Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Friend evicting elderly tenant

479 replies

AppalachianWoman · 30/11/2022 09:08

Would it change the way you felt about your friend if he evicted an elderly (70+) tenant so he could move into the house instead? The rent was paid upfront through a lifetime of agricultural labor from late childhood but the friend who recently inherited the estate feels they are owed cash payments and the property. The tenant cannot read or write and was widowed a year or two ago, has no children of his own but some step children from his marriage. The friend currently occupies another, smaller, property on the estate and was expected to move into the largest house which is very grand indeed but requires extensive renovation. He is daunted by the work and expense and has instead become fixated on the property the elderly farmhand lives in.

It feels emotionally immature of me to drop a friend over a difference in values but I am shocked that he would even consider this course of action. I don’t want to be friends with someone who acts this way, how can I exit gracefully or should I try to support him as he has supported me emotionally through decades of friendship?

OP posts:
HeckyPeck · 30/11/2022 14:00

Doodadoo · 30/11/2022 13:03

If he allows the farmhand to remain in a four bed home and realistically, the man may well live another 20 years, it is in fact charity to allow him to remain. The elderly man has no legal right to the house.

If he moved in before 1989, he will be classed as an agricultural tenant with a regulated tenancy. He would have a right to live there, even without a formal tenancy.

From shelter:

Your right to live in your home does not end even if you lose your job or retire or if the property is sold.

In most cases, the only way that your landlord can evict you is to supply you with suitable alternative accommodation. This must be either another regulated tenancy or another tenancy with similar strong rights.

england.shelter.org.uk/housing_advice/private_renting/farm_workers_living_in_tied_accommodation

OP, I'm really pleased you're looking out for this man. Too many tenants don't know their rights.

When you contact the parish priest, please share the info from shelter.

You could also let your friend know that it would be an illegal eviction if the gentlemen moved in before 1989. Hopefully that will make him think twice even if he is low on morals,

Kennykenkencat · 30/11/2022 13:59

AppalachianWoman · 30/11/2022 13:43

Thank you for all the advice, I appreciate it and will follow up the links when I can. I thought I would be judged for judging my friend, and for concerning myself with his business. The estate runs at a loss and has done for many years before my friend inherited it from his uncle. It’s a huge burden. Contractors farm the land but everything else is falling into ruin. It’s in England in a very pretty area.

The situation is making me very sad. I don’t want to confront him about it due to personal hardships he is undergoing that are unrelated to this inheritance and because he has unconditionally supported me through similar hardships in my past. It worries me that he is fixated upon the only house he can’t immediately take possession of right now and therefore he will never be happy. I’ve encouraged him to talk at length about the situation as he is not the sole beneficiary of the entire estate but has inherited responsibility for most of it without any formal preparation. I don’t want to abandon him but I will find a way to contact the parish priest to see if they can help the tenant and I will also email some of the other suggestions such as the farming union and the homelessness charities.

I would recommend that your friend gets together with who ever has inherited this estate, an accountant who knows about farming and the farm manager and anyone who knows about farming on a business level to see how badly the farm is doing and how long they can last. Are they claiming all the subsidies or is there a pathway to making the estate profitable.
It might be that selling off all or part of the estate to save the rest or just putting the whole thing up for sale in lots and seeing what they can get for it and walking away is the only route forward.

Instead of trying to evict a tenant who has every right to live there. Your friend needs to educate himself pdq on farming. This old guy would have probably taught him a thing or 3 even without being literate and I would suggest he is going to have more problems than he has now if he continues down this path as people who could help him won’t and very soon this poisoned chalice of an inheritance will come tumbling down on him.

Your friend needs to get his head out of his arse and stop thinking he is Lord of the Manor and people are going to bow and scrape to him and do as they are told.

He is part owner of a failing business and he is targeting the wrong person to make himself feel in control

Eastereggs1 · 30/11/2022 13:58

It sounds like it could be an agricultural tenancy, which can be very complicated. It very much depends on the agreement.

www.gov.uk/agricultural-workers-rights/agricultural-tenancies

If the worker loses their job or retires, they can stay in the accommodation. The farmer can ask them to start paying rent - or a higher rent than before. If the farmer and worker cannot agree on a rent, they can go to a rent assessment committee.

If the farmer wants the property back, they can apply to the courts, although they may have to provide the tenant with suitable alternative accommodation. If nothing suitable is available, the tenant may be entitled to re-housing by the council.

C8H10N4O2 · 30/11/2022 13:58

AppalachianWoman · 30/11/2022 13:43

Thank you for all the advice, I appreciate it and will follow up the links when I can. I thought I would be judged for judging my friend, and for concerning myself with his business. The estate runs at a loss and has done for many years before my friend inherited it from his uncle. It’s a huge burden. Contractors farm the land but everything else is falling into ruin. It’s in England in a very pretty area.

The situation is making me very sad. I don’t want to confront him about it due to personal hardships he is undergoing that are unrelated to this inheritance and because he has unconditionally supported me through similar hardships in my past. It worries me that he is fixated upon the only house he can’t immediately take possession of right now and therefore he will never be happy. I’ve encouraged him to talk at length about the situation as he is not the sole beneficiary of the entire estate but has inherited responsibility for most of it without any formal preparation. I don’t want to abandon him but I will find a way to contact the parish priest to see if they can help the tenant and I will also email some of the other suggestions such as the farming union and the homelessness charities.

With respect - what formal preparation do you need to know its fundamentally wrong to throw out an agricultural tenant, housed in return for a lifetime of work?

What formal preparation do you need to think a smaller but modernised house is "too good" for that person who gave a lifetime of work in return for accommodation?

This person may have been supported to you and his peers but frankly, filling holes in his budget by reneging to the loss of a low paid labourer suggests that he doesn't value or respect people who are not his peers.

Local support would be good, Agricultural Workers union/benevolent groups are more likely to provide support to a former agricultural worker. An Age Concern group may also be able to help along with Shelter. NFU/CLA represent the owners' interests rather than labourers.

UniversalAunt · 30/11/2022 13:55

So much for Noblesse Olibge.

antelopevalley · 30/11/2022 13:55

A relative of mine worked some tenanted land and lived in a tied cottage he had been born in. When he became very elderly and could no longer work, he told the estate he had to retire. They gave him a year to find somewhere else to live. A big deal at his age.
Another younger relative lives in a tied cottage as an agricultural worker. I hope he will be okay.

Treaclemine · 30/11/2022 13:46

Dear Doodadoo,
It has been the custom in the past for properties on agricultural land to be "tied" to workers on that land. It has also been customary for verbal agreements to be struck as to the holding of the occupants of those properties, and for that agreement to be "lifetime". My grandfather had such a verbal contract with a landlord of whom he was a normal tenant, which was rescinded at short notice when the LL's daughter wanted the house when she got married. (My grandfather was respected in the village and known for starting up a branch of Joseph Arch's Agricultural Labourers Union. Not everyone repected him for that.) Grandad was able to buy a small farm freehold, so not to bad an outcome. That was between the wars. During my lifetime, on the other side of the family, my father's cousin was a gamekeeper with a verbal contract for lifetime occupation, not just for him, but his wife if she outlived him. Which she did, and the contract dissolved, leaving her, and her learning disabled son homeless. Fortunately, his employer, a well respected charity for the learning disadvantaged, managed to house them.
The agricultural world doesn't work like city folks think.
People who own things they intend to keep shouldn't make promises they intend to break, or to allow their inheritors to break.

Emotionalsupportviper · 30/11/2022 13:46

butterpuffed · 30/11/2022 13:28

@AppalachianWoman . Similar happened to me a few years ago when I was in my 60s , as my landlord decided to move his elderly mother into my flat.

If this landlord serves an eviction notice , when it comes to only six weeks left , his tenant will be declared homeless AS HE IS OVER 60 and the council will find him a flat in an independent living complex . This happened to me, I have a nice fairly large flat.

I was told this is the case with all councils in the UK , but it needs to be checked with Shelter .

What if the council doesn't have a property available?

Council accommodation is like hen's teeth nowadays, and the waiting lists are massive. Apart rom which, this is the man's ^home" with memories - a place he's worked for and presumably is content in. Why should he move if he isn't legally obliged to?

And even if it is legal, ethically it is a horrible thing to do.

EilonwyWithRedGoldHair · 30/11/2022 13:46

ILoveeCakes · 30/11/2022 09:46

Sounds like something out of a Thomas Hardy novel. They make grim reading in terms of how ordinary, working, people are treated

I knew of an elderly lady, she'd gone into service at about 16, stayed working in that house until she died in her 80's. She stayed in the kitchen, the even more elderly lady of the house would sit in a different room. I found it very sad, the two of them there, mostly on their own, but no company to each other, still maintaining outdated social roles.

Kennykenkencat · 30/11/2022 13:45

Doodadoo · 30/11/2022 13:26

A question for all of the charitable posters:

If your parents die and leave you a house which is rented out, do you let that tenant remain there rent-free, or do you attempt to move in yourself if you're struggling to house yourself for example? Genuine question. We all love to give, but we don't live in a communist country. Yes, I'm sure that the farmhand has been a loyal and hardworking employee. But has he more right to your parents' house than you have?

In simple terms yes he does have more rights to live there

It all depends on what the circumstances, length of time the house has been rented, whether it has an agricultural occupancy, or the tenants have a signed AST for 12 months or they are sitting tenants.

Even if your family are on the streets you can’t just tell another family/couple/person to move out because you own the house and you want to move in

It has nothing to do with being charitable. There are laws that protect the tenant to stop this sort of thing from happening. It isn’t the 1960s where if you bought a place with a tenant in you just paid a few heavies to go round and throw the family and all their belongings into the streets.

FlamingJingleBells · 30/11/2022 13:43

My response was to @Doodadoo

FlamingJingleBells · 30/11/2022 13:43

In answer to your question, the farm hand does have a right to the house because he wasn't paid decent wages. He was given accommodation in lieu of wages so yes he either needs to be paid for 50+ yrs of work or housed until he dies. He's protected by law in this as it's a common practice in certain industries like farming.

The landowner in question has already got a house he's living in, he just wants the OAP's house.

AppalachianWoman · 30/11/2022 13:43

Thank you for all the advice, I appreciate it and will follow up the links when I can. I thought I would be judged for judging my friend, and for concerning myself with his business. The estate runs at a loss and has done for many years before my friend inherited it from his uncle. It’s a huge burden. Contractors farm the land but everything else is falling into ruin. It’s in England in a very pretty area.

The situation is making me very sad. I don’t want to confront him about it due to personal hardships he is undergoing that are unrelated to this inheritance and because he has unconditionally supported me through similar hardships in my past. It worries me that he is fixated upon the only house he can’t immediately take possession of right now and therefore he will never be happy. I’ve encouraged him to talk at length about the situation as he is not the sole beneficiary of the entire estate but has inherited responsibility for most of it without any formal preparation. I don’t want to abandon him but I will find a way to contact the parish priest to see if they can help the tenant and I will also email some of the other suggestions such as the farming union and the homelessness charities.

OP posts:
HamBone · 30/11/2022 13:42

Morally, your friend is in the wrong and I think you should point that out to him, plus the fact that the local community will think badly of him (if he doesn't care about the moral aspect, realizing that he'll be shunned might have an impact). Regardless of the legalities, turning a vulnerable elderly person (and being illiterate makes him especially vulnerable) out onto the street is very wrong.

As PP's have pointed out, long term a four-bedroom farmhouse might not be suitable accommodation for an elderly person, especially if they have physical ailments. Instead of evicting him right now, your friend might want to make inquiries with the council about alternative accommodation (e.g., a retirement flat) when the time comes.

Anyway, I'd make it clear to your friend that you're shocked by their attitude, and you won't be able to remain friends if they summarily evict this person. Sometimes you have to be blunt.

SirVixofVixHall · 30/11/2022 13:42

AppalachianWoman · 30/11/2022 09:52

My friend is in the UK, the farmhand worked for the relation who bequeathed my friend the estate. Friend is not a farmer so has contractors who take care of that. I will see about contacting someone who can advocate for the farmhand, it may be a legally permissible act but the inhumanity of it is distressing.

I totally agree OP. Bloody awful thing to do to this poor old man. Your friend is lucky enough to have been given so much by his ancestors, and yet cannot extend any generosity towards an elderly man who has helped his family for his entire life.
I would be sternly telling my friend how shocked I was ! Would perhaps the local vicar have a word ? Someone neutral like that might help sway him ?

Emotionalsupportviper · 30/11/2022 13:41

Your friend is a sh!t, not to put too fine a point on it.

I would tell him so. And I hope that the tenant has a watertight, iron-clad tenancy contract and can stay there as long as he wants to, or until his death.

This will be very stressful for him though. Does your "friend" not ever think that if it wasn't for all of the hard and doubtless skilled work this man put in to the estate he inherited, then it wouldn't have the value it has now?

I couldn't do it to anyone - not if I wasn't desperate, and it doesn't seem that your "friend" is.

C8H10N4O2 · 30/11/2022 13:40

Doodadoo · 30/11/2022 13:26

A question for all of the charitable posters:

If your parents die and leave you a house which is rented out, do you let that tenant remain there rent-free, or do you attempt to move in yourself if you're struggling to house yourself for example? Genuine question. We all love to give, but we don't live in a communist country. Yes, I'm sure that the farmhand has been a loyal and hardworking employee. But has he more right to your parents' house than you have?

Are you the landowner then?

Yes if someone had worked all their lives for my family who gave him reduced pay in return for lifetime accommodation of course I'd honour it. He has paid for it with labour in advance, often to the great advantage of landowners in the past.

When the current 70 yr old was 14/15 this was still standard model of agricultural employment - cheap labour for landowners as the cottages had little income potential quite often. An illiterate labourer would be unlikely to have started work later than 14 even in 1960s as pupils could be excused the last year if the had jobs to go to - unsurprisingly it was poor kids from poor families who were out at work as early as possible. Its not unusual for agricultural workers of this era to put in 50 -60 plus years of cheap labour to earn that retirement home.

Landowners did fine out of the deal.

caitlinrose · 30/11/2022 13:38

Is this a real story? I do not quite buy it, to be honest.

How can you pay your rent in advance through a lifetime of labour? And how has he been working since he was an older child? Older child to me means younger than a teenager so 11/12?

Since when has child labour been abolished?

Mamma80 · 30/11/2022 13:37

The land agent is effectively now employed by your friend. Of course they are all for it. Its a power inbalance and driven by business decisions. What your friend has failed to grasp is that inherited wealth like that only exists because of the people who worked their lives to sustain the estates. To pick and choose which parts of your obligations you should uphold while effectively keeping the spoils is disgraceful. Hate to say it but your friendships dead because you'll never look at them the same. I would tell him why tho. He needs someone to stand up to him.

Doodadoo · 30/11/2022 13:33

Fladdermus · 30/11/2022 13:29

That laws around tied agricultural tenancies are different. So stop spouting shite and trying to sound clever when you clearly don't have a sodding clue.

Well, perhaps you can educate me with your cleverness and your sodding clue about 'tied agricultural tenancies' of which you have no knowledge as to whether that exists in this case.

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 30/11/2022 13:32

To the (thankfully minority of) people agreeing with the landlord that this man is now a 'squatter' grabbing himself an unfair massive freebie: do you also think the same of people who sacrifice a large proportion of their earnings for decades to pay into a pension and then have the 'audacity' to expect to receive what they've already paid for after they retire? No different, really.

Doodadoo · 30/11/2022 13:31

CaptainMyCaptain · 30/11/2022 13:10

You don't know he has no legal right.

The OP stated he is illiterate. I suggested a couple of reasons why this might be the case.

Well, he has no legal right as he is a tenant. The OP's friend has inherited the house of which the elderly man is a tenant. Tenant. Not owner.

Honestly, I'd love to house the poor and the vulnerable and the elderly. However, I am not generous enough to leave myself in a worse position than a former employee.

It's all fine in theory. Who would want to evict a loyal employee? Ideally, nobody.

My employers have paid for expenses, hotel accommodation, flights, travel etc. When I left the company (or in the case of this man - retired), I wouldn't expect my employer to continue to pay for me!

Wauden · 30/11/2022 13:30

FlamingJingleBells · 30/11/2022 10:51

Get in touch with Age UK and similar charities who will be able to advocate & signpost the gentleman to help. Please let the man know asap that he isn't to sign or put an x on any document given to him by your friend or his employees. I've heard of cases where a signature/ agreement has been taken by fraudulent means.

The old man must not 'sign' anything, tell the old man!

CloudyYellow · 30/11/2022 13:29

Please do the right thing and inform Shelter about this. This poor man needs protection from this monster.

Fladdermus · 30/11/2022 13:29

Doodadoo · 30/11/2022 13:26

A question for all of the charitable posters:

If your parents die and leave you a house which is rented out, do you let that tenant remain there rent-free, or do you attempt to move in yourself if you're struggling to house yourself for example? Genuine question. We all love to give, but we don't live in a communist country. Yes, I'm sure that the farmhand has been a loyal and hardworking employee. But has he more right to your parents' house than you have?

That laws around tied agricultural tenancies are different. So stop spouting shite and trying to sound clever when you clearly don't have a sodding clue.