Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask for no photos/videos to be taken at school performance?

283 replies

Christmasbahhumbug · 30/11/2022 10:42

DD can’t be in photos/videos online. There are genuine reasons for this. School are very good and I think would put a ban in place if I (or any other parent) asked.

In previous years I have kept her home on special nursery/school days where photos/videos might be taken.

Over the summer, DD really wanted to join in and school allowed photos/videos and asked parents to keep them off SM but unsurprisingly this was ignored.

I get it, I really do. I would love a picture/video of DD having fun/performing with all of her friends but we just can’t.

Do I deny other parents/grandparents/children that pleasure by asking for no photos/videos or yet again have DD miss out completely?

OP posts:
TeenDivided · 04/12/2022 16:24

@Happyher A party is different as it is not the same risk.

There is a specific risk attached to school based events as in it attaches the child directly to a specific location and school.

Additionally a party is smaller, so in our case at least, the hosting parents would know not to take pictures of DD, whereas in a school nativity there would be loads of parents who didn't know us.

Happyher · 04/12/2022 15:58

JustLyra · 04/12/2022 12:40

It’s human nature to want to pics of your child enjoying the self where it’s allowed.

I don’t disagree. It’s natural to want them.

Its utterly selfish to think that want should trump a small child being able to take part in their school show safely.

Wanting your child to be safe isn’t remotely comparable in selfish terms to whinging that you can’t take a photo.

And private parties aren’t remotely comparable to school events either.

The number of straw men people will happily throw at this is unreal. The issue is small child being able to take part safely over an adult’s right to be able to take photos of something they’re watching…
that so many think their “right” to photos and watching trumps the child being able to take part safely says so so much.

You seem to take exception to me being able to see both sides of this whilst you can only see one. A party is not different in that the same risk is involved. You can’t just dismiss that because it doesn’t fit your narrative

MrsSkylerWhite · 04/12/2022 13:51

Photos and video were banned at our now adult kids’ schools years ago.
a member of staff videotaped all events excluding particular children as necessary and it was sent out to parents on dvd (shows how long ago that was 😁)

LlynTegid · 04/12/2022 13:49

A 100% ban on photographing other people's children in school would have my support.

In addition to the reasons the OP has (which is none of our business), there are some who would harm someone's child to get back at them. Think of all the hatred there is towards refugees and asylum seekers for example.

Schuyler · 04/12/2022 13:28

JustLyra · 04/12/2022 13:04

So accurate.

It’s very telling on here that people are all about how everything should be done to keep children safe and protect them.

Unless of course that means they can’t take photos at their choice.

And heaven forbid schools and social services (you know the ones who should have done something in tragic cases) follow up on comments made by a MN’etters child. Then it’s a waste of everyone’s time and intrusive.

I bet they post on threads where children have been harmed or murdered and say it’s “oh so sad 😭 “ and “people should have done more to protect them”. Sooooo let’s protect them.

Schuyler · 04/12/2022 13:26

I cannot believe there are grown adults (I assume?!) on this thread saying things like “very upset” and “it’s not fair”. Really?!! A child’s safety could be compromised. Their life could be at risk. My children are fortunate they are safe and protected from harm. I don’t need photos of them as an angel in the actual play at the expense of another child’s safety. I cannot imagine reading a thread like this and still having the audacity and arrogance to say it’s not fair and I’d be upset! OP doesn’t need a guilt trip.

My husband is a teacher so he’s never seen a play. That still isn’t as important as ensuring a child like the OP’s DD is kept safe.

JustLyra · 04/12/2022 13:04

TeenDivided · 04/12/2022 12:59

People (generically) on MN often fall over themselves to show how kind and inclusive they are.

Until it impacts them and their kids.

Then it's 'my right to photo my child' or 'my child can invite who they want to their party' rather than be understanding to the child whose background means there's a safeguarding risk, or who is nice enough but a bit immature compared to their peers (often due to SEN or again a disrupted background).

So accurate.

It’s very telling on here that people are all about how everything should be done to keep children safe and protect them.

Unless of course that means they can’t take photos at their choice.

And heaven forbid schools and social services (you know the ones who should have done something in tragic cases) follow up on comments made by a MN’etters child. Then it’s a waste of everyone’s time and intrusive.

TeenDivided · 04/12/2022 12:59

People (generically) on MN often fall over themselves to show how kind and inclusive they are.

Until it impacts them and their kids.

Then it's 'my right to photo my child' or 'my child can invite who they want to their party' rather than be understanding to the child whose background means there's a safeguarding risk, or who is nice enough but a bit immature compared to their peers (often due to SEN or again a disrupted background).

JustLyra · 04/12/2022 12:40

It’s human nature to want to pics of your child enjoying the self where it’s allowed.

