Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Be honest: Do you think single and childfree people are less than?

528 replies

Sonervousimgonnathrowup · 29/11/2022 10:13

I am that person.
It suits me.
But fucking hell do I get comments, questions and often it seems like I’m treated like a second-class citizen.

Do people still today look down on single / childfree people?

OP posts:
Spottedslug · 30/11/2022 11:11

Passthecheeseboard · 30/11/2022 00:57

Yes definitely, society does view women as less worth if they are not mothers or don’t have the potential to be a mother.

The discrimination is everywhere but overt, it can be the look of judgment you get when someone asks if you have children and you say no. It can be nosey and presumptuous follow up questions ‘do you want children?’ ‘When are you going to have children then?’.

It can be the assumption that your spare time is less valuable if you’re not parenting a child, expectation to do overtime at work, work late (while mothers with children can leave early, a woman at my work usually leaves 3 hours before the end of the shift, leaving the rest of the team short staffed at the busiest time due to ‘child care issues’ ). It can be the pressure to work Christmas because you don’t have children (presuming I don’t have children so obviously I don’t want to spend time with my family during Christmas), it can be not being able to take annual leave in the school holiday’s because that’s the time parents should take priority. I can think of many more examples. I’m guessing everyone here saying this doesn’t happen are all mothers and generally have no idea how it feels on the other side of the fence…

Mothers get lots of attention for reproducing, gender reveals, baby showers, celebrations at birth. Showered with gifts at each event. And yes it’s nice to be a part of those celebrations but just don’t forget your childfree friend’s birthday when it comes around (and how generous they were at your celebrations) …

Women who are childfree are definitely treated as less worthy, and are frequently discriminated against in both professional and social situations. I actually think it’s quite a sexist attitude… You don’t see men without children being treated differently or judged for being childfree.

Yup. 100%. not to mention the differences in employers attitudes when taking maternity leave as opposed to asking for a sabbatical. The one and only time I asked for an unpaid sabbatical I was almost laughed out of the office for the audacity of my request - how very dare I to think I could leave the business for a year's holiday and then waltz back in!!! This, after years of witnessing my colleagues go off on maternity leave numerous times! Some timed it so they'd come back, do a few months as required before calculating when they could go off again on maternity! It's absurd and unless you're the other side of the fence, you'll never see how unfair and unjust the system can be to childfree folk.

fairydustt · 30/11/2022 11:02

GrannyWeatherwaxsHatpin · 29/11/2022 10:22

Nope. I'm single and childfree (by choice) and my life isn't less than that of others, it's just different.

Can we play the Childfree Thread drinking game?

  • Sips for anyone who says "Well, yes I do because [insert tedious reason here]";
  • Gulps for "You don't know love until you've had a child; and
  • Drink everything in the house for "Why are childfree people on MUMSnet?"

Don't forget that child free people can never feel tiredness either. We can't feel love or tiredness, we are essentially robots

LynLynette · 30/11/2022 10:20

Mothers get lots of attention for reproducing, gender reveals, baby showers, celebrations at birth. Showered with gifts at each event. And yes it’s nice to be a part of those celebrations but just don’t forget your childfree friend’s birthday when it comes around (and how generous they were at your celebrations

I didn’t have any of those things. My sister got married a few days before my due date and everyone was so wrapped up in that I barely got a look in. She also had her wedding on my birthday so that pretty much got bypassed that year as well. It’s only some people that do all that kind of stuff, not everyone does.
Plus if you only see the party, gifts and stuff it looks great but what I found was lots of people were very nice to me - even complete strangers - offering me a seat on bus, asking me when I was due, telling me I was glowing, getting me a cup of tea etc, but other people (including nurses in the hospital) were horrible, making out like I was being precious if I ever said I was tired, telling me to get on with it, a few men I knew who used to be really nice to me started blanking me, people started rumours about me.
Once these men that were working on the grounds outside my apartment building left a load of equipment on the path, I shouted over to them to ask if they could move it, they shouted back just step over it, I said I’m nearly 9 months pregnant and one them shouted What do you want a fucking medal?
Also, once you have the baby (for me anyway) the attention immediately switches to them, people don’t give a shit how you are and instead of getting offered a cup of tea, you end up making it for everyone else while they pass the baby round.
Everybody expected me to be out of bed, dressed and ready to bounce back and go out to meet them for coffee right away and when I said I was sore or tired or whatever it was all eye rolls and sneers.
I don’t think anyone in my family has actually listened to a word I’ve said since dd was born 3 years ago. It’s like I’m a shadow. I hate being the centre of attention normally and even I find it demoralising.
And people are only really interested when babies are newborns. Lots of family members lose interest after that or once someone else has a baby in the family. Then you’re just another slightly haggard mother with a screaming teething baby getting dirty looks in the doctors office and unsolicited advice on how to settle them down coming from every direction.
Some women may get a lot of positive attention for reproducing, I didn’t find it that way and it’s certainly balanced out with negatives.

