Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Fairly contributing to finances with baby

211 replies

ChampagneLassie · 30/11/2022 13:31

DP earns a lot and has enjoyed generous increases lately. I got made redundant and subsequently had a baby who is now 8 months so no income. We both had approximately equal savings pre baby but I'm running down my savings to live on whilst he's adding to his and it doesn't feel fair. Presently we split joint finances 50/50 and each deal with our own personal. We're TTC with intention that I'll wait till B2 is 1 before getting a job.
I'd have hoped we'd be getting married by this point but not on the cards. He's open to discuss this and paying more. I don't know what I think is fair to ask for. Im conscious that the longer this goes on the bigger impact to me long term. Ideally he'd value me homemaking and SAHM for time frame and just pay for everything till I got another job but that seems unlikely. I'm thinking all joint expenses Any suggestions?

OP posts:
Cluelessdiyer · 30/11/2022 19:41

Are you proposing to share your savings with him OP?

gaf · 30/11/2022 19:35

I don’t understand why you had a child with someone who isn’t sure your relationship is forever and doesn’t want to commit. Why did he have a child?

TarquinOliverNimrod · 30/11/2022 19:33

I just can’t get my head around these
kind of relationships. You have a child
together. You’re the mother of his child. What’s his should be yours and vice versa. Sounds so clinical and cold all this ‘his money’ nonsense. I’m on maternity leave and have full access
to OUR joint funds, which is how it should be.

Don’t have another child with this tight arsed knob.

CloudyYellow · 30/11/2022 19:31

yoyy · 30/11/2022 18:42

I'm quite confused tbh. Are the savings so considerable that he feels you can easily afford 50:50? If the savings are so considerable how come you are renting? You want to have a 2nd even if you're alone, how will you support yourself?

This.
There has been a drip feed here. The considerable savings change the optics of this scenario along with OP not wanting to work. If you can live for 10 years on your savings I can see why he thinks 50/50 is reasonable.

Coffeepot72 · 30/11/2022 19:25

Idon't see your situation as being particularly unfair. You've made the decision to stay at home. Why should he fund that? I think it's fair that you pay money out of your savings.

The OP is at home caring for the baby they both created, why shouldn’t he fund that?

Coffeepot72 · 30/11/2022 19:22

I think the OP is getting a hard time for being upfront about something a lot of women lie about - getting pregnant when everything isn't quite as you'd want it to be, because there's not enough time to try to fix everything (or find "Mr Right". Lots of women do exactly the same thing but pretend they're more in love than they are, or that they can't see their partner's flaws, or "never wanted marriage anyway".

I agree @Rumplestrumpet

FinallyHere · 30/11/2022 19:21

Suggestions for how to approach something more equal.

I am so sorry you find yourself in this position.

You have given away all your negotiating power, are not happy with your situation (nor should you be) and are now wondering what you can leverage to improve the hand you have chosen.

That's a really tough position to be in.

ryantubridysthumb · 30/11/2022 19:19

I don't see your situation as being particularly unfair. You've made the decision to stay at home. Why should he fund that? I think it's fair that you pay money out of your savings. Particularly given the situation that it seems a fairly transactional relationship. You're not really a team. Neither of you sound great to me. I bet he would be delighted to know that he was 'just there'. You're using him as a sperm donor and he's enjoying a home with no commitment.

Venetiaparties · 30/11/2022 19:02

'I have decided not to go ahead with a second child, I have come to realise I have been left in a precarious position with a man that seems unwilling to commit to me in any way. Unless you are able to offer marriage within the next year and you are able to give the baby and I the security we deserve, then I can't see that we have a future at all. In the meantime I would like all of my savings replaced and access to joint money as I look for a job'

That is how you bring it up.

You lay your cards on the table.
Stop side stepping the issue, come out with it, and mean it. You have settled for second best, it is time now to look at what you are now saddled with very very clearly.

Venetiaparties · 30/11/2022 18:57

I understand why you made the decision you did for a longed for baby, I would never have done this, but I can see why you did, and hoped the rest would come good, but it hasn't and it is unlikely to.

You have to save yourself now and your baby, if you go ahead with the second child then you do so knowing it is going to be extremely hard on your own, without the resources, without security and two under two is beyond knackering and it will be for another 16 years or more. By signing up for another child you are sabotaging your whole life by a few hormones.

