Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Friend evicting elderly tenant

479 replies

AppalachianWoman · 30/11/2022 09:08

Would it change the way you felt about your friend if he evicted an elderly (70+) tenant so he could move into the house instead? The rent was paid upfront through a lifetime of agricultural labor from late childhood but the friend who recently inherited the estate feels they are owed cash payments and the property. The tenant cannot read or write and was widowed a year or two ago, has no children of his own but some step children from his marriage. The friend currently occupies another, smaller, property on the estate and was expected to move into the largest house which is very grand indeed but requires extensive renovation. He is daunted by the work and expense and has instead become fixated on the property the elderly farmhand lives in.

It feels emotionally immature of me to drop a friend over a difference in values but I am shocked that he would even consider this course of action. I don’t want to be friends with someone who acts this way, how can I exit gracefully or should I try to support him as he has supported me emotionally through decades of friendship?

OP posts:
Kennykenkencat · 02/12/2022 14:38

There is no such thing as squatters rights . Squatting is illegal in residential homes in the U.K.

This man though is not a squatter and he has a legal right to remain in the property till he dies.
You can’t have it both ways. You can’t pay someone a tiny wage, have them work for you for the whole of their working life and then say you want the house you gave them a life time tenancy to instead of a proper wage back when it suits you.
The farm is a business. As a business it owns a property with a sitting tenant in there. Even if the person inheriting the estate was homeless that house is not a place he can live in as it is already occupied.
I could buy many properties that come up at auction with sitting tenants in. They go for very little money because you are buying in effect a buy to let property with a top rental income of £50 or £100 per month and until that person leaves on their own accord or you offer them enough to go elsewhere or they die or just refuse everything on offer you are responsible for the maintenance on that property for the next 20/30 or 40 years or for however long they live.
In that time you could end up homeless. You still can’t evict who ever is living in the property you own.

Mumofsons87 · 02/12/2022 13:41

I'd help the elderly man get legal advice. Squatters rights perhaps.

Kennykenkencat · 02/12/2022 13:12

Doodadoo · 30/11/2022 17:20

Are we back to killing Grandad now?
I sort of missed that from lockdown. 😆

The man is not elderly. He's not 90. He's 72 and retired. He has worked his whole life for one employer. As part of that employment contract, his accommodation was included - nothing shabby - a 4-bed house. He has retired and has made no provisions for moving out or providing himself with accommodation. If he was led to believe that he had a lifetime tenancy, then the OP has a point. The OP doesn't appear to know that particular piece of info though. But who the hell believes that they can live an entire life on someone else's' property? I'm literate but a bit dopey at times. Does that excuse me from contracts? Fuck no!

Personally, there's a house up the road which I quite fancy. Have I the right to live there until death if I'm their cleaner for a lifetime?

The nephew has now inherited the estate and as the evil landowner owns 3 properties on the estate but lives in the smallest property. The estate is haemorrhaging money.

While I'm sure that the 'nephew' would love to keep the elderly man in situ, the nephew may well end up on his arse quicker than the elderly man!

If my dc inherited my property and someone found it appropriate to plonk their entitled behinds in my dc's property, I'd come back and haunt them!

But the wages he was on would have meant he had a life time tenancy.

If you cleaned the house down the road and worked for the family full time from being a child and were given a house to live for the east of your life and a minuscule wage then yes you get to keep the house.

Also if he has been living in the house since before 1989 on even a peppercorn rent then he can stay. It is illegal to evict him.

This has nothing to do with providing for his future. How could he do that on the wage he was paid. If this person now want him out and won’t offer him any other accommodation then buying him out is the only other option. Compensating him for the lost wages he should have earned if he didn’t have a lifetime tenancy.

What you think is fair or not fair isn’t what the law says.
Otherwise what is to stop anyone snapping up a property at auction on the cheap because it has life time tenants in and then evicting them and selling the property on

sue20 · 02/12/2022 12:07

AppalachianWoman · 30/11/2022 15:49

I don’t think many people know about his idea of evicting the farmhand yet, only his wife and one other beneficiary (who wants the same house) and the person who I think is the land agent or the farm accountant. I expected at least one of them to talk him out of it. I suggested the house swap and at first he said it was a good idea but called back later to say ‘but we’ve just done the kitchen’. I suggested buying or renting a vacant property nearby when he felt trapped by his situation and he said that it didn’t make sense when he already owns these other houses. The last I heard was he was going to get legal advice to find out the extent of his obligation to this former employee of his uncle’s. To me his actions are repugnant because he already has so much and yet it’s not enough but I know this is an immature response to what is probably a complex situation. Also I can’t rule out the possibility that I’m envious of his good fortune and the opportunities it creates.

