Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

WIBU to take DD's advent calendar away to teach her to say thank you

109 replies

ItsNotReallyChaos · 29/11/2022 18:39

My DD (5) is articulate and has full understanding of basic manners but she's driving me mad at the moment because she won't reply 'hello' if someone says hello to her, won't say 'bye' as we leave somewhere.

I've just given her her advent calendar and she didn't say thank you.

She's not a spoilt child in terms of material stuff. I only really buy presents for birthday/Christmas, with the occasional book bought in between times but she just never seems grateful to receive things. You'd think she received stuff on a daily basis if you saw her not-bothered response to being given something nice.

I feel like I've failed her as by now, hello, goodbye and thank you should be automatic.

Any advice?

And would it be totally unreasonable to take the Advent calendar away to try to teach her the hard way to say thank you!

OP posts:
anexcellentwoman · 29/11/2022 19:58

How some mumsnetters love to talk about 'punishing' little children. The way to teach children is by 'modelling' good behaviour and never forgetting to praise and praise a child who remembers to say thank you. Look at how schools promote behaviour management. It is always positive. A child who constantly is criticised learns to not say anything for fear of getting into trouble.

ItsNotReallyChaos · 29/11/2022 19:56

Thank you to everyone that has responded.

I didn't take it away from her but I was considering it. I won't and I knew deep down that I wouldn't but I was frustrated and it made me feel like trying to teach her the lesson the hard way.

I've taken the more constructive replies on board and will in particular think about the negative effects of me putting pressure on her to say expected greetings etc.

OP posts:
EdPsychonaQuest · 29/11/2022 19:51

*Oh for crying out loud.
Kids misbehave.

Doesn't mean they have anxiety / mutism / autism / ADHD or whatever else is so easily thrown around on here. There really is no need to try and label a child the second manners slip out the window.*

Actually, kids with selective (as in situational) mutism are very likely indeed to have difficulty with "basic politeness" words, as these are the words they will have repeatedly been placed under immense pressure to say. They are exceptionally high "communication load" words.

Communication load is the idea that not all speech is equally difficult. If you think about it, you know this; for example if you had to speak to a colleague about their personal hygiene you'd rehearse, consider your words carefully, feel anxious etc. That's just you experiencing high communication load. People with SM are way more sensitive to "risk" and "pressure" in speech.

OP it would be sensible to ask in her education setting how her communication is developing. This could be early signs of communication stress. Ask specifically if she speaks to adults and children, if she initiates any speech or only replies, and if she joins in fully and freely. In the event that you are picking up a communication issue, it's much much easier to support early on. The national charity SMiRA has a great website with lots of info on.

saraclara · 29/11/2022 19:50

They speak freely a lot of the time now (7) but really struggle with thank you, hello, goodbye and sorry, it’s common with selective mutism. It’s because the use of these phrases put particular focus directly on the child and makes them feel anxious.

Exactly that. I had a friend at uni who communicated completely normally until he was ever asked his name. He couldn't say it. Clearly something about the attention specifically on him and asking for something personal to him, rendered him unable to speak.

Obviously, being young and being his friends, we'd cover for him and jump in with "oh, you don't know Dave?" Or something along those lines.

pigsDOfly · 29/11/2022 19:49

Poor little thing doesn't need to be punished like that.

Do you lead by example? Are you saying thank you to her if she passes you something for example?

She's 5 she will forget and just needs a gentle reminder each time not harsh, way over the top punishment.

WorkerBee83 · 29/11/2022 19:44

Maybe she doesn’t enjoy receiving a gift? Some kids prefer to give or it could be asd? Xx

Individewl · 29/11/2022 19:41

How is she in general with speaking to unfamiliar adults?

I have a DC who has selective mutism, they didn’t talk to unfamiliar adults at all, also wouldn’t speak to g parents, uncles aunties etc until
around the age of 4. They speak freely a lot of the time now (7) but really struggle with thank you, hello, goodbye and sorry, it’s common with selective mutism. It’s because the use of these phrases put particular focus directly on the child and makes them feel anxious.

if your daughter is generally ok with other communication I would suggest just continuously modelling, 5 is still young. I think the removal of the Advent calendar would be quite harsh as it’s a whole months punishment

onmywayamarillo · 29/11/2022 19:32

This is awful! So many of these posts recently
Kids are kids just let them be, model behaviour you'd 'like' 5 yr olds have so much to navigate now, just say thanks that's nice every time she engaged with you . And she will model that behaviour back.

If they don't please do not make a big deal out of it 😀

JenniferBarkley · 29/11/2022 19:31

Wibbly1008 · 29/11/2022 19:14

Poor little thing might be shy, or feel awkward in social situations.

Exactly, punishing her would be a complete overreaction.

