Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think this response from my fellow student was quite uncalled for and OTT?

128 replies

Ahsoka2001 · 29/11/2022 17:14

I'm a postgrad student and for our next assessment we have to do a group presentation. They're randomly assigned and I was originally in a group of 4, but then it turned out the other 2 had been put in by mistake and I was left in a pair with just one other student.

Our seminar tutor emailed another group consisting of 3 students politely asking if me and my partner would be able to join theirs.

Then one member of the group replied at 2am with a huge email (almost 1,500 words) saying that no, it's not OK, because most of their work has already been finished on the basis of 3 people performing, not 5.

OK...I can kind of see what he means, but there's more. He said very bluntly to the tutor that as a "customer" paying £10K his personal time should not be interfered with due to her "poor management of forming the groups" (he thought he'd have to re-schedule free time to accommodate us joining).

Also, he said if she insisted I join his group he would discuss leaving the university with his personal tutor because his confidence in the quality of teaching here would be ruined. He seemed to be trying to tell her how to handle the situation himself e.g. "Most important for you is to consider the options below on how to handle this" and "Consider these points and discuss with your colleagues if necessary".

Also - "Lecturers are required to respond in 72 hours. You gave me less than 24 hours to respond to your email" and "Are you seriously considering inflating the group by 66%?"

^ Just to give you an idea of the email's tone.

Regardless of the tutor's management of things (some other students have had similar thoughts) I can NEVER imagine writing something like that to a lecturer as a student. Am I wrong, or was this an uncalled for response?

OP posts:
latetothefisting · 29/11/2022 18:58

Okay so his response was drastically over the top and inappropriate BUT I don't entirely disagree with all the angst about students feeling like consumers and being entitled if they don't get a good service - universities are run like businesses now. Students pay ridiculous fees today, and we (the tax payers) also further subsidise universities, all of which adds up to a LOT of money.

It's not inappropriate to expect a certain level of teaching and organisation for that. If I was doing my course now, I'd be paying roughly £83 per lecture/seminar before even thinking about books/living costs, etc. If you were paying that per hour for private tuition for your child, or your organisation was paying ten grand a year for you to do an external course, and it was crap, of course you'd have a right to complain. Unfortunately universities are no longer composed solely of the brightest students keen for knowledge being taught by wise old professors through clouds of pipe smoke - hundreds of thousands of not-particularly academic young people are going to uni because they know that jobs which by no means NEED a degree to do will demand one, so they ARE paying for a service. Similarly, some tutors (which from OPs comments sounds like it applies to hers!) ARE a bit shit and shouldn't be above criticism (albeit not in the format this guy chose).

How do you know exactly what he said, OP? Did he/the tutor cc you in, because that's also not appropriate of either of them!

BacklogBritain · 29/11/2022 18:47

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

DohaDragon · 29/11/2022 18:46

There’s actually a lot of research which shows that students who view themselves as consumers perform poorly academically compared to students who see themselves as learners. Maybe find him some of this research and send him a link Grin

certainly the message from SLT is that students are not consumers and to nip any such expectations in the bud. Certainly lecturers are caught in the middle and morale certainly is on the floor.

i am actually thinking of transferring to criminology (I have a degree in that as well), as I am so fed up with some of my current students. Actually that’s not fair, it’s not really the students, probably more the subject…..it lends itself to students needing more support which yes we try like mad to provide but don’t get the staff to do it. Plus I’d like to teach a subject with a nice normal length summer break rather than 2 weeks! The thought of a summer with no students so I have time to prep is a total fantasy.

personally I’ve been a student at 7 different universities. I haven’t studied on a course yet without issues, some disorganisation, some not so great teaching, etc. I’m not saying it’s acceptable to have a poor course but I do think that the expectations of some sort of magical perfect course is probably not realistic.

BacklogBritain · 29/11/2022 18:41

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

poefaced · 29/11/2022 18:41

ZiggyAndChanelle · 29/11/2022 17:17

you know you’re not wrong so why are you asking if YABU

Why are you even posting on this thread if you can't be helpful? Grow up.

LolaSmiles · 29/11/2022 18:37

He sounds like a prize arsehole with a sense of self-importance.

I'm surprised the lecturer put you and the other student into one group though. It would have made more sense to allocate each of you to a different group.

I'd bet my money he thinks he is buying a qualification and is looking for any excuse to complain so if (when) he gets a grade he is unhappy with he can try to throw his weight around.

girlmom21 · 29/11/2022 18:37

Is this the first time it's happened? It sounds like the straw that broke the camels back to me.

How does removing the other two from your group then adding you to a group of 3 make sense?

DohaDragon · 29/11/2022 18:36

LindseyHoyleSpeaks · 29/11/2022 18:19

@JenniferBarkley @DohaDragon - Why is it the fault of your students that their course costs more to run than you charge? They have been sold a product for a price. You/your university need to deliver that product.

We do deliver “the product”. They get 37 hours of teaching a week.

the complaint I had wasn’t about teaching but was about the fact that students are given for free one item at the start of the course. There is an issue with their item and have been told no replacement free of charge as admin are blaming the student for the issue. The student says it’s not their fault. The issuing of items is nothing to do with me but the student contacted me complaining (I do see their point) so I emailed on their behalf saying I felt it was unfair and I’ve been told by admin that they’re not budging. 🤷‍♀️

Softplayhooray · 29/11/2022 18:35

@Userg1234 'poor service'? What is this, McDonalds drive thru? 😄

LindseyHoyleSpeaks · 29/11/2022 18:35

@ChristmasPickleRick - really? 🙄

Softplayhooray · 29/11/2022 18:34

It's shitty students like that who are destroying the HE sector, pushing good lecturers out with infantilising rules like 'respond in 72 hours or you get a warning from your manager', and students thinking they're owed something just because they paid a few, and speaking to their lecturers like shit. I worked in education in admin for a while and I remember the 72 hour thing, I think it's very common. The management just wanted the money and the staff were treated like shit. These days motivation is on the floor there apparently.

