Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To consider selling my house and renting instead

242 replies

90sfilmsforever · 29/11/2022 21:03

I've had a rough few years and I'm struggling to stay afloat financially as a single parent. Today I found out that my megalomanic boss isn't making my fixed term contract permanent, even though this was promised previously and I have worked my arse off to prove myself and had nothing but glowing feedback from my line manager.

I own my house with no mortgage but a small family loan on it that I pay back monthly. I've had a catalogue of disasters with plumbing and other house stuff in recent months that means I can't even afford to replace my only work shoes that fell apart two months ago. Since then I've been wearing a pair borrowed from my eldest that are too big for me. With necessary house repairs, a car disaster as well and the cost of living sky rocketing I've been in my overdraft for a good week before getting paid for the last few months, despite being in a professional salaried job. And now I find I'm going to be unemployed in less than 3 months.

I have no buffer or savings anymore due to afore mentioned disasters. There are no jobs in my field at the moment as due to the nature of my work they mainly come up at certain points in a year. I've been looking - just in case- since September and there have been two jobs. One I applied for and they withdrew due to covering the vacancy in house in the end. The other I applied for and heard nothing despite me always usually gaining an interview as my application is strong and I have lots of experience.

Would I be mad to sell up and rent to give me some breathing space, better job prospects than a small dead end town? I'd happily sell and relocate somewhere cheaper to buy but my daughter has to be within commuting distance of her dad and everywhere around here (south east) is so expensive to buy. Plus I'd have to pay back the family loan if I sold so that's already £50k I'm down. I have no real friends or ties where I am and we are both miserable. I love my little house but hate the town and the lack of prospects. Is it such a mad idea? In a few years my daughter will be at uni or old enough to decide where she lives irrespective of where her dad lives, so I/we could potentially relocate to a cheaper area then and still buy mortgage free with what's left, or with a better job I could get a mortgage in this area in the future. Am I mad??

OP posts:
LadyEloise1 · 30/11/2022 08:56

I certainly wouldn't sell and then rent.
Security of tenure is vital in these difficult times, particularly with a dd with poor mental health.

She doesn't like the area but wants to be near her Dad a tosser who should, but doesn't contribute financially to her upbringing. Hmmmm !!!

ZeldaWillTellYourFortune · 30/11/2022 08:53

Wow, @Winter2020! Excellent advice!

Winter2020 · 30/11/2022 08:42

Just to add - do not pay for debt advice - use a free charity. Fee charging companies that fee money could be going towards your debts.

Be wary of IVAs as companies get paid for them so they benefit from you taking one.

If in doubt ask on the money saving expert debt free wannabe section for advice. Many debt experts on there.

Charley50 · 30/11/2022 08:40

Yes you would be mad to sell to rent. I don't really understand your work problem tbh. You could work in a supermarket if you can't get a teaching job in the next 3 months. You need to sort your utility bills out as that is not right. How much a month are you paying for your loan? Is it going into your mums bank account or the care home? Care home fees are £1000 a week.

Once you daughter has done her GCSEs then maybe think about selling and buying straightaway in an area you actually like.

Winter2020 · 30/11/2022 08:39

I'm sorry things are so stressful and I'm sorry about your mum - I'm sure she would pause the repayments to her if she could.

I agree with most others that I wouldn't sell up to step off the property ladder - only to buy cheaper if you decide to do that.

You have a mortgage free house except for this 50k loan - which you are not charged interest on. You won't be in a stronger position other than "downsizing" to cheaper.

I would also urge you to speak to Stepchange or CAP (Christians against poverty) or national debt line.

They can help you draw up a budget and decide what you can afford to pay creditors. So for example the loan you are paying. You might be paying £250 but find you can offer them £40 for example. You are supposed to offer all of your creditors in fair proportion to what you owe and can afford.

With poor credit and no need for a mortgage you don't have to worry about your credit rating if you default on loans.

