Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that Adam White should have never been sent to prison and we're way too soft on career criminals!

230 replies

Unicornenthusiast · 30/11/2022 12:15

I watched 24 Hours in Police Custody on catch up. A father and husband, a completely law abiding tax payer was chasing after two career criminals who had tried to burgle his garage, where he kept thousands of £ worth of tools he needed for work.

Adam White and the two thugs were in an RTC, the thugs were injured and Adam was sentenced to 22 months in prison for GBH. He lost his life savings, his job and his wife had an abortion because she wouldn't have been able to support a new baby and their two existing children whilst he was in prison.

The two thugs received community service...

Here's a link to the full story www.lbc.co.uk/news/adam-white-24-hours-in-police-custody-backlash-fund-raised-crooks-avoid-jail/

Yes he probably shouldn't have chased after the thugs, but he didn't actually intend to harm anyone. Violent domestic abusers and career criminals seem to escape prison sentences all the time, yet a hardworking father had a custodial sentence to set an example.

I feel so sorry for Adam and his wife, especially since they had to make the heartbreaking decision to end her pregnancy due to all this.

OP posts:
Thebestwaytoscareatory · 01/12/2022 13:50

AlfredBasedman · 01/12/2022 13:13

I wouldn’t go as far as amputating limbs, but I think we should be looking at minimum 10 year sentences for any offences that involve breaking into family homes, if we have to cram our prisons to bursting point to achieve that, so be it.

So you're increasing prisons terms but just for burglary offenses? That doesn't seem very "just" to me. If you want "proper justice" you'd need to increase terms across the board, but that would mean any future Adam White would be looking at 22+ years inside instead of 22 months.

Increasing prison sentences also does nothing to address the underlying causes of crime and increases the liklihood of turning petty criminals into hardened ones with zero prospects when they're eventually released.

Charlieiscool · 01/12/2022 13:32

I noticed that during the interview it showed that the lawyer he’d had to pay for did nothing. He shouldn’t have chased them admittedly; he should have left them to carry on supporting their expanding families with further crime with no consequences or impedance by the police. When the career criminals were interviewed they had a lawyer butting in and they went “no comment” and got away with it all. The one with the head injury wasn’t wearing a helmet and all their injuries were arguably self inflicted. I think Adam was guilty but he was the one that should have got community service.

Laughingravy · 01/12/2022 13:30

Charlielr
They got all their defence paid for by the tax payer, whilst Adam had to spend his life savings on paying for a defence.

The little of our justice system that works only works for the poor and the rich. Those in the middle get the justice they can afford, because of the massive cuts to legal aid. If Adam had been found not guilty there would be no guarantee his legal expenses would be covered. Our justice system can be as effective at leaving those caught in it destitute and distraught as a criminal act on them can.

I can recommend reading The Secret Barrister book, though it's often not to good for the blood pressure.

ThisGirlNever · 01/12/2022 13:28

If I'm ever on a jury deliberating a case such as this, I won't convict the victim.

You can't be held accountable for coming to the 'wrong' decision. Unfortunately, too many people clearly think they have to make the 'right' decision and we end up with cases like these.

Lawyers should be free to tell the jury 'if you don't think the accused has actually done anything wrong, you're free to return a Not Guilty verdict.' The powers that be don't want people to know that, though, so it's illegal.

Spread the word!

en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jury_nullification

XanaduKira · 01/12/2022 13:28

Charlielr · 01/12/2022 12:45

I think it’s more the fact that the criminals actually didn’t get a prison sentence and they got enjoy living with this family, carry on living their ‘life’ and one had a new born. They got all their defence paid for by the tax payer, whilst Adam had to spend his life savings on paying for a defence. Adam helped the police in their interviews, whilst the others were ‘no comment’ interviews.

None of this would not have happened if it wasn’t due to the actions in the criminals in the first place.

Its absolutely this. It's shocking that the actual criminals didn't get a custodial sentence. I agree that sentences for burglary should be much harsher - definitely significant jail time as right now there is no deterrent at all.

AlfredBasedman · 01/12/2022 13:13

Thebestwaytoscareatory · 01/12/2022 13:08

What is "proper justice" exactly?

Hellhole prisons with no luxuries or entertainment?

Draconian sentences for all offenders? 10 years and a hand chopped of for burglary maybe?