Sorry I don’t get how your response is immature or what would be wrong with feeling envious. You do sound a bit naive though. As you can see by vote here this “friend” is not generally supported in his actions. I’m hoping that it’s discovered that the original owner has legally protected his employee and friend. If he hasn’t I would imagine it wouldn’t occur to him that they were at risk of being evicted by the benefactors. The worst part of it all is this man not considering one obvious option because he’s just “done the kitchen” unbelievable. I really hope the tenant has rights of tenure. Well he may have been supportive to you in the past everyone is a mixture. But this is showing true colours. Ditch him

sue20 · 02/12/2022 11:50

FuckabethFuckor · 30/11/2022 09:22

Are you in the US? (I was thinking, 'Appalachian', and how you spelled 'labor'.)

Whether or not this is legal would be down to your local ordinances and property laws. But ultimately it would depend on whether the tenant is paying rent, whether or not he has any state/government support to pay (or help pay) the rent, and whether there's any terminology in the tenancy agreement (or whatever legal document covers rented housing) that accounts for any upfront payment.

Morally, ethically, it's difficult to say without more context. He might be cynically turfing an old bloke out of his lifelong home, or he might be trying to get rid of a squatter.

A squatter can be so for many reasons and in many ways. They aren’t necessarily an”or” ie the option which is OK to evict.

Gingernan · 02/12/2022 11:01

I think as we age we sometimes realise some of our friends are horrible people.
It came to me that an old friend was ok to me and was all about faaaamily a bit like the Krays or various people on Eastenders but hated pets and was scornful to anyone who liked animals. I wish I'd admitted years ago she wasn't very nice.
I think the op should wean herself off her friend if he has this attitude to a vulnerable tenant. Honestly though if I was the old guy ( ha,I'm the same age) I'd want to go somewhere I was wanted,and I wouldn't want to clean a 4 bedroom house.

angela99999 · 02/12/2022 10:25

Workawayxx · 30/11/2022 09:14

If it was a tied cottage and the elderly man had lived there a long time I’d be very surprised if he can just evict him. It sounds like he’d need some solicitors advice. But yes, I would think less of the friend especially if he has other options for places to live and sounds like he owns a lot of land/housing.

I'd say that this is likely. Unfortunately if it comes to court your friend may well know the people who are making the decisions. However he is a very long-term tenant and he does have rights as a sitting tenant.

Bleachmycloths · 02/12/2022 08:38

Your friend is going to have a long, hard fight on his hands if the tenant seeks good advice. Unfortunately, he’s vulnerable so it’s likely he will be confused and upset. The best way you can help is to make the tenant gets advice. You need to report his plight to the authorities. I’m not an expert so I’m not sure who. Start with the CAB online and take it from there.

Devora13 · 02/12/2022 08:31

'That’s what I suggested but my friend balked at it because he has recently remodeled the kitchen and installed some mod cons.'
Sounds really greedy to me then. I just think some privileged people lack empathy and really cannot put themselves in others shoes.
A line from a song I really like (Saltwater by Julian Lennon) 'What will I think of me the day that I die?' always good to reflect upon.

Blossomtoes · 02/12/2022 08:20

He didn’t need to. The law on agricultural tenancies pre 1989 is very clear and it obviously applies in this case.

verconfused2 · 02/12/2022 05:37

I think it’s sad his uncle did not something in place to protect this man - he prob thought he didn’t have to. The uncle was clearly ok about the arrangement I would have assumed he would have wanted this to continue.

Scarriff · 02/12/2022 01:03

Perhaps you can help the elderly tenant yourself? Like others writing in, I'm not sure what the law is in your part of the world, but from what you say, this is wrong. If you can, please get some advice for the tenant from your own area and help his to act accordingly. Make sure he does not move from his house without a very sound legal agreement. My own limited experience is that if he moves even temporarily, your friend's grip on the property gets tighter.

We all hope like you that he has a secure tenancy. When you are clearer, maybe you can help broker a deal.

mussymummy · 01/12/2022 22:23

Man not mad!!!

mussymummy · 01/12/2022 22:22

Self entitled rich friend evicting elderly mad who had 'served his family all his life. Wow what a c*nt.