Ask for advice about the loan to your mum as well. I think the theory is if you offer what you can afford to pay then even if it went to court you would only be asked to pay what you can afford anyway. Your mum wouldn't want you to lose your home to pay this. I know it isn't her choice now but the local authority are not going to quickly act to boot you out of your home if payments reduce while you are between jobs. Those wheels would grind very slowly.

The Debt Free Wannabe section of the Money Saving Expert website has a lot of people who are very knowledgeable about your rights managing debt.

I think you need to be more open minded in your job search. You could teach outside of your specialism (some subjects struggle to recruit specialists) or get a job in a different sector.

If you could get an evening and weekend job in a supermarket or hospitality you could keep your days free for supply teaching - and if you think you will only get two days supply that shouldn't be too much.

Doing supply is good because it's getting your face know in lots of schools if jobs or longer term supply come up.

Strip it back and you are mortgage free and in uncertain work. Due to the fact that you are mortgage free any work should tide you over in the very short term. You would claim universal credit if your income is low and default on your loans and debts for a while if you have to.

You describe paying off utility debt from £2000 down to £300. If you are paying it off at £100 a month (might be more like £150 from the sound of your bills) that debt will be gone in the next three months.

Like most of us you feel you need to pay all your obligations but you might need to learn about and adopt a new attitude where you know what your priority bills are and what you cannot afford to pay doesn't get paid for a while. It's scary if you have never not paid loans and debts but it is officially a "thing". That's why unsecured credit is more expensive- it's risky for the lender. You prove what you can afford and pay it and then generally lenders don't bother to take you to court as even if they did they wouldn't get more.

You can do this x

jeaux90 · 30/11/2022 07:03

Single mum here too. Totally get the burden, it sometimes feels too heavy.

I'd say don't sell though. The risk of not being able to get back into the housing market would outweigh the short term benefit for me.

I'm biased perhaps though, took me ages to get on the housing ladder.

Mummyoflittledragon · 30/11/2022 07:01

FlamingJingleBells · 30/11/2022 06:32

No don't sell your house as its your long term future asset. Rents are astronomical atm and in my area almost three times the cost of an average mortgage. I pay £700 pcm mortgage for a 3 bed house down south. The same house on my street is being let for £1800 pcm with a 10% increase for a new tenant. Your equity from your house sale won't last long if you rent.

Then getting back on the housing ladder after renting will be extremely expensive. You won't get much for your money if you buy in a few years time.

Options are:

  • take a lodger
  • let out your home
  • take a small home improvement loan out and renovate your home
  • sell but downsize to a smaller home But do not sell and then rent a house, that's a bad idea and complete waste of money.

Renting out her home is not an option for financial reasons. Op doesn’t even have the set up costs let alone a financial buffer. Any kind of loan is dependent on being able to pay it back longer term and is as risky as a zero % spending or balance transfer credit card.

Dexionmagic · 30/11/2022 06:51

Out of the (admittedly hot) frying pan and into the fire.

Is a second p/t job out of the question?

FlamingJingleBells · 30/11/2022 06:35

www.charityjob.co.uk/

You can set the filters to hybrid or remote only when searching for a new job.

FlamingJingleBells · 30/11/2022 06:32

No don't sell your house as its your long term future asset. Rents are astronomical atm and in my area almost three times the cost of an average mortgage. I pay £700 pcm mortgage for a 3 bed house down south. The same house on my street is being let for £1800 pcm with a 10% increase for a new tenant. Your equity from your house sale won't last long if you rent.

Then getting back on the housing ladder after renting will be extremely expensive. You won't get much for your money if you buy in a few years time.

Options are:

  • take a lodger
  • let out your home
  • take a small home improvement loan out and renovate your home
  • sell but downsize to a smaller home But do not sell and then rent a house, that's a bad idea and complete waste of money.
Wallywobbles · 30/11/2022 06:19

To me the answer is obvious - change jobs. I retrained as a instructional designer while teaching more than full time. I worked 7 days a week for a year to pull it off. It wouldn't be a huge change for you. Your teaching experience is invaluable.

