Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

My Mother's Christmas Meltdown

758 replies

Venetiaparties · 29/11/2022 10:51

Oh god, wise ones on MN, I really need some advice.

I have been NC with my Dad for a year (and on and off for many years before that) due to childhood abuse and his treatment of my children (17,15 and 12) and the fact he isn't very nice to any of us when we used to visit. We just see my mum on her own now.

I was under the impression my parents were going to my sister's house for Christmas this year, but she has now accepted an invitation with family in Scotland and won't be here. She said she will be back to see them Boxing Day evening.

We booked to see some friends overseas, partially because I was finding the idea of spending Christmas with my Dad really stressful.

My mother has had the most epic meltdown this morning about spending the whole of Christmas on their own. She won't be seeing any family at all until boxing day evening. We leave on the 21st and get back on the 28th currently.

I am wracked with guilt at the idea she is going to be alone with my grumpy and miserable Dad for the whole of Christmas without any of us, he isn't especially nice to her either and I know she is going to be sobbing on Christmas morning and I am going to feel dreadful.

What on earth do I do?

There is no way dm would come with us (already suggested) and leave him here.
There is no way my sister can take them, there is no room in the car as it is, nor space when they get there.

I feel cornered, and I am tempted to cancel our trip and try and see them, I don't know how I will manage with my Dad, the thought gives me serious anxiety but for my mum's sake should I be changing our plans?

OP posts:
BrightYellowDaffodil · 29/11/2022 14:07

I don't think I can totally look at what she has done if I am honest. I am not ignoring the posts talking about her part in this, only suggesting that if I do I might see something unseeable. Unbearable.

A good therapist can help you unpack this carefully and in a safe and right way. It is very hard to come to terms with, let alone accept the knowledge of what someone has done to us - someone from whom we had every right to expect protection and love - but it can be done.

rookiemere · 29/11/2022 14:07

I remember your posts from last year and I think the most saddening part for me was your DM walking away and leaving you and your DCs to it. Her own DD and DGCs.

Your DH sounds wonderful, stay strong for your DCs.

Venetiaparties · 29/11/2022 14:06

upfucked · 29/11/2022 13:38

Have you tried speaking to your sister to see how she manages it? Maybe she isn’t managing it as well as you might think or maybe she has some tips.

My sister says every kid was beaten when we were young, and every family had a tyrant for a father. Our lives were not exceptional and at least he paid the bills (I know her standards are not so high!) and he didn't leave us (So wish he had) and she forgives him because she doesn't need to hold grudges.

She does say that it was worse for me, as the older child he saw me as being able to withstand more, she was slighter and small for her age. I also would protect her by hiding her behind the bed or under the quilt and tell her to lie dead still. We could hear his running footsteps on the stairs so we had seconds before he would burst in. He also found her more compliant and like my mother. I was always the 'difficult' one.

One day I picked up a heavy brass lamp and hit him with it as he attacked me as young teenager. I don't know what made me do it. I was scared he would kill me and I acted instinctively. I already had scars on my face from the last beating, and I did not want another one. Vanity perhaps! He never touched me again, but unleashed a different kind of cruelty after that. One that has been harder to bear in some ways. Harder to prove, and harder to stop.

OP posts:
whumpthereitis · 29/11/2022 14:05

Venetiaparties · 29/11/2022 13:57

I think if I sat down and really thought about everything my mother has done or enabled I would get so angry, so livid that I might never ever be able to put the anger away again.

She would often direct my father to the room I was in the rampage and carry on cooking.

I don't think I can totally look at what she has done if I am honest.
I am not ignoring the posts talking about her part in this, only suggesting that if I do I might see something unseeable. Unbearable.

The problem is that you do know, and you’re not actually faced away from it, and nor are you in denial. You’re turned towards it already, looking around it but not meeting it’s proverbial eyes. It’s right there, and it’s not going away. You’re not avoiding damage by not looking at it eye to eye, all you’re doing it changing the way in which it is inflicted.

As difficult as it may be to truly face it, is it actually going to be less difficult than what you’re experiencing now?

AcrossthePond55 · 29/11/2022 14:05

I remember your previous post about the video. It made me sick to think that someone could be that, well, inhuman to their own child.

As far as your mum, you need to remember that she willingly put her children between herself and her abusive husband. By refusing to leave, by refusing to defend her children she made you all her 'shield' because she knew if she'd raised hell his anger would have been turned on her. And I'm sorry, her MH 'fragility' does not absolve her from doing this.

You, on the other hand, have chosen to put yourself between your abusive father and your own children. You've chosen to protect them (and yourself) from further torment and abuse. This is what someone does who loves their children more than themselves.

