Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Fairly contributing to finances with baby

211 replies

ChampagneLassie · 30/11/2022 13:31

DP earns a lot and has enjoyed generous increases lately. I got made redundant and subsequently had a baby who is now 8 months so no income. We both had approximately equal savings pre baby but I'm running down my savings to live on whilst he's adding to his and it doesn't feel fair. Presently we split joint finances 50/50 and each deal with our own personal. We're TTC with intention that I'll wait till B2 is 1 before getting a job.
I'd have hoped we'd be getting married by this point but not on the cards. He's open to discuss this and paying more. I don't know what I think is fair to ask for. Im conscious that the longer this goes on the bigger impact to me long term. Ideally he'd value me homemaking and SAHM for time frame and just pay for everything till I got another job but that seems unlikely. I'm thinking all joint expenses Any suggestions?

OP posts:
ChampagneLassie · 30/11/2022 17:47

TicketToParadise · 30/11/2022 16:29

Why assume you’re on the same page.

You we’re together for years, most young couples discuss future in that timeframe, let alone when you’re in the mid 30’s!

We did discuss it, lots and he led me to believe he was, on the same page. And I waited and ultimately he wouldn't commit to marriage but agreed to have a child. So my options were end it (which we had a break and I wasde asted) or try. Marriage wasn't as important to me, baby was more important but over time I now feel strongly I'd like to be married and like some of responses, on here I feel I've been a bit of a mug. I thought he'd be proposing when I had the baby. It's not gone like that

OP posts:
AnneLovesGilbert · 30/11/2022 17:46

Do you see why a lot of people are confused that the person you have sex with, live with, have had a child with, is someone you can’t discuss finances with? It’s not imperfect, it’s dysfunctional.

Nanny0gg · 30/11/2022 17:37

ChampagneLassie · 30/11/2022 13:31

DP earns a lot and has enjoyed generous increases lately. I got made redundant and subsequently had a baby who is now 8 months so no income. We both had approximately equal savings pre baby but I'm running down my savings to live on whilst he's adding to his and it doesn't feel fair. Presently we split joint finances 50/50 and each deal with our own personal. We're TTC with intention that I'll wait till B2 is 1 before getting a job.
I'd have hoped we'd be getting married by this point but not on the cards. He's open to discuss this and paying more. I don't know what I think is fair to ask for. Im conscious that the longer this goes on the bigger impact to me long term. Ideally he'd value me homemaking and SAHM for time frame and just pay for everything till I got another job but that seems unlikely. I'm thinking all joint expenses Any suggestions?

What a prince!

Stop paying half. Stop eating into your savings. Do not have another baby.

And honestly - if he thinks this has been the right way to behave, Leave the Bastard.

gaf · 30/11/2022 16:43

It’s unbelievable that you’ve never had a conversation beyond baby, assumed marriage would happen and now are too nervous to talk about it. How can you have a relationship without any communication? Or does that sum things up, because it’s not a real relationship, just a situation.

TicketToParadise · 30/11/2022 16:29

ChampagneLassie · 30/11/2022 16:25

Not really, I met someone had fun, fell in love and assumed we were on same page re marriage, babies. Aware of my age I prioritise baby over marriage but assume that will come soon. And here I am. Trying to now tackle some of the bigger stuff that I'd been to nervous to bring up before.

Why assume you’re on the same page.

You we’re together for years, most young couples discuss future in that timeframe, let alone when you’re in the mid 30’s!

ChampagneLassie · 30/11/2022 16:25

Cluelessdiyer · 30/11/2022 16:16

I was going to say he’s being awful until I read that you’re basically using him to fund your desire for a baby.

Onviously he agreed to that. But I’d say he’s pretty clear that the whole relationship is ultimately transactional.

i actually understand that he doesn’t want to subsidize you staying at home
when you’ve made a decision not to do it on your own but to use him for his resources.

i think you’re as awful as he is in this arrangement

i feel very sad for any children brought into this massively dysfunctional set up

Not really, I met someone had fun, fell in love and assumed we were on same page re marriage, babies. Aware of my age I prioritise baby over marriage but assume that will come soon. And here I am. Trying to now tackle some of the bigger stuff that I'd been to nervous to bring up before.

