Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Racism in the Royal Family

593 replies

StoneofDestiny · 30/11/2022 19:06

Susan Hussey has resigned. Philip was coming out with similar comments in public all his life, yet there was no move to get rid of him. AIBU to think this is more royal hypocrisy?

OP posts:
TooBigForMyBoots · 30/11/2022 22:12

Hills2022 · 30/11/2022 21:44

You must be extremely disappointed that a big event put on to raise the profile of and focus on VAWG has been completely overshadowed by a furore started on twitter. Such a missed opportunity

I disagree. Most people wouldn't even have known about the event. And people are now donating to Sistah Space.

I'm glad Ngozi Fulani spoke out. As the Palace said Racism has no place in our society.

Hills2022 · 30/11/2022 22:11

Backstreetsbackalrightdadada · 30/11/2022 22:07

But as others have said here, with their personal experience, there’s a big difference between someone taking genuine interest in your heritage and someone basically asking “why are you black and why are you here”. The retelling of the conversation is clear as to which this is. Hussey has not rebutted the account. Buck Palace has condemned her words. Hussey wasn’t clumsy and ill advised, her questions are repeated, pointed and she reiterates her real point (believing - despite correction - that Fulani isn’t British). What she said was racist.

By comparison, Fulani has said per the Beeb that she “was in shock after it happened and anybody who knows me knows I don't take this kind of nonsense,"
"But I had to consider so many things. As a black person, I found myself in this place where I wanted to say something but what happened would automatically be seen as my fault, it would bring [my charity] Sistah Space down. It would be 'oh, she has a chip on their shoulder'." Incredibly sad and a shit night for what should have been a focus on DV and the work charities like Sistah Space do.

I don't need you to agree with me. You asked me what I thought, you have a different view. The difference is you seem to think your opinion is fact, whereas I am well aware that my opinion is just that, an opinion.

lollipoprainbow · 30/11/2022 22:09

What's Camilla had to say on the subject considering it was her event ??

StoneofDestiny · 30/11/2022 22:09

I would like to ask, without prejudice, how any white person politely asks a POC where their family originated without the question being regarded as racist? I would genuinely like to know

Why would you ask that of someone you've just met, at a function they have been invited to and you are never likely to meet again? Surely questioning about people's background isn't first meeting stuff!
Besides - it wasn't a polite one off question, it was a harassing interrogation by a stranger.

OP posts:
Lifeomars · 30/11/2022 22:08

my mum raised me not to be racist, if she was still alive she would be in her 90's, age is no excuse. I have read the transcript of the conversation and found it appalling, no way would she have persisted with this line of questioning if Ngozi had been white. None of us who are white really have a clue about the constant micro aggressions that non white people face as they go about their lives. I was in a long-term relationship with a man of Jamaican heritage and believe you me we had some vile remarks addressed to us as a mixed race couple. When he talked to me about some of his lived experience and all the stuff you just have to let go of simply to get on with your life I used to wonder how anyone copes. Just one tiny example, when we travelled abroad we would always be pulled over by customs and our bags would be searched, now why would that be, it never happended when I flew alone or with a white companion. We live in a racist society, some of it is vile and blatant, a lot of it is equally vile but covert and subtle.

Sakura7 · 30/11/2022 22:07

YumSushi · 30/11/2022 22:03

What do you mean she wasn't answering the questions? Yes she was.

Her answers weren't good enough for Susan Hussey, or the racists in this thread.

The faux innocence is quite incredible too.

Several posters here should be ashamed, but I doubt they're capable of feeling such a thing.

Backstreetsbackalrightdadada · 30/11/2022 22:07

Hills2022 · 30/11/2022 21:58

As I said earlier in the thread, we don't know where the conversation went after that as it hasn't been reported. Fulani wasn't answering the questions she was IMO being disingenuous. I have not said I think she didn't say it, I don't agree that it was racist, but I do think it was clumsy and ill advised.

But as others have said here, with their personal experience, there’s a big difference between someone taking genuine interest in your heritage and someone basically asking “why are you black and why are you here”. The retelling of the conversation is clear as to which this is. Hussey has not rebutted the account. Buck Palace has condemned her words. Hussey wasn’t clumsy and ill advised, her questions are repeated, pointed and she reiterates her real point (believing - despite correction - that Fulani isn’t British). What she said was racist.