You have your much loved baby, now is the time for seeing clearly the terrible position you are now in, and getting a new job as soon as possible. Split the cleaning and finances and get back to your high earner status asap. Protecting yourself AND your baby so you have options and security.

Your dp has played a blinder, he basically has a baby without the cost, he has a clean house and cooked dinners without lifting a finger or paying anyone else too. Sex on tap, and a 'grateful' wife type at home doing it all and using her savings and paying HIM to be there! Why on earth would he get married? There is no incentive or upside for him now op. I would start letting him know that if you are not married in the next 12 months then you will be reconsidering your future, and Australia looks very appealing.

You have given him everything and paid for the privilege.
Don't compound your mistake by having another baby whatever you do.

ChampagneLassie · 30/11/2022 18:54

Cluelessdiyer · 30/11/2022 18:00

@Itsbeenashortyear i totally agree - this is a rare scenario loke
thos where I have no sympathy for the op

he told her who he was.

she didn’t want to have a baby on her own and wanted to use his resources

he hasn’t demanded that she doesn’t work. I think op said is she worked theyd share the childcare costs??

OP has put herself right in this situation with full knowledge and wants another baby!

Well yes your right and I'm not looking for sympathy. Suggestions for how to approach something more equal. Baby is only 8 months.

OP posts:
yoyy · 30/11/2022 18:42

I'm quite confused tbh. Are the savings so considerable that he feels you can easily afford 50:50? If the savings are so considerable how come you are renting? You want to have a 2nd even if you're alone, how will you support yourself?

uncomfortablydumb53 · 30/11/2022 18:33

You can't nudge him into marriage
It seems like he's telling you in so many words
He won't marry you until he's sure you'll last forever?
No one knows that do they?!
It seems your scared to discuss this properly as hell say what you don't want to hear
Propose to him, then you'll see
It's actions than count, not words

Newlifestartingatlast · 30/11/2022 18:29

redastherose · 30/11/2022 13:42

Don't have a second baby without being married. He should be covering 100% of all household expenses and your personal expenses whilst you are at home looking after the baby, unless he doesn't think of you as a family then that is what should have happened as soon as you were made redundant. If you can get another job and put the baby in childcare and each pay the cost in accordance with your then earnings. You are subsidising his life at the moment not the other way round. I imagine you are covering the cost of childcare and all household cleaning cooking shopping etc which would presumably have been shared equally previously so by doing all of those things you are saving him money.

This
deargod, over and over women are sleep walking i to this
never have a baby deliberately without the legal backing of a marriage - that’s what marriage is for. Not a wedding day. Not romance. Legal and financial protection
of course he doesn’t want to get married- you’re the one that taking the financial hit and being exposed . You’ve already allowed him to do that when you went and had a baby and continued to live with him without marriage. Why would he change that when he’s laughing all the way to the bank
please don’t be an idiot- time or another child will just make this situation worse. Stop right now

011899988I9991197253 · 30/11/2022 18:18

he doesn't want to get married until he's sure we're going to last "forever"

Why would you have another child with someone who feels like this?

Sounds like you’re just an option for him.

Cluelessdiyer · 30/11/2022 18:09

OP it sounds like his commitment isn’t there. You need to ask him to confirm. And then you will know.

i have a friend in almost the exact same situation. He wouldn’t marry her. Wouldn’t share finances (they bought a house but all split 50/50). They had IVF for the baby and split that 50/50.

Guess who’s last name the baby has and guess who does most of the childcare. Guess who’s reduced their hours at work and who hasn’t etc

she stays with him because she doesn’t have the courage to leave is my view. I could be wrong of course. But I struggle not to roll my eyes when she talks about how lovely and nice he is.

its unlikely you’re going to get the happy ending you want. Time to move forward with a realistic plan for your future

Rumplestrumpet · 30/11/2022 18:08

I think the OP is getting a hard time for being upfront about something a lot of women lie about - getting pregnant when everything isn't quite as you'd want it to be, because there's not enough time to try to fix everything (or find "Mr Right". Lots of women do exactly the same thing but pretend they're more in love than they are, or that they can't see their partner's flaws, or "never wanted marriage anyway".

The thing is OP, this situation is untenable, and your DP should really see that. He wanted a baby too (it was planned) and he needs to step up and cover some of the cost. That includes paying more towards household costs because you're looking after the baby. Or to put it another way - he'd be paying half of the childcare (£1500/month for us) if you did go back to work, so at the very least he should be paying you £750 more a month to cover this.