OP posts:
TeaAndJaffacakes · 30/11/2022 16:23

I agree with everyone saying he should be paying for everything more or less or you should be going back to work and contributing proportionally to your salaries to all expenses including childcare.
BUT, if you are just trying to get some money out of him right now, I have two propositions that he absolutely can’t argue with.
If you were to split up, he would have to pay child maintenance of 16% of his income. As your finances are separate and he doesn’t want to get married and you are doing all the childcare, he should start paying you the equivalent directly now.
Or. He should pay you his half of what full time child care (50hours per week at least) would cost, otherwise you’re massively subsidizing him at the moment.
Would either of these options put your savings in a healthier position OP?

Wishimaywishimight · 30/11/2022 16:21

Honestly OP, I would concentrate on getting back to work and forgetting about another baby. This guy is married to his wallet, he has no interest in getting married to you (share all his worldly goods with you? I think not!) and honestly I doubt he wanted a baby, he just went along with whatever you wanted. I doubt he will stick around, especially if another expensive mouth to feed arrives on the scene. You will most likely end up on your own with the child(ren) anyway so you would be wise to push back for now, try and get him to take the padlock off his wallet to support his family and make sure you keep your 'running away fund' well stocked up.

stuntbubbles · 30/11/2022 16:20

ChampagneLassie · 30/11/2022 16:15

I guess that is what has led me to bringing it up. I want more but I don't want to be too pushy

You’re in a relationship with someone with whom you have a child and are TTC another but you’re worried about being too pushy?! That sounds like early days dating worries: “if I ask him to be exclusive he might dump me!”

Money aside, do you feel like an equal partner in the relationship, as in you feel fully loved and respected? Or did you settle for someone who wasn’t that into you but was willing to procreate because the clock was ticking?

ChampagneLassie · 30/11/2022 16:19

HungryandIknowit · 30/11/2022 16:00

It sounds like he wasn't keen on a baby for financial reasons and now he's viewing it as your decision and responsibility. It seems like he thinks of you as two individuals rather than a couple with shared responsibility for a baby. In my view he should be paying until you are earning, depending on the disparity in your savings. But you need to have an honest conversation about what you and he both want. It's a tricky one as it sounds like he would prioritise his financial position over having another baby, and using the fact you desperately want another one to essentially force you into paying as you want it more. I personally don't think I could get past it as well as the lack of commitment; it shows an incredibly uncaring attitude and a certain level of apathy towards you.

He just wasn't in a rush for a baby. He doesnt begrudge money on baby at all and his assumption seems to be that everything joint comes from joint account - so childcare would be joint too. It's just that my share is from savings.

OP posts:
Cluelessdiyer · 30/11/2022 16:16

I was going to say he’s being awful until I read that you’re basically using him to fund your desire for a baby.

Onviously he agreed to that. But I’d say he’s pretty clear that the whole relationship is ultimately transactional.

i actually understand that he doesn’t want to subsidize you staying at home
when you’ve made a decision not to do it on your own but to use him for his resources.

i think you’re as awful as he is in this arrangement

i feel very sad for any children brought into this massively dysfunctional set up

ChampagneLassie · 30/11/2022 16:15

Gettingmyheadtogether · 30/11/2022 15:14

Instead of looking at this situation in terms of how you’d be worse of without him than you are right now, run those calculations again and see how your financial situation would look in 5 years time if you were a single mother, working, claiming whatever benefits you’re entitled to, building a pension pot and you’d held onto your savings Vs no savings, no maternity pay, no pension, and poorer prospects.

I guess that is what has led me to bringing it up. I want more but I don't want to be too pushy

OP posts:
Wishimaywishimight · 30/11/2022 16:13

Having another baby with this tight bastard should be way down your list (if not taken off it completely!). He is expecting you to pay half of everything while you are earning nothing but are at home taking care of his child?

Surely you can see how wrong this is OP - is this really how your saw your life / family panning out? Is this what you would consider a loving, caring relationship??

Ilovetocrochet · 30/11/2022 16:09

RosieLemonadeAndSugar · 30/11/2022 13:49

How can you pay 50/50 when you have no job? Absolutely unfair of him to expect you to use your savings.