Growth industry. Much better pay than teaching. I absolutely love what I do.

Look at MicroMasters in Instructional Design and Technology on EdX. And Learning Experience Design on NovoEd (free course).

Currently to up your income you could tutor online.

Don't sell your house. It'll be a big step towards homelessness.

Mummyoflittledragon · 30/11/2022 06:13

I am a landlord. You will find it extremely difficult to find a rental in your position. Competition is very high now as the government has forced anyone without deep pockets out of the market. Don’t rent out your house, that has disaster and repossession written all over it.

I would stay put for now. I get your dd wants to run away and so do you. But she’s in the crucial GCSE years so you simply can’t. Look into all the online options available to you. If you’re physically at home but online teaching when your dd is home from school, does that work?

If all else fails, I would get a lodger. Selling your home and finding yourselves made homeless by a Landlord will be far worse for your dd’s mental health. As for the suggestions to move areas, it may be good in the future but your dd needs to be mentally in a good enough place to take the train or bus alone to see her dad otherwise you’ll be ferrying her around a lot and that doesn’t sound feasible right now.

TinkyWinkyRainbowHead · 30/11/2022 06:11

I think you’d be totally bonkers for selling up. My mum did that with her outright owned home. I literally begged her not to and spelled out what would happen if she did. She’s a stubborn old thing who sold it, spent the proceeds on crap and now has to live with us as she’s skint. She’s also still working in her 70s part time. You don’t want that for yourself, surely? You need the security of owning somewhere.

noworklifebalance · 30/11/2022 05:47

90sfilmsforever · 29/11/2022 23:32

My house is worth 270k based on estate agents valuation- they were spot on with the valuation on my last house and sold it for exactly what they had valued it for within days of it going on the market.

So pay back the 50k loan and I'm left with 220k less fees etc.

I know in another part of the country I could buy a lot for far less than this but even flats in the nearest ( slightly better for jobs) towns are 300k up now

I really wouldn’t sell in that case esp as earlier on you said how bad your credit history is - you will struggle to buy a house and renting will burn through any money you have from the sale.
If you have to stop working/retire early due to ill health then things will be extremely tough.

Check your fuel bill account - do you really need to pay £350/month?
A couple of years ago I checked mine and realised we were 1000s in credit and so dropped our monthly payments from almost £400 down to £50.
Currently, the account says I should be paying £400+/month but I have set it to £150 and it’s covering the bills. I may need to up it but we live in a large, draughty house. Yours shouldn’t be that expensive esp if you only have the heating on for an hour a day.

GordonShakespearedoesChristmas · 30/11/2022 05:28

In reality OP it's doubtful you could rent atm. If your credit history is that bad you will not be accepted. Shit but true. Even paying upfront won't guarantee acceptance as they will still have concerns about your reliability.
I can see why you're considering this, I really can. So looking at the facts-It's a very small 2 up 2 down terrace that would sell for more than £200k? If you then rented at say £1250 per month ( yes that's realistic) and spent at your current income rate (as you have no mortgage but still spend your whole salary) you would be going through it at £3250 per month. 150,000 (after paying back your Mum) / 3250 = 46 months. It would all be gone in less than 4 years (other than if you managed to get another job to top it up).
However 4 years is enough time to get your poorly daughter to her next stage of life without you being so run down all the time that you're at breaking point. If you manage to get back into work it will last longer, or you'd be able to use it as a deposit. 6 years on your credit file would be clear.
So, to sum up, I think you should go talk to a letting agent and see if you would be able to do it in the first instance. Then work out what you would do if completion happened and you'd not got a rental (Airbnb etc).
I don't hold with this keep it at all costs. Life turns in a sixpence. Poverty is never ending misery. Use your asset for you and your daughter.
BTW have you considered becoming an Apprenticeship Tutor? There are usually vacancies for Teaching Assessors and it pays circa £32k often remote. Just a thought! Good luck OP.