The best solution would have been to move this elderly man into the smaller accommodation but from your posts this sounds like its not feasible in your friends eyes cos he put a new kitchen in. I have no words well none that would be allowed. How are you friends with this person?

Please set up a go fund me to get this elderly gentleman decent legal advice because your friends sounds just horrible.

WotsitsMadeIn1927 · 01/12/2022 21:05

bloodyplanes · 30/11/2022 09:52

I wouldn't just think less of the friend, I would tell them what an absolute cunt they were being and then dump them as a friend if they continued with the plan to evict this poor man.

This exactly 👏🏻

AmberMcAmber · 01/12/2022 20:21

If he’s inherited it, does he need the additional income from it? Tbh I think I’d flat out tell him how badly he is behaving and whatever happens happens to that friendship but if I were in that position and desperately wanted the farmhands place I’d offer a swap & maybe if the guy was still up for it, ask him to help me renovate the main estate (even if it’s just tinkering with bits)

Greenshed · 01/12/2022 19:46

Seems exceedingly cruel and immoral to me, but I’m afraid that some are swayed by money rather than have than any sense of what is right and wrong. Your friend just does not see that what he is doing is wrong on so many levels, but still, I suppose he won’t care, he’ll have more money in the bank. Hope he sleeps easy at night.

Mumof3PrettyBoys · 01/12/2022 19:43

How sad for the old man. Your friend .. a self centered pilchard! He should be thankful for a friend like you OP, you have a heart of pure gold!

If he is true and values your friendship, he would appreciate you being honest with him about how this is making you feel towards him as a friend and what it potentially means for the poor old man.

Try for the sake of humanity to get your friend to at LEAST house the man like for like (rent free) or leave him be and invest the money he is spending getting his legal advice on renovating the biggest house and live in that!

Missingpop · 01/12/2022 19:29

It’s highly likely the uncle would have it somewhere that the farm hand has tenancy for life; which will be legally binding; failing that common decency should kick in with all of the beneficiaries to evict an elderly gentleman just through sheer greed is very low & very selfish; your friend sounds like a nasty self centred greedy person I’d question whether the friendship is worth saving after this little stunt. I do applaud your efforts to help the gentleman who I assume is totally oblivious at the moment.

StarCourt · 01/12/2022 19:27

op your friend sounds entitled, heartless and devoid of moral fibre.

SuddenlyMummy · 01/12/2022 19:17

You’re not being unreasonable and you sound like a kind friend and a good human. Keep trying to explain to your friend why you are struggling with decision. In the meantime, the farmhand should also be getting legal advice. I’m happy to help if there’s a way you can PM me on here (sorry I’m more of a MN reader than user!)

Emotionalsupportviper · 01/12/2022 19:04

Anele22 · 01/12/2022 18:33

If advise the elderly tenant not to move. The landlord will have to take him to court. Could take years.

Agree - but very stressful for the tenant. Just for peace of mind the poor man may not want to go down this route.

Treacletoots · 01/12/2022 19:03

Actually. This jogs a memory. I recall when the government rejigged the tenants fee act a couple of years ago, there was an explicit exclusion to the requirements for both housing association, local authority and agricultural property.

What this means is that they explicitly excluded these types of tenancies from the extra protection the PRS (private rental sector) received. If this wasn't a policy written by wealthy landowners FOR wealthy landowners I don't know what is.

Prettydress · 01/12/2022 19:02

Dear OP, whatever your motives are, your friend is acting in an appalling way and you are definitely doing the right thing by flagging this up with your friend. I have to say I would find it very hard to not be envious if a friend inherited so much. And that envy would most probably turn into something quite bitter if they acted in such an ungrateful way. As harsh as this sounds, it's only a matter of time your friend or his children will legitimately inherit the farm hands house and he seems to have so much when this other person seems to have so little. I do hope that the law protects him.

You are absolutely not being unreasonable for this to effect how you felt towards your friend.

toastfiend · 01/12/2022 18:58

AppalachianWoman · 30/11/2022 09:14

Not evicted yet, friend is seeking legal advice. He doesn’t understand why or if he is obligated to house this man.

He doesn't understand? What's wrong with him - is he totally morally bankrupt?

Whether he goes ahead with this appalling course of action or not that would be enough for me to walk away from the friendship, and I'd spell my reasons out very clearly to him before I did so. To have that little regard for this man's lifetime of service to the estate he has inherited is revolting. What an entitled piece of shit.

Swipe left for the next trending thread