Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask SS to leave

259 replies

fisher7 · 29/11/2022 22:41

I feel awful writing this but I'm at a loss on what to do next

18yo SS lives with me full time, his mum passed away 9 years ago and my DH passed away during the first lockdown which hit us all hard. He had the choice of going and living with his aunt (mums sister) but he declined as he wanted to stay with me and she lived quite far away.

He attended counselling for a while but then stopped as he said it wasn't helping, he did go back to his old self eventually and seemed to have been coping fine.

Before he turned 18, he'd only drank once with his friends which was at 17 about 6 months before his 18th. Since he's turned 18, he goes out and drinks almost everyday, he's even smoked weed a few times. He spends most of his day on his Xbox, he doesn't help around the house with tidying etc.

Earlier, he was out and me and the other rest of us ate dinner, one of the DC’s washed up as it's their turn he got back and ate his dinner and then left his plate on the side. I asked him to wash it up, he said no and told me to do it, I told him he's an adult now etc which led to him shouting that I'm not his mum so I can't tell him what to do, he hates me, wishes I died and not his dad etc. DS(13) then came down and told him to leave me alone, SS then started shouting at him that he can't tell him what to do either and pushed him and went to his room.

DS is fine but has said he doesn't want to go to his dads tomorrow and leave me with SS. I have been to speak to SS and he's apologised and I've asked if he'll speak to me properly tomorrow when the other children are at school but he's refused and told me to leave him alone.

I know I probably am, but will I BU to ask him to leave and stay somewhere else?

OP posts:
Fleurdaisy · 30/11/2022 09:34

Can you look at going back to counselling? Maybe suggest you go together?
I can remember one of my friend’s dc hit problems as a teenager and it was all related to the death of her father when she was 4. The counsellor said it often comes back to bite them on the bum ( her words) when they’re teenagers.

I’m so sorry for your loss , dealing with your own loss is bad enough but when it affects multiple children too it’s even tougher.
All his behaviour is because he’s hurting, he doesn’t hate you, but I think professional help is needed.

CarolineHelston · 30/11/2022 09:33

I think my point - wilfully misunderstood? - is that when someone is testing boundaries, you reassure them by demonstrating where the boundaries exist. My stepson had a difficult time in later adolescence. He lived with us for limited periods but there was a time when we asked him to leave. He was smoking skunk and this had a really bad impact on everybody else in the family. He did go, but we always stayed in touch/kept up regular contact. Ultimately he's doing fine now and we have a good relationship. I think now - and perhaps even then - he appreciates/appreciated d our consistency and reliability.

I think those who say, 'Poor child' may not fully appreciate how destructive weed is and how impossible it is to deal with addictive behaviour until the addict is ready to change.

Teakind · 30/11/2022 09:27

That poor, poor boy. His behaviour isn't exactly rare for someone his age and he's dealing with life changing grief.

Please stick by him

AnneLovesGilbert · 30/11/2022 09:25

Peedoffo · 30/11/2022 09:20

In MN world do kids and siblings not physically fight? It was a push me and my brother used to scrap all the time only stopped late teens early 20s.

Not sure avoid the snarky “MN world” but I’ve got 3 siblings and we’ve never physically fought since we were tiny. It’s not abnormal, it’s normal and a sign of a well adjusted healthy upbringing. I’m sorry that wasn’t the case for you but it’s nothing to brag about.

ClangingBell · 30/11/2022 09:25

OP, everyone in your household is grieving. It makes everything different and there are obviously posters here who’ve never parented bereaved children and don’t understand the effects of childhood trauma. You can acknowledge that and that your SS in particular is in need of support without saying he can stay in your house without boundaries. You need to talk to him at a time when he’s calm and hasn’t been drinking. Reassure him that you’ll always be there to support him, but that you have to balance the needs of all the children in the house and that he can’t continue living there if the younger children aren’t safe. Offer him support to get his emotions under better control. College obviously isn’t for him at the minute, but he needs to get into work or training. Doing that will reduce his time for drinking and brooding. Set a timescale for him doing that. It sounds like he needs counselling, but setting up too many demands at once will only make him more likely to fall.