Crikeyalmighty · 30/11/2022 02:49

If you had considered shared ownership OP- something like this in Guildford might suit- good area for work too and a good area with a teen . Would give you the security of tenure and also some cash still in bank - if you bought say40% outright - you would end up with monthly rent and service charge combined of around £685 which I think is well doable. Personally I would think about it rather than live just any old place because it's cheap housing.

www.rightmove.co.uk/properties/123232121#/?channel=RES_BUY

JennyForeigner · 30/11/2022 02:11

I would consider moving. The courts are not there to get involved where there is a genuine need and your daughter will have to come to terms with it. As other posters have said property is comparatively cheap in the Midlands, transport links and other things are great, and we have a desperate undersupply of any kind of teacher.

But it isn't an immediate solution. Selling up to solve a problem rarely works - imagine the pressure you will be under. People are wankers about property and someone will scent blood. The last thing you need is a complete arsehole downgrading their offer by £50k on the day before completion because they have figured out you are desperate.

If you can sell your house you can break the emotional link enough to rent it, and trial something in a better long term area. It would make it harder for your ex to prove intent for a permanent move too.

In the meantime someone here recommended skills bootcamp - free government online qualifications. In your position I probably would be tutoring with no need to stick to your core subject as your skills are transferable, but I am doing a 3 month project management qualification at about 16 hours per week with careers advice and interviews at the end. I signed up a week ago and will start straight away. It's worth investigation if you are unsure about teaching longer term.

RobertsRadio · 30/11/2022 01:07

Frankly I'd decide which area you want to move to that will give you good prospects for employment, affordable housing and then sell up in order to buy another property outright in the new area.

Your ex screwed you over financially and hardly contributes any CM, he is flaky about seeing your DD and both of you are miserable living in your current area. So just take that leap and move away for your financial and mental well-being. But, don't rent, buy in the new area, renting would be a crazy idea when you own your own home.

Jammy62 · 30/11/2022 00:40

Keep your property

Thelnebriati · 30/11/2022 00:32

@90sfilmsforever IDK if this will help, but there are schemes where you part buy and part rent. If you know where you want to live, you can search for a property, its more secure than private renting;
movingsoon.co.uk/shared-ownership-part-buy-part-rent/

Ilovehatecleaning · 30/11/2022 00:20

I know it's been mentioned but do consider online tutoring. You could even work self employed. I teach using Google Classroom and it's very straightforward.
Good luck

NewNovember · 30/11/2022 00:15

Sell up and buy a one bed flat give your dd the bedroom. In a few years she will likely move out anyway. It will ge much cheaper to maintain and for bills.

HeyThereDelilahhh · 30/11/2022 00:10

If you live in a touristy area, could you maybe supplement your income by putting your room on Airbnb? You could make it available only on the nights your daughter is at her dads and you could stay in her room, or else rent the house out completely if you had somewhere you could also stay?

Maybe not a long term solution, just an idea that might help tide you over!

ZeldaWillTellYourFortune · 30/11/2022 00:05

If you sell and move to a cheaper area, you likely are moving to an area with fewer earning opportunities, perhaps more crime/social problems, lower appreciation of housing values.

Cling to what you have now and figure out some way to generate more cash. If you are in a tourist area, can you fix up your room as an AirBnB? Bunk in with your daughter if you have guests.

As I wrote on a previous thread, I pay nearly 100 a night for pet sitting. Are you in a position to take in small/medium dogs while their owners are on holiday? Or do drop-in pet sitting around your area?

Good luck. I know it's a horrid position now but when people liquidate their equity they also tend to fritter it,and once it's gone you are in a VERY precarious position.

Are you getting all the benefits and child maintenance you are entitled to?

Would you mother forgive the loan? Or allow you to pause repayment?

Allsnotwell · 29/11/2022 23:59

There are loads of online teaching posts -

Some international schools have full time teachers - my friend looked into this a few months ago.

Easy work at home - good pay.