I wouldn’t go as far as amputating limbs, but I think we should be looking at minimum 10 year sentences for any offences that involve breaking into family homes, if we have to cram our prisons to bursting point to achieve that, so be it.

Thebestwaytoscareatory · 01/12/2022 13:08

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

What is "proper justice" exactly?

Hellhole prisons with no luxuries or entertainment?

Draconian sentences for all offenders? 10 years and a hand chopped of for burglary maybe?

Charlielr · 01/12/2022 12:45

I think it’s more the fact that the criminals actually didn’t get a prison sentence and they got enjoy living with this family, carry on living their ‘life’ and one had a new born. They got all their defence paid for by the tax payer, whilst Adam had to spend his life savings on paying for a defence. Adam helped the police in their interviews, whilst the others were ‘no comment’ interviews.

None of this would not have happened if it wasn’t due to the actions in the criminals in the first place.

AlfredBasedman · 01/12/2022 12:44

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

TortugaRumCakeQueen · 01/12/2022 12:39

astronewt · 30/11/2022 12:58

No. No. No.

Your line of thinking is exactly how we move back towards a world in which you can lynch a Black man for being accused of assaulting a white woman and the law will quietly look the other way, because you're a "good hardworking honest person" and everyone knows black people are shifty and violent and dangerous.

Remember the name Emmett Till? Because you should. The fourteen-year-old boy who was beaten, shot, and dumped in the river because he was accused of flirting with a white woman and his murderers were acquitted. That's what you're endorsing. More Emmett Tills.

That's quite a stretch, must have taken some mental gymnastics that. 🙄

wombat1a · 01/12/2022 12:32

The flip side is thou if they had been sentenced severely for their previous trips to court they wouldn't have been on the streets to continue their life of crime. If we had a 3 strikes and out syste,m where they had gone down for 5 years for a 3rd burglary then they wouldn't have been able to provoke this man in the first place.

MichelleScarn · 01/12/2022 12:15

Can't believe all the apologists for the career criminals! 'Oh they didn't actually get a chance to burgle, they only went equipped'...
Am surprised no one's brought up that they probably had a hard childhood poor lambs and it's their way of life so what's to be expected.

OldTinHat · 01/12/2022 12:09

Don't forget the serious injury was in part due to one of the scrotes not wearing a helmet. The injuries wouldn't have been so severe if he'd worn one.

I believed AW when he said he lost control on the bend and clipped them. He said that from the beginning, even moments after the crash when he was clearly in shock.

I believe a dangerous driving conviction would have been appropriate, but GBH and a prison term? That's so wrong imo. Suspended, yes, but actual prison time, no.

I wonder what the jury think now after seeing the programme and if they still stand by their decision.

BigSandyBalls2015 · 01/12/2022 11:56

The jury had to find him guilty because he did it!!

I was also enraged watching it but he shouldn't have done that. Obv if those scrotes weren't on his property attempting to rob him, they wouldn't have been injured, but we can't all go around behaving like that. They should also have been jailed for their part in it, they've both got criminal records for all sorts of shit and are a far more worry on the streets than Adam.

DH has a nice car on the drive, his pride and joy. I don't sleep as heavily as him and I sometimes hear voices outside. If I saw his car being stolen I wouldn't even wake him as I would worry he would do something stupid like this in the heat of the moment.

AccioChocolate · 01/12/2022 11:50

He was wrong because he chased them, that was really stupid. But you're not wrong that it should never have happened in the first place and they should have done time for their part in it

Laughingravy · 01/12/2022 11:47

Maverickess
It's all about Adam's behaviour, how he should have been better, what he should and shouldn't have done, how we're apparently holding him to higher standards than the burglars and not about the chosen actions of the two people that started all this in the first place.

Whichever Govt department or organisation for one reason and another it's become all about easy targets. Dealing with recidivists, tax dodgers, child support dodgers etc etc is often difficult and expensive so go for the low hanging fruit and hit those targets.

Adam's sentence was harsh but it may make the law abiding, like you and I, think twice about our actions. What's making everyone angry is the 'justice; dealt out to the pair of criminals won't make a single one think twice about the pain and misery they mete out by their behaviour.

XanaduKira · 01/12/2022 08:53

MatildaTheCat · 30/11/2022 12:28

I feel extremely sorry for Adam and his wife. He didn’t set out with the intention of injuring them, he was acting purely on adrenaline. He could easily have been killed himself in the ensuing crash.

