Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Should i ask my partner to cover all the bills instead of us sharing?

182 replies

twinklestarin · 29/11/2022 22:50

My partner works full time and earns around 200-250 per day. I am currently a stay at home mum to our DS who is almost 3 and DD who is 5 months old. I do intend to start work once my youngest is old enough to go nursery. For now i've been doing a private tutoring job from home which i only earn £550 per month. I could earn more but its hard to do more due to juggling the home and children. My partner expects me to contribute a share to all the bills, food shopping and anything related to the kids. By the time i have done all of this i have a very small amount of money left to myself or non at all. Sometimes I would like to buy myself books, or go out with a friend or get my hair done but just dont have much money left. Considering that my partner earns considerably more than i do, would it be fair if i asked him to cover all the bills , and with the money i earn i can use that to cover all expenses related to the kids and myself.

OP posts:
emptythelitterbox · 30/11/2022 09:43

What a greedy grabby Scrooge he is. I bet he squeaks when he walks.

Men used to take pride in providing for their families but somewhere along the way the 50/50 bullshit came along which of course benefits men! Now there is an entire generation of selfish greedy gold-digging men.

Contact the links PP have given you and work towards being free of this oaf.

Murdoch1949 · 30/11/2022 09:43

He's being thoughtless and tight. You need to get your ducks in line by preparing a budget, of incomes & expenditure. Work out your pro rata shares, based on your very unequal incomes. He earns, conservatively, 4 times as much as you - because most of your work is unpaid home/childcare - so he should pay 4 times the costs. You need to present this as a fully costed document, that he can examine and consider. Include the local childcare costs that are being saved by you being the primary carer, so he has an idea of what you are actually contributing to the family finances - few men appreciate the horrendous costs of nurseries, thinking it's £20 pd! Obviously this is while you are a FT stay at home parent, and will change when you are back at work, but the principal can remain, with a budget that is based on your respective earnings, fairly.

billy1966 · 30/11/2022 09:40

Tuilpmouse · 30/11/2022 00:08

It's so utterly depressing that these situations seem to come up again and again on MN...

Firstly, don't marry him as others suggested before you shared more details... He's treating you like shit and threatening you if you left. He's an abusive twat and I hope you find the strength to LTB.

This.

You are being abused financially and threatened.

You need to contact Women's aid and ask for help.

Tell family and friends the truth about him.

Stop protecting him.

Start planning.

Keep a note of his threats.

Let your GP and Health Visitor know that he is abusive and threatening you.

Stop thinking your relationship can be saved, it can't.

Accept the truth and start to detach while you get organised.

He is not a good man, just another abusive waste of space that thinks you are stuck.

Any hint of aggression from him, call the police.

We are here for you.

Peedoffo · 30/11/2022 09:37

Tell him you are going back to work and present him the childcare bill which will be proportionate to both your earnings.

WalkingThroughTreacle · 30/11/2022 09:35

Reading all your posts it seems clear that neither of you actually want to be in this relationship. Do both of you, and the kids, a favour and separate, then sort out child support and your own finances. Who knows? In time you may find someone that actually cares for you and makes you happy. You won't find happiness as long as you stay in this situation.

Notanotherone6 · 30/11/2022 09:22

You're a family. You pool your money. Anything else is bloody selfish.

ahagwearsapointybonnet · 30/11/2022 09:18

PonyPatter44 · 29/11/2022 22:57

Not this again. If you share children, you share household costs proportionally. So if all your bills (including children's costs) come to £1000, and your partner earns 85% of the household income, he puts in £850, you put in £150.

I despair of the number of times this question gets asked.

I disagree, this doesn't work out fair if there's a big disparity in income, especially if the bills are high compared to income. The employed partner may well be able to pay 85% of the bills but STILL have way more spending money than the other partner, even if the non-employed partner is working just as hard looking after the children, doing housework etc.

For example - if total income for the month is £2000 but bills come to £1500, the employed partner, if earning/paying out 85% of those, would pay £1275 on bills but would still have £425 a month left to spend on themselves, or around £100/week. But the non-working partner, although "only" paying £225 on bills, would be left with just £75 of spending money for the whole month - less than £20 a week. (Plus if that is the only cash they have, they may well end up spending much of it on kids' activities, in my experience, as a lot of the mums-and-tots type activities want cash...).

So this is really unfair on the non-working parent and will over time make a huge difference to what they can do/have access to compared to their partner, and their ability to build up any savings. If you further increase the proportion of income spent on bills, that personal spending money ends up pretty much disappearing altogether for the non-working parent. (And remember that the working parent is also likely to be topping up their pension at the same time, so also adding to their savings for later life, while the other isn't getting any!)

