Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that Adam White should have never been sent to prison and we're way too soft on career criminals!

230 replies

Unicornenthusiast · 30/11/2022 12:15

I watched 24 Hours in Police Custody on catch up. A father and husband, a completely law abiding tax payer was chasing after two career criminals who had tried to burgle his garage, where he kept thousands of £ worth of tools he needed for work.

Adam White and the two thugs were in an RTC, the thugs were injured and Adam was sentenced to 22 months in prison for GBH. He lost his life savings, his job and his wife had an abortion because she wouldn't have been able to support a new baby and their two existing children whilst he was in prison.

The two thugs received community service...

Here's a link to the full story www.lbc.co.uk/news/adam-white-24-hours-in-police-custody-backlash-fund-raised-crooks-avoid-jail/

Yes he probably shouldn't have chased after the thugs, but he didn't actually intend to harm anyone. Violent domestic abusers and career criminals seem to escape prison sentences all the time, yet a hardworking father had a custodial sentence to set an example.

I feel so sorry for Adam and his wife, especially since they had to make the heartbreaking decision to end her pregnancy due to all this.

OP posts:
Thebestwaytoscareatory · 02/12/2022 02:33

healthadvice123 · 01/12/2022 22:41

@Thebestwaytoscareatory I never made assumptions about you , but you did about me , you tagged me not the other way.
And your caring nature obviously doesn't extend to all
Lots of people have bad childhoods they don't all become criminals and even if they do if punishment were better maybe it would deter more.
Also understanding that as people feel like the poilce and justice system isn't fit for purpose more things like this will happen.

The first time you @'ed me you said "some just don't want to change no matter what do gooders think who never ever spoken to anyone like this."

So you assumed that a) I was a "do gooder" (whatever that is) and b) I'd never spoken with someone who was hardened criminal, both of which are wrong tbh.

You've also assumed I have a caring nature, but that's only half true. There's many many people I'd love to help but equally there's just as many who I'd gladly watch drown, hell I'd even push more than a few in to be quite honest.

Thebestwaytoscareatory · 02/12/2022 02:21

ThisGirlNever · 01/12/2022 20:37

@Thebestwaytoscareatory People like you are the reason crime is out of control.

We had our catalytic converter stolen last year and it ruined Christmas because we couldn't drive to visit relatives - not to mention the repair bills. I don't give a fuck if the thieving scum had difficult childhoods. I had a traumatic childhood and I don't go around stealing shit from other people.

The career criminals in this case deserve the birch and a long stretch inside. If they'd been stamped on the first time they were caught, they might not have tried their luck a second, third, fourth, fifth, sixth, seventh and eighth time.

Fuck 'em.

People like me are the cause of increasing crime?

People like me, who want to tackle the root cause, properly fund and resource the justice system, and help stop offenders from reoffending through rehabilitation are the cause. Who knew!?

And here's me thinking it's the people who've systematically underfunding and destroyed the justice system over the last decade or so that shouldered that responsibility.

Silly old me.

Laughingravy · 02/12/2022 01:05

healthadvice123
I didn't see the Episode so can't say if he ran them off the road or gave chase to try and catch them, but he got prison they never, they were armed with things that could be weapons and were entering a house with children etc yet that wasn't taken in account

He was charged with a moving traffic offence, namely causing serious injury by dangerous driving. The who and the why of those that were injured isn't relevant with such a charge. Any mitigating circumstances could be taken into account in sentencing.
And they didn't actually get chance to attempt to get in, he disturbed them as they were checking it out. Also they were after his motorcycle, which was in the garage not the house.

healthadvice123 · 01/12/2022 22:44

@Thebestwaytoscareatory ai don't align myself with anyone either , I have my own thoughts .

healthadvice123 · 01/12/2022 22:42

@Branleuse yes but dd he hope to just catch them somehow in a moment of madness as opposed to run them off the road on purpose? I have no idea

healthadvice123 · 01/12/2022 22:41

@Thebestwaytoscareatory I never made assumptions about you , but you did about me , you tagged me not the other way.
And your caring nature obviously doesn't extend to all
Lots of people have bad childhoods they don't all become criminals and even if they do if punishment were better maybe it would deter more.
Also understanding that as people feel like the poilce and justice system isn't fit for purpose more things like this will happen.

