Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

My Mother's Christmas Meltdown

758 replies

Venetiaparties · 29/11/2022 10:51

Oh god, wise ones on MN, I really need some advice.

I have been NC with my Dad for a year (and on and off for many years before that) due to childhood abuse and his treatment of my children (17,15 and 12) and the fact he isn't very nice to any of us when we used to visit. We just see my mum on her own now.

I was under the impression my parents were going to my sister's house for Christmas this year, but she has now accepted an invitation with family in Scotland and won't be here. She said she will be back to see them Boxing Day evening.

We booked to see some friends overseas, partially because I was finding the idea of spending Christmas with my Dad really stressful.

My mother has had the most epic meltdown this morning about spending the whole of Christmas on their own. She won't be seeing any family at all until boxing day evening. We leave on the 21st and get back on the 28th currently.

I am wracked with guilt at the idea she is going to be alone with my grumpy and miserable Dad for the whole of Christmas without any of us, he isn't especially nice to her either and I know she is going to be sobbing on Christmas morning and I am going to feel dreadful.

What on earth do I do?

There is no way dm would come with us (already suggested) and leave him here.
There is no way my sister can take them, there is no room in the car as it is, nor space when they get there.

I feel cornered, and I am tempted to cancel our trip and try and see them, I don't know how I will manage with my Dad, the thought gives me serious anxiety but for my mum's sake should I be changing our plans?

OP posts:
MrsSkylerWhite · 29/11/2022 12:47

She’s an adult, mentally capable?
In which case, she made the decision to stay with a man who abused her child, she knew that came with consequences and she must live with them.
This isn’t on you (or your sister). Frankly, I’d have nothing to do with her, either. What kind of mother stays with a man who abused her child?

katmarie · 29/11/2022 12:47

You said yourself the messaging around Christmas and family is painful for you, it doesn't take a trained psychotherapist to suggest that this is one of the times where you are forced to face the fact that your family life just wasn't like that and was so far removed from it, that it's had a lifelong impact on you. And the messages are everywhere, you can't escape them. That has to hurt, and while the rest of the year the messaging we see about family life is a lot more muted, over Christmas there is an expectation of family life being perfect and happy and all that. Of course we all know that no one's family life is really like in the adverts, but for someone like you, who had such a great deal of mixed up emotions over your family, your parents, your own experiences, and wanting to protect your children and give them what you didn't have, then it's bound to be messy and painful. Your mum is adding to that by laying her upset on you, effectively giving you her distress to hold as well as your own.

I think you're right that getting through this year and sticking to your boundaries will make future years easier. And I also think your response to your sister is spot on, she's under no obligation to have them every year, and she shouldn't feel guilt that on the years she doesn't, they will be on their own. Just beware that she may be in a different place to you, and might try and manipulate you to act to alleviate guilt that she might be feeling on that. Again, not your burden to carry.

A previous poster said that you are going to feel guilt and pain over Christmas, and I think she is right. But I think it's important to know that those feelings are just feelings. Accept they are there, sit with them a bit of you feel you can, acknowledge they exist. But don't let them own you. You might benefit from therapy, cbt perhaps, or something called acceptance and commitment therapy, to help you manage how you're feeling.

And in the meantime, don't try too hard to hide that it's tough for you. I get putting on a brave face for the kids, and there's a limot to what young people need to know. But lean on the adults in your life who do love you and care for you. Let them support you when you feel crap.

toomuchlaundry · 29/11/2022 12:47

NC = no contact @KAYMACK

LiesDoNotBecomeUs · 29/11/2022 12:47

This year is for you and for your family.
It is perfectly reasonable for you to go ahead and dedicate it to yourselves.

Separating yourself from your parents is always going to be difficult. You have been managed to see yourself as bound to them beyond the ways required of any daughter.

Your mother has chosen to stay with your father (this Christmas but also throughout your childhood... just think about whether you would stay with someone who did those things to your children). It was lovely of you to give her an option to go with you. Her choice to stay does not obligate you in any way.

It is loving of you to stay in touch with her over the years -despite her failure to protect and parent you in the past. However, you are not responsible for your mother's happiness.

You are responsible for the happiness/well-being of your children and perhaps also your DH.

Sparkletastic · 29/11/2022 12:47

KAYMACK this isn't the thread for you to get the hang of Mumsnet on.

cakeycakes · 29/11/2022 12:46

Venetiaparties · 29/11/2022 12:33

Okay so Christmas for me as a young child would mean for one day a year we would try and be a normal, happy 'family' without anyone being hurt.

