Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Fairly contributing to finances with baby

211 replies

ChampagneLassie · 30/11/2022 13:31

DP earns a lot and has enjoyed generous increases lately. I got made redundant and subsequently had a baby who is now 8 months so no income. We both had approximately equal savings pre baby but I'm running down my savings to live on whilst he's adding to his and it doesn't feel fair. Presently we split joint finances 50/50 and each deal with our own personal. We're TTC with intention that I'll wait till B2 is 1 before getting a job.
I'd have hoped we'd be getting married by this point but not on the cards. He's open to discuss this and paying more. I don't know what I think is fair to ask for. Im conscious that the longer this goes on the bigger impact to me long term. Ideally he'd value me homemaking and SAHM for time frame and just pay for everything till I got another job but that seems unlikely. I'm thinking all joint expenses Any suggestions?

OP posts:
ChampagneLassie · 01/12/2022 10:26

WibbleW0bble · 30/11/2022 21:06

investments normally outperform property so the idea of selling my investments to buy property feels risky to me

Also, sure, this may be theoretically correct. But you are a parent now. Surely the prospect of having no home and no way to finance a home in x amount of years is far more risky than the abstract risks of investments vs property?

Well yes this does cross my mind a bit now. However I think I'm much safer with flexibility of renting, for example I could easily move for a new job. Appreciate the concern but that isn't a problem I need solving.

OP posts:
AccioChocolate · 01/12/2022 10:25

If you can't share a bank account you shouldn't share a baby, but I do get that a biological clock ticking can make people lose sight if that or make it less important. I think he's a jerk but at the very least he should be paying you as though you're a full time nanny.

DrinkFeckArseBrick · 01/12/2022 10:24

You're a family. Mat leave isnt a holiday it's for the purposes of ensuring the child has a bond with primary caregivers. I cant believe anyone expects their 'partner' to contribute 50pc when they're not earning. I use the term partner in inverted commas as the whole point of a partnership is you both recognise the others contribution and help each other out. If you split now youd be so vulnerable having used your savings to live on.

Families pool resources. This means all money into a central pot, shared savings and equal spending money. Alternatively you can go back to work while he takes some shared parental leave

ChampagneLassie · 01/12/2022 10:19

NoSquirrels · 30/11/2022 22:57

I think, given that he doesn’t want to commit to you wholeheartedly and long-term, that’s the basis on which to have the discussion.

DP, I understand you don’t want marriage and although you know my feelings on that - I am a bit hurt you don’t consider our relationship strong enough to be ‘forever’ - I have accepted that instead we have a no-commitments approach and so we are and will remain financially separate. It is starting to feel a little uncomfortable though that you are earning more and saving more, whilst I am eating into my savings as the parent who is staying at home to provide childcare. Can we discuss on that basis how to equalise things better? I could return to work on a FT basis and then we’d need to split the childcare costs - I don’t want to do that if it’s not absolutely necessary because for a lot of reasons I think it makes sense for me to keep having a career break and have another baby as soon as possible. And there are other benefits to me being at home too.

This, is the sort of tact I'm. Going down

OP posts:
Itsbeenashortyear · 01/12/2022 05:49

LeavesOnTrees · 30/11/2022 23:24

If you disappeared tomorrow, how much would he have to pay someone to do all the things you do?

Full time nanny, cleaner and housekeeper.
That is what you are bringing to the table financially. As someone who worked in finance it seems odd you've not included this in your part of the 50/50 set up.

But if he disappeared tomorrow, Ops living expenses would also massively increase. Plenty of single parents work in professional roles and don’t have housekeepers and cleaners.

That argument may work if Op being a sahp was something they agreed together. Op says above they didn’t. She just decided she wasn’t going to work and was going to self fund it.

Thats the issue. It’s never been discussed because Op took the decision to stay at home unilaterally. She knows it’s not something he would agree to fully, but won’t raise it incase she doesn’t get her 2nd baby.

If dp unilaterally decided to be a sahp, I wouldn’t be happy about funding it either. It should be a joint decision and that’s when it’s discussed.

LeavesOnTrees · 30/11/2022 23:24

If you disappeared tomorrow, how much would he have to pay someone to do all the things you do?