Your mother is responsible for her own hell. She chose it when she didn't leave when you were children, and she is choosing to stay in it. This is NOT your responsibility. No one expects someone to rush into a burning house or a busy motorway to rescue someone who is willingly standing in the middle of it refusing to walk to safety. I know how hard it is to leave an abusive relationship, I've been there. But it can be done. I know because I did it.

You are right to put yourself and your family first. You are right not to pander to this abusive bastard. You have offered your mother an alternative and her answer is to want to drag you back into an abusive situation. Again, putting herself and what she wants ahead of what she knows is best for you. Don't let her do this.

I do agree with your sister that she shouldn't have to host them every year. But that doesn't mean you have to alternate years. It just means that every other year your mother will be given the same choice, come to us by yourself or stay at home. And your sister needs to respect that.

JustCakeInDrag · 29/11/2022 14:05

It is a good plan to put your phone away on Christmas Day. Remember to do the same with DH and the DC’s phones if your parents have their contact details. They will try to contact you and ruin you day from afar by some means or another, possibly via your sister. Send your ‘merry Christmas’ messages on Christmas Eve and give the phones to DH to put away. Block numbers if necessary.

LazyDaisy22 · 29/11/2022 14:00

Lots of good advice here and I’ve nothing new to add except to wish you, your husband and children a very happy Christmas. Your DH and DC are your family and you will be with them for Christmas, where you are safe and loved.

BrightYellowDaffodil · 29/11/2022 14:00

I don't need to 'fix' my mum's Christmas by throwing myself and my children under my father's bus (again) dm is old enough to organise something special if she wants to. There are plenty of things happening where they live and she could book something. But she won't because she would rather be the aggrieved victim that has been 'left' on her own at Christmas, she WILL have a god awful Christmas because she believes that will teach us a lesson for leaving her.

All of how your DM behaves - ALL of it - is her choice. She knows enough about how the behaviour to which you've been exposed impacts you (to the point of apologising for it) and she knows that the behaviour to which you continue to be exposed by your father is wrong. And she chooses not to do anything about it.

She knows she has choices in terms of where she spends her Christmas and even whether or not to stay in her marriage. And she chooses not to change anything.

Like an addict, you can't change anything for them unless they are prepared to change themselves. You can only stop yourself being dragged down with them.

I hope you have a peaceful and happy Christmas with your DH and children. You absolutely deserve it Flowers

clairelip · 29/11/2022 13:59

FuckoffeeBeforeCoffee · 29/11/2022 11:03

You need to put your children first.

Why is her Christmas more important to you than theirs?

Exactly this, your mother allowed you to be abused by your horrible farther, don't do the same to your children

Venetiaparties · 29/11/2022 13:59

whumpthereitis · 29/11/2022 13:57

You’re well versed in justifying her actions, but understanding why someone has acted as they does not mean that they’re not accountable for said actions. Your father can undoubtedly provide ‘reasons’ for acting the way he does, but does that negate his own abuses? Or the impact they have had? No.

She was, and is, a grown woman with agency. The fact that she was mistreated by your father does not mean she is above reproach for her own mistreatment of you. And she did mistreat you, in fact she still mistreats you AND now your children as well.

she has enough agency to take you to task for what she considers to be a slight, so she absolutely is capable of it. She knows exactly what buttons to press with you in order to manipulate you into feeling and acting the way she wants you to. She knows which ones to press because she’s the one that installed them. She has power, but she uses it against you.

I know. I can't really face it. It is very difficult to look at her part in this.

OP posts:
ChristmasDecisions · 29/11/2022 13:58

OP your dad is a horrific abuser and you need to maintain NC. You know your priority needs to be your DC. You have offered your mum help and she doesn't want it. Maybe she never will. But she is your parent and not your responsibility. You didn't ask to be bought into that situation. You say she apologised but actions speak louder than words and she has made none.

She cries that she won't see family? Offer for her to come on holiday with you. She cried and says she can't leave your dad? You tell her she absolutely can but she is choosing not to. If she doesn't see you it's because she has chosen not to.

If you see her when you get back say she has to come to you and maintain you are and will always be NC with your dad going forward. She or your sister claim it isn't fair? You tell them what isn't fair is that you were horrifically abused as a child and you will be protecting yourself and your children. You don't want to need to apologise to your children the way she has had to apologise to you. Reiterate that if she wishes to leave him your offer of help is still there. If she chooses to stay she will continue to lose contact witj those that love her due to his behaviour.

