Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that Adam White should have never been sent to prison and we're way too soft on career criminals!

230 replies

Unicornenthusiast · 30/11/2022 12:15

I watched 24 Hours in Police Custody on catch up. A father and husband, a completely law abiding tax payer was chasing after two career criminals who had tried to burgle his garage, where he kept thousands of £ worth of tools he needed for work.

Adam White and the two thugs were in an RTC, the thugs were injured and Adam was sentenced to 22 months in prison for GBH. He lost his life savings, his job and his wife had an abortion because she wouldn't have been able to support a new baby and their two existing children whilst he was in prison.

The two thugs received community service...

Here's a link to the full story www.lbc.co.uk/news/adam-white-24-hours-in-police-custody-backlash-fund-raised-crooks-avoid-jail/

Yes he probably shouldn't have chased after the thugs, but he didn't actually intend to harm anyone. Violent domestic abusers and career criminals seem to escape prison sentences all the time, yet a hardworking father had a custodial sentence to set an example.

I feel so sorry for Adam and his wife, especially since they had to make the heartbreaking decision to end her pregnancy due to all this.

OP posts:
AlarmClockMeetWindow · 01/12/2022 05:04

For those who think Adam did right, where does vengeance and vigilantism stop?

Again, I don't agree with it. But, many "rougher" areas used to be much safer for decent people when they were effectively "self-policing".

If we don't want people to do that, then the police and CPS need to do their job properly and get the criminals out of society. Investigate and prosecute properly, and the justice system impose appripriate sentences that are comparable to the severity of the crime, and take into account properly the likelihood of future offending based on a person's history of offending.

There also needs to be proper support for those leaving prison because it is proven that this shows reoffending is massively reduced. They should NOT go back to the same area, same contacts etc and should have someone checking in on them regularly and providing support with jobhunting etc: a scheme like this existed in the early 2000s with fantastic results but was then scrapped.

Thefts, burglaries and violent crimes will increase now as the do during every recession. What is the police's plan to deal with this properly? If they don't have one, then of course people will try to defend themselves, sometimes with tragic consequences. The fault here lies entirely with the "justice" system that provides no justice at all. Burglaries, theft, sexual assault and rape all effectively decriminalised. It's entirely predictable that people would then "take the law into their own hands".

AlarmClockMeetWindow · 01/12/2022 04:44

Suedomin · 30/11/2022 12:27

Yes the criminals were wrong but he has no need to pursue them. You say he didn't intend to harm them what did he Iintend to do? He was driving dangerously chasing them why? He wasn't in danger and they attempted to steal his tools but didn't get them.
We can't allow vigilante justice.

Perhaps because if he'd stayed home and reported it to the police they'd have given him a crime reference number and done no investigation at all. And the next night they would have been out again trying to burgle someone else.

I don't agree with what he did, but the solution here is that the police and CPS do their job and that serial offenders are put and kept in prison.

dealornodeal1 · 01/12/2022 03:17

Threadkillacilla · 30/11/2022 12:34

I do feel sorry for the Whites but you can't get away from what he did. What was he chasing them for? He'd removed the threat to his family and belongings but carried on chasing to do what?
I really wouldn't want to be in that position.

I had a burglar climb through my bedroom window while I was asleep and living alone (silly to have the window open, I know, but I was young). My reaction surprised me. I wanted to kill him. I scared him so much that he ran and I even ran after him for a bit. I caught him trying to break into my home 3 times, in the end and the final time I took the law into my own hands and jumped him and held something sharp to his throat. The police were useless of course. I even found out who it was, a local burglar who had been in prison for the same thing and they didn't do anything.
Unfortunately, we all hope we'll have clarity and do the right thing in the eyes of the law, especially if we have young children at home but instincts take over.

Thebestwaytoscareatory · 01/12/2022 02:04

Florenz · 01/12/2022 00:01

You mean if the criminals had caused death or injury to an innocent party? Yes, absolutely. Look at how many deaths or injuries are caused by criminals now. What do we do? Send them to "prisons" where they get free food, no rent, no mortgage, no bills, free playstation, and who pays for it all? The same law-abiders who are put at risk of criminals in the first place. It's an absolute joke.