JenniferBarkley · 29/11/2022 18:33

Chatrattoria · 29/11/2022 18:32

Could you respond with an R U OK HUN? Just for me?

Literal lol Grin

Chatrattoria · 29/11/2022 18:32

Could you respond with an R U OK HUN? Just for me?

entropynow · 29/11/2022 18:32

Userg1234 · 29/11/2022 17:23

Is this the final straw? Have there been problems with this lecturer before?

He is right he is a customer and is spending a lot of money for the seemingly unorganized course you are on.

As I've got older I am more accepting that mistakes happen but don't put up with poor service

You seriously think this is the right approach? Blimey, what happened to wanting to learn? Or are you one of those ( I came across one as a student myself) who thinks they are just buying a qualification and you can treat lecturers like shop assistants if they don't give you what you want and screw everyone else? Not that I would dream of being that rude to a shop assistant.

OnlyFannys · 29/11/2022 18:30

Fladdermus · 29/11/2022 17:21

If I were her I'd have to respond that I was very sorry that he felt he had to leave the university but I accept his decision and have notified the relevant departments that he is no longer a student. Preferably late on Friday so he can stew over the weekend.

But that's why I'm not allowed near any sort of service role.

"Byeeee Felicia"

PlaitBilledDuckyPuss · 29/11/2022 18:29

titchy · 29/11/2022 18:21

It is true though isn’t it? I know it’s not your fault at all and that’s a horrible way to email. But it is such a lot of money I don’t really blame people for feeling that they’re consumers and should be able to expect good service.

Why do you assume it's true? Have you seen all of Doha's materials? No, thought not. Hmm

Bearing in mind the anonymity of this forum, I think the poster can only have been referring to the principle of a service being worth what a person pays for it, rather than any specific tutor's course offering.

JenniferBarkley · 29/11/2022 18:29

They have purchased the opportunity to learn, and complaints about poor administration or conduct that's not in line with the uni's regs or the programme spec are fair enough.

They have not bought the right to a qualification or a particular mark. They have certainly not bought the right to speak to their lecturers like that, and an email with that tone would be against our guidelines for how we expect students to conduct themselves. A polite response that the bulk of the work was already completed likely would have been politely accepted. Or, as others have said, they would have been reminded that one of the aims of groupwork is to practice working with others and that in the real world teams can change.

ChristmasPickleRick · 29/11/2022 18:26

LindseyHoyleSpeaks · 29/11/2022 18:19

@JenniferBarkley @DohaDragon - Why is it the fault of your students that their course costs more to run than you charge? They have been sold a product for a price. You/your university need to deliver that product.

You’ll be the first one moaning when STEM degrees cost 30K in tuition fees, to reflect the actual cost.

surreygirl1987 · 29/11/2022 18:26

Whaaaaat?! That's awful! I would never take that sort of tone!

That said, if they really have done a lot of work already, he does have a right to be frustrated. Even more so if this contributes to a final degree grade. But there are other ways of dealing with this...

titchy · 29/11/2022 18:21

It is true though isn’t it? I know it’s not your fault at all and that’s a horrible way to email. But it is such a lot of money I don’t really blame people for feeling that they’re consumers and should be able to expect good service.

Why do you assume it's true? Have you seen all of Doha's materials? No, thought not. Hmm

LindseyHoyleSpeaks · 29/11/2022 18:19

@JenniferBarkley @DohaDragon - Why is it the fault of your students that their course costs more to run than you charge? They have been sold a product for a price. You/your university need to deliver that product.

winniesanderson · 29/11/2022 18:17

There's a couple of fellow students a bit like this on my postgrad course. It's distance learning so seminars etc online and its excruciating when they get going. I'm paying too, and it's to hear from my lecturer and my peers. To be able to just get on and do my work, not the constant pontificating and nitpicking about random elements of the universities procedures. If people aren't happy they have every right to politely raise this but not at the expense of others work/learning.

newnamethanks · 29/11/2022 18:16

ohhhhh, he's definitely minor management material and will spend his working life complaining he's constantly overlooked, his talent isn't appreciated, etc etc. He should invest a bit more of his cash in a 'people skills' course.

JenniferBarkley · 29/11/2022 18:14

DohaDragon · 29/11/2022 18:12

No I do agree but there’s better ways of wording it. Sadly universities haven’t changed anything regarding provision, staffing, service since tuition fees were introduced. Which is out of my control but I have to bear the brunt.

Though thankfully I could if I wanted to point out to my students that their course actually runs at a loss and costs more than 10k per student to run and they’re getting subsidised by the likes of the criminology students. I’ve never actually told a student that but I do think it sometimes. 😂

If I taught in a lab based subject I'd be reminding students of this every other sentence.

JenniferBarkley · 29/11/2022 18:12

Another lecturer who sees the odd email like this and is thoroughly unsurprised. Thankfully yet to receive one directly but it's just a matter of time.