By comparison, Fulani has said per the Beeb that she “was in shock after it happened and anybody who knows me knows I don't take this kind of nonsense,"
"But I had to consider so many things. As a black person, I found myself in this place where I wanted to say something but what happened would automatically be seen as my fault, it would bring [my charity] Sistah Space down. It would be 'oh, she has a chip on their shoulder'." Incredibly sad and a shit night for what should have been a focus on DV and the work charities like Sistah Space do.

YumSushi · 30/11/2022 22:06

XingMing · 30/11/2022 22:01

SaySomethingMan · Today 21:37
XingMing · Today 21:30
I'm white so unlikely to be asked this question, but I would like to ask, without prejudice, how any white person politely asks a POC where their family originated without the question being regarded as racist? I would genuinely like to know. For the record, I live in the Celtic fringe.
Why do you want that information from a stranger? Why do you feel a stranger owes you that information?

I don't feel owed anything. Except that if as and when I meet a person, perhaps out walking my dog on moorland, which is how I meet most acquaintances, I do tend to ask how they found their way to this corner of the world. It's remote, there's not much employment, and it's poor, so what brought you here seems a good and neutral starting point for getting to know a person. It''s open and neutral, and if your answer is anything other than open and communicative, then I am a bit reserved.

Then ask something like "have you always lived on the moors - I've only been here xyz years myself"

HermioneKipper · 30/11/2022 22:05

As a mixed race person I can’t count the times people have asked me where I’m REALLY from. I’m English piss off

StoneofDestiny · 30/11/2022 22:05

I have been asked in a rural place (not England) who my people are, I never ever take offence to it, they are curious and interested. Wouldn't even cross my mind there was any discrimination

Oh come on, that's not what happened.

I'm a Scot. If I was asked where I'm from I'd say Scotland. If I was asked where I was really from, I'd say Glasgow. If I was pushed further, 'where are you really from, who are your people', I'd certainly feel bewildered, interrogated and certainly increasingly angry - as the implication would be I'm not Scottish or Glaswegian!
If said interrogator touched my hair..................

OP posts:
WimpoleHat · 30/11/2022 22:04

I would like to ask, without prejudice, how any white person politely asks a POC where their family originated without the question being regarded as racist? I would genuinely like to know.

It’s probably not a great question to someone you don’t know that well. You generally wouldn’t ask a white person where their family came from the first time you met them - so why wouldn’t you just accept an answer like “Hackney”? You tend to get more information about people naturally, as you get to know them better. Whatever their heritage or skin colour.

YumSushi · 30/11/2022 22:04

Americano75 · 30/11/2022 22:02

Exactly.

I felt so wretched for Ngozi Fulani, it wrecked the day for her.

Yes hopefully the King invites her to something else as a massive apology

YumSushi · 30/11/2022 22:03

Hills2022 · 30/11/2022 21:58

As I said earlier in the thread, we don't know where the conversation went after that as it hasn't been reported. Fulani wasn't answering the questions she was IMO being disingenuous. I have not said I think she didn't say it, I don't agree that it was racist, but I do think it was clumsy and ill advised.

What do you mean she wasn't answering the questions? Yes she was.

Americano75 · 30/11/2022 22:02

YumSushi · 30/11/2022 21:54

Funny isn't it, they couldn't silence the member of public.

Exactly.

I felt so wretched for Ngozi Fulani, it wrecked the day for her.

XingMing · 30/11/2022 22:01

SaySomethingMan · Today 21:37
XingMing · Today 21:30
I'm white so unlikely to be asked this question, but I would like to ask, without prejudice, how any white person politely asks a POC where their family originated without the question being regarded as racist? I would genuinely like to know. For the record, I live in the Celtic fringe.
Why do you want that information from a stranger? Why do you feel a stranger owes you that information?

I don't feel owed anything. Except that if as and when I meet a person, perhaps out walking my dog on moorland, which is how I meet most acquaintances, I do tend to ask how they found their way to this corner of the world. It's remote, there's not much employment, and it's poor, so what brought you here seems a good and neutral starting point for getting to know a person. It''s open and neutral, and if your answer is anything other than open and communicative, then I am a bit reserved.

MotherOfRatios · 30/11/2022 21:59

Hills2022 · 30/11/2022 21:44

You must be extremely disappointed that a big event put on to raise the profile of and focus on VAWG has been completely overshadowed by a furore started on twitter. Such a missed opportunity

It happens within the sector, there's a lot of racism within the sector check out www.endingracisminvawg.org

to me it's just another networking event just at a much posher place.