You do realise people have agency over their own actions right? You might get away with a heat of the moment decision that injurys someone but the moment you at time into the equation you're going to have to deal with the consequences. White had ample opportunity to stop his course of actions but didn't. Once you start allowing vigilant justice you're on a really slippery slope.

You think it's acceptable to chase after two burglars and run them off the road, so what else is reasonable? Would it be OK to chase them into their homes and knife them or is that too far? How about tracking them down a week later and cutting of their hands?

What about other crimes, are they fair game for vigilante justice and if so which ones? If I see someone texting and driving is it OK for me to spin them off the road?

Allow that sort of action won't improve justice or reduce crime, in fact it will do the opposite.

It would also do you the world of good to try and gain a bit of insight into real prison life instead of what you read on the DM.

Like most things in this country underfunding and poor government leadership are what is causing failures in the justice system. Plenty of studies have shown that the way prisoners are treated has a huge impact on reoffending rates, as does the support available upon release. Norway has one of the, if not the, lowest reoffending rates in the world and they pursue a rehabilitative justice system.

If you want to minimise crime that's the way to do it but too many people like you will screech about "soft-touch" for that to ever happen.

WhirlyTwirly · 01/12/2022 01:29

Florenz · 30/11/2022 23:31

We are ridiculously soft on criminals in this country. There should be no "human rights" for criminals, if you want rights, they come with responsibilities.

Society should be run for the benefit of law-abiders, and criminals dealt with in the most efficient way to keep law-abiders safe and protected from crime.

Totally agree.

They shouldn’t be allowed any compensation as their injuries were sustained due to the crime they had committed and the fact they were riding a stolen motorbike with no insurance themselves. They need to now live with the consequences of their actions.

Yes Adam shouldn’t have chased them but it does look like it was adrenaline led.

Clearly the issue here though is with repeat offenders. Clearly not enough is being done.

VaggieMight · 01/12/2022 01:19

The saddest part of this is that the victim and his partner felt so pressured that they chose to have an abortion.

I was very shocked that he got 22 months in jail. It should have been a suspended sentence.

Had he not given chase, the culprits would have gotten away and the police involvement would have been minimal.

user1477391263 · 01/12/2022 01:12

Difficult topic.

He probably did go too far. But the trouble is that burglary appears to have been effectively decriminalized in the UK. It's inevitable that people are going to start taking the law into their own hands at some point. Why on earth haven't the criminals been put in jail for a long time?

WhyAreAllTheGoodUserNamesUsedUp · 01/12/2022 00:56

I have just watched this programme and found it very sad. Of course he shouldn’t have chased the bulgulars and it’s tragic any harm came to them; if he’d had 5 minutes to think I strongly suspect he wouldn’t have taken this action, but he acted on impulse and it’s a completely natural impulse to protect your family. He would have been high on adrenaline and it was a fight or flight response.
Whilst this could apply in a number of crimes which are not pre-meditated, I think there are clear extenuating and mitigating factors here. He is not a vigilante but a victim who acted unwisely but spontaneously when he was a victim of crime . He poses no risk to others and I cannot see why it was in the public interest for the CPS to persue this.
I have some personal experience of something vaguely similar, albeit thankfully with no one injured. Several years ago we awoke to find burglars in our house. My husband ran out and confronted them on our driveway as they drove our car away ( packed with our possessions). He had no intention of harming them, and it was his safety that was most at risk, and he wouldn’t have taken the risk if he hadn’t acted in the heat of the moment when our family felt threatened ( like Mr White we had two young children in the house and the need to protect them is overwhelming). Of course he couldn’t have stopped them driving away, but he acted on instinct to do something to try and protect us.
A month later our car was found after it crashed in a hit and run. One of the drivers fled, the other was a known recidivist and was tagged after a recent release from prison. Amongst other things, a large Bowie knife and rope was found in the back, but despite a positive ID parade apparently there was not enough evidence to link them to our burgularly and they were not charged. We remain psychologically scarred.
I am a complete pacifist and am abhorrent to any form of retaliation, but I don’t believe any violence was intended here . It’s easy to be judgmental if you haven’t experienced something like this and human psychology tells us that many of us would instinctively act in this way if under extreme threat. Studies have shown that about 20% of people take decisive action in an emergency, about 25% of us become hysterical and the rest of us freeze and don’t know what to do and/ or follow everyone else. It’s the 20% who take action who are most likely to survive a disaster. Admittedly the action here was not well thought through , but little is during an emergency, and that does not make a crime.