There is such an obsession on here with pleases and thank yous - tone and overall behaviour are much more important to me.

Keep gently prompting, and praise her when she gets it right. She'll get there.

SirenSays · 29/11/2022 19:27

TheYearOfSmallThings · 29/11/2022 18:50

"What do you say.....?"

"What do you say.....?"

"What do you say......?"

She's only 5, you have to keep prompting until it becomes automatic.

This
Feels a bit mean to give it and then take it away later.

geraniumsandsunshine · 29/11/2022 19:22

Just keep modelling it to her. She will pick it up

MelchiorsMistress · 29/11/2022 19:21

Find a reason why the advent calendar has to be kept on a high up shelf so she has to ask politely and say thank you every day if she wants to open it.

InSummertime · 29/11/2022 19:19

Short pull up each time.

did you want the advent calendar? Did you like it?

what do you need to respond with?

FatGirlSwim · 29/11/2022 19:18

She’s five, you’re being ridiculous.

But a pp is right that you should consider low profile Selective Mutism. The pressure to say these words (which are apparently the very hardest for people with SM to say) will increase her anxiety and make it less likely that she will be able to speak.

being given a gift and the pressure to give an exoected response can be overwhelming for young children (and some adults).

Don’t punish her, and don’t pressurise her, it will come.

As for others… advocate for your child. ‘ She is finding those words hard to say right now’ - and model saying thank you. But don’t tell her off.

ThreeblackCats · 29/11/2022 19:18

She’s 5. I remember having to prompt “say thank you” quite frequently at that age. Especially if the child has been overwhelmed with an unexpected something.

Chose your battles op, keep reminding her to say hello or thank you. Don’t punish her for the entirety of December, that’s just nasty. Just keep parenting, reminding her of her manners.

Onnabugeisha · 29/11/2022 19:17

ItsNotReallyChaos · 29/11/2022 18:47

How can she have a full understanding of basic manners if she doesn’t say hello, bye or thank you 🤷‍♀️

I mean that she knows that she should say hello and goodbye and thank you. I think she forgets the thank yous but with hello in particular, she just doesn't want to.

Please stop pressuring her to say hello and goodbye or thank you to total strangers. She could be shy or autistic.

As for expecting a thank you for an advent calendar I think that’s a bit OTT. Does she also need to thank you for the Christmas tree?

bonnielochs · 29/11/2022 19:17

My 13 and 14 year old still need reminders on "Thankyou". Infuriating as manners is something that's always been taught to them by me and extended family. I think it's a mix of minor rebellion, little bit of entitlement and also just them still being young and their brains being squishy.

Parenting is a long stretch. I have faith that they will be well rounded humans eventually 😊

ladydimitrescu · 29/11/2022 19:16

She's FIVE - calm down ffs! Total over reaction and would be a bloody horrible thing to do!

Wibbly1008 · 29/11/2022 19:14

Poor little thing might be shy, or feel awkward in social situations.

aSofaNearYou · 29/11/2022 19:13

YABU. It's not innate in her so she's not going to magically figure out why you're punishing her. As others have said, you just have to keep reminding her.

Kanaloa · 29/11/2022 19:12

Just say ‘Amelia, remember your thank you. It’s polite to say thank you when you’re given something. Amelia, it’s rude to ignore people, we always say hello/bye.’ Snatching away her advent calendar isn’t going to teach her to say thank you, it’s the kind of weirdly aggressive thing that could really confuse and hurt a child.

Also remember to model it. I know so many parents who are the type to be snapping ‘what do you say, what do you say’ as soon as their child is handed anything, but they aren’t quick to say ‘thank you for doing that, James’ when their child does something for them. Do you make sure to thank her and each other regularly?

ldontWanna · 29/11/2022 19:10

TheYearOfSmallThings · 29/11/2022 18:50

"What do you say.....?"

"What do you say.....?"

"What do you say......?"

She's only 5, you have to keep prompting until it becomes automatic.

This. Years and years of "what do you say..?", modelling and reminding.

She's 11 now and still forgets occasionally. It happens.

AutisticLegoLover · 29/11/2022 19:03

It's the 29th November, why have you given it her now?
She might feel awkward and uncomfortable rather than deliberately being rude. She's only little, give her a break.

MrsPnut · 29/11/2022 19:01

Do you all say please and thank you to each other at home? I'd be working on these things in the home and not really pushing it too hard elsewhere.

It's different saying bye to Granny than saying it to strangers (and we spend so much time telling our kids not to talk to strangers anyway).

Dotingmumandgranny · 29/11/2022 19:00

What an overreaction to a simple issue. Of course a 5 year old isn't subconsciously trying to tell you something. She hasn't yet learned to say please and thank you, that's all. She'll get there.

Swipe left for the next trending thread