So I'm with Changingplace - the only really fair way to do it (assuming the work being put in by both partners is reasonably equal, and with two under-3s and a part-time job, I'm sure it is at least equal!), is to pool all income and then get equal spending money each after bills/savings.

Nina9870 · 30/11/2022 09:14

Of course he should pay the lot!
I’m on mat pay and my husband pays for everything while I’m off looking after the kids full time, saving us 50 quid a day in nursery fees!! It’s only right he pays the bills
You’re contributing plenty, it’s just not money

Onefootinthegroove · 30/11/2022 09:11

Absolutely financial abuse.
I left mine before kids were in the picture, he was abusive in most ways tbh.
Financial abuse can creep up on you , so once its pointed out it can be a shock and take time to come to terms with.
My a-ha moment was after walking home from work for 3/4 of an hour with a hole in one shoe ( because he took my wages to pay bills and he was " skint" so I couldn't buy a new pair or get mine repaired) to find a note from him saying he had taken his best mate out for a meal for his Birthday.

Unfortunately I didnt ( couldn't afford to ) leave straight away but I did start confiding in friends.

He wont ever change op.

VollywoodHampires · 30/11/2022 09:06

eelieza · 29/11/2022 22:51

You get less than minimum wage he should cover everything and the kids stuff and just have that to yourself

This, he’s being a knob, don’t stand for it.

ReneBumsWombats · 30/11/2022 09:01

Backtothegymgirl · 30/11/2022 08:05

I don’t understand the point of these threads. It’s completely and utterly irrelevant what anyone else thinks. What matters is what he thinks. And he thinks he should not pay for you. As cunty as it is, that’s his thoughts. He is hardly going to change his mind as some randoms on mumsnet said he should.

you knew though, and you proceeded to have not one but two kids with him and put yourself in this situation. Kept on shagging him and having babies. Like poking yourself in the eye with a big stick , saying shit thst hurts. Fuck it, I’ll poke the other one.

so yes ask him, but you already know he will tell you to do one, that’s why you’re on here. So the bottom line is if you want more money you need to earn it. Because there is nothing coming from this piece of shit.

This is very unkind, which is all the more galling because it's also true.

Not married, either.

He isn't going to change, OP, as you know. He is a tight arsed dick who doesn't love you and does nothing at home and he won't change. So if any changes are going to be made, they need to come from you.

So I suggest looking into how you can support yourself, through working, benefits and child maintenance, and make plans to leave. You have neither his love, money nor time as it is, so what are you actually going to lose?

Sassysimplelife · 30/11/2022 08:51

I know this isnt entirely the point of the thread, but if you're in the UK, have you looked into claiming maternity allowance?

www.gov.uk/maternity-allowance

It's for those who are self-employed or not entitled to SMP for other reasons such as not being with a particular employer for long enough. If you are entitled and haven't been claiming I believe it can be backdated for a cou9le of months.

Softplayhooray · 30/11/2022 08:50

twinklestarin · 29/11/2022 22:53

@eelieza I did think this too but thought it might be too much of a stretch to ask

I remember being in an even worse situation than this, and I had to lay the law down to my partner (years and years ago when my boys were very little). Turns out my DH was feeling very stressed about being the main breadwinner although he wanted the arrangement that we had (me at home with the kids, him working, no childcare costs). That stress came out in taking the piss put of me in that whatever money he transferred to me was not only 100% taken by bills but what he transferred was LESS than the bills and I ended up in overdraft. It was a difficult conversation at the time but he improved a lot.

He looks back now and by his own admission was an asshole and can't believe he was such a twat and not organising finances properly. He's totally relaxed about all that stuff now.

But point is, push him on it and don't take it.

BMW6 · 30/11/2022 08:49

Backtothegymgirl · 30/11/2022 08:05

I don’t understand the point of these threads. It’s completely and utterly irrelevant what anyone else thinks. What matters is what he thinks. And he thinks he should not pay for you. As cunty as it is, that’s his thoughts. He is hardly going to change his mind as some randoms on mumsnet said he should.

you knew though, and you proceeded to have not one but two kids with him and put yourself in this situation. Kept on shagging him and having babies. Like poking yourself in the eye with a big stick , saying shit thst hurts. Fuck it, I’ll poke the other one.

so yes ask him, but you already know he will tell you to do one, that’s why you’re on here. So the bottom line is if you want more money you need to earn it. Because there is nothing coming from this piece of shit.

I have to say this is my reaction too. FFS.

TimeForTeaAndG · 30/11/2022 08:49

stopbeeping · 30/11/2022 08:11

My husband pays every single bill as I am a SAHm

Unless he is going to babysit so you can work I don't think you should contribute at all except to kids clubs kjds clothes and that's it then the rest for you

It's not babysitting when it's their own kids. It's parenting.

