday. B did the maths wrong and at the last minute needed everyone to pay about £200 more per head.

A struggles with money. She rarely has any to spare and I can appreciate that may be difficult. However, for as long as I’ve known her she’s spent her money on things I can’t understand: multiple concert tickets for the same tour, makeup, etc etc.

I don’t struggle as much. I’m in a well paid job and my dad died unexpectedly when I was younger so I have a small inheritance. I appreciate I’m lucky to sometimes have the money I do have and I have a lovely home and life (although I would give most of it up for a second longer with Dad, but that’s a different point…) However, I budget extremely carefully, I rarely buy anything expensive.

I do, however, think that A has an idea I’m rich, because I have historically been happy to buy a round of drinks etc without any complaints or needing to split, etc.

so, back to the holiday. A couldn’t afford the extra amount so I offered to pay so she could still go. This was last year. July I think. I think she paid back a small amount, maybe £50, in September ish.

Since then. I had a baby in March- she briefly said she knew she owed me some money and I said not to worry about it for now. Nothing since.

Last month I messaged what I thought was a very nice message just saying “sorry, I know it’s a bit awkward, but you still owe me X. Can you figure out if you can pay me back before the end of the year? Let me know if it’s an issue.” Or something along those lines. She didn’t reply, but did transfer the money. So I said thank you. I was quite stunned to not have any message saying “sorry it’s taken so long” or any acknowledgement at all. It all felt quite passive aggressive.

Meanwhile, we’re planning a friend’s birthday party next year- it’s a big one. I’ve paid for the accommodation upfront, as well as for a meal. A has agreed to the price per head at all times. When I paid for the meal last month, a friend asked when I wanted everyone to start paying their shares. I’d paid most of it in August.

I figured out 50% per head and asked if everyone could maybe pay that chunk before Christmas. A piped up that she thought it was “short sighted” (in November) to ask people to pay anything before Christmas. I should add, we’re talking £60. It felt very pointed and directed at me - we still hadn’t (haven’t) spoken since I said thank you for the money. I left it that those who could pay, can, but if it’s not possible then it’s fine to wait.

I’ve since found out that A messaged B back when I asked her for the money and effectively said how awful I was for asking for money when she didn’t have any. Bearing in mind she’d just bought some very expensive earrings which cost over £400.

I’m just so upset that she seems to somehow think I’m the bad guy for asking for my money back. She seems to be going to other friends and trying to get them “on side” and they don’t seem to be biting but equally aren’t standing up for me either.

It seems to be absolutely immaterial to her that I have a young baby, on SMP, and that I also have to pay for Christmas too. And now I have to see her at the party which she still owes me for…!

it sounds dramatic but I’m really quite devastated that a friend would treat me this way.

So, mumsnet, was I unreasonable? Or have I missed something where i may have been unreasonable? Or is she just a CF who hoped I wouldn’t remember what she owes me?

OP posts:
Butitsnotfunnyisititsserious · 01/12/2022 08:55

Maybe it’s just me, but even if I thought someone didn’t “need” the money, I’d still want to pay people back the money I owe…

OP that's how decent people should behave. She knew she owed you money, if she didn't budget paying you back rather than buying herself jewellery, that's her problem. I wouldn't lend anymore to her in future. She doesn't come across as grateful

Peashoots · 01/12/2022 08:55

Of course You aren’t being unreasonable OP. She’s a cheeky cow and if she’s splashing the cash in your group chat, other people will see her exactly for what she is. I would be mortified in her place.

Moneyowed2021 · 01/12/2022 08:53

PissPotPourri · 01/12/2022 08:48

You say you haven’t spoken with her since she paid back the money, yet know she has new earrings and how much they cost? How do you know and are you sure about this? If the info has come from a friend, are you sure it’s correct and the friend isn’t stirring?

The earrings were two weeks ish before I asked for the money back. Also we’re on a group chat and she mentioned there.

she then went on to plead poverty to B when I asked for the money.

OP posts:
TinkyWinkyRainbowHead · 01/12/2022 08:48

I’m not sure why you’re not learning that your friend is a free loader. Also, don’t ever pay for things up front for people. You need to set a date that people pay you and then you buy that many tickets. No arguments and you’re never out of pocket.

PissPotPourri · 01/12/2022 08:48

You say you haven’t spoken with her since she paid back the money, yet know she has new earrings and how much they cost? How do you know and are you sure about this? If the info has come from a friend, are you sure it’s correct and the friend isn’t stirring?