Ofcourseshecan · 01/12/2022 00:40

Threadkillacilla · 30/11/2022 12:45

I think his sentence was steep though and the other two should have had minimally double whatever he got. The sad thing is prison will have had an impact on Adam but for the others just a business cost.

If he had caught these thieves and handed them to police, Adam might have saved his friends and neighbours from being robbed.

Theft of work tools is a major loss that can bankrupt a tradesperson. An ordinary builder, plumber or electrician can easily have thousands of pounds worth of tools, which they need to earn their living.

Profit margins may be so tight that some can’t afford insurance, and others are badly hit by rising insurance premiums if the make a claim. It’s a widespread crime because it’s guaranteed profitable at very little risk. People who call themselves “honest” buy stolen tools at boot sales, even with identifying marks visible or obviously scraped off.

Even if the thieves are caught, the penalties are low.

I can’t help wondering if that’s due to class bias in the legal system: the victims are ordinary working-class people. They don’t really matter.

Maverickess · 01/12/2022 00:22

I don't think the main issue here is the fact Adam White got a sentence for what he did - although I think it was heavy considering the circumstances, but, he could have killed or injured himself or anyone else on the roads or pavement and as impulsive as the decision was, he does need to face the concequences of that.

I think the main issue is the lack of action against the career criminals who have previously committed so many crimes, and who were free to commit more, who were fleeing the scene of an attempted crime, on a stolen motorcycle (another crime) with no tax, insurance or helmets (more crimes) and who now stand to make money in compensate for the whole incident. And who were then apparently caught in another untaxed and uninsured car (yet more crime). And yet they're free to continue with this? What are they suing for? Loss of earnings from the burglaries they couldn't commit because they were injured?!

The main issue here, as with so many others, is that this man and his family have had their lives completely ruined and they will likely never recover from that, where as the career criminals stand to come out of this better than before. That's all kinds of wrong and why people are so pissed off about it.

kierenthecommunity · 01/12/2022 00:02

He got locked up for GBH but wasn’t the charge one of causing serious injury by dangerous driving? Which is what he did. He took a gamble pleading not guilty as there was quite a lot of evidence.

Florenz · 01/12/2022 00:01

hugznotdrugz · 30/11/2022 23:58

If he had of caused death or injury to a innocent party due to his driving would you still feel the same?

You mean if the criminals had caused death or injury to an innocent party? Yes, absolutely. Look at how many deaths or injuries are caused by criminals now. What do we do? Send them to "prisons" where they get free food, no rent, no mortgage, no bills, free playstation, and who pays for it all? The same law-abiders who are put at risk of criminals in the first place. It's an absolute joke.

hugznotdrugz · 30/11/2022 23:58

If he had of caused death or injury to a innocent party due to his driving would you still feel the same?

Florenz · 30/11/2022 23:55

FrauleinEngelhart · 30/11/2022 23:40

@Florenz agree. So logically, chasing after the 2 criminals with a 2 ton weapon (Large 4 x 4) with intent to harm is worthy of punishment too ? If he'd inadvertently hit a pedestrian would that be ok ?
What happened to the neighbour's pick up he trashed ? Some criminal damage going on there no ?

Chasing after criminals in order to protect your home, family and property is perfectly OK, yes. If he'd hit a pedestrian, charge the criminals as they are the causation. Same as if someone causes an accident and a non-fault driver hits an unoccupied, parked vehicle. It doesn't go against the non-fault driver, it goes against the fault driver, even though they didn't make contact with the parked vehicle.

Peedoffo · 30/11/2022 23:55

Yuck the most he should have got was a suspended sentence. He was law abiding previously until provoked by two career criminal scumbags who will carry on thieving.

drpet49 · 30/11/2022 23:52

Lockheart · 30/11/2022 12:25

So nothing of his was actually stolen, and he caused a dangerous car accident some time after the attempted burglary when the other two were no longer on his property or a risk to him and his family?

It sounds like the right course of action was taken.

This

FlorettaB · 30/11/2022 23:51

Ok, attempted burglary, which will obviously carry a lower sentence than burglary and a guilty plea which automatically means a lighter sentence.

I would have no problem with the two burglars being sent to prison but it can’t be acceptable for someone to run them off the road for their crime. They were on a motorbike. It’s pure chance that they’re not paralysed or dead. If you’ve witnessed a motorbike accident and seen the violence with which a body is sent flying through the air you’ll never forget it. For those who seem to think it’s acceptable because they were criminals, think about all the other road users. Driving recklessly, chasing a motorbike, it was pure chance that no one else was hurt. You can’t have people doing that.

FrauleinEngelhart · 30/11/2022 23:40

@Florenz agree. So logically, chasing after the 2 criminals with a 2 ton weapon (Large 4 x 4) with intent to harm is worthy of punishment too ? If he'd inadvertently hit a pedestrian would that be ok ?
What happened to the neighbour's pick up he trashed ? Some criminal damage going on there no ?

Florenz · 30/11/2022 23:31

We are ridiculously soft on criminals in this country. There should be no "human rights" for criminals, if you want rights, they come with responsibilities.

Society should be run for the benefit of law-abiders, and criminals dealt with in the most efficient way to keep law-abiders safe and protected from crime.

jcyclops · 30/11/2022 23:25

Sentences don't seem wrong based on the facts. White should have been advised to plead guilty.

One man convicted by jury of "causing serious injury by dangerous driving" after pleading not guilty.
Two other men convicted of (non-violent) "attempted burglary" after pleading guilty.

As usual, what is wrong with the UK's justice system is that February to September is 22 months.

Judijudi · 30/11/2022 23:20

The 2 who attempted to burgle his home were disgusting but it in no way means he should be allowed to deliberately run them off the motorbike with his big powerful car, he has no right to take the law into his hands. They were stealing, but he deliberately tried to injure them that does not compare.

WatchoRulo · 30/11/2022 23:14

FlorettaB · 30/11/2022 16:59

They didn’t actually break in though did they AFAIK. So maybe going equipped?

Both the scrotes pleaded guilty to attempted burglary.

AlexaM86 · 30/11/2022 23:02

The whole thing just shows how out of touch the CPS are with the public. I really hope this sparks a review and reform of it in its entirety or we will definitely see more vigilantism. I don’t think many would question Adam getting some form of sentence if the other two had actually received decent sentences themselves. Especially given Adam’s willingness to help with investigations and clear remorse versus their indignant silence and continued offending. No wonder people are reluctant to interact with the police.

It reflects poorly on the police, but in truth a lot of them have the same frustrations with the CPS.

I personally feel that minimum sentences should double each time a person is convicted of a crime - I genuinely don’t care if that means someone ends up with 25 years for petty theft if they’ve done it that many times.

WatchoRulo · 30/11/2022 22:27

The justice system has operated to protect the thieves - shown a warning that people can't act in response to their actions. The decent people have had to move house, presumably because the system can't (or won't) protect them from reprisals by scum. It all looks a bit one-sided.

WatchoRulo · 30/11/2022 22:25

I've had a chance to watch this now. The two thieves were playing the system - claiming not remember things they'd discussed their memory of on camera with others. One claimed to be too badly injured to be interviewed after the incident but Police found him as the passenger in a vehicle driven by the other scrote. That vehicle was on false number plates and wasn't registered to either of them.
If an "example" had to be made of Mr White for his actions, when will it be time for the thieving scrotes to be shown that society in general won't tolerate their actions? Or is it, as it appears to many of us, that the justice system can only punish honest people who have something to lose.

Swipe left for the next trending thread