Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Fairly contributing to finances with baby

211 replies

ChampagneLassie · 30/11/2022 13:31

DP earns a lot and has enjoyed generous increases lately. I got made redundant and subsequently had a baby who is now 8 months so no income. We both had approximately equal savings pre baby but I'm running down my savings to live on whilst he's adding to his and it doesn't feel fair. Presently we split joint finances 50/50 and each deal with our own personal. We're TTC with intention that I'll wait till B2 is 1 before getting a job.
I'd have hoped we'd be getting married by this point but not on the cards. He's open to discuss this and paying more. I don't know what I think is fair to ask for. Im conscious that the longer this goes on the bigger impact to me long term. Ideally he'd value me homemaking and SAHM for time frame and just pay for everything till I got another job but that seems unlikely. I'm thinking all joint expenses Any suggestions?

OP posts:
ChampagneLassie · 01/12/2022 19:17

Propertyindisrepair · 01/12/2022 18:06

@TheMatriarchy yrah I get that. But in this situation the OP didn’t even ask him or agree for her to be sahm. I suspect becaue she knows full well he’s really not actually committed and she was hell bent on having a kid and being a sahm

hes clearly a dick. But I don’t think he’s ever pretended to be otherwise.

and maybe he actually wouldn’t be a dick if the op actually asked him

And I'm not a, SAHM as such, circumstances are such that I didn't get mat leave, I was intending on getting a job but logically having another baby sooner makes sense from career perspective a d my personal well being.

I had a interview this afternoon for a role... I'm deliberating. Maybe I do get a job and if I decide and am able to get pregnant again deal with it.

OP posts:
babyjellyfish · 01/12/2022 19:16

ChristmasCwtch · 01/12/2022 19:10

I despair reading posts like this!!

General learned wisdom from these types of posts needs to be… Don’t have a baby with someone who is selfish and doesn’t want to marry you and don’t give up work to be their unpaid drudge and childcare whilst running down your own safety net. You’re absolutely buggered if he decides to piss off elsewhere 🤦🏼‍♀️

Not having a baby with someone who doesn't want to commit properly is 100% sound advice to someone who is in their early 20s, but when they're in their late 30s not having a baby with the person they're currently with might mean not having a baby at all.

Yes in an ideal world you wouldn't be in that situation but some people are, and I can see why some choose to take these risks.

ChristmasCwtch · 01/12/2022 19:10

I despair reading posts like this!!

General learned wisdom from these types of posts needs to be… Don’t have a baby with someone who is selfish and doesn’t want to marry you and don’t give up work to be their unpaid drudge and childcare whilst running down your own safety net. You’re absolutely buggered if he decides to piss off elsewhere 🤦🏼‍♀️

ChampagneLassie · 01/12/2022 19:02

JuneOsborne · 01/12/2022 15:46

You seem articulate and bright. It sounds as though you have had a good career.

If this was a work based problem how would you approach it?

Cold hard facts about the financial situation seem easy to lay out. Your eating into your savings, he's adding to his. You've both had a baby, but your bank balance is suffering. The balance needs restoring. What are the options? That's how I'd approach this. Give him the problem and ask for his solutions. These will tell you a lot about how he views you and your 'worth'. Go from there.

Thanks for the compliment and you're suggestion I think that is the best way to go. I guess I'd hoped he'd have realised and suggested this himself. But this sits more comfortably than me demanding something or comparing with the cost of the service I am delivering.

OP posts:
Redburnett · 01/12/2022 19:02

Joint account that all his salary goes into. All expenses come out of that, household, children's needs, personal expenses. Nothing else is fair given the circumstances and choices you have both made.

Doingmybest12 · 01/12/2022 18:56

I would talk to him about doing half of the domestic duties and childcare or charge him for his 50% that you currently provide. Or is he going to share the load and you get back to work..how did you start a family with a man when you hadn't agreed how you would be managing this as a couple. You can't have another baby until you have sorted this out.

babyjellyfish · 01/12/2022 18:46

ChampagneLassie · 30/11/2022 17:59

Yes you've got it. I'm just looking to nudge the dial so I'm not too screwed.
To answer other posters. We talk openly now, he doesn't want to get married until he's sure we're going to last "forever" I so wonder if at this point it is largely financialky influenced though. When we met iwas higher earner with much more assets and he asked omif I'd want a pre nup to protect me and I'd said no I believe you share everything. Situation has changed somewhat

What jumps out to me here is that when he asked about a pre-nup you said no, you believe in sharing, but he clearly doesn't believe in sharing.

I think you see the three of you as a family, whereas he still sees you as independent individuals.

