Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask SS to leave

259 replies

fisher7 · 29/11/2022 22:41

I feel awful writing this but I'm at a loss on what to do next

18yo SS lives with me full time, his mum passed away 9 years ago and my DH passed away during the first lockdown which hit us all hard. He had the choice of going and living with his aunt (mums sister) but he declined as he wanted to stay with me and she lived quite far away.

He attended counselling for a while but then stopped as he said it wasn't helping, he did go back to his old self eventually and seemed to have been coping fine.

Before he turned 18, he'd only drank once with his friends which was at 17 about 6 months before his 18th. Since he's turned 18, he goes out and drinks almost everyday, he's even smoked weed a few times. He spends most of his day on his Xbox, he doesn't help around the house with tidying etc.

Earlier, he was out and me and the other rest of us ate dinner, one of the DC’s washed up as it's their turn he got back and ate his dinner and then left his plate on the side. I asked him to wash it up, he said no and told me to do it, I told him he's an adult now etc which led to him shouting that I'm not his mum so I can't tell him what to do, he hates me, wishes I died and not his dad etc. DS(13) then came down and told him to leave me alone, SS then started shouting at him that he can't tell him what to do either and pushed him and went to his room.

DS is fine but has said he doesn't want to go to his dads tomorrow and leave me with SS. I have been to speak to SS and he's apologised and I've asked if he'll speak to me properly tomorrow when the other children are at school but he's refused and told me to leave him alone.

I know I probably am, but will I BU to ask him to leave and stay somewhere else?

OP posts:
Annabelle3 · 30/11/2022 03:21

DuchessDandelion · 30/11/2022 03:15

An 18yo pushing his brother - no matter how unacceptable- doesn't make him an "abusive man".

I'm usually the first to shout and have helped others leave abusive relationships. This is a boy - he didn't magically ping into being an adult man at 00:01 on his birthday a few months ago.

He's dealing with huge grief and pain and needs support. No one is suggesting that the the op put herself and her biological son at risk, but that she needs support for all three of them to come through this.

Yes, an 18 old man pushing his stepbrother does make him abusive. Add on 10 years and have him pushing a 13 year old child or a woman. Still think it's not abusive? What are you waiting for, for him to actually hit them before you call out his abusive behaviour for what is?

At what stage is he an adult then? Where do you draw the line? 00:01 the day after his 21st? Or his 25th? You're arguing semantics.

The fact is, at 18 he is able to drink, vote, enlist to fight in wars. He is, an adult. And, he is stronger than the female OP, and a 13 year old boy.

OP also said that he was fine until he started drinking every day just because he was legally able to. I don't think this is so much about grief but about a aggressive and selfish person using the drink as an excuse. With or without the loss of his parents, I think he'd still be the same person.

MNMH · 30/11/2022 03:17

user1477391263 · 30/11/2022 03:12

Yeah I'm baffled at the level of vitirol here.

It's not vitriol. I actually said, do some family counselling and talk about this first.

But if the kid is depressed and in a bad way, then just saying "poor little thing!" and enabling him, and letting him go on living this pathetic half-life as a room-recluse smoking weed, is not going to help him. He needs to start helping himself as well--nobody can do it all for him. Having a job or study that he goes to every day and having some clear rules and boundaries about behavior are important.

I apologize. That wasn't directed towards you. I may have quoted you by accident. Your post was not at all vitrolic.

DuchessDandelion · 30/11/2022 03:15

An 18yo pushing his brother - no matter how unacceptable- doesn't make him an "abusive man".

I'm usually the first to shout and have helped others leave abusive relationships. This is a boy - he didn't magically ping into being an adult man at 00:01 on his birthday a few months ago.

He's dealing with huge grief and pain and needs support. No one is suggesting that the the op put herself and her biological son at risk, but that she needs support for all three of them to come through this.

pinheadlarry · 30/11/2022 03:13

ElephantInTheKitchen · 30/11/2022 01:40

You want to make a traumatised 18 year old orphan homeless because they are behaving like many teenagers before them?

I bet you wouldn't be thinking of kicking him out if your DH were alive, or if it were your own biological child. Your DH would probably be turning in his grave if he knew you were thinking of this.

YWBVU to kick him out.

If my biological 18 year old was behaving like this I would be sending him on his way
Especially if he was getting physical with my younger son and wishing death on me
How do you know the husband wouldn't have kicked him out too?

