Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask for no photos/videos to be taken at school performance?

283 replies

Christmasbahhumbug · 30/11/2022 10:42

DD can’t be in photos/videos online. There are genuine reasons for this. School are very good and I think would put a ban in place if I (or any other parent) asked.

In previous years I have kept her home on special nursery/school days where photos/videos might be taken.

Over the summer, DD really wanted to join in and school allowed photos/videos and asked parents to keep them off SM but unsurprisingly this was ignored.

I get it, I really do. I would love a picture/video of DD having fun/performing with all of her friends but we just can’t.

Do I deny other parents/grandparents/children that pleasure by asking for no photos/videos or yet again have DD miss out completely?

OP posts:
Saltywalruss · 30/11/2022 15:33

also I would be very upset if I wasn't allowed to take a video myself

Why would you be "very upset"? You don't need to record everything your child does. Of course it's nice to have a video of theirs nativity, but it's not something to get upset about.

The photos/filming of a school performance is not the purpose of it!

Saltywalruss · 30/11/2022 15:23

Henuinequest · 30/11/2022 12:04

No, it's 1) not fair on everyone else 2) not enforceable. People will take sneaky pics.
Try to make sure your DC isn't in obvious grp photos and if you do see SM posts with your kid in the pic speak to school who will speak to the parents.
Sorry, but the world doesn't revolve around you.

🙄

Adultchildofelderlyparents · 30/11/2022 14:48

@CulturePigeon I wholeheartedly agree with you!

Fink · 30/11/2022 14:22

I know you've updated to say you'll withdraw her, but honestly I would still speak to the school.

It shouldn't be hard to enforce, if the school are good and come down on people who break the ban. No photos and video during the performance, possibly they could even announce that we have some vulnerable children who are at risk of significant harm if their images are seen on social media. Maybe that would convince some of the real hard of thinking.

I think the school should set aside some time after the performance for parents to take photos of their own children in their costume, which is all you really need as a keepsake anyway. If you tell people in advance they'll have that opportunity, it should minimise the perceived 'need' to record the actual performance.

CarefreeMe · 30/11/2022 14:17

YABU

Lots of children aren’t allowed photos and I guarantee your child won’t be the only one.

If someone posts a photo on SM then report it and get it removed.
No one should be having photos of anyone else’s child up without their permission.

Snugglemonkey · 30/11/2022 14:15

walkinwardrobe · 30/11/2022 13:22

To be honest I think that whilst it would be nice for a community, in this case a school, to come together for the benefit of an individual, I don't think it's realistic, and at the end of the day if there is a real possibility that your child could come to harm, I'd have to take the responsibility upon myself, and not let her participate, however difficult that may be.
I would say however , to be prepared for when your child is older. You will have zero chance of policing other children's social media, however much you may like to. At some point your child is going to end up online. In the same way that someone with an airborne allergy won't know and can't control what others on a train are eating, for example you won't be able to stop unknown pre-teens randomly posting stuff. Hopefully by that time their appearance will have changed enough for it not to be so risky.

I disagree that it is unrealistic, because our school has. We have a photo ban and people respect it. The school shares appropriate images. We also have a nut free school. There are plenty of examples of schools coming together as a community and the safety of a child is definitely a good reason for it. Any parent who posts anything that has not been approved should be banned from attending all future school events.

PonkyPonky · 30/11/2022 13:59

Of course you want to keep your child safe so YANBU on that front. But from another point of view, I am desperately hoping to be able to record some of my sons first nativity as DH can’t get out of a work thing so is going to miss it. I would never dream of putting the footage online and I wouldn’t have thought anyone else would do either. We have a lot of military families in our school so I would hope that videoing would be allowed for all the absent parents. So hopefully in my case they’ll allow it with a strict no SM rule. I would try and get your child into a role where their face was covered from now on. It’s not great for the people who can’t make it if they miss that memory entirely

twoshedsjackson · 30/11/2022 13:55

Similar arrangement at the music festival where I volunteer; no filming/photography during the performance, a chance to take a picture afterwards (especially if brandishing a trophy!) having made sure that no child is in the picture without prior permission. We have had at least one instance where the parents of a prizewinner had to ask that her victorious result should not be posted on our website.
In my friend's choir, there are two girls who know without prompting that they should discreetly withdraw from photo-ops; at the moment, your daughter may be too young to understand, but that will come.

wildseas · 30/11/2022 13:44

@Christmasbahhumbug you might have already thought of this and realised it isn't possible but just incase its helpful - I have also seen this dealt with by schools the other way round.

So, when handing out the parts for the play the child who can't be photographed is the narrator (and is positioned on a seperate podium at the back of the hall behind the audience); is dressed as a sheep/cow etc and wears a full face mask; is an angel and is covered in glitter and floaty bits all over which disguises their face etc. That way the photos aren't a danger because child is unidentifiable. This has the benefit that you don't have to discuss with the child - its just their part/costume.

I have also seen it done where cameras are banned during the performance but there is a "curtain call" at the end when children go up for pictures which is announced to parents beforehand. Your child participates in the play but doesn't go up for the pictures.

I would say that in both of those cases you have to risk assess because there is still a small chance it could get onto socials (eg if child removes mask and a parent snaps a picture at that moment) but it massively reduces the chance.

Potatosaladfiend · 30/11/2022 13:39

@Christmasbahhumbug
As an alternative would the school allow you to come in and watch the dress rehearsal? (Which she could take part in?)
Our school are brilliant and have a blanket no photo rule. They say that any parents caught trying to sneak a photo will be told to delete it and leave immediately (they even had the local pc come to watch the nativity and explain the child protection reasoning before the show.)
They video the performance and then share stills/blurred out videos with parents afterwards. I’ve never seen any photos taken or any shared so it seems to work.