It was an amnesty of sorts with everyone doing their best to keep things 'nice' and it was like balancing on the most fragile eggshells, doing our level best to avoid a detonation.

Dad would try and be a Dad, and put toys together and watch us open presents. He would at least try.
So it came to mean everything to me, because the rest of the year he was either hitting me, berating me or not at home. The 'not at home' was the best option by far. But for that one day a year at Christmas I could have the fairytale. I could be a loved daughter and someone that mattered. It usually didn't last beyond late morning, and we would be lucky to get to Christmas lunch before he would start to scream and shout or worse, or throw toys at my head or make me cower and we would sometimes choke back our tears forcing down Christmas lunch with noddy holder in the background, and watch my mother work her way steadily through the wine, before she would blow with anger and drunkenness. The evening was sometimes spent holding her hair by the toilet as she vomited, and rubbing her back for hours whilst she cried that it was another year ruined. It was the one day there was actual hope.

So over the years Christmas became this delicate, fragile construct of hope. A day that I always hoped and prayed there might be love and kindness. For one day I could pretend I was loved and it was all okay.

That is why Christmas means too much to me. Even now.
And there is still flickers of the same hope, that it will one day come good.
I know it won't. But there it is.

Like many others on this thread, I'm speaking from experience, which is why I want to try and pick apart this:

'dad would try and be a dad.'

No, OP. NO.

He made a conscious, proactive choice to behave a certain way, and he did it IN ORDER TO CONVINCE YOU THINGS WERE GOING TO BE ALRIGHT SO HE COULD BLOW IT UP IN YOUR FACE LATER. I have been there and done that and got that t-shirt. Our christmases were similarly awful. It would be fine in the morning, and just as you relaxed and thought yes, we're going to have a good day, he'd turn on us. We hadn't appreciated our presents well enough. We hadn't given him good enough presents. We'd pulled a slight face when he'd started eating the sweets we'd been given. We were ungrateful shits who were ruining his life, and he couldn't even have a good christmas because of it.

The christmas morning 'trying to be a dad' was just as manipulative as everything else. It wasn't him being a good dad. It wasn't him trying. It was a trick. It was a lie. Abusers keep victims in place by giving them breadcrumbs of hope. It's a method of control. And it's still working, even now, because a part of you is terrified of what will happen if you don't go at christmas, and so you're dangerously close to telling yourself that maybe it is OK to go, because it might be OK this time, despite all evidence to the contrary, and because a painful christmas is routine and familiar and a hard habit to break. That's why your OH wants to be abroad, because he can see what's coming.

But you can have a perfect family christmas. It's in reach. You can build your own from scratch with the family you made for yourself, your children.

Pashazade · 29/11/2022 12:46

Stick to your guns OP and on Xmas Day give your phone to DH. Good luck.

KAYMACK · 29/11/2022 12:45

Venetiaparties · 29/11/2022 10:51

Oh god, wise ones on MN, I really need some advice.

I have been NC with my Dad for a year (and on and off for many years before that) due to childhood abuse and his treatment of my children (17,15 and 12) and the fact he isn't very nice to any of us when we used to visit. We just see my mum on her own now.

I was under the impression my parents were going to my sister's house for Christmas this year, but she has now accepted an invitation with family in Scotland and won't be here. She said she will be back to see them Boxing Day evening.

We booked to see some friends overseas, partially because I was finding the idea of spending Christmas with my Dad really stressful.

My mother has had the most epic meltdown this morning about spending the whole of Christmas on their own. She won't be seeing any family at all until boxing day evening. We leave on the 21st and get back on the 28th currently.

I am wracked with guilt at the idea she is going to be alone with my grumpy and miserable Dad for the whole of Christmas without any of us, he isn't especially nice to her either and I know she is going to be sobbing on Christmas morning and I am going to feel dreadful.

What on earth do I do?

There is no way dm would come with us (already suggested) and leave him here.
There is no way my sister can take them, there is no room in the car as it is, nor space when they get there.

I feel cornered, and I am tempted to cancel our trip and try and see them, I don't know how I will manage with my Dad, the thought gives me serious anxiety but for my mum's sake should I be changing our plans?

Also, is NC - non-contactable? non-communicative? or something more sinister?

Thanks in advance.

I find the abbreviations pretty confusing, as they break up the narrative.