I never understand once people move in and have kids why their money isnt joint.

X amount spent on bills
X amount for savings
X amount for each partner to do with as they wish

Totally agree. When I got married, both our wages went into our joint account and all bills were paid from that account. We did transfer a small amount to our own accounts each month for personal things but mainly used the joint account. When I became a SAHM nothing changed except of course I was not earning so not putting any money into our account. But all bills came from it and I used it to buy things for the children and for myself. I used my personal money mainly to buy birthday and Christmas gifts for my husband. When money got tight due to inflation I stopped taking any money from the joint account until I went back to work.

We never argued about who had spent what and trusted each other not to waste money. We did discuss the cost before buying expensive things which tended to come out of any ravings.

My daughter, who has just bought a house with her partner, was horrified when I told her how we managed our finances!

Whoneedsleep · 30/11/2022 16:01

All money goes into one pot.
Bills paid for, whatever’s left is joint to spend on whatever.

Anything else isn’t fair!

HungryandIknowit · 30/11/2022 16:00

It sounds like he wasn't keen on a baby for financial reasons and now he's viewing it as your decision and responsibility. It seems like he thinks of you as two individuals rather than a couple with shared responsibility for a baby. In my view he should be paying until you are earning, depending on the disparity in your savings. But you need to have an honest conversation about what you and he both want. It's a tricky one as it sounds like he would prioritise his financial position over having another baby, and using the fact you desperately want another one to essentially force you into paying as you want it more. I personally don't think I could get past it as well as the lack of commitment; it shows an incredibly uncaring attitude and a certain level of apathy towards you.

CatJumperTwat · 30/11/2022 15:57

baby was planned

So he wanted a child and was aware that you weren't using contraception?

Notanotherone6 · 30/11/2022 15:34

You have kids. You're living together as though you're married. Everything that anyone earns, or gets paid in benefits, goes into a joint account and you bloody share it. It's called being a family.

Ansjovis · 30/11/2022 15:31

Not all women who are in precarious relationship situations are there because of domestic violence. From what you've said here, you are one of those women. He's willing to have two children with you, tying you together effectively for the rest of your lives, but he's not willing to marry you because that's too big a commitment? What an absolute joke. I would be laughing if I hadn't seen it all before.

This man is in a much better financial position than you are, he's not married to you and you are not working. Wake up! If he decides to leave you, you will be up the creek without a paddle. You may wish to believe he'd never do that but this is a man who neither wants to provide for the mother of his children or encourage her to provide for herself by staying economically active. If I were in your shoes I would certainly not bank on him sticking around. Please look in to protecting yourself here.

RandomMusings7 · 30/11/2022 15:22

Is he a good dad, @ChampagneLassie?

Does he spent time with baby? Do any feeds, nappies, nightwakings?

Buy stuff for the baby unprompted?

Merryoldgoat · 30/11/2022 15:22

Ffs. Every single day. It’s so depressing.

011899988I9991197253 · 30/11/2022 15:19

Dragging innocent children into this mess is awful.

Inertia · 30/11/2022 15:18

Given that you are paying 50 % of costs, I hope you are a) invoicing your partner for providing child care, and b) he is paying 50% of all child related costs.

Your financial position is very precarious- I would do everything you can to maintain your own career and insist your partner shares childcare costs.

Gettingmyheadtogether · 30/11/2022 15:14

Instead of looking at this situation in terms of how you’d be worse of without him than you are right now, run those calculations again and see how your financial situation would look in 5 years time if you were a single mother, working, claiming whatever benefits you’re entitled to, building a pension pot and you’d held onto your savings Vs no savings, no maternity pay, no pension, and poorer prospects.

Survey99 · 30/11/2022 15:13

You are basically two housemates that enjoy each others company, shag each other and have babies but are essentially only concerned with their own separate wants - even when it comes to big ticket items like children. You are not a partnership or a team.

You have chosen to accept this set up as your very comfortable financial cushion lets you short term and I would be very worried about your long term security when the money runs out.

My advice would be to reflect on the bigger picture before bringing another child into such a dysfunctional "family".