Branleuse · 01/12/2022 21:44

healthadvice123 · 01/12/2022 19:55

@Branleuse but maybe community service etc and not prison and maybe if we had more poilce to show up and feel that when people do get caught they are punished
Having been burgled and ny kids being petrified if being in their own home , I hated the burglar and he swans around without a care , I would of felt better if his life was impacted more by punishment.
I get we can't all be vigilantes but its often adrenaline and nit thinking and going in survival mode that makes people act irrationally , a recent case people on here were all agreeing with the reaction
We have to get tougher to stop more people feeling like they have to take in to their own hands

Ive also been burgled too. Its a horrible feeling.
If he had got hold of them straight away and battered them Id say fair enough. Using your massive car as a weapon though is another thing entirely.

BrotherlyNonLove · 01/12/2022 20:39

I really hope those 2 scallies get their comeuppance.

ThisGirlNever · 01/12/2022 20:37

@Thebestwaytoscareatory People like you are the reason crime is out of control.

We had our catalytic converter stolen last year and it ruined Christmas because we couldn't drive to visit relatives - not to mention the repair bills. I don't give a fuck if the thieving scum had difficult childhoods. I had a traumatic childhood and I don't go around stealing shit from other people.

The career criminals in this case deserve the birch and a long stretch inside. If they'd been stamped on the first time they were caught, they might not have tried their luck a second, third, fourth, fifth, sixth, seventh and eighth time.

Fuck 'em.

Thebestwaytoscareatory · 01/12/2022 20:28

healthadvice123 · 01/12/2022 18:56

@Thebestwaytoscareatory what is you people supposed to mean , what do you mean by that , and you have no idea about my life or interaction with people
And at no point did I say it was ok to torture someone
But many many live in povertt etc they all turn in to criminals and some of the worst ones have had good lifes as well
But victims need to always be put ahead of the criminal , my kids did not deserve to feel unsafe in their home due to one random repeat offender who gives zero shits about anyone

You people = those on this thread defending acts of vigilantism, some of whom have said they think it is ok to torture burglars to death, that's the type of people you align yourself with when you support vigilante justice.

I have as much an idea as to your life and interaction with people as you do about me. Why are you allowed to make assumptions and judgements on my character/life but I can't do the same to you?

No, your kids don't deserve to feel unsafe in their home due to one persons actions but then the repeat offender I spoke about in a previous post didn't deserve to be raped by multiply men and his dad for 2 years either. You know what will reduce the chances of either of those things happening again? Addressing the underlying societal causes of crime, surely it would be better to stop things like that happening in the first place rather than just focusing punishing those who do end up offending?

AllyCatTown · 01/12/2022 20:15

I get that vigilantism shouldn’t be encouraged but my main issue with it is bystanders and innocent people being caught up in it. If I’d been on the jury in cases like Sarah Sands I’d have found not guilty.

bellabasset · 01/12/2022 20:11

I watched the programme and it made me very sad that this man ended up in prison due to his reaction to those scrotes who broke into his house. A bloody waste of space earning their living by thieving from others.

I've got my Irish families temper - as well as my English grans. I don't think of danger if someone's in trouble. In Ireland a young man was being beaten by other young me and I walked out in case my dsis car was damaged, it stopped the fight and fortunately the lad only had a broken arm and fingers and his head wound was superficial as I'd stopped him from being clubbed with a scaffolding pole.

What surprised my dm when I passed my test first time in my 30's was that I'm a calmer driver than my dsis. I remember saying that a car was a lethal weapon.

The scrotes hadn't got into the family home or done any damage. But Adam foolishly got into his powerful £30,000 Merc and was speeding when he rounded a bend losing control of his car. It was quite an impact as the bike smashed into two other vehicles. As another poster said he could have killed an innocent bystander(s). But whilst I understand why he was charged and that justice was done under the law morally It's another story. I hope the scrotes get nothing for their claim.