HotWashCycle · 29/11/2022 12:45

Your last post is so heartbreaking OP. The dream of a perfect Christmas that never can be (with your parents at least). Don't even let her come away with you this year. She sounds toxic in her own right. Go with DH and DC and have a lovely time far away. Don't even stay in contact via phone. She has chosen to stay with your DF and plenty of people have Christmas alone with their other half. Their choice. If she does not like it she can volunteer to give Christmas lunch at a homeless charity. You will have the best Christmas ever without the usual stresses, doing it your way with your own lovely family.

toomuchlaundry · 29/11/2022 12:44

DM = dear mother

Merlott · 29/11/2022 12:44

OP that update has made me cry.

OP you do not need to save your mother. It was wrong of her to put that burden on you in the first place. You were a child. You were their prisoner. You were powerless and you needed protection and she wasn't there for you.

Have you ever had talking therapy?

It would be helpful to dig down deep enough to get angry at your mother for what she did. She is just as guilty as F because she was an adult, she stood by and watched it all happen and did not protect you. She still isn't protecting you now, given the earlier update about playing the video while she goes and tidies and pretends it's not happening.

She is an abuser too. She does not deserve your concern or your kindness.

I am so sorry. Please continue breaking free and leave FOO to their own horrible mess, you deserve a wonderful life free of it all.

KAYMACK · 29/11/2022 12:44

Venetiaparties · 29/11/2022 10:51

Oh god, wise ones on MN, I really need some advice.

I have been NC with my Dad for a year (and on and off for many years before that) due to childhood abuse and his treatment of my children (17,15 and 12) and the fact he isn't very nice to any of us when we used to visit. We just see my mum on her own now.

I was under the impression my parents were going to my sister's house for Christmas this year, but she has now accepted an invitation with family in Scotland and won't be here. She said she will be back to see them Boxing Day evening.

We booked to see some friends overseas, partially because I was finding the idea of spending Christmas with my Dad really stressful.

My mother has had the most epic meltdown this morning about spending the whole of Christmas on their own. She won't be seeing any family at all until boxing day evening. We leave on the 21st and get back on the 28th currently.

I am wracked with guilt at the idea she is going to be alone with my grumpy and miserable Dad for the whole of Christmas without any of us, he isn't especially nice to her either and I know she is going to be sobbing on Christmas morning and I am going to feel dreadful.

What on earth do I do?

There is no way dm would come with us (already suggested) and leave him here.
There is no way my sister can take them, there is no room in the car as it is, nor space when they get there.

I feel cornered, and I am tempted to cancel our trip and try and see them, I don't know how I will manage with my Dad, the thought gives me serious anxiety but for my mum's sake should I be changing our plans?

"There is no way dm would come with us"

I am lost at this part.

Can someone interpret "dm" for me?

Thanks.

Usernameisunavailable · 29/11/2022 12:43

Typo - feelings of guilt not failings of guilt! You are not failing in any way, you are doing the best you can!

ChristmasPickleRick · 29/11/2022 12:43

Do not change your plans. Do not fuck up your children’s Christmas for your mother, who is a grown adult and could have left her arse husband by now.

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 29/11/2022 12:43

Your update is really heartbreaking OP. I’m so sorry

Dutch1e · 29/11/2022 12:43

Venetiaparties · 29/11/2022 11:36

Can I be completely frank.

What happened to me as a child shouldn't happen to anyone, and I have so far managed to give my dc a very different life.

That said I can't get past my guilt for leaving my mother, and it is her choice to stay, with such a bully. It is very very hard to leave her there knowing what he is like.
So whilst I will move heaven and earth to break the cycle and I have managed really well, Christmas with all of the fuzzy adverts and happy families really really hurts like hell and it is very testing. Because I still want to make this okay for my mum. Despite her not protecting us as dc, and still not being able to do so now.

That does not mean I am going. Or will not put my dc first.

It means for me this is really painful and a hard and difficult decision to make.

I think you're doing brilliantly. Drifting away from awful family members and their enablers is a much longer process than people realise. There's rarely a dramatic single moment like in films is there... just a series of sad and bleak steps, some of them backwards.

You're doing the right thing and I wish I could say something to help ease the hurt but I can't. It just feels shit. It will feel good and right eventually, but this is a tough Christmas and my heart goes out to you.

2bazookas · 29/11/2022 12:42

You don't have to do anything. Your mother is a grown adult and perfectly capable of making her own alternative plans.

She could whizz off alone.
She could visit a friend
She could spend xmas volunteering at a shelter , making xmas for people worse off than herself.
Or she could be one of the charity recipients at the local shelter xmas lunch.