ConnieSaks · 30/11/2022 10:10

I envy you!

Heartonmysleevee · 30/11/2022 10:00

Imobsessedwithsuccesion · 30/11/2022 09:41

I'm single and childfree by choice and have definitely had the pity. I have no idea why as I am the plenty of holidays and social stuff cliche that lots of single and childfree folk don't like either {grin}

My life works great for me. I am always suspicious of all the folk saying 'I envy you' on these threads though. If it was so good, why did you give it up?!

Some of us have always known we want kids and others changed their mind at 40 and decided to have kids. Then others just always knew they didn't want them.

There's many reasons it's quite easy for most to get pregnant you hear it all the time "it was just the once" or an accident. You can't send them back once they are here can you?

DameHelena · 30/11/2022 09:57

hattie43 · 30/11/2022 09:54

No I wouldn't . Being single and child free is the most stress free way to live . Other than financial constraints you have total ability to live your life as you wish with no compromises

Grin Grin 'no compromises' 'stress free'
So no one without kids has work/family/friends/illness/general life shit.
Like as if.

antelopevalley · 30/11/2022 09:57

Spottedslug · 29/11/2022 23:14

If this is aimed at me, well I think it's bloody difficult if you are both a parent on top of other caring responsibilitie s, in the same way it's hard going to be childfree with a long term health condition and caring for a sick relative! life can be tough for a lot of people, with or without children .My objection to the pp was her assertion that childfree women had greater earning power without considering any other variables! childfree women are not a homogenous group

Although I agree, in a family with more than 1 adult child, it is generally the daughter who is childfree who takes on the bulk of the caring. I have seen this time and time again. And those not caring underestimate how much time it actually takes.

hattie43 · 30/11/2022 09:54

No I wouldn't . Being single and child free is the most stress free way to live . Other than financial constraints you have total ability to live your life as you wish with no compromises

Imobsessedwithsuccesion · 30/11/2022 09:41

I'm single and childfree by choice and have definitely had the pity. I have no idea why as I am the plenty of holidays and social stuff cliche that lots of single and childfree folk don't like either {grin}

My life works great for me. I am always suspicious of all the folk saying 'I envy you' on these threads though. If it was so good, why did you give it up?!

Sceptre86 · 30/11/2022 05:34

No, I don't. I have kids but I do recognise that people can live a very happy, fulfilled life without. Dh's friend and colleague is 43, no kids, getting married and is happy. I don't know her well enough to know if she has wanted kids, never found anyone she wanted them with before, or if she has tried and it hasn't happened for her and it's none of my business. She's lovely whenever I meet her, shows a genuine interest in our kids and is an interesting, good person.

My mum is different though. She thinks many women who don't have kids to be 'selfish' the career before family types in her words. I've challenged this view several times and explained that other women are not less than just because they chose to make different choices to her. She always knew she wanted kids but it's OK that other people have always known that they don't. People are entitled to their opinions but we also have a right to challenge them and I frequently do tell her. She doesn't understand because it's alien to her.

willsonwanda · 30/11/2022 05:25

no i think they are smart

garlictwist · 30/11/2022 05:22

I don't have kids and am 40 now so at an age where a lot of people do.

I don't feel looked down on but I do think society/advertising/the general way things are set up and spoken about assumes that you are in a family (whatever that looks like) and I do feel a bit "outside" of that.

There is little recognition for how difficult it is financially for a single adult, for example, no help, no rail cards, no representation in the media.

Single women are usually shown as young and hot and having lots of wild dalliances.

HappinessAlley · 30/11/2022 04:49

I don't know if people look down on childless people, but since becoming a parent, I've noticed I'm treated differently by the general public. I never noticed it before, but it does feel a bit like joining a club where you're more accepted.

Tandora · 30/11/2022 04:42

Tandora · 30/11/2022 04:41

@ExhaustedFlamingo I've known a few woman in their 50s/60s/70s who are childless and they all have a unique selfishness, despite being very lovely people

😮😮. I Cannot just believe what I just read- what an awful / prejudiced / judgemental thing to say 😨. It’s so upsetting that people hold these views. And complete bollox. In my experience having kids (especially when said kids are small) can people incredibly selfish. (I say this as a person with small kids). People can become incredibly entitled and assume that the world revolves around their children. It’s generally a phase and most people get over it.

Also , is it just childless “women” you find so “uniquely selfish”? How misogynistic 🤮

*can make people incredibly selfish.

Tandora · 30/11/2022 04:41

@ExhaustedFlamingo I've known a few woman in their 50s/60s/70s who are childless and they all have a unique selfishness, despite being very lovely people

😮😮. I Cannot just believe what I just read- what an awful / prejudiced / judgemental thing to say 😨. It’s so upsetting that people hold these views. And complete bollox. In my experience having kids (especially when said kids are small) can people incredibly selfish. (I say this as a person with small kids). People can become incredibly entitled and assume that the world revolves around their children. It’s generally a phase and most people get over it.