Hes 18, if he wants to play by his own rules then he can make his own way in the world..
Op has continued to support and look after him and he's unappreciative.

If OP allows him to stay and continue this behaviour, he will not become a well adjusted man
He will think its OK to hit younger children, he will think its OK to be lazy , he will think its OK to blame women and he will not learn to control his emotions
Its sink or swim for him, he needs to decide who he wants to be

user1477391263 · 30/11/2022 03:12

Yeah I'm baffled at the level of vitirol here.

It's not vitriol. I actually said, do some family counselling and talk about this first.

But if the kid is depressed and in a bad way, then just saying "poor little thing!" and enabling him, and letting him go on living this pathetic half-life as a room-recluse smoking weed, is not going to help him. He needs to start helping himself as well--nobody can do it all for him. Having a job or study that he goes to every day and having some clear rules and boundaries about behavior are important.

Annabelle3 · 30/11/2022 02:54

Truffoiled · 30/11/2022 02:36

There is no misogyny on this thread.

I don't think you give two hoots about the OP, frankly. You are using the OP's thread to shout down women and accuse them of enabling abuse. That is an appalling and ludicrous position.

You have absolutely nothing useful to say, and yet no doubt you'll be here all night, yelling at people. 🙄

Expecting a woman to stay in a house with an abusive man, IS misogyny. No matter which way you spin it.

I care very much about children being in violent and unstable homes. It's clear you don't, and are projecting your lack of care onto me as a way to shout me down. Well I will stand up for vulnerable women and children even if you won't. You are the one who has nothing useful to say except to enable abuse of the OP and a child.

Not once have you shown any concern to the OP's position or that of her young child. Not once.

If this was any other thread where a woman was talking about being a home with an aggressive/violent/drinking male and she had a young child, we'd all be telling her to leave asap or get him to leave.
So, why the difference here?

Orangesare · 30/11/2022 02:48

Maybe a bit if a break to his aunts and whilst you get some mh support in place for him and a job lined up for him.
college can be really hard for teens but a supportive workplace with more adults around to interact with can be much better. Start to see different sides to life, support from others etc.

Truffoiled · 30/11/2022 02:48

Ay, I'm off too. Good luck OP. I hope you find the way forward together, and brighter days lie ahead.

MNMH · 30/11/2022 02:40

Theabsoluteshit · 30/11/2022 02:38

I've been a confrontational arsehole on this thread (and there is definitely some projection going on 😂), but you, on the other hand have not. Don't get dragged down by the goady posters and stand up for what you think is right (why the hell shouldn't you?), it won't take you far wrong that's for sure!

(that was my grans favourite saying - doing right , won't take you far wrong!)

Thanks! I appreciate this❤

Apologies for derailing the thread. All the best to you, OP.

Theabsoluteshit · 30/11/2022 02:38

MNMH · 30/11/2022 02:32

Thanks so much. ❤
I tried to be kind in the end and I'm STILL getting dragged, lol.

I've been a confrontational arsehole on this thread (and there is definitely some projection going on 😂), but you, on the other hand have not. Don't get dragged down by the goady posters and stand up for what you think is right (why the hell shouldn't you?), it won't take you far wrong that's for sure!

(that was my grans favourite saying - doing right , won't take you far wrong!)

Truffoiled · 30/11/2022 02:36

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

There is no misogyny on this thread.

I don't think you give two hoots about the OP, frankly. You are using the OP's thread to shout down women and accuse them of enabling abuse. That is an appalling and ludicrous position.

You have absolutely nothing useful to say, and yet no doubt you'll be here all night, yelling at people. 🙄

GLADragss · 30/11/2022 02:34

Annabelle3 · 30/11/2022 01:17

The handmaiden-like expectations of a woman to put up with abuse from someone that isn't even her son is quite depressing. Especially as she has a child herself to consider. I thought Mumsnet was supposed to be supportive of women, obviously not. Enabling abuse and an unstable home simply because someone lost their parents so we should feel sorry for him (many of us experience worse than losing parents) is decidedly anti-woman, and anti stability for a child. This thread is truly depressing. OP, please ignore posters who think you should put up with abuse and disrespect, you have your son who is at a vulnerable age to consider. Please put him and yourself first. You do not have to subject yourselves to this, do not be a martyr for someone else's child who is now an adult.