JustLyra · 30/11/2022 13:37

DD’s school is super strict on this. The HT previously had an issue with a violent ex turning up having spotted a child in a photo some idiot had posted on a community Facebook page with literally thousands of followers.

They don’t allow photos during the performance. At the end they recreate a few scenes that can be photographed and people can also take individual photos of their child.

Anyone who tries to take photos during performances is asked to leave and banned from all future school events (and she sticks to it).

milkysmum · 30/11/2022 13:29

Always been the case in DCs school. No photos/ filming during performances. At the end parents are invited to take photos of their own child/ small group ( eg of shepherds ) on stage.

EilonwyWithRedGoldHair · 30/11/2022 13:28

Skiphopbump · 30/11/2022 10:49

When my children were in primary school they banned videoing and photographing during performances- it was so much more enjoyable! We were allowed to take photos of our own children in the hall afterwards.

This is such a good idea. I hated going to the nativity and just being able to see people's phone screens rather than the performance.

Hankunamatata · 30/11/2022 13:27

Is it a performance where she can wear a mask as part of her character?

MulderSmoulder · 30/11/2022 13:26

Please don’t let her miss out OP. Just talk to the school, I’m sure they can arrange something.

Our school has a no filming/photo policy and everyone respects it. If the teachers saw someone breaking the rules they’d ask them to delete it, they’d end up embarrassing themselves.

walkinwardrobe · 30/11/2022 13:22

To be honest I think that whilst it would be nice for a community, in this case a school, to come together for the benefit of an individual, I don't think it's realistic, and at the end of the day if there is a real possibility that your child could come to harm, I'd have to take the responsibility upon myself, and not let her participate, however difficult that may be.
I would say however , to be prepared for when your child is older. You will have zero chance of policing other children's social media, however much you may like to. At some point your child is going to end up online. In the same way that someone with an airborne allergy won't know and can't control what others on a train are eating, for example you won't be able to stop unknown pre-teens randomly posting stuff. Hopefully by that time their appearance will have changed enough for it not to be so risky.

Severntrent · 30/11/2022 13:12

I think you should ask the school to ban photos during the performance because the other parents broke the rules about sharing. So unfortunately this is the consequence. I'm sure parents would understand that people have put children at risk by sharing, so unfortunately they're having to be stricter.
They cld do individual photos afterwards maybe.
But it's a no brainer for me if parents can't be trusted not to share. Your daughter shouldn't miss out because there are stupid people. Her involvement is more important than being able to take a photo or two.

elevenplusdilemma · 30/11/2022 13:08

Our school have had this issue before and over the years there have been various solutions, e.g:

School releases 'official' video / photos with those children who mustn't be identified blurred out. Parents asked to make a voluntary contribution to PTA funds for the video / photos.

Full cast call on stage at the end of the performance (minus relevant children who get tasked with other things such as shaking the donation bucket by the exit door or handing out mince pies to the parents so they don't feel left out) - parents are invited to come up and take photos of the children on the stage.

Parents can take photos of their child only in the hall after the show.

Speak to the school to see if you can agree on a fair solution. TBH, I think it's much nicer for everyone if parents watch the show without waving a phone / camera around in front of their faces anyway and wish all schools banned them for performances.

Wiaa · 30/11/2022 13:04

My DC's school do a little rerun at most events without the children who don't have permission, so a little fake race after the real one. For the jubilee they did dances and they were all done twice one you could film and one you couldn't. It sounds like they are just going to get them to get back on stage in their positions for the photos at the Nativity. They even ask the parents if they mind being in the photos

yikesanotherbooboo · 30/11/2022 13:02

I think that the best policy is no photos or filming at all. Parents can then take a photo of their own child alone or school can and sell them if they think there would be a market. Any other option is discriminatory.

Soothsayer1 · 30/11/2022 13:00

'My right to video my child is more important to me than keeping your child safe.'
Videoing your child in the school play is a normal and natural thing to want to do, the problem is that this normal and natural thing also makes it much easier for predators to target their prey.
I'm not disagreeing with you but the way I see it at the underlying problem is that, because of the way society has advanced technologically, normal natural things can now be extremely dangerous for other people☹️

mam0918 · 30/11/2022 13:00

Also when my oldest had his first school play in reception we all went back to the class room and could get a proper photo of JUST our child in their costume.

Thats honestly the only school photo I have really kept, although I took photos other years they just hid forgotton in the back of my phone somewhere.

mam0918 · 30/11/2022 12:57

My oldest DS in his last year of school an announcement was made before the nativity that 2 children taking part where vunerable and in care and under a 'no photo/video order' was implace so pictures couldn't be taken.

Theres 2-3 years mixed in the nativity and I have no idea who the 2 kids in care where (although I assume siblings since it started at the same time) but they made it seem pretty strict.

SantaOnFanta · 30/11/2022 12:56

It's a difficult one because these performance are precious memories to me and I would like one or two photos for my own personal use.
The school needs to clamp down on those breaking the SM rules so no one suffers.

MarshaBradyo · 30/11/2022 12:54

Christmasbahhumbug · 30/11/2022 12:48

Thank you to all who have responded. Sadly it confirmed my belief that while most parents ‘get it’ and would adhere to a request not to film/take photos and put them on SM, there are a significant few who would do it anyway & the risk those could potentially expose her to are just too high.

She won’t be taking part. She will be very upset as she’s still too little to understand. I want to keep her in our little protective safe bubble a little while longer before she knows the full truth of why she can’t be involved.

Thanks again for responding.

Oh that is sad. Can you speak to the school before withdrawing her?