Full time nanny, cleaner and housekeeper.
That is what you are bringing to the table financially. As someone who worked in finance it seems odd you've not included this in your part of the 50/50 set up.

NoSquirrels · 30/11/2022 22:57

I think, given that he doesn’t want to commit to you wholeheartedly and long-term, that’s the basis on which to have the discussion.

DP, I understand you don’t want marriage and although you know my feelings on that - I am a bit hurt you don’t consider our relationship strong enough to be ‘forever’ - I have accepted that instead we have a no-commitments approach and so we are and will remain financially separate. It is starting to feel a little uncomfortable though that you are earning more and saving more, whilst I am eating into my savings as the parent who is staying at home to provide childcare. Can we discuss on that basis how to equalise things better? I could return to work on a FT basis and then we’d need to split the childcare costs - I don’t want to do that if it’s not absolutely necessary because for a lot of reasons I think it makes sense for me to keep having a career break and have another baby as soon as possible. And there are other benefits to me being at home too.

yoyy · 30/11/2022 22:07

It's a huge flag that he doesn't want to commit despite having a baby

yoyy · 30/11/2022 22:05

There isn't anything wrong with renting & many wealthy people do it for convenience.

Propertyindisrepair · 30/11/2022 21:07

have you taken into account the less riskier benefit of leverage from property?

also the mortgage b rent benefits and lack of cgt on residential property?

WibbleW0bble · 30/11/2022 21:06

investments normally outperform property so the idea of selling my investments to buy property feels risky to me

Also, sure, this may be theoretically correct. But you are a parent now. Surely the prospect of having no home and no way to finance a home in x amount of years is far more risky than the abstract risks of investments vs property?

WibbleW0bble · 30/11/2022 21:02

Ive moved frequently, we might move abroad

For the love of God, unless you are moving back to your home country, do not even contemplate moving abroad with this relationship set up. Total disaster waiting to happen.

Stomacharmeleon · 30/11/2022 21:01

What's odd..
You feel you can't talk about money with him.
He is not sure if you are 'forever' but is happy for you to get pregnant repeatedly.

You both seem to be passively sleepwalking through major life decisions but are on different pages. You have got what you wanted and are now trying to draw him onto the same page as you. He hasn't changed his trajectory though.

You reap what you sow and all'

ChampagneLassie · 30/11/2022 20:58

AnotherEmma · 30/11/2022 20:19

Why on earth are you renting if (pre baby) you were both high earners with enough savings to live on for ~10 years?! That's crazy!

You've made some strange decisions. Why stay with him if he's not willing to give you financial security through marriage and/or other things? (fully shared finances including savings, he pays for everything while you're not earning including paying into your pension, sorting wills and life insurance to make each other the beneficiary, etc etc) You must protect yourself. If I were you I would be looking for a job and would go back to work ASAP. If you split you wouldn't be entitled to UC (because of your savings) so you would need to look into shared ownership, I think that's the only way you could do it - use savings to buy your share outright and pay rent for the rest.

Ive moved frequently, we might move abroad, I thought I'd wait till I was settled with someone before buying a property - I worked in finance and investments normally outperform property so the idea of selling my investments to buy property feels risky to me. Lots of reasons.

I stayed with him mainly because I love him, like so much that it hurts in some ridiculous teen angst way. Now I also stay with him because of the baby. But mostly I really love him. Someone said I should have more self respect. I am disappointed in myself about this, I do deserve better.

OP posts:
Puddywoodycat · 30/11/2022 20:30

Take him to somewhere they train teens to work in a nursery, go under cover and work there.

Then tell DH even though you are both able to keep your DC at home in a loving parents arm's....you will be handing baby over to said poorly paid disinterested teen so you can work full time and no baby 2.

Coffeepot72 · 30/11/2022 20:25

The main issue is that you didn’t communicate. You got what you wanted (a baby) and he got what he wanted (a relatively casual relationship), but neither of you thought what would happen when these two things collided

@WibbleW0bble excellent point

AnotherEmma · 30/11/2022 20:19

Why on earth are you renting if (pre baby) you were both high earners with enough savings to live on for ~10 years?! That's crazy!