Also , is it just childless “women” you find so “uniquely selfish”? How misogynistic 🤮

Passthecheeseboard · 30/11/2022 00:57

Yes definitely, society does view women as less worth if they are not mothers or don’t have the potential to be a mother.

The discrimination is everywhere but overt, it can be the look of judgment you get when someone asks if you have children and you say no. It can be nosey and presumptuous follow up questions ‘do you want children?’ ‘When are you going to have children then?’.

It can be the assumption that your spare time is less valuable if you’re not parenting a child, expectation to do overtime at work, work late (while mothers with children can leave early, a woman at my work usually leaves 3 hours before the end of the shift, leaving the rest of the team short staffed at the busiest time due to ‘child care issues’ ). It can be the pressure to work Christmas because you don’t have children (presuming I don’t have children so obviously I don’t want to spend time with my family during Christmas), it can be not being able to take annual leave in the school holiday’s because that’s the time parents should take priority. I can think of many more examples. I’m guessing everyone here saying this doesn’t happen are all mothers and generally have no idea how it feels on the other side of the fence…

Mothers get lots of attention for reproducing, gender reveals, baby showers, celebrations at birth. Showered with gifts at each event. And yes it’s nice to be a part of those celebrations but just don’t forget your childfree friend’s birthday when it comes around (and how generous they were at your celebrations) …

Women who are childfree are definitely treated as less worthy, and are frequently discriminated against in both professional and social situations. I actually think it’s quite a sexist attitude… You don’t see men without children being treated differently or judged for being childfree.

Gronkle · 29/11/2022 23:33

Definitely not, my sister is 60 and childfree, she has a great life. She's interesting, fun and kind, I adore her.

ipreferthecat · 29/11/2022 23:29

@Norriscolesbag

You sound utterly ghastly I suspect many people find you irritating and smug

Spottedslug · 29/11/2022 23:14

Goldenbear · 29/11/2022 22:59

That argument doesn't work though and it is always used to suggest all sorts of people have caring duties. How about if you are struggling to earn more due to childcare 'and' hours committed to looking after an elderly parent?

If this is aimed at me, well I think it's bloody difficult if you are both a parent on top of other caring responsibilitie s, in the same way it's hard going to be childfree with a long term health condition and caring for a sick relative! life can be tough for a lot of people, with or without children .My objection to the pp was her assertion that childfree women had greater earning power without considering any other variables! childfree women are not a homogenous group

Usethesausageasabreakwater · 29/11/2022 23:13

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Heartonmysleevee · 29/11/2022 23:08

Spottedslug · 29/11/2022 22:54

Right I give up at this point. I'm not inferring that you are against the childfree at all. What is getting lost in translation, is that just because a woman doesn't have a child does not necessarily and as a given ,mean that they have it easier. Our struggles just look different to yours. You have problems with earning more due to childcare etc, whereas I may have a similar problem because I'm caring for a parent . What I do agree on, is that it shouldn't be a race to the bottom. But this judgemental take on how you think the "other half" live won't help that

Yes you need to give it up. People with kids have parents too. Or do you think it's only the childless that might incur elderly sick parents?

I'm not been goady either.

Goldenbear · 29/11/2022 23:03

Again, I just don't think there is an air of mystery to the childfree, obviously this depends on your context but at early 40's my DH and I know loads of people in that category, my DH has a 39 yearsold colleague that has only just moved out of his parents' home. I mean where we live it is not some sort of curiosity.

Goldenbear · 29/11/2022 22:59

That argument doesn't work though and it is always used to suggest all sorts of people have caring duties. How about if you are struggling to earn more due to childcare 'and' hours committed to looking after an elderly parent?

Balletandbooks · 29/11/2022 22:59

Ooh I am single and childfree too! I think we attract curiosity, pity by those who are happy in their relationships and with their children, and envy from those who are not.

I just feel alone a lot of the time so it’s lovely to connect with other single childfree women :-)

Spottedslug · 29/11/2022 22:54

Lookout3 · 29/11/2022 22:40

@Spottedslug you lost my attention when you started talking about luxury life. After that I just zoned out tbh. Because that's not what I was saying about single childless people.

But some of these points and not just yours are like a race to the bottom. Well I have 2 kids to pay for and you only have 1 for example, the CMS debates on here can get nasty too.

I think you can't fathom because I don't agree with you and OP that you feel I'm against the childless.

Right I give up at this point. I'm not inferring that you are against the childfree at all. What is getting lost in translation, is that just because a woman doesn't have a child does not necessarily and as a given ,mean that they have it easier. Our struggles just look different to yours. You have problems with earning more due to childcare etc, whereas I may have a similar problem because I'm caring for a parent . What I do agree on, is that it shouldn't be a race to the bottom. But this judgemental take on how you think the "other half" live won't help that