He is still abusing you. He is abusing you through your contact with your mum. You know he is waiting for you to cave because of how upset she is. He knows he can use and manipulate her to get what he wants. As long as you're in contact with her and she is with him you will be abused. You may not be willing to cut contact with her, but that is the truth.

Gerwurtztraminer · 29/11/2022 13:57

@Venetiaparties Your last post is fantastic, please do as you have written and go on your holiday with lovely supportive DH and teen DD's and turn your phone off on Christmas Day. If you feel yourself wobbling come back and read your posts again. Stay stong.

And yes, get that therapy so you can unpick those complicated feelings about DM. You are starting to see she is not just a victim in her relationship with your father, but it will take time to work through that.

Venetiaparties · 29/11/2022 13:57

I think if I sat down and really thought about everything my mother has done or enabled I would get so angry, so livid that I might never ever be able to put the anger away again.

She would often direct my father to the room I was in the rampage and carry on cooking.

I don't think I can totally look at what she has done if I am honest.
I am not ignoring the posts talking about her part in this, only suggesting that if I do I might see something unseeable. Unbearable.

OP posts:
whumpthereitis · 29/11/2022 13:57

Venetiaparties · 29/11/2022 13:23

If anyone on here is in any doubt about what it means to stay with a man like this, then take a look at my mum. She is a broken shell of a person, with one friend left as the others have disappeared, even the best ones (they couldn't stand my father) and now she has nothing but him and his cruelty. She is prevented from seeing her dc and gc because they have to keep themselves safe. So the true cost of staying, is enormous and still growing. I wish I could put it on national TV every week.

The reality is that women in this situation stand to lose absolutely everything eventually, even themselves.

I had to put that out there, for all my pain and difficulty I do have a healthy and happy life most of the year, which is not fraught with danger, anger and violence. I can walk away. At least I can.
For me it is a choice.
Some people staying with men like this, it gets much worse as they age. And it becomes harder and harder to walk away or they simply can't due to ill health.

Leaving is always the best thing, and in the long run you stand the best chance of preserving other important relationships.

You’re well versed in justifying her actions, but understanding why someone has acted as they does not mean that they’re not accountable for said actions. Your father can undoubtedly provide ‘reasons’ for acting the way he does, but does that negate his own abuses? Or the impact they have had? No.

She was, and is, a grown woman with agency. The fact that she was mistreated by your father does not mean she is above reproach for her own mistreatment of you. And she did mistreat you, in fact she still mistreats you AND now your children as well.

she has enough agency to take you to task for what she considers to be a slight, so she absolutely is capable of it. She knows exactly what buttons to press with you in order to manipulate you into feeling and acting the way she wants you to. She knows which ones to press because she’s the one that installed them. She has power, but she uses it against you.

FictionalCharacter · 29/11/2022 13:56

Venetiaparties · 29/11/2022 11:00

My dh says this is sadly the consequences of staying with an abusive man, and that we can't possibly put our kids through a Christmas with my Dad due to my FOG. It is not fair and I am being played.

But my poor mum is also a victim of both domestic violence when we were younger and now she is older coercive control. She is no way going to leave him, I have tried for decades.

Your DH is absolutely right, and you are not responsible for your mother’s poor choices.

Soakitup37 · 29/11/2022 13:54

Venetiaparties · 29/11/2022 13:23

If anyone on here is in any doubt about what it means to stay with a man like this, then take a look at my mum. She is a broken shell of a person, with one friend left as the others have disappeared, even the best ones (they couldn't stand my father) and now she has nothing but him and his cruelty. She is prevented from seeing her dc and gc because they have to keep themselves safe. So the true cost of staying, is enormous and still growing. I wish I could put it on national TV every week.

The reality is that women in this situation stand to lose absolutely everything eventually, even themselves.

I had to put that out there, for all my pain and difficulty I do have a healthy and happy life most of the year, which is not fraught with danger, anger and violence. I can walk away. At least I can.
For me it is a choice.
Some people staying with men like this, it gets much worse as they age. And it becomes harder and harder to walk away or they simply can't due to ill health.

Leaving is always the best thing, and in the long run you stand the best chance of preserving other important relationships.

