Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To have the telly off when the sitter is here

62 replies

SherbettingSherbert · 29/11/2022 13:36

DD does nursery 2 mornings a week so I use the sitters.co.uk service on other days when I have a freelance project on (I'm self employed). Usually just 3 hrs at a time.

It's worked well and most sitters have been really great.
I try to be as considerate as possible, sitters are welcome to eat, drink whatever they see and I don't expect any nappy changes or meals to be made or given due to the time-slot. I'm in the house anyway and happy to take a quick break for that. DD is 2.5 and no longer naps.

She has books and toys (not a room-full, but enough) and we have a small garden with a little swing and slide if they want to get outdoors for a bit.

One thing I'm not so keen on is having the telly on. We're not against screen time and have used it but DD can get fixated so we're limiting even more now. DP and I don't have it on either unless were watching something specific in the evenings.

I don't want the sitters to get bored here so I mention they can stick it on if they need a break. It's not been a big problem and most don't at all or do for a little bit towards the end.

However, we've had a couple of sitters going straight for the telly option, on for almost 3 hrs of kids TV with DD mostly sat like a veg.

Admittedly it's only been a small number of times but I'd like to stop it happening again and take the TV option completely off the table.

So am wondering...

IABU: It's not fair to ask a sitter to be here for 3 hrs without the option

IANBU: They're there to look after DD and it's ok to expect their attention to be on her the whole time

Also, any suggestions for extra games or activities to provide so I'm not asking them to sit together in silence would be great. (silence and toddler hahahaha)
We have a little ipad and I would be happy for them to use it to stream music or the radio though.

(Apologies for the long post, I'm not always great at being concise!)

Thank you!

OP posts:
DragonWasp · 29/11/2022 22:39

Why wouldn't you expect them to change their nappy?

Can't you use a childminder instead? Or a regular one or two babysitters rather than a different sitter each time. It must be a bit unsettling for your child to be looked after by a different sitter each time.

CaptainMerica · 29/11/2022 22:30

YANBU, but this does seem like an odd childcare arrangement. Surely a regular childminder/nanny would be better and no more expensive? Then you would get more continuity, and they would get to know your child. Rather than a succession of random sitters?

No judgement though - I know how hard childcare can be to find. But if you have a choice of sitters, surely there must be a suitable nanny?

TheLostNights · 29/11/2022 22:30

Yes it's a long time to occupy a kid in one room which is often the case when the weather is bad.
As I said before, kids of that age have a very short attention span so very hard to keep them engaged in any particular activity. Looking after my friends 2 year old in a similar scenario was mindnumbing. All the activities and toys got about 5 minutes of his time and then that was it. Very tough.

Greatbiggoldfish · 29/11/2022 22:26

I think you are confusing childcare with babysitting .. sitters is for babysitters in my view

poefaced · 29/11/2022 22:21

As well as taking the remote away, unplug the TV.

Onnabugeisha · 29/11/2022 22:20

I think the “no nappy changes” is grim. Sitters should change a toddlers nappy when it is needed. I always did as a sitter. I’d scrap that right away. A minimum is surely that your child isn’t sitting in their own urine or poo for up to 3 hrs.

I think no TV is a fair rule. I’d add some activity toys they can do. Like toddler sized giant legos. Those big wooden jigsaw puzzles. Colouring books. Cars/trucks to push around with dolls for imaginative play. A play tent. Hand puppets.

waterrat · 29/11/2022 22:14

I tnink its a bit unreasonable expecting a young babysitter to occupy a child they dont know indoors for thst long tbh. I alwaýs found toddlers easier in the outside world

FirstnameSuesecondnamePerb · 29/11/2022 20:07

I think it's a question of expectations really. Only ever used sitters.co.uk for evening when my youngest was 7ish. I seem to remember it was expected that they would be kinda ready for bed etc. Although actually they were always very happy to play/read stories and chat etc.
I think you can probably work through who clicks with what you are after and just not have again those that don't.

Thighdentitycrisis · 29/11/2022 19:59

I’m not a fan of tv for kids but I’d be interested to test how long we actually spend entertaining/supervising a toddler non stop without going out for a walk, doing household stuff with toddler alongside us, e.g. just putting out this washing Dd, you can help me, etc

Im very old so in no way claim to have a fresh memory of caring for a toddler in their own home. However, I do remember once being asked to care for a child who didn’t know me, while their parent worked upstairs and it was pretty hard.

justdontkno1 · 29/11/2022 19:53

Yadnbu , we had the same . I am always v accommodating towards babysitters as we have three kids but usually when we got one when they were small, I timed it so the youngest would be napping, no nappy changes , the dcs would already be fed. It isn’t cheap per hr where we live either. I always said if they wanted or it was too much for them they could put on the tv for a little bit, this resulted in all of them sticking it on for hours, it pissed me off so much tbh….
I remember being their age and babysitting and I interacted with the kids and played with them, I wouldn’t have dreamt of sticking on the tv for the whole time as I got that the parents were paying me and that I should try and engage the kids. We gave up tbh and now kids are a bit older and we just swap over a lot.

Galliano · 29/11/2022 19:45

The site positions the childcare offered as a bit of an exceptional/occasional service. The hourly rates are very low and more babysitting remuneration than dedicated childcare professional rates so I wouldn’t be surprised with tv watching - I’d just expect the child to be kept safe if I booked through this. If I regularly needed childcare I’d make a more structured arrangement for care with a provider covered by the early years foundation curriculum.