I agree with this. 18 or not, he’s not your responsibility ultimately and is an adult. If he was respectful then fair enough, but compromising the safety of your household and worrying your other children, it’s not unreasonable to ask him to leave. You aren’t morally chained to him for life.

MNMH · 30/11/2022 02:32

Annabelle3 · 30/11/2022 02:32

You came on here, didn't reply to the OP and tried to pick a fight with me. Without even addressing the OP first. You get what you give. Maybe offer some kind words to the OP, which is what this thread is about, and stop looking to take your own issues out on strangers.

Ok. 👍🏾

Annabelle3 · 30/11/2022 02:32

MNMH · 30/11/2022 02:29

What's wrong with you? I was perfectly civil.
Work on your anger issues instead of taking it out on internet strangers.

Jesus.

You came on here, didn't reply to the OP and tried to pick a fight with me. Without even addressing the OP first. You get what you give. Maybe offer some kind words to the OP, which is what this thread is about, and stop looking to take your own issues out on strangers.

MNMH · 30/11/2022 02:32

Theabsoluteshit · 30/11/2022 02:30

Hey, your thoughts are worth something. Live and learn and wake up tomorrow to do it all again. ❤

Thanks so much. ❤
I tried to be kind in the end and I'm STILL getting dragged, lol.

Theabsoluteshit · 30/11/2022 02:30

MNMH · 30/11/2022 02:26

I apologize for ever interacting with you. I should have just kept my thoughts to myself.

Hey, your thoughts are worth something. Live and learn and wake up tomorrow to do it all again. ❤

MNMH · 30/11/2022 02:29

Annabelle3 · 30/11/2022 02:28

Yes, you should have. Maybe now you could interact with the OP instead. Or is offering kindness to her too much trouble for you?

What's wrong with you? I was perfectly civil.
Work on your anger issues instead of taking it out on internet strangers.

Jesus.

Annabelle3 · 30/11/2022 02:28

MNMH · 30/11/2022 02:26

I apologize for ever interacting with you. I should have just kept my thoughts to myself.

Yes, you should have. Maybe now you could interact with the OP instead. Or is offering kindness to her too much trouble for you?

Annabelle3 · 30/11/2022 02:27

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

MNMH · 30/11/2022 02:26

Theabsoluteshit · 30/11/2022 02:25

I have displayed kindness, you've displayed zero. I'm still way ahead of you.

No. You haven't.

You have displayed a lot of things, but not kindness

Thank you❤

MNMH · 30/11/2022 02:26

Annabelle3 · 30/11/2022 02:24

I just noted on your lack of kindness.

I have displayed kindness for the OP, and her child. Which is far more than you have done.

Where is YOUR kindness for the vulnerable OP and her vulnerable son? Have a look at your own hypocrisy, when you've displayed zero kindness, at least I have displayed kindness, you've displayed zero. I'm still way ahead of you.

I apologize for ever interacting with you. I should have just kept my thoughts to myself.

Theabsoluteshit · 30/11/2022 02:25

I have displayed kindness, you've displayed zero. I'm still way ahead of you.

No. You haven't.

You have displayed a lot of things, but not kindness

Annabelle3 · 30/11/2022 02:24

MNMH · 30/11/2022 02:22

I didn't put words in your mouth. I just noted on your lack of kindness.

I'll also post as I please. You're not a a mod here.

But I'll stop responding to you as you wish. Not worth it.

I just noted on your lack of kindness.

I have displayed kindness for the OP, and her child. Which is far more than you have done.

Where is YOUR kindness for the vulnerable OP and her vulnerable son? Have a look at your own hypocrisy, when you've displayed zero kindness, at least I have displayed kindness, you've displayed zero. I'm still way ahead of you.

Annabelle3 · 30/11/2022 02:22

Theabsoluteshit · 30/11/2022 02:20

How is a grown man more vulnerable that a grown woman?

I'm thinking you are (deeply) guilty of misogyny there!

The clue is the grown man is not more vulnerable than a woman. That's the point, which is where your misogyny is on display. You disregard the needs of the woman, for a grown man.

MNMH · 30/11/2022 02:22

Annabelle3 · 30/11/2022 02:20

Likewise. Don't put words into my mouth. Perhaps reply to the OP and address her concerns, instead of replying only to me.

I didn't put words in your mouth. I just noted on your lack of kindness.

I'll also post as I please. You're not a a mod here.

But I'll stop responding to you as you wish. Not worth it.