Liorae · 30/11/2022 08:43

Worrywart2022 · 30/11/2022 08:25

I really don’t understand this when people have kids together. My DH currently earns more than me but if I go back FT I will earn more than him (which I’m planning on doing). That said, his career progression will be better than mine so he will likely outearn me again soon after.

ALL our money is joint money and we don’t consult each other on purchases for ourselves unless they are out of the ordinary. We are married and have 2 kids together so why shouldn’t everything be in the family pit?

Possibly because the kids were not wanted by the father and he doesn't feel responsible for them. Bad attitude but very common.

Chimna · 30/11/2022 08:34

So if he wants things to work this way, he needs to do an equal share like he is asking you to do. 50% of childcare, cooking, cleaning. How the fuck else are you supposed to be earning? He's abusing you OP.

DillyDallyDooo · 30/11/2022 08:30

neverbeenskiing · 30/11/2022 08:16

Can people RTFT before commenting? 5 pages in and OP is still being told to marry this abusive, controlling twat.

Also the "bill him for childcare" comments are pathetic. OP is being financially abused. This is a man who believes she doesn't have the right to access the washing machine in her own home because she's on a lower wage than him. Do you really think being presented with a bill for childcare is going to make him have an epiphany and start treating her with respect? FFS.

Fully agree with this. OP posts basically saying he's a controlling twat, mumsnet tell her to marry him! Unbelievable.

I understand the half a house entitlement and all that, but is that all people on mumsnet care about whether you're entitled to half a house or not? Do they not care about sanity, happiness, mental health, safety? 😶😶

Blowthemandown · 30/11/2022 08:29

@twinklestarin definitely don’t divide into kids and non-kids expenses! But do have the conversation that goes ‘you earn X times as much as me, plus I do all the child and house care which would cost a fortune if we had a nanny (quote him the going rate). This is soul destroying for me, I can’t even treat myself to a book or haircut and we have to work out a more equitable way of doing it’. You could even suggest he tries giving up all his hobbies and treats and does all the bed times for a month so he can see it’s relentless.

You can also point out that you can’t do more to earn more, as there is no time with the current arrangement because it’s just overwhelming.

poefaced · 30/11/2022 08:28

Survey99 · 30/11/2022 08:26

Not this again. if you live as a family you pool all family money, communicate and have joint financial outlooks and goals.

I despair at the number of times this is suggested as a way for a family to operate their finances.

I think both yours and @PonyPatter44 are valid and fair. I think you are preaching to the choir.

Survey99 · 30/11/2022 08:26

PonyPatter44 · 29/11/2022 22:57

Not this again. If you share children, you share household costs proportionally. So if all your bills (including children's costs) come to £1000, and your partner earns 85% of the household income, he puts in £850, you put in £150.

I despair of the number of times this question gets asked.

Not this again. if you live as a family you pool all family money, communicate and have joint financial outlooks and goals.

I despair at the number of times this is suggested as a way for a family to operate their finances.

Worrywart2022 · 30/11/2022 08:25

I really don’t understand this when people have kids together. My DH currently earns more than me but if I go back FT I will earn more than him (which I’m planning on doing). That said, his career progression will be better than mine so he will likely outearn me again soon after.

ALL our money is joint money and we don’t consult each other on purchases for ourselves unless they are out of the ordinary. We are married and have 2 kids together so why shouldn’t everything be in the family pit?

neverbeenskiing · 30/11/2022 08:16

Can people RTFT before commenting? 5 pages in and OP is still being told to marry this abusive, controlling twat.

Also the "bill him for childcare" comments are pathetic. OP is being financially abused. This is a man who believes she doesn't have the right to access the washing machine in her own home because she's on a lower wage than him. Do you really think being presented with a bill for childcare is going to make him have an epiphany and start treating her with respect? FFS.

Liorae · 30/11/2022 08:15

ThreeblackCats · 30/11/2022 06:56

I guess you could bill him for childcare, cooking, cleaning, laundry, shopping, bedroom services etc.
Find out the going rate for a nanny or au pair, private chef, cleaner etc and log your hours go for the month. I can guarantee you he will baulk when you hit him with the bill.
Once you charge him approximately ten times what he’s earning, which is about what you’re worth, money he’s contributing to his pension because he has you looking after his children and running the home, money he seems to think his own children should be grateful for rather than expect, then maybe he might start to appreciate you. But I doubt it.

More likely to tell you to leave and take your bill with you.

Adelais · 30/11/2022 08:13

God this thread is depressing.

Men like this never change so the only option is to leave him. He won’t want full custody of the kid, it’s just a threat he uses to make you stay.

Contact women’s aid for help.
It’s probably worth going back to work, you should get some help with childcare costs and universal credit if you don’t earn much

Good luck