Hills2022 · 30/11/2022 21:58

Backstreetsbackalrightdadada · 30/11/2022 21:53

Why did Hussey not have anything to add, at all, to any of Fulani’s answers? Even when Hussey got the info she wanted, she wanted it for no reason - no interest in Fulani’s heritage at all. She pushed that Fulani was not British, even having been told she was. Hussey was not interested, not in any of the answers. And her approach and what she said was racist. Buckingham Palace has said it was unacceptable. Not sure why you’re defending her. She hasn’t denied it herself.

As I said earlier in the thread, we don't know where the conversation went after that as it hasn't been reported. Fulani wasn't answering the questions she was IMO being disingenuous. I have not said I think she didn't say it, I don't agree that it was racist, but I do think it was clumsy and ill advised.

HRTQueen · 30/11/2022 21:57

Jesus wept some of the answers in here

Though I’m not surprised it’s still hard for some to accept that being racist isn’t just about using insulting words

they certainly understand they just do not agree

Museya15 · 30/11/2022 21:57

I have been asked in a rural place (not England) who my people are, I never ever take offence to it, they are curious and interested. Wouldn't even cross my mind there was any discrimination.

ImperialLeather00 · 30/11/2022 21:56

As a black woman born in the UK, I’ve been asked questions like this my whole life.
I’m sick of it and brown people shouldn’t have to explain or justify their heritage.

People ask: Where are you from?
I say: london/UK

(This is where the question should stop).

They then say: no where are your parents from?
I say: London/UK as both were born here.
They then say: no you know what I mean where are you really from?

I used to go into my background but I don’t anymore as don’t need to as am British have answered that and now
I say: You mean why am I black?

That is basically what Lady S meant by her line up of questioning & to suggest otherwise is just ignorance.

YumSushi · 30/11/2022 21:54

Americano75 · 30/11/2022 21:53

The minute I heard this story I made the connection with Meghan Markle, and I was right. This particular person was not only tasked with 'helping' MM 'acclimatise' to life in the royal family but is supposed to have declared that the marriage 'would end in tears'.

Her behaviour was abhorrent and probably as much of a last straw as anything.

Funny isn't it, they couldn't silence the member of public.

JoeMaplin · 30/11/2022 21:54

NurseButtercup · 30/11/2022 19:44

You're really digging deep to stick to this ridiculous notion of "what did Ngozi expect..." And how Ngozi was expected to compensate for this woman's racism...you sound ridiculous.

I get asked this very same question every single week. I'm sick of it. I wear a nurses uniform, I have a very british name, a very british regional accent, I'm british I was born here. There is no reason for anybody to ask me this question, but they do and never accept my response. The follow up question is usually one of the following: where am I originally from or, when did you get here or when are you going home? It's all beginning to grate.

I'm glad this has been reported & discussed. I look forward to the day when nobody asks me this question in this manner ever again.

I’m so sorry you are asked this question constantly. And that some people on this thread are being so Ignorant.

I am white so I know I do not truly understand, so I have made it my business to read and to understand as best I can.

YumSushi · 30/11/2022 21:53

Hills2022 · 30/11/2022 21:46

Why do you need to know anything about people, you don't need to know if people have siblings, you don't need to know if people like football, you don't need to know any personal information about anyone, but sharing information and being interested in other people is pretty much how human relationships are formed.

But not at a reception where someone has been invited due to their charity work and they've told you they are from the UK.

Backstreetsbackalrightdadada · 30/11/2022 21:53

Hills2022 · 30/11/2022 21:46

Why do you need to know anything about people, you don't need to know if people have siblings, you don't need to know if people like football, you don't need to know any personal information about anyone, but sharing information and being interested in other people is pretty much how human relationships are formed.

Why did Hussey not have anything to add, at all, to any of Fulani’s answers? Even when Hussey got the info she wanted, she wanted it for no reason - no interest in Fulani’s heritage at all. She pushed that Fulani was not British, even having been told she was. Hussey was not interested, not in any of the answers. And her approach and what she said was racist. Buckingham Palace has said it was unacceptable. Not sure why you’re defending her. She hasn’t denied it herself.

Americano75 · 30/11/2022 21:53

The minute I heard this story I made the connection with Meghan Markle, and I was right. This particular person was not only tasked with 'helping' MM 'acclimatise' to life in the royal family but is supposed to have declared that the marriage 'would end in tears'.

Her behaviour was abhorrent and probably as much of a last straw as anything.

Swipe left for the next trending thread