I don’t disagree. It’s natural to want them.

Its utterly selfish to think that want should trump a small child being able to take part in their school show safely.

Wanting your child to be safe isn’t remotely comparable in selfish terms to whinging that you can’t take a photo.

And private parties aren’t remotely comparable to school events either.

The number of straw men people will happily throw at this is unreal. The issue is small child being able to take part safely over an adult’s right to be able to take photos of something they’re watching…
that so many think their “right” to photos and watching trumps the child being able to take part safely says so so much.

Happyher · 04/12/2022 12:17

JustLyra · 04/12/2022 00:28

It is utterly selfish for an adult to think their wish to both watch the show and take a photo is superior and "fairer" than them being able to watch and a young child being able to participate in safety.

People only giving a shit about themselves and their own wishes is exactly what's wrong with the world.

It’s not selfish. It’s human nature to want to pics of your child enjoying the self where it’s allowed. What happens when the child gets invited to parties. Is this rule going to be imposed there too. I very rarely post pics on social media and mine are for friends and family only so I’m not an advocate of posting everything online, but it’s obviously popular for a lot of people. I’m an outsider looking in here and I can clearly see the unfairness on both sides. Your last sentence in your post above applies to both sides of this. There are solutions that the school could put in place that would keep all happy.

CaptainMyCaptain · 04/12/2022 07:47

JustLyra · 04/12/2022 00:28

It is utterly selfish for an adult to think their wish to both watch the show and take a photo is superior and "fairer" than them being able to watch and a young child being able to participate in safety.

People only giving a shit about themselves and their own wishes is exactly what's wrong with the world.

100%

Hesma · 04/12/2022 06:39

Your school shouldn’t put you in this predicament, they should have a ban in place already. No child should be excluded from activities. As a parent I’d love to share pics of school plays, sports days etc on SM but safeguarding is too important. I work in a school however and I don’t think it’s until you’ve done safeguarding training training or are responsible for a vulnerable child that you are truly aware of how important it is and how some little ones have been through so much already in their little lives. They need protecting but it is also so very important that they feel encouraged to join in and not be made to feel different. Speak to the school OP and keep up the good work, you’ve got this 🤗

Allsnotwell · 04/12/2022 00:35

Not sure of the type of play or show here - but is it not possible for some children to have their faces painted - like a camel or what ever so they can’t be recognized from photos? Very difficult with a hat/scarf/snowman/alien type disguise?

Just an alternative suggestion.

JustLyra · 04/12/2022 00:28

Happyher · 03/12/2022 23:25

I look at this from a neutral position- there was no social media or camera phones when my kids were at school. So I’m not claiming any entitlement but simply speaking for other parents who want to take pics. That isn’t what’s wrong with the world and it’s not selfish

It is utterly selfish for an adult to think their wish to both watch the show and take a photo is superior and "fairer" than them being able to watch and a young child being able to participate in safety.

People only giving a shit about themselves and their own wishes is exactly what's wrong with the world.

iamjustwinginglife · 04/12/2022 00:10

Could your child take part with an adapted costume so her face isn't visible? You could make it really fun and she wouldn't miss out.

Happyher · 03/12/2022 23:25

JustLyra · 03/12/2022 21:16

And that's what's wrong with the world.

People think it's "fairer" that adopted/abused/endangered children miss out than they miss out on their photographs.

Selfish really doesn't cover it.

I look at this from a neutral position- there was no social media or camera phones when my kids were at school. So I’m not claiming any entitlement but simply speaking for other parents who want to take pics. That isn’t what’s wrong with the world and it’s not selfish

RIPhouseplants · 03/12/2022 22:29

My kids school have specifically asked parents not to take pictures because there is a safeguarding risk for a particular child. Everyone has the opportunity to take a pic of their own child at the end.
I would never post a pic with someone else in it online anyway but I think it’s good that the school has said that a child is actually at risk (the child has not been named) because people have probably taken it more seriously than if they just said ‘don’t take pics’ which would probably be ignored by some.

ISeeTheLight · 03/12/2022 22:24

DDs school (state, primary, academy) has a blanket ban on phones, cameras or other recording equipment on school grounds. We also filled in a form re consenting to photos on social media, website etc (which we declined). This also goes for any events, nativities, summer fayres etc. Parents respect it and I'm very happy they're so strict. I thought this was standard to be honest, surprised it's not in other schools.

Tessabelle74 · 03/12/2022 22:16

@Gemcat1 maybe she's fled domestic violence so doesn't want photos of her child over social media? Maybe her child is adopted and she doesn't want her photo all over social media? You have no idea why some people protect their children

PoppyPopPop · 03/12/2022 22:05

Can't believe some of the comments. I am a teacher. I'm missing my nursery aged son's Christmas songs and my year 1 daughter's nativity this year (and probably will in the future too) because they both clash with the two performances of my year 1 classes nativity. I'd love a video of their performance but I would never want a child would be excluded in order for me to get this so will take a photo of them at home in their costumes and hope they have a lovely time singing with their friends. I'd far rather all were able to participate safely.