Most of all, make it clear that you are his parent and will be there for him but that doesn’t mean he gets to do what he wants and continue living in the house.

Peedoffo · 30/11/2022 09:20

In MN world do kids and siblings not physically fight? It was a push me and my brother used to scrap all the time only stopped late teens early 20s.

Sadbeigechildren · 30/11/2022 09:19

What a sad situation. Unfortunately he does now need to go as you have a violent, abusive man in the house. He should go somewhere where a man is present. It's very sad for him.

billy1966 · 30/11/2022 09:18

AnneLovesGilbert · 30/11/2022 00:02

You have to do what’s best for yourself and your own children. If that means saying he needs to go to his aunt’s till he can behave properly in your home then do that. Everyone’s got their limit and you sound like you’ve reached yours. I’m so very sorry you’ve lost your husband, I can’t imagine what you’ve gone through 💐

This.

This sounds very hard for him and you.

I feel very sorry for him but aggression of any type is completely unacceptable.

Your son is clearly affected and fearful for you.

Completely unacceptable.

He needs to go to his aunt and take some time out.

I would make it very clear that while you love him deeply, you don't accept ANY aggression from ANY male and he has crossed a line with you.

I would tell you the same if it was your own son, and I have two.

All bets are off when aggression is exhibited.

Life is hard and he cannot be allowed to think that others will put up with whatever behaviour he wants to dish out.

Thereon lies behaviour that will end up with him being an abusive waster.

You can be loving and kind whilst having firm boundaries and letting him know he has now crossed a line.

You need your own son to see your boundaries too.

kingtamponthefurred · 30/11/2022 09:18

Tell him it isn't personal-nobody gets to live in your house who pushes other people around and does not do his fair share of the housework.

gannett · 30/11/2022 09:17

Anyway it's clear that this situation has been precipitated by turning 18 - he knows he's legally an adult now, which on the one hand gives most 18yos an "I can do what I want now" attitude but would also make an orphaned 18yo suddenly, acutely aware of how alone he is in the world.

The whole "you're not my real mum" thing is an expression of what he's actually scared of - that the OP doesn't see him as her real son and that he is as alone as he fears.

With that in mind I think focusing on some practicalities is best.

He's apologised so he knows he crossed a line. That should be the starting point for a serious talk about serious house rules: no physical aggression, fair share of chores (with a rota if necessary).

Reading between the lines I assume he's not that close to his aunt, so an intervention from her would be meaningless. But he needs to get himself into counselling asap.

I assume he has a job to pay for the drinking and weed? I think it's time for a talk about longer-term career goals. Not necessarily from the OP but from someone in his field who can point him towards specific goals. It seems that he's both grieving and unfocused - he needs counselling to help with the former and mentoring to help with the latter.

Peedoffo · 30/11/2022 09:16

WoolyMammoth55 · 30/11/2022 07:19

OP, no idea if you're still reading but wanted to ad my thoughts. My DSis was a bereaved child and had massive abandonment issues, which I'm sure your SS also has.

They play out as a (mostly) unconscious desire to test the boundaries of people, to see if they love her enough to stay, or find out if they too will abandon her.

PLEASE DON'T SEND HIM AWAY. It would really make the abandonment much worse.

Please try to connect to him, tell him you love him, that he always has a home with you and that you'll always be there for him. Then ask him to get his act together - back to college/apprenticeship, rules around drinking, no more drugs, helping at home, and ideally also counselling.

He's at such a vulnerable time - either he keeps it together and gets to have a decent life, or he drops off the radar and ends up unemployable, criminal, or addicted... You are the only parent-figure he has left to get him through this time, please don't walk away.

This 100 percent. How he is treated now will have ramifications for the rest of his life. If he's thrown out now with no support he may well go down the drugs, criminality route.

Some love and support will very much help him. He has abandonment issues already, throwing him out will confirm to him he's alone in the world.