I was surprised he was found guilty and sent to prison given all the circumstances and was enraged that the actual criminals didn’t even get a custodial sentence‘because it would have been hard for them given their injuries.’

I wish the Whites well and hope their lives can be recovered.

Totally agree with this.

Maverickess · 01/12/2022 08:37

You do realise people have agency over their own actions right? You might get away with a heat of the moment decision that injurys someone but the moment you at time into the equation you're going to have to deal with the consequences.

I think the issue many are having is that only seems to apply to Adam White and not the criminals who have done this so often they're called career criminals.
They're not, nor does it appear they've had to in the past (being free and all to burgle Adam's house in the first place and then get caught in a car with no tax or insurance and now not locked up either) facing the concequences of their actions, they too had agency over their actions and too chose to break the law, likely because they knew there'd be no concequences, or even if caught they'd be minimal compared to the damage they cause to their victims. And theirs wasn't a spur of the moment, defensive decision. They chose to break into someone else's property with the intention of stealing their possessions for their own gain, and chose to make off on a stolen motorcycle not wearing helmets.
If we're going to rehabilitate criminals, we first need to put some effort into actually catching them and then rehabilitation, as it is even if caught, the concequences are so low they don't serve as a deterrent or rehabilitation. In fact these two are going to be rewarded with compensation.
It's really a rather lazy way to distribute justice, to harshly punish those who defend themselves because the justice system doesn't, to put people off doing that, rather than tackle the issue of the two thugs who made a life out of crime and lock them away to protect society or rehabilitate them so they don't offend again.

It's all about Adam's behaviour, how he should have been better, what he should and shouldn't have done, how we're apparently holding him to higher standards than the burglars and not about the chosen actions of the two people that started all this in the first place.

AlarmClockMeetWindow · 01/12/2022 08:18

Nope. I'm saying bright people don't tend to go around stealing vehicles and trying to burgle people repeatedly.

Ponoka7 · 01/12/2022 07:23

AlarmClockMeetWindow · 01/12/2022 05:14

Probably make little difference at all to people of their level of intelligence.

So if people who have learning difficulties/disabilities crack their skull, it makes no difference? What a stupid comment. Do you think that all criminals have low intelligence and those who do naturally have low intelligence (such as those who have LD's) are natural criminals? That used to be the attitude at the turn of the century.
A lot of the language used on this thread takes us back to a time when making an allegation against a man of ' good standing in the community', married, working, priest etc would have been a waste of time. Very few women would be believed, or victim blamed if the man was 'decent'. The working class had no chance against someone of a higher status etc etc.

FlorettaB · 01/12/2022 06:37

’However, truly decent people do not go off on vigilante missions’

I think that’s very harsh. I don’t think that any of us can know how we’d react to a situation like that. People who think they’d confront the burglars might well freeze - it’s a common reaction. People who are generally very calm and rational might find they react aggressively.

I don’t know anything about Adam White as a person and while I think it’s right that he’s held accountable for the consequences of his actions - he did cause serious injury - it’s entirely possible that he’s a decent, reasonable man who had a moment of madness in response to a stressful situation.

poefaced · 01/12/2022 06:19

What did Adam spend £50k on? His legal defence?

Snugglemonkey · 01/12/2022 06:01

AlfredBasedman · 30/11/2022 12:26

I agree OP. Decent people are being trod all over by scum while middle class liberal bedwetters bleat on about how letting criminals do what they want is a sign of a ‘civilised society’.

Noone is advocating that criminals do what they want. However, truly decent people do not go off on vigilante missions. They think about how their actions may impact others, especially when vehicles are involved. A car can easily be a killing machine. He behaved like a thug. He is paying a high price, but he could have killed people and that is not ok.

MintyFreshOne · 01/12/2022 05:23

If you want to minimise crime that's the way to do it but too many people like you will screech about "soft-touch" for that to ever happen

I don’t think Norway’s system is going to work in the UK. Population is not diverse there and the social welfare system much stronger.

You will more likely have America’s experience with rehabilitative justice in blue states, which has just led to more crime.

AlarmClockMeetWindow · 01/12/2022 05:14

Cheesuswithallama · 30/11/2022 13:22

I wouldn't say cracked skull is getting off....

Probably make little difference at all to people of their level of intelligence.

Swipe left for the next trending thread