None of that is your problem or your responsibility. Being the daughter of a drama queen is a warning not to follow in her footsteps.

toomuchlaundry · 29/11/2022 12:42

Does your DM have any other family, siblings she can see/go to over Christmas?

I don't know how your sister can bear to be with them. I know you say he treats her DC better as they are boys, but I assume he isn't particularly pleasant to your mum and sister when they are there.

I am so sorry your parents treated you like this. You should not have had to stay with your parents

Venetiaparties · 29/11/2022 12:41

billy1966 · 29/11/2022 12:29

I remember your shocking posts of earlier this year, your childrens distress at witnessing this.

You poor woman.

You are still in the grips of his abuse and your family are too.

Are you in therapy?
You need to be.

If you were posting about your husband I would be suggesting you leave him and take your children with you to get away from his abusive father, and protect your children.

I mean this very very kindly, but you bringing your children to your fathers house to witness his behaviour, is abusing your children IMO.

So what if you have some vision of how you want Christmas to look like, that doesn't give you the right to drag your children into the home of a toxic poisonous man to witness him abusing you.

You are very wrong.

You were wrong last year, you are wrong this year.

Your husband needs to protect his children from your family and YOU too, if you consider putting your children in this position EVER AGAIN.

He is trying to do that by booking holidays.

I feel very sorry for him.

I feel very sorry for you too, and I don't mean to be harsh, but you cannot be allowed to abuse your children because of Fear Obligation Guilt to your abusive parents.

Your husband is correct.
This is the consequence of staying witj an abusive man.

You cannot be allowed to sacrifice your children again at the alter of your poisonous father and his toxic marriage.

Please seek help asap so that you can see this.

Your MH does not trump your childrens well being.

Your mothers trumped yours and look how damaged that has left you.

Please seek help so that your childrens future is not impacted any more than it is.

I really wish you strength and bravery.

Yes I remember your wonderful posts and how supportive they are. I am working on it! Believe me, I am working on it. I accept entirely what you are saying. By putting my mother first, I am allowing my own children to be abused. This is hard to swallow, but totally true. Which is why we won't be going. Thank you for posting. I think I needed to hear all of these replies to find the resolve I was looking for.

OP posts:
Usernameisunavailable · 29/11/2022 12:41

Your DH is right. Other posters are right. No way should you cancel your plans, especially as you have given your DM the option to join you. It’s just ONE day of the year. She is with him the other 364 days or the year, so how different is Christmas Day really, except for the hype? Sounds like if you cave in and have Christmas with your abusive DF you’ll ruin the whole day for yourself, your DH and your children. Try to put aside your failings of guilt over your DM or you’ll feel even worse for spoiling it for your family and giving your DF continued power over you.

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 29/11/2022 12:41

She has chosen to stay with him. She has chosen not to protect anyone else from his abusive behaviour.

You can’t then put her feeling above your own when she’s the only one who can change the situation.

nonevernotever · 29/11/2022 12:40

I remember your post last year. Please please please do not buckle this year. As you've said, if you get through this one it will get easier.

speakout · 29/11/2022 12:40

RampantIvy · 29/11/2022 12:36

I know I need to put my own children first. And I have been doing so for many years.

You also need to put yourself first.

It means for me this is really painful and a hard and difficult decision to make.

Everyone else who has posted on this thread has the clarity of being distant from the emotional involvement here, and the obvious answer is do not be guilt tripped into having another miserable Christmas. It isn’t fair on you and it isn’t fair on your DC. If you can’t do it for yourself then do it for your children.

As an aside why didn’t your DH challenge your dad when he played these videos? My husband would have gone apeshit and wouldn’t have cared how much he upset the perpetrator.

Don’t let your father win this one, and repeat this to yourself if you feel yourself wavering.

RampantIvy
I know I need to put my own children first. And I have been doing so for many years.
You also need to put yourself first.

I agree. OP you need to come first. Remember the analogy of oxygen masks on a plane- whose mask needs to go on first? The mother or the child?

Paq · 29/11/2022 12:40

I think I remember your earlier threads. You don't owe your parents the Christmas of their choice. Look after yourself and your family Flowers

DysmalRadius · 29/11/2022 12:38

Your mum has the option of seeing you for Christmas and SHE is choosing not to.

The fact that your father is awful may seem like the crux of the matter, but it's actually not necessarily the issue. You've got a classic MN Christmas dilemma:

Your mum wants one thing
Everyone else in the family wants other things
You have offered your mum a compromise
She has turned that down and is holding out for her preference despite knowing that doesn't work for you or your family

The details and reasons are different, but this scenario plays out in families all over the world.