You've made some strange decisions. Why stay with him if he's not willing to give you financial security through marriage and/or other things? (fully shared finances including savings, he pays for everything while you're not earning including paying into your pension, sorting wills and life insurance to make each other the beneficiary, etc etc) You must protect yourself. If I were you I would be looking for a job and would go back to work ASAP. If you split you wouldn't be entitled to UC (because of your savings) so you would need to look into shared ownership, I think that's the only way you could do it - use savings to buy your share outright and pay rent for the rest.

Hoowhoowho · 30/11/2022 20:07

If this is a purely transactional relationship (and that seems it’s how he sees it) your way ahead is clear. You continue to pay half the costs, however he either does 50% of the childcare or pays you to do it. He should also do 50% of the domestic labour (housework, mental load stuff etc) if he isn’t he should consider financially compensating you for this.

This way you both do 50% of everything. Currently he pays 50% of bills and does less than 10% of the rest. That isn’t fair and he should see that. Your choices re employment, childcare etc are each your own but you both have equal responsibility for bills, childcare and domestic labour. He needs to work out how to manage his share of the latter.

WibbleW0bble · 30/11/2022 19:53

Respect to you OP. At least you’ve had the balls to admit you got pregnant in far from ideal circumstances. A lot of people can’t seem to see that on MN.

The main issue is that you didn’t communicate. You got what you wanted (a baby) and he got what he wanted (a relatively casual relationship), but neither of you thought what would happen when these two things collided. I think the only thing you can do is lay it straight to him, that your finances are deeply precarious while he adds to his wealth, with no shared assets. You have to be prepared though for him to say you should get a job and financially contribute. For what it’s worth, I think that would be your best option - not many people, (married or otherwise) have the luxury to sit at home having babies in quick succession without a second income.

ChampagneLassie · 30/11/2022 19:52

Someone asked if he's a good dad. I think he is. I do lion share of childcare and household but I think that's pretty standard compared with others I know. I don't think he'll be tight with her.

OP posts:
Orangesare · 30/11/2022 19:51

NRFT.
I think you have two separate issues

  1. marriage

  2. Money
    i would tackle 2) first. He should fund all the household expenses rent utilities food etc, everything he is using as well. You should get the family allowance even if he has to pay it back. You are just left with your own expenses car, but not all fuel as you’re taking the baby places, clothes hair.

  3. not sure what you can do about this one but it’s not such a pressing issue once you have sorted out the money

ChampagneLassie · 30/11/2022 19:50

CloudyYellow · 30/11/2022 19:31

This.
There has been a drip feed here. The considerable savings change the optics of this scenario along with OP not wanting to work. If you can live for 10 years on your savings I can see why he thinks 50/50 is reasonable.

I'm trying not to drop feed. We had approx equal amount savings when we had baby. But whilst I'm eating into mine, he's earning very well and adding to his. I agree I think it's fair I drew on them to some extent. It feels less fair now. I'll need my savings to support me if I ever do want to buy a, property, retire, can't work for some reason etc etc and until I am working again I increasingly realise I do have to rely on myswlf

OP posts:
ChampagneLassie · 30/11/2022 19:46

Thanks this is a helpful suggestion re childcare. The maintenance is less than his 50% now

OP posts:
ChampagneLassie · 30/11/2022 19:44

yoyy · 30/11/2022 18:42

I'm quite confused tbh. Are the savings so considerable that he feels you can easily afford 50:50? If the savings are so considerable how come you are renting? You want to have a 2nd even if you're alone, how will you support yourself?

Yes I think that was the case initially, but my investments have tanked whilst costs have risen and rather than going back to work at 6 months I'm still not working now. Furthermore his earnings have gone up and he's done very well such that it seems much less fair now. I guess I think me funding 6 months might arguably be fair but it doesn't feel fair now.
We rent for various reasons. Owning a property wouldn't really change any of this and isn't something I particularly want to do.

OP posts:
Itsbeenashortyear · 30/11/2022 19:43

Coffeepot72 · 30/11/2022 19:25

Idon't see your situation as being particularly unfair. You've made the decision to stay at home. Why should he fund that? I think it's fair that you pay money out of your savings.

The OP is at home caring for the baby they both created, why shouldn’t he fund that?

Because it wasn’t a joint decision. Op decided to just not find another job when made redundant because she could afford to finance it.

Swipe left for the next trending thread