Iamtheonwandlonely · 01/12/2022 08:40

She sounds like one of these people that get to a lend but hate paying it back.
I think the only thing going forward is not to pay for things for her.
She doesn't have the money,she doesn't go.

Moneyowed2021 · 01/12/2022 08:32

Ineedsleepandcoffee · 30/11/2022 22:51

I think you are confusing what it is to be kind. You are giving people the impression that you don't need the money but then seen to be upset that they don't realise that you do need the money

Maybe it’s just me, but even if I thought someone didn’t “need” the money, I’d still want to pay people back the money I owe…

OP posts:
Moneyowed2021 · 01/12/2022 08:31

SliceOfCakeCupOfTea · 01/12/2022 08:13

But I thought you said she mentioned paying you back and you said not to worry?

I'm not saying you should just grind through, but I would have asked for the money by the end of october so I could include that money in my budget, or even September if you thought there might be an issue getting it back in time.

Not quite. She said she knew that she owed me money. She said she felt bad about owing it to me and that she felt terrible and that she intended to pay me when she got a bonus she was due.

I told her not to worry about it, ie not to feel terrible. But I definitely didn’t say “never worry about how much you owe me.”

OP posts:
SliceOfCakeCupOfTea · 01/12/2022 08:13

Moneyowed2021 · 30/11/2022 22:16

But she didn’t try to pay back? She said she would, she didn’t.
I’m also budgeting through those months, that’s why I could do with the monies owed paid back. I can’t see why there’s such a double standard where I’m meant to take the hit over the festive period, and somehow it’s rude to ask for monies owed then…?

But I thought you said she mentioned paying you back and you said not to worry?

I'm not saying you should just grind through, but I would have asked for the money by the end of october so I could include that money in my budget, or even September if you thought there might be an issue getting it back in time.

Ineedsleepandcoffee · 30/11/2022 22:51

I think you are confusing what it is to be kind. You are giving people the impression that you don't need the money but then seen to be upset that they don't realise that you do need the money

DelilahsHaven · 30/11/2022 22:49

My friends and I have opened a bank account to save up for trips away but putting a monthky amount in, which has worked quite well. We've taken it in turns to be in charge of an account, so that it isn't all down to the same person to organised everything. I think PayPal have a kitty function too.

CantFindTheBeat · 30/11/2022 22:23

OP,

You are casual with lending money and that sends mixed messages to some people.

You know your friend is shit with prioritising spends and budget. From your messages, it's been clear for a long time.

Yet you still enable her.

You need to get your own boundaries clear. You say to her 'no worries, in your own time', etc, and then you bubble in anger that it's not repaid in the timeframe you've internalised.

She's treating you like an older sister who's job it is to bail her out, because you've give yourself that role.

Step away from that.

Moneyowed2021 · 30/11/2022 22:16

SliceOfCakeCupOfTea · 30/11/2022 22:06

Yeah I would never ask for money back in November/December/January unless I was desperate. I budget to get through these months so I would be upset especially if I'd tried to pay back earlier on.
That said, she should have paid back asap whether you said don't worry or not.

But she didn’t try to pay back? She said she would, she didn’t.
I’m also budgeting through those months, that’s why I could do with the monies owed paid back. I can’t see why there’s such a double standard where I’m meant to take the hit over the festive period, and somehow it’s rude to ask for monies owed then…?

OP posts:
Moneyowed2021 · 30/11/2022 22:13

Blueberrywitch · 30/11/2022 22:11

YANBU and you’re not being too casual about it! I pay upfront for things all the time and don’t give strict payment times, my friends usually pay me back fairly quickly and I send a quick text reminder if not. Sometimes they pay for things for me upfront and I can be slow at paying back as I am bad at admin, if they chase I apologise profusely and pay ASAP.

However, just to make you feel better, I once went away with a group and one of my friends bought a friend as a plus one - the so called friend never paid my friend back for a few bills that she covered at the time and also…. never spoke to her again - it was almost £1000!! She lived overseas and she has literally just disappeared off the face of the earth to avoid paying my friend back. So, some people are just really weird about money.

Thank you! This sounds much more how my friends and I organise things. I don’t feel like we need to formalise times to pay back etc as I’ve never had an issue before.
oh that does make me feel better. Maybe some people just are different about money!

OP posts:
Blueberrywitch · 30/11/2022 22:11

YANBU and you’re not being too casual about it! I pay upfront for things all the time and don’t give strict payment times, my friends usually pay me back fairly quickly and I send a quick text reminder if not. Sometimes they pay for things for me upfront and I can be slow at paying back as I am bad at admin, if they chase I apologise profusely and pay ASAP.