Applefruitcake · 29/11/2022 19:28

No definitely not being unreasonable. I am an agency nanny (although no experience with sitters.co.uk) and I would always avoid TV for toddlers unless it's absolutely the last option e.g. they're being really fussy or I need to make food and can't safely leave them around me. This is more likely to happen over a longer period, but 3 hours is a very short amount for babysitting.

boymum9 · 29/11/2022 15:10

I'm 100% not against screen time in any way personally but if I'm paying someone to be there looking after my children I'd definitely not want them (the children) to be sat in front of it the whole time! (Or any of the time if they're only being watched for 3 hours)

Mariposista · 29/11/2022 14:55

3 hours is not a long time. They can survive without tv. There are a million things you can do with a toddler for that time besides tv.

ICanHideButICantRun · 29/11/2022 14:43

You should talk to Sitters about that. I used to work for them and they would take that really seriously.

Do they put on adult TV or children's TV when they arrive?

TheLostNights · 29/11/2022 14:42

I'm in 2 minds.
I looked after my friends 2 year old a while back and was so tedious trying to entertain him indoors. Kids that age have a very short attention span and don't always settle into activities.
I would allow it for a while maybe towards the end but I would also encourage the sitter to take the child out. So much better all round doing that.

Creameggs223 · 29/11/2022 14:40

Invest in a tuff tray and set up an activity on that before sitter arrives plenty of inspiration for them on Google.

TheOrigRights · 29/11/2022 14:38

I just had a quick look at their website. I wanted to see what service they advertise.
YANBU - it's clearly stated that it's day time childcare, NOT babysitting (which they do provide, but is a different service). They should all have at least 2 years' professional childcare experience.

If I wanted my toddler to watch TV for 3 hours I'd get a 6th former in and expect to pay a lot less.

Bookworm20 · 29/11/2022 14:37

Op, one thing I did find when mine were about that age actually was they didn't play with toys much that were around all the time. With the exception of a favourite toy, I used to seperate the toys/games/books into boxes and each week bring out a different box. So there were things they hadn't seen or played with for a couple weeks. It did really seem to get them then playing with stuff that otherwise had sat there for 2 months untouched and they didn't seem at all interested in. When they hadn't seen it for a couple weeks asuddenly they'd play with it for ages.

So maybe have some stuff put away, that isn't available to her all the time, that you bring out when you have a babysitter over. That way DD might be more engaged with the toys, and easier for the babysitter to keep her entertained for longer.

Bookworm20 · 29/11/2022 14:32

I think it would be reasonable to say you'd prefer no TV during those hours, but can be used if really necessary. As in, if DD is not feeling well and doesn't want to do lots of activities or is being particularly fussy and awkward and a half hour chill with a cartoon might be helpful.
Other than that, no, I'd expect a babysitter hired during the day to be doing things to keep DD occupied. Things even like just drawing pictures or helping her with a little jigsaw or something.

Just make sure there are some easy activity type toys available - jigsaws, felt pictures, colouring stuff, building blocks, play food, stuff like that.
Though I remember mine at 2.5 were mostly interested more in trying to help me with stuff! It can be hard to keep them entertained all the time at that age. Just be firm the TV is an absolute backup option (for DD) and you'll likely find most would then only use it as such.

Pastashapes123 · 29/11/2022 14:31

Tv is fine - at the end of the day when the child is tired and the carer needs to prepare a meal or whatever . Paid childcare in the day should be stimulating . I’d leave out play dough , jigsaws and picture books and only suggest tv if DC happens to be tired like after recovering from a cold or if they’ve had a mega busy morning swimming or something.
Ive only ever had childcare settings use tv at kicking out / handover time to keep them quiet and busy so that they could chat to parents and make sure everyone went home with the right shoes on .

SherbettingSherbert · 29/11/2022 14:31

Great, I feel a bit better about it now. Wasn’t sure if I was being too harsh.

It’s the sitters.co.uk service and most seem to be experienced childcarers making extra cash. They’re insured, qualified and experienced (mostly).

Taking DD for a walk is a fair suggestion for sitters we’ve had before and DD knows but I don’t feel comfortable with new sitters taking her out as she’s having a bit of a phase of being a runner when out and even DP and I struggle to contain her sometimes (slowly improving thankfully!).

I really need to make the most of the 3hrs and can’t spend too much of that time prepping someone else to take her out.

Like I said we do have a small garden and DD likes going out there so that’s always an option.

I like the suggestions to just put the control away and mention what DD likes to do.

Thanks all!

OP posts:
Yayyayitsaholiholiday · 29/11/2022 14:24

You can request for specific people not to come again. Request the ones you like (favourite them on the site) they will be the ones offered the jobs with you.

helpfulperson · 29/11/2022 14:20

It depends if they are childcare or a babysitter.

NuffSaidSam · 29/11/2022 14:20

Are they allowed to take DD out?

If not, I'd probably allow a bit of TV towards the end of the 3 hour slot if they need it. I think it's quite a long time to entertain a child you don't know in a house you don't know.

It's different if you're a regular nanny and you're there all the time, but if they're doing one-off sessions I think it's quite hard!

Swipe left for the next trending thread