I get that he never said he was up for supporting the three of you financially while you stay at home. But he was happy to have one child and he is happy to have another, and happy for you to stay at home for several years doing unpaid labour which would have to be paid for out of your joint income if you went back to work, so I do still think he is having his cake and eating it. I think he twigged that your biological clock was ticking and you knew your best chance of having the children you wanted was to stay with him even in less than ideal circumstances, and he's taken advantage of that.

Clearly it isn't fair for the two of you to be paying 50:50 when he is earning a high salary and you are earning nothing. If you invested your savings in a property and he paid the mortgage you would at least have a joint asset and some security. I know you say you could live off your savings for 10 years, but what if it takes you 18 months to get pregnant again, then nine months of pregnancy, then a year's maternity leave? You'll have burned through a third of your savings. And that's assuming you find a job easily after 5+ years out of the workplace, which is far from guaranteed.

In your shoes I would definitely talk to him about managing your finances more fairly, but I would also try to get a job. I know you don't want to, but you have no financial security other than your savings right now, and you have no idea how long it will take you to get pregnant and have a healthy full-term pregnancy.

Propertyindisrepair · 01/12/2022 18:06

@TheMatriarchy yrah I get that. But in this situation the OP didn’t even ask him or agree for her to be sahm. I suspect becaue she knows full well he’s really not actually committed and she was hell bent on having a kid and being a sahm

hes clearly a dick. But I don’t think he’s ever pretended to be otherwise.

and maybe he actually wouldn’t be a dick if the op actually asked him

TheMatriarchy · 01/12/2022 18:01

@Propertyindisrepair

TheMatriarchy · 01/12/2022 17:59

No one is suggesting the OP doesnt pay her 50% of everything, but what is not being acknowledged is what his 50% is. The OPs work and time is not free to him, he doesn't get that benefit from a girlfriend, he needs to pay for her time or pay for someone else's to do the same work. It is that simple.

If OP wasn't doing it, they would have to pay someone else. Her being made redundant and then picking up the work that someone else would have to be paid to do, doesn't mean he gets her work for 'free', just as he wont allow her anything for 'free'. That is fairness.

itsacatcafe · 01/12/2022 17:52

Why are there threads like this every day? I can't believe what some woman have to put up with. There is something seriously wrong with society that men think this attitude is acceptable and women are conditioned to expect next to nothing. Very depressing.

Sceptre86 · 01/12/2022 17:50

*ultimately even.

Sceptre86 · 01/12/2022 17:50

This is such a strange post because ultimelately you've had a baby with someone who wasn't really arsed about having one isn't massively keen on having another, would prefer you to get a job but will essentially go along with whatever you want for an easy life.

I don't pool my finances with my dh. We have separate finances and always will. We both contribute to our household and kids though. So even on mat leave whilst being paid I did pay the bills but once I moved over to smp he took over. Likeqise he paid for the children's childcare because he earned more than me. Youc You can have a committed relationship with separate finances but the key is to be on the same page re shared costs so mortgage, rent, bill, all kids expenses.

You don't have the great relationship you think you do. If I was dwindling down my savings I would share that information with my dh. He would not be OK with that and we'd work things out. That is what your partner should be doing. If he isn't convinced that you are forever hence doesn't want to marry you he shouldn't be ttc with you either.

It's really tough because he has shown who he is from the get go and really hasn't wavered but you've ignored so many red flags to get a baby.

For now you've asked for advice. I'd say speak to him, explain you can't afford a 50:50 contribution because you have no actual income. See what he says. Explain your investments aren't bringing in much, how he responds will tell you how committed he is to you. I'd put ttc on hold if not off the table.

plusk · 01/12/2022 16:56

He is using you and treats you like you are his bangmaid.

Coffeepot72 · 01/12/2022 16:50

Cold hard facts about the financial situation seem easy to lay out. Your eating into your savings, he's adding to his. You've both had a baby, but your bank balance is suffering. The balance needs restoring. What are the options? That's how I'd approach this. Give him the problem and ask for his solutions. These will tell you a lot about how he views you and your 'worth'. Go from there.

@JuneOsborne excellent advice!

FinallyHere · 01/12/2022 16:37

If this was a work based problem how would you approach it?

Excellent advice from @JuneOsborne

If I have understood the situation correctly, OP prioritised have a baby over getting married, figuring that share costs 50:50 with this man would be better than going it alone.

Now that OP has a better understanding of the reality, which means that she is sharing costs 50:50 and doing all the household and parenting work, the question of a fairer division of work xx and costs has appeared.

Usually, I'm all for fairness in that division, so long as both parties agreed together to share the enterprise.

Promising to go halves in order to get agreement and then trying to change that division further along the road does not, to me, satisfy the fairness test.

Thinking of it as a business venture helps I think to show up that unfairness.