However, just to make you feel better, I once went away with a group and one of my friends bought a friend as a plus one - the so called friend never paid my friend back for a few bills that she covered at the time and also…. never spoke to her again - it was almost £1000!! She lived overseas and she has literally just disappeared off the face of the earth to avoid paying my friend back. So, some people are just really weird about money.

Moneyowed2021 · 30/11/2022 22:10

Clymene · 30/11/2022 22:04

Is she single? Is she happy about it?
Do you think she's resentful that you (presumably) have a partner and a baby etc. and so in her mind your life is easier?

Yes single, not happily. I don’t know if it’s resentment but there definitely is an underlying idea from her that I have everything and she doesn’t. I think that’s partly why I’m always keen to make sure she feels included and isn’t upset - not guilt, but more I don’t want to make her feel worse?

OP posts:
SliceOfCakeCupOfTea · 30/11/2022 22:06

Yeah I would never ask for money back in November/December/January unless I was desperate. I budget to get through these months so I would be upset especially if I'd tried to pay back earlier on.
That said, she should have paid back asap whether you said don't worry or not.

Moneyowed2021 · 30/11/2022 22:05

Sorry @MelchiorsMistress I realise my last reply was sarky.

I suppose my issue with people saying how expensive Christmas is, is that it’s also expensive for me. And it’s been almost a year and a half of this money being owed. So (mixed messages aside) am I meant to just take the hit over Christmas, because someone else hasn’t got the manners to offer to pay money owed?

thank you @momtoboys I think it’s helpful to have that perspective! I don’t necessarily want to not be her friend, if I can get over the hurt of it…

OP posts:
Clymene · 30/11/2022 22:04

Is she single? Is she happy about it?
Do you think she's resentful that you (presumably) have a partner and a baby etc. and so in her mind your life is easier?

momtoboys · 30/11/2022 21:59

You are not being unreasonable wanting or asking for your money back. However, could you maybe just ring her and say "I feel like things have been awkward between us since I asked you for my money and I hope it won't come between us" or something similar. 20 years of friendship is a long time.

RunningFromInsanity · 30/11/2022 21:59

You said not to worry ‘for now’ and then decided it should be paid back at the most expensive time of the year.
I think this is the main issue, plus asking for the next lot of money before Xmas too.

But if she can afford £400 earrings then that changes it I suppose.

Moneyowed2021 · 30/11/2022 21:57

MelchiorsMistress · 30/11/2022 21:23

she briefly said she knew she owed me some money and I said not to worry about it for now.

Something went wrong around this time in the story. Was there some particular thing that meant it would have been difficult for her to pay at that time? Tbh, while she should have made sure she paid it back no matter what you said, I can see why she’s struggling now. You said not to worry ‘for now’ and then decided it should be paid back at the most expensive time of the year.

Honestly? I had just had a baby and it wasn’t at the top of my list. She said she was aware she owed me money, felt terrible about it, but would pay me back when she was paid some big bonus she was owed and that she wanted to sort it asap. I said, thanks, but don’t worry or get upset about not having paid it. The “don’t worry” was less a “never pay” and more a “don’t feel terrible about not having paid.” Or at least that’s what was intended.
also, is early November the most expensive time of the year? When does the normal year end and the Christmas-is-expensive-nothing-else-can-be-paid- time begin?

OP posts:
MissMisss · 30/11/2022 21:53

Shes a cheeky friend. Top and bottom of it. Lends money hoping to not pay it back. Regardless if you've gave mixed messages or not, shes tried to get away without paying you.

In future I would say:
Yes sure I'll throw it all on my card so here's my bank details and once I have all the money in I'll make payment.

MelchiorsMistress · 30/11/2022 21:23

she briefly said she knew she owed me some money and I said not to worry about it for now.

Something went wrong around this time in the story. Was there some particular thing that meant it would have been difficult for her to pay at that time? Tbh, while she should have made sure she paid it back no matter what you said, I can see why she’s struggling now. You said not to worry ‘for now’ and then decided it should be paid back at the most expensive time of the year.

Moneyowed2021 · 30/11/2022 21:13

Thanks everyone, definitely some good points here… I don’t think I’m going to stop being kind or changing how I do things too much.

@CoffeeMama1 ’s points are especially helpful to me - if she’s not prioritising these things then it’s not my role to make sure she can go… She’s just historically been very upset about being left out and I want to avoid the drama. But here I am in drama anyway! So I will be trying not to worry if she can’t or won’t take part…

Thank you all!

OP posts: