Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To consider selling my house and renting instead

242 replies

90sfilmsforever · 29/11/2022 21:03

I've had a rough few years and I'm struggling to stay afloat financially as a single parent. Today I found out that my megalomanic boss isn't making my fixed term contract permanent, even though this was promised previously and I have worked my arse off to prove myself and had nothing but glowing feedback from my line manager.

I own my house with no mortgage but a small family loan on it that I pay back monthly. I've had a catalogue of disasters with plumbing and other house stuff in recent months that means I can't even afford to replace my only work shoes that fell apart two months ago. Since then I've been wearing a pair borrowed from my eldest that are too big for me. With necessary house repairs, a car disaster as well and the cost of living sky rocketing I've been in my overdraft for a good week before getting paid for the last few months, despite being in a professional salaried job. And now I find I'm going to be unemployed in less than 3 months.

I have no buffer or savings anymore due to afore mentioned disasters. There are no jobs in my field at the moment as due to the nature of my work they mainly come up at certain points in a year. I've been looking - just in case- since September and there have been two jobs. One I applied for and they withdrew due to covering the vacancy in house in the end. The other I applied for and heard nothing despite me always usually gaining an interview as my application is strong and I have lots of experience.

Would I be mad to sell up and rent to give me some breathing space, better job prospects than a small dead end town? I'd happily sell and relocate somewhere cheaper to buy but my daughter has to be within commuting distance of her dad and everywhere around here (south east) is so expensive to buy. Plus I'd have to pay back the family loan if I sold so that's already £50k I'm down. I have no real friends or ties where I am and we are both miserable. I love my little house but hate the town and the lack of prospects. Is it such a mad idea? In a few years my daughter will be at uni or old enough to decide where she lives irrespective of where her dad lives, so I/we could potentially relocate to a cheaper area then and still buy mortgage free with what's left, or with a better job I could get a mortgage in this area in the future. Am I mad??

OP posts:
Hankunamatata · 29/11/2022 22:22

If your credits bad would you even pass credit check to rent?

HungryandIknowit · 29/11/2022 22:22

Bad idea, especially as it sounds like you'd be doing it with the intention to move to a more expensive area. That means that - aside from potential house price increases - you would be eating into your capital and therefore less able to afford another house in future. I would sleep in the living room and get a lodger or let the house and rent a 1 bed flat (sleeping in living room again). It sounds like you could get another job soon so it would be temporary.

90sfilmsforever · 29/11/2022 22:22

GorgeousLadyofWrestling · 29/11/2022 22:09

I feel like you’re only really answering the things you can reply in the negative with. There’s a lot of good advice on this thread for things you could try - look at benefits, make it work with a lodger for the sake of much needed income, find any job to see you through, etc etc.

We bought our first flat two years ago. I shudder now to think about how hard renting is for people, particularly with children. We have 3 young kids and there is nothing that would make me go back to renting, unless I had exhausted every avenue.

A lodger is definitely out of the question due to the house (no spare room/ not fair on DD to make her share with me as her room is her sanctuary) I'd sleep on the sofa if needed but our front door opens straight into the lounge so not ideal with a lodger and DD wouldn't cope with a stranger in the house. I'm really not trying to be negative, I just didn't expect such a massive landslide against selling and that was the only light I could see at the end of the tunnel.

OP posts:
AutumnCrow · 29/11/2022 22:21

As per pp, what's with the £350 a month energy bill on a 2 up 2 down terrace?

mumda · 29/11/2022 22:21

The cost of living is the same without you owning a house. Check out rents but make sure you're sitting down.

Alysskea · 29/11/2022 22:21

Avoid becoming a renter if you can. I pay extortionate amounts to live in a mould-filled house while unable to get on the property ladder despite dual income
(both in professional careers). It’s dire. I know your situation is really challenging but I don’t think renting is the solution.

X2Kids · 29/11/2022 22:19

Sorry about the typos

deplorabelle · 29/11/2022 22:19

What are the repairs that need doing to the house?

Your energy bills are ridiculously high for a two bed terrace where all the occupants are out during school hours. Do you have heating and hot water on permanently? Or has the energy company set the DD wrong (ie are you massively in credit?) Or are you servicing debt on the account?

It sounds like you have had a horrendous time, but it also sounds like you've spent a lot of money on eg kitchen and bathroom, and I think you need to be really honest with yourself about how good you are at making financial decisions. I think you are currently being beguiled by the fantasy of free money being liberated from the equity on your house but it's unrealistic. You would be giving up your stability and the house you've made perfect. It could take a year to realise the money and you definitely won't get back what you've spent doing improvements. You probably won't sell at all without doing whatever the repairs are and you'll have a horrid time getting a rental property with no guarantee you could stay beyond 12 months. You WOULD spend money getting set up in the new place and every monthly payment would be money down the drain.

MyAutocorrectWishesMeDeaj · 29/11/2022 22:18

In your situation, not mad at all.

X2Kids · 29/11/2022 22:18

OP you're being given some really useful suggestions
Tutoring
WFH jobs
Supermarket jobs
Get some debt support
Get a benefits check
Ring round suppliers to see if they can help.

Just breathe and try to take some of this in. You're quite fixated on just doing teaching/supply. You will have lots xx of transferable skills, that will tied help find something until you can by in a cheaper area.

converseandjeans · 29/11/2022 22:18

Are you eligible for tax credits? Also you could do some extra work like a bar job, sell stuff on vinted.

I would stretch overdraft as far as you can tbh & look at paying back once DD is older.

I think you should also contact union about losing your job.

GettingItOutThere · 29/11/2022 22:18

no - do not sell. do anyhthing in your power tokeep it!

be mad to get off the property market and rent. The people in the same street as me pay 3x what i pay for my mortgage on their rent!!
and they will never own it!

you will not get any housing benefit help either as you have capital

EngTech · 29/11/2022 22:17

Renting is ok up to a point

What happens if you get a No Fault Eviction?

If I was in the same position as you, I would stay in the house but consider other options 👍

MadelineUsher · 29/11/2022 22:16

It's now in perfect condition after plumbing/drain disaster repairs. This is what has put me in such a precarious financial position... paying for the repairs.

Even more stupid to sell it now and rent.

MadelineUsher · 29/11/2022 22:15

Am I mad??

Yes. Don't do it. Sit down with someone more rational than you and go over your other options - a bank manager would be a good place to start, perhaps.

90sfilmsforever · 29/11/2022 22:14

bellac11 · 29/11/2022 22:08

I dont understand the maths.

The house is in perfect condition but needs huge investment and repairs to the degree that it would literally bankrupt you to obtain

You earn about 25k as a qualified teacher in the south east, where teachers are in high demand but cant get good supply jobs that pay well, in fact you said they only just pay too much to get benefits?

It's now in perfect condition after plumbing/drain disaster repairs. This is what has put me in such a precarious financial position... paying for the repairs.

My friend does supply and has worked no more than two days a week since September... usually less, despite being available everyday with hood transport and is child free so never needs to organise last minute childcare, school runs etc. He's being paid on the equivalent day rate of a NQT despite being a previous leadership scale teacher.

OP posts:
litlealligator · 29/11/2022 22:14

There would likely be part time jobs you could get where you could work from home - remote tutoring, editing dissertations for non English speaking students, remote admin/PA type work etc. Likely the best bet to tide you over until a job comes around.

YoSofi · 29/11/2022 22:13

Honestly OP, a single adult family with no income and bad credit is not going to be accepted for a rental.

For every rental that goes on the market, there will be at least 20 people applying for it. Landlords can afford to be choosy, you won’t get a look in and I say that as a renter.

Aquamarine1029 · 29/11/2022 22:13

I can't get a loan - poor credit history linked to the relationship with my ex husband. I can't even get a credit card. Tried to get a secured loan for house repairs- the only one that would accept me had an apr of 68%!

Of course it would be absolutely insane to sell your home. With your dire credit rating you'd never find a rental.

You need to take a deep breath and start being logical. You're not thinking clearly right now and I fear you could make a knee jerk decision that you would deeply, deeply regret.

gamerchick · 29/11/2022 22:13

90sfilmsforever · 29/11/2022 21:31

She's nearly 15 and her mental health is not good at the moment and this would destroy her, she really needs her own space. She's only just got her room to herself after her older sister moved back in during lockdown when unis shut and then couldn't afford to move out for ages.

Then why on earth would you move her into insecure housing where you could get turfed out any minute.

You need to breathe and look into benefits if the time comes. Start job hunting instead.

thelobsterquadrille · 29/11/2022 22:12

If you can't even get a credit card there's almost no way you'd be able to rent.

converseandjeans · 29/11/2022 22:11

Rent would be over £1000 a month - I reckon keep the house.

We both have OK jobs but live in permanent overdraft, I think you would be worse off. You will struggle to get a mortgage with no job.

Mumoftwo2021 · 29/11/2022 22:11

Sorry Op, I am not sure if anyone else has said but rental agencies tend to do credit checks before renting out a property, so that option may be a dead end for now with your credit history and no possible guarantor or employment.

Now is a hard time for a lot of people, so ring around who your bills are paid to and explain the situation, they may have something in place similar to covid, where they will reduce or freeze your payments for 3 months, try to reduce your outgoings as much as you can and pay your essentials like council tax, mums care, & food first. Any unemployment benefits will help towards these costs.
Also enquire about any extra money you are entitled to, eg energy payments

good luck and I hope you manage to sort something out that your happy with.
xx

YouOKHun · 29/11/2022 22:11

My 18 year old DS is also tutoring (French GCSE and A level) and making about £200 a week. He’s good at what he does but isn’t a qualified teacher like you - could this work for you? I know others have mentioned it already but it seems like it might provide a buffer? Try and hang on to your house. Renting isn’t stress free, has its own insecurities and it’s very expensive at the moment.

NeedSleepNow · 29/11/2022 22:10

I can 100% understand your concerns. I'm a single parent with 3 children and am currently paying a mortgage on the further marital home. I need to get a few basic repairs done to the house but can't afford to at the moment after my car needed fixing and wiped it my small amount of savings, I can't even afford to get my boots rehealed or buy some new jeans which I desperately need and I'm having to sell a lot of stuff to fund Christmas. I could sell the house and rent but I know that rental prices are sky high at the moment and the equity would be used up within a few years, to rent my current house would cost me 3x my monthly mortgage payments!

I really think you shouldn't sell and rent. You are just throwing money away by doing that. Could you rent your house out and then rent a place for you and your daughter elsewhere/somewhere cheaper until she is at uni and then sell and relocate properly? If you sell now and rent you might find it very difficult to get back on the housing ladder in the future.