Good luck

ChampagneLassie · 30/11/2022 18:03

Itsbeenashortyear · 30/11/2022 17:54

So he told you he wouldn’t get married, but would have a child. You went ahead with the child assuming he would propose anyway?

I really wasn't that fussed about marriage, but aware of biological clock. Over time I've become much keener on being married. I guess I've changed.i don't like that we have different surnames. Meeting other married parents and we're not. All his family are married and there is pressure from them too and I find it somewhat embarrassing. I guess partly it would signal his commitment which I suppose I perceive to not be there

OP posts:
Merlott · 30/11/2022 18:01

Wtf

Cluelessdiyer · 30/11/2022 18:00

@Itsbeenashortyear i totally agree - this is a rare scenario loke
thos where I have no sympathy for the op

he told her who he was.

she didn’t want to have a baby on her own and wanted to use his resources

he hasn’t demanded that she doesn’t work. I think op said is she worked theyd share the childcare costs??

OP has put herself right in this situation with full knowledge and wants another baby!

ChampagneLassie · 30/11/2022 17:59

Itsbeenashortyear · 30/11/2022 17:53

Why is he a bastard?

He has never told op he intends to be the sole earner in the family.

Op chose to not look for other work after she got made redundant. And they kept the 50:50 in place with her being really happy to continue to pay it.

Op is fully aware he doesn’t want to finance the whole family. She is aware he wanted to wait for a baby and doesn’t want another so soon. But she does. She won’t broach the subject because she knows he will stop TTC and want her to go back to work instead.

He hasn’t pretended to be anything other than what he is. He isn’t going to get married and sees them as separate entities, financially. Both contributing half. Op says he is open to adjusting it. Maybe he will suggest op goes back to work and both pay half the childcare fees.

Op admits she wouldn’t even be with him if her biological clock wasn’t ticking away. Her being at home wasn’t a joint decision. It was hers because she can afford to finance it.

Yes you've got it. I'm just looking to nudge the dial so I'm not too screwed.
To answer other posters. We talk openly now, he doesn't want to get married until he's sure we're going to last "forever" I so wonder if at this point it is largely financialky influenced though. When we met iwas higher earner with much more assets and he asked omif I'd want a pre nup to protect me and I'd said no I believe you share everything. Situation has changed somewhat

OP posts:
Itsbeenashortyear · 30/11/2022 17:54

ChampagneLassie · 30/11/2022 17:47

We did discuss it, lots and he led me to believe he was, on the same page. And I waited and ultimately he wouldn't commit to marriage but agreed to have a child. So my options were end it (which we had a break and I wasde asted) or try. Marriage wasn't as important to me, baby was more important but over time I now feel strongly I'd like to be married and like some of responses, on here I feel I've been a bit of a mug. I thought he'd be proposing when I had the baby. It's not gone like that

So he told you he wouldn’t get married, but would have a child. You went ahead with the child assuming he would propose anyway?

Itsbeenashortyear · 30/11/2022 17:53

Nanny0gg · 30/11/2022 17:37

What a prince!

Stop paying half. Stop eating into your savings. Do not have another baby.

And honestly - if he thinks this has been the right way to behave, Leave the Bastard.

Why is he a bastard?

He has never told op he intends to be the sole earner in the family.

Op chose to not look for other work after she got made redundant. And they kept the 50:50 in place with her being really happy to continue to pay it.

Op is fully aware he doesn’t want to finance the whole family. She is aware he wanted to wait for a baby and doesn’t want another so soon. But she does. She won’t broach the subject because she knows he will stop TTC and want her to go back to work instead.

He hasn’t pretended to be anything other than what he is. He isn’t going to get married and sees them as separate entities, financially. Both contributing half. Op says he is open to adjusting it. Maybe he will suggest op goes back to work and both pay half the childcare fees.

Op admits she wouldn’t even be with him if her biological clock wasn’t ticking away. Her being at home wasn’t a joint decision. It was hers because she can afford to finance it.

RandomMusings7 · 30/11/2022 17:51

stuntbubbles · 30/11/2022 17:48

Propose to him.

You absolutely can.

And to circumvent potential silly excuses tell him you want a small register office type of deal. No actual wedding reception, a couple hundred pounds and one hour of his life to get it done.

Then at least you'll know where you stand.

stuntbubbles · 30/11/2022 17:48

Propose to him.

Swipe left for the next trending thread