My DM was thrown out at 14 by her SD after her DM died she went into care. She had lived there since the age of 3. My DM has had mental health issues for much of her life. Perhaps if she had been shown love , compassion and care her life might have been different.

Emotionalsupportviper · 30/11/2022 09:15

GoonerGirl5231 · 30/11/2022 08:42

Rather than hit the nuclear option and ask him to leave, could you ask the aunt to intervene asap and talk to him about his behaviour? It could be he's acting up precisely because he's scared he's going to lose you and his home – that if he pushes you enough, his fears will be realised and then he can tell himself I told you so. It's warped thinking, but it's what people often do when they fear loss.

That's a very good point. I hadn't thought of this.

Emotionalsupportviper · 30/11/2022 09:13

Aleaiactaest · 30/11/2022 08:37

i would tell him he is your son and will be treated just like your own because you care about him. And because you care about his future you will have high expectations. And then I think you just treat him like you would your own DS if he went off the rails a bit due to an identity crisis/trauma of losing both parents so young. Would you kick your own DS out in the same situation? If yes, then go ahead.
I really think he needs to feel that you are his mum.

I absolutely endorse all of this.

I would not suggest "kicking him out" - but I really think that a few weeks break with his aunt - especially if it helps him to break the cycle of drinking and becoming increasingly depressed - may give everyone involved a better perspective.

I haven't read all posts so apologise if I've missed it, but has this poor boy had any grief counselling/ anti-depressants etc?

Stillprocessing · 30/11/2022 09:08

Was just thinking the same. Poor boy

gannett · 30/11/2022 09:08

poefaced · 30/11/2022 08:19

FFS, pushing someone IS physical aggression. But in your eyes, it doesn't count because OP and her son are only step-mum and step-brother.

He pushed his younger brother but yet you expect us to believe HE felt cornered? Pull the other one Hmm

Teenagers pushing siblings is perfectly commonplace behaviour. It's not right and it shouldn't be tolerated but it's not abuse, it's not a precursor of abuse and it's not a reason to throw someone out of the house. Your insistence that most posters are minimising male violence is outrageously offensive to victims of actual domestic abuse.

CarefreeMe · 30/11/2022 09:06

FFS, pushing someone IS physical aggression. But in your eyes, it doesn't count because OP and her son are only step-mum and step-brother.

Why are you trying to make this a step parent/child issue when it isn’t.

It doesn’t matter if this was the biological child or not.

I can guarantee that her biological children are also going to have outbursts every now and then and like most children will also probably push someone one day.

It’s concerning that you are so focused on him being a step child that I wonder if you would also kick the biological child out or call the police if OP had pushed him out of the way?

Emotionalsupportviper · 30/11/2022 09:05

Hapoydayz · 29/11/2022 22:47

Poor boy, what unimaginable pain he is going through.

What unimaginable pain they are both going through!

And how frightened OP's son must be to fears much for her safety if she is left alone with SS.

I agree that he is a deeply unhappy and troubled young man, but that doesn't mean it's OK to expect OP to absorb all of that pain and anger - particularly one there are younger children in the home who are affected by his aggressive behaviour

Part of it may just be ordinary *rsey adolescent behaviour which is exacerbated by grief. If his dad was still around there may still have been a degree of it, but it would have been easier to handle.

A PP has suggested that he stay with his aunt until over Christmas at least - give everyone a chance to have some breathing space, and see how things go after that, and it would certainly be better if he wasn't drinking so much (but try to stop a young man drinking with his mates!).

The situation has the potential to become a physically abusive one and no-one wants it to get to that stage. He is an adult, albeit a very young one and a very unhappy one, Send him to his aunt @fisher7 - he may or may not return, but you both need some space from each other. He will be able to open to his aunt in a way that he can't to you because of his (unfounded) resentment.

If he is drinking he may even lash out at your DS and hurt him if he tries to protect you - and even if he doesn't, you don't want your son feeling worried and upset all of the time. It will do everyone - including him - good to have some space.

DrBlackbird · 30/11/2022 09:01

Tough love is banal, unimaginative, and ineffective. Especially when it comes to children. Tough love is absolutely nothing in comparison to nurturing love.

Not my words. But completely agree with them.

SirVixofVixHall · 30/11/2022 08:59

18 might be legally an adult, but I think most 18 year olds are still boys, not men. Especially this cohort who have been through Covid, and this boy has also lost his father, having lost his mother at only nine.
It seems that he is using drink to deal with his feelings of floundering about, lost and grieving. The drink then seems to be a big part of the rudeness and bad behaviour ? So in your place I would be focusing on that as a starting point.
I think throwing him out over some not unusual teenage behaviour, when he is so lost, would be pretty terrible for him. I assume that as you have been in his life since he was six, and you have a 13 year old from a different relationship, then your younger children must be your SSs half siblings ?
He needs more support, and more love now, not less.

CarolineHelston · 30/11/2022 08:51

I believe in tough love.

Refusing to undertake the most minimal domestic tasks, shouting and pushing, substance abuse are all highly problematic, especially when a single parent has to consider the welfare of her own younger child.

I think the underlying problem is that the young person is not ready to look at the impact of the losses he has suffered. Drugs and computer games are functioning as an escape. But the poster cannot make him address this when he's not ready. I think it would be far better for him to go elsewhere for a while, whether that's to an aunt or sofa surfing with friends. Or he could make attempts to live as 'an adult' - which would mean finding work and/or studying, looking for alternative conversation

This might - though no guarantees - help him to realise that he's actually better off with the OP. There then might be the basis of a conversation about ground rules (No illegal drug use in the house or coming back stoned. Tidying up after himself. No verbally or physically aggressive behaviour. Committing to getting some help to look at how loss has affected him.)

DrBlackbird · 30/11/2022 08:51

DuchessDandelion · 29/11/2022 23:05

Please don't, let him stay. Yes boundaries needed as others said, but he's not coping at the moment and he needs you more than ever

This. He’s lost both parents and only just 18. Jesus. No, he’s not handling his grief and anger ‘well’, but that’s no surprise. He must be feeling so unloved.

There was a reason he wanted to stay with you and not his aunt. Yes, it’d be hard for you to see your DS pushed, but your DS needs to stay out of the arguments between you and your SS and trust that you can handle them on your own.

Children need our love the most when they deserve it the least. Please don’t abandon this boy.

ReformedWaywardTeen · 30/11/2022 08:43

Sorry but you're grieving too, you also have a DS who needs you as he's 13.

SS is a man, an adult. Yes he lost his father but you lost your husband. You've had to be strong for the pair of you and no doubt it hit your DS too

I would tell him straight, you either show some respect and stop acting like a child or you leave. You have the right to feel safe in your home, as does your DS. He pushed him. That's unacceptable. It's assault. And once they start they don't stop.

I would call the aunt and say he needs to go to her. I hope she's being supportive of you.

GoonerGirl5231 · 30/11/2022 08:42

Rather than hit the nuclear option and ask him to leave, could you ask the aunt to intervene asap and talk to him about his behaviour? It could be he's acting up precisely because he's scared he's going to lose you and his home – that if he pushes you enough, his fears will be realised and then he can tell himself I told you so. It's warped thinking, but it's what people often do when they fear loss.

Eleusa · 30/11/2022 08:38

What has he had in the way of counselling? He has been through the terrible trauma of losing both parents at a very young age- I am not at all surprising that it is manifesting like this.

Whether it's the right thing for him to stay with his aunt for a while is something for you all to discuss, and either way you need to be very clear with him about what is not acceptable (with pushing your son at the top of the list). But simply to tell him to leave would be appalling- he needs much more support, not less.

Aleaiactaest · 30/11/2022 08:37

i would tell him he is your son and will be treated just like your own because you care about him. And because you care about his future you will have high expectations. And then I think you just treat him like you would your own DS if he went off the rails a bit due to an identity crisis/trauma of losing both parents so young. Would you kick your own DS out in the same situation? If yes, then go ahead.
I really think he needs to feel that you are his mum.