“At least you can leave, you have a choice”

well so does your mother, she chooses to stay, chooses to lose friends and family. I’m not saying it clear cut as that but she has made her choice.

she cannot go off on one about this knowing full well why nobody wants to be around him. Again these are choices. You are fully entitled to make your own. Your children will notice the effects of the circumstances regardless of how you try and protect them, even if your mother doesn’t talk about your father in front of them that’s going to be a red flag, I remember your post from Christmas last year and I thought it was awfully sad, he’s still being an abuser and your mother is still turning a blind eye. It’s frankly disgusting at this point that your mother still doesn’t have your back, but still wants you to drop Your plans so she’s not “alone” - every circumstance you bend to her needs shes enabled to stay with him, something has to give if she’s going to ever get away from him, and that is mostly likely to be the risk of losing contact with you and the grandchildren.

its an awful situation but I don’t have sympathy for your mother given the amount of chances she would have had over the years to make amends and she CHOOSES not to. That to me speaks volumes.

ifIwerenotanandroid · 29/11/2022 13:54

Good for you, OP. Well done for making plans to have a happy time with your own family.🎄

Stravaig · 29/11/2022 13:52

That sounds like a very fine and healthy plan, OP!

birder · 29/11/2022 13:50

He waited until your DH wasn't there OP, taking the dog for a walk? I found it a hard read. Never, ever see this monster again. Your mother has/had choices.

Venetiaparties · 29/11/2022 13:50

I wanted to say how sorry I am to those that are living with this, and this time of year can be so hard and tests even the strongest resolve. I have come to dread this time of year, and the pressure it brings and I will know real progress when August comes and goes and I am not worrying about how I will avoid my dad.

I do feel so much better and brighter, and like a weight has been lifted since I started this thread. So many supportive and kind messages that have made me cry at my desk. I needed to it all, even the posts that are hard to read. You are such lovely people - thank you

I don't need to 'fix' my mum's Christmas by throwing myself and my children under my father's bus (again) dm is old enough to organise something special if she wants to. There are plenty of things happening where they live and she could book something.
But she won't because she would rather be the aggrieved victim that has been 'left' on her own at Christmas, she WILL have a god awful Christmas because she believes that will teach us a lesson for leaving her. So I am not calling her on Christmas morning. I will send a cheery voice note and turn off my phone. So I don't allow them to wreck my children's day with hysterics which are guaranteed to come on the day.

I am going to have a pain free day or as close as I can get, and that will be my present this year, and a revisit to my therapist in the new year. I know my mum has some responsibility for this, and I am pretty sure she knows she is being manipulative by calling and sobbing down the phone earlier. It is all part of the same pattern.

I am not doing this anymore.

OP posts:
Franklyfrost · 29/11/2022 13:50

I’m sorry it’s so difficult for you. Christmas adverts are designed to make you feel inadequate so forget that idea.

Take the time to imagine what a realistic and special Christmas is for you. Consider what your partner and your kids would like most. And then prioritise that vision.

Parenting your mother sounds like a deep habit. Could you reframe it as: if your mother is incapable of looking after herself and her children then she’s the last person who should be deciding what’s best for you and your children.

123sunshine · 29/11/2022 13:49

She's not by herself she is with your father. Some pople are actually by themself. Enjoy your Christmas and don't give it a second thought, you've made plans and your family unit is looking forward to them. You can never make everyone happy. It hideous the pressure people are put under at Christmas by family etc.

JustLyra · 29/11/2022 13:49

I think I need more therapy !!

This is seriously worth considering @Venetiaparties

I went back to therapy when I realised I’d hit a point (after I’d become a parent myself) where I was actually more angry with my mother than my father.

My father was an obviously evil scumbag who was abusive and just vile. My mother’s part in it (we were used as a deflection shield by her) only really hit me hard when I looked at my own children and thought “how could you use your own children to protect yourself like that?”

FetchezLaVache · 29/11/2022 13:48

Your mother is a massive womanchild, OP. She should have protected you when you were a child, but she didn't - that was her choice.

You too have a choice as a mother - put your children first or subject them to this monster of a grandfather, simply because of your DM's poor choices.

(I know that's a very simplistic view of things from an outsider, but your DH is an insider and I see he agrees with everyone on this thread, so bloody well done for ending the cycle of abuse by marrying a decent man.)

LiesDoNotBecomeUs · 29/11/2022 13:48

OP I wonder if even though she is your mother, you do not see the relationship she really has with your father except from outside. It looks all suffering for her from where you stand but what if it is not? There are some posts above where women in her situation turn out not to be helplessly trapped. There is choice and the relationship is something they are part of.

You are reading your mother's feelings as being what yours would be in her shoes... but she is not you and her feelings are not just like yours.

You suffer on her behalf -knowing how you would feel under his control and suffering his cruelties. You forgive her for not protecting you from him.

You are not her though and you don't share her feelings for him.
You didn't stay and you are activly protecting your children.

(If you feel any doubt about going away for Christmas keep in mind that even when you stayed, your mother wasn't happy... and you became seriously ill due to staying. You can't save everyone! )

Swipe left for the next trending thread