JustLyra · 03/12/2022 21:16

Happyher · 03/12/2022 20:49

im sorry but I think you are being unreasonable. If all the other parents are happy for photos why should just one parent spoil it. It’s really up to you to give some age appropriate reasons to your daughter why she can’t take part rather than expect other parents to accommodate you. Most will probably take furtive photos anyway. Whatever your reasons for your restrictions it’s not fair to impose them on the whole class

And that's what's wrong with the world.

People think it's "fairer" that adopted/abused/endangered children miss out than they miss out on their photographs.

Selfish really doesn't cover it.

Happyher · 03/12/2022 20:49

im sorry but I think you are being unreasonable. If all the other parents are happy for photos why should just one parent spoil it. It’s really up to you to give some age appropriate reasons to your daughter why she can’t take part rather than expect other parents to accommodate you. Most will probably take furtive photos anyway. Whatever your reasons for your restrictions it’s not fair to impose them on the whole class

HenGab4 · 03/12/2022 20:42

PestorPeston · 03/12/2022 20:26

How old are you trying to pretend to be?
I have photos of my grandmother from the 1920s.

I'm quite impressed that you and your DC manage to survive without your hippocampus, neocortex and amygdala.

When you sneakily record your child's Christmas play
It is likely a child in that school is at risk of abuse, has been removed from a dangerous and chaotic life and has been placed into Foster care or with adoptive parents.

You then post a picture with the child in the background. A friend shares it, the abusers see it and know the child's school.
This child then has to pack up belongings move to a new home, new school, new carers, new life, the previous carers are also at risk along with their own children........ All because some needed to share it on fb, just follow school policy, they don't tell you not to record because they are miserable. They tell you this to protect vulnerable children.

My mother was a widow with 5 children under the age of 7. She didn’t have a lot so no she didn’t have a camera. We were the kids who went on holidays to Wales for a week run by the church. We have the odd picture of a class photo. Taken by the school.

Re read my comment. I said ask the parents to not share on social media. Keep the pictures for families. You know those pictures that can be printed and put into an album to keep.

Having worked in a women’s refuge I know full well of the dangers women face from violent partners. I have also fostered children and have photos from when they were younger. Printed in albums for them from when they have taken part in activities in school and when on holidays with us.

Glad you have lots of pictures of your grandma in the 1920’s. She must have been wealthier than my mother who was adopted after losing her parents in WW11.

PestorPeston · 03/12/2022 20:26

HenGab4 · 03/12/2022 20:19

My children are now adults and are not happy that as children I was banned from taking pictures and videos. They have no memories to share with their families of what they did as children.

Allow parents the right to make memories but ask them not to share on social media. That way everyone is happy.

We didn’t have cameras when I was young so I have nothing to share with my children and grandchildren but with technology now why wouldn’t we want to make memories to keep?

How old are you trying to pretend to be?
I have photos of my grandmother from the 1920s.

I'm quite impressed that you and your DC manage to survive without your hippocampus, neocortex and amygdala.

When you sneakily record your child's Christmas play
It is likely a child in that school is at risk of abuse, has been removed from a dangerous and chaotic life and has been placed into Foster care or with adoptive parents.

You then post a picture with the child in the background. A friend shares it, the abusers see it and know the child's school.
This child then has to pack up belongings move to a new home, new school, new carers, new life, the previous carers are also at risk along with their own children........ All because some needed to share it on fb, just follow school policy, they don't tell you not to record because they are miserable. They tell you this to protect vulnerable children.

HenGab4 · 03/12/2022 20:19

Christmasbahhumbug · 30/11/2022 10:42

DD can’t be in photos/videos online. There are genuine reasons for this. School are very good and I think would put a ban in place if I (or any other parent) asked.

In previous years I have kept her home on special nursery/school days where photos/videos might be taken.

Over the summer, DD really wanted to join in and school allowed photos/videos and asked parents to keep them off SM but unsurprisingly this was ignored.

I get it, I really do. I would love a picture/video of DD having fun/performing with all of her friends but we just can’t.

Do I deny other parents/grandparents/children that pleasure by asking for no photos/videos or yet again have DD miss out completely?

My children are now adults and are not happy that as children I was banned from taking pictures and videos. They have no memories to share with their families of what they did as children.

Allow parents the right to make memories but ask them not to share on social media. That way everyone is happy.

We didn’t have cameras when I was young so I have nothing to share with my children and grandchildren but with technology now why wouldn’t we want to make memories to keep?