Angelofthenortheast · 01/12/2022 20:10

The fact that the two robbers didn't even want to prosecute is enough for me to agree. That young guys three children would've been far better off with him IN jail, as opposed to Adam White's child who now doesn't even exist and his poor wife...it was awful

healthadvice123 · 01/12/2022 19:56

@Snnowflake yes police don't get a say just present evidence etc

healthadvice123 · 01/12/2022 19:55

@Branleuse but maybe community service etc and not prison and maybe if we had more poilce to show up and feel that when people do get caught they are punished
Having been burgled and ny kids being petrified if being in their own home , I hated the burglar and he swans around without a care , I would of felt better if his life was impacted more by punishment.
I get we can't all be vigilantes but its often adrenaline and nit thinking and going in survival mode that makes people act irrationally , a recent case people on here were all agreeing with the reaction
We have to get tougher to stop more people feeling like they have to take in to their own hands

WheelOfFish · 01/12/2022 19:53

If our legal system was fit for purpose and could be relied on to provide some kind of semblance of ‘justice’ then maybe people wouldn’t feel like they needed to take the law into their own hands.

Increasingly the only people who seem to suffer the consequences of their actions are the generally law-abiding middle. The rich pay to get off and for the scumbags it’s the price of doing business.

Branleuse · 01/12/2022 19:26

healthadvice123 · 01/12/2022 19:05

@Branleuse well if the police were to show up then yes they would of chased and many a time a criminal had run off the road being chased
I didn't see the Episode so can't say if he ran them off the road or gave chase to try and catch them, but he got prison they never, they were armed with things that could be weapons and were entering a house with children etc yet that wasn't taken in account
If someone breaks into my house I will defend it and hit them with the nearest thing if I feel threatened.
TradesMen have their tools stolen a lot and its crippling , he never intended to cause them injury , they will of planned their burglary and are then joking about it all

The law is fairly clear on what constitutes self defence, and this isnt it. The burglars had left.
He did what most people would want to probably do. Track the bastards down and give them a kicking. He went and chased them in a car in a rage. You just cant do that and get away with it. It could have been him that got killed or an innocemt pedestrian.
Theres a lot of things that are tempting to do in retaliation when we are wronged, but we cant just do them. No matter how tempting.

Snnowflake · 01/12/2022 19:13

Not sure why the police are being blamed surely it's the justice system that imprisoned one and let off the others.

healthadvice123 · 01/12/2022 19:05

@Branleuse well if the police were to show up then yes they would of chased and many a time a criminal had run off the road being chased
I didn't see the Episode so can't say if he ran them off the road or gave chase to try and catch them, but he got prison they never, they were armed with things that could be weapons and were entering a house with children etc yet that wasn't taken in account
If someone breaks into my house I will defend it and hit them with the nearest thing if I feel threatened.
TradesMen have their tools stolen a lot and its crippling , he never intended to cause them injury , they will of planned their burglary and are then joking about it all

Royalbloo · 01/12/2022 19:01

Agreed Branleuse

Royalbloo · 01/12/2022 19:00

And aren't the police tasked with preservation of life (all life) first?

healthadvice123 · 01/12/2022 18:59

@Cheesuswithallama its also a fact that many many who have hard childhoods don't become criminals and also thats some had perfectly good childhoods
If the punishment was stricture it would deter more and repeat offenders not let if lightly to continue to cause major trauma to others then maybe the numbers would drop, and prison actually a punishment

Branleuse · 01/12/2022 18:57

Sounds like they likely did take circumstances into account which will be why he got less than 2 years.
Fact is that was not self defence. You dont do a car chase and run people off the road ,even burglars.

healthadvice123 · 01/12/2022 18:56

@Thebestwaytoscareatory what is you people supposed to mean , what do you mean by that , and you have no idea about my life or interaction with people
And at no point did I say it was ok to torture someone
But many many live in povertt etc they all turn in to criminals and some of the worst ones have had good lifes as well
But victims need to always be put ahead of the criminal , my kids did not deserve to feel unsafe in their home due to one random repeat offender who gives zero shits about anyone

Royalbloo · 01/12/2022 18:54

...but cannot imagine if I were in the same situation I could wholeheartedly say it wasn't my fault, when questioned.