JuneOsborne · 01/12/2022 15:46

You seem articulate and bright. It sounds as though you have had a good career.

If this was a work based problem how would you approach it?

Cold hard facts about the financial situation seem easy to lay out. Your eating into your savings, he's adding to his. You've both had a baby, but your bank balance is suffering. The balance needs restoring. What are the options? That's how I'd approach this. Give him the problem and ask for his solutions. These will tell you a lot about how he views you and your 'worth'. Go from there.

Propertyindisrepair · 01/12/2022 15:17

I think you should ask yourself why you so desperately love someone who’s just not that into you OP.

id say there’s a whole host of issues underlying this…

HungryandIknowit · 01/12/2022 15:01

Based on your last couple of posts and the fact that he doesn't want to get married he doesn't sound very mature or reliable. It also sounds like perhaps you sense that you like him more than he likes you? I may be wrong just picked that up from what you've said. In any case, if he views you as a partnership he should be paying all (factoring in mat pay), and if he views you as individuals (and you're ok with that) he should be paying you for your childcare, cleaning, admin, etc. services at market rate.

ChampagneLassie · 01/12/2022 14:59

Overandunderit · 01/12/2022 14:01

How many red flags do you need. The utter bullshit that some women will put up with from their DPs is staggering. Please want more for you and your DC and do not have another child with this man.

🙋‍♀️I get it. And responses here have given me pause for thought re TTC. I was in denial about how bad it all is. Its not just money at all.

I love him, so much and I really thought with a baby he'd be committed and everything would just evolve naturally. I didnt imagine that it would feel like this. 😥

OP posts:
ChampagneLassie · 01/12/2022 14:55

Propertyindisrepair · 01/12/2022 14:18

@TheMatriarchy as others have said this is a situation where the op has made a unilateral decision to stay at home. No indication her partner is requiring her to do this at all

it seems quite possible if she went back to work he might do more - it hasn’t been discussed because op doesn’t want do it

If I went back to work I imagine I'd have to do more, coordinating nannys/nursery etc. He might pay half cost but I'd be doing bulk of the life admin.

OP posts:
ChampagneLassie · 01/12/2022 14:51

LeavesOnTrees · 30/11/2022 23:24

If you disappeared tomorrow, how much would he have to pay someone to do all the things you do?

Full time nanny, cleaner and housekeeper.
That is what you are bringing to the table financially. As someone who worked in finance it seems odd you've not included this in your part of the 50/50 set up.

I wanted to focus on the practical. Emotional stuff re baby and I had no idea what it was going to be like. I also thought I might want to hire a nanny and workasap, I really didn't know.i guess I wasn't too worried re finances. But I'm reevaulating now, things change.

I think many of responses in this thread have hit on that relationship isn't that secure. Which I fear. We have been doing couples counselling (I initittard as I wanted more emotional intimacy) but its seems like we just go around in circles, he brings up really banal every day things and generally ends up conceding that we're both a bit tired and life is tough with a baby. the counsellor is very feelings focused but it's on the miniutia - ie he says I snapped at him. B/c he took too long getting up to help with baby and counsellor encourages 10 mins of him saying how he feels and then same me saying how I feel about this one incident. I think he thinks relationships should all be like the early days, (I'm first long term woman he's lived with) and is looking for froth and fun and I'm increasingly frustrated he doesn't just value what we have.

OP posts:
Propertyindisrepair · 01/12/2022 14:18

@TheMatriarchy as others have said this is a situation where the op has made a unilateral decision to stay at home. No indication her partner is requiring her to do this at all

it seems quite possible if she went back to work he might do more - it hasn’t been discussed because op doesn’t want do it

Overandunderit · 01/12/2022 14:01

How many red flags do you need. The utter bullshit that some women will put up with from their DPs is staggering. Please want more for you and your DC and do not have another child with this man.

TheMatriarchy · 01/12/2022 13:45

Depending on where you live a fulltime nursery place for one child is about £1200 / month, a cleaner who does all your household cleaning and laundry would be about (say 6hrs a week at £15/hr) £360/month. So say £1600/month is what it would cost to outsource what you are doing, so he should be transferring you £800/month for his share.

This is assuming he does 50% of childcare in evenings and weekends and shares cooking and all other household and child admin equally too. If he doesn't you need to charge extra for that too. Look into fulltime live in nanny costs, its about £35,000 per year.

At the moment he is having his cake and eating, its exploitative of him and in no way should you consider any more children (or carrying on with the relationship) if he doesnt change his ways.

Although personally, I would be getting back to work asap, and adding to my savings and pension again, as someone who is happy to take advantage of their partner like is, is not a long term bet.

Bottom line, without the security of marriage there is no way you should be doing any of his 50% domestic and childcare for free.