Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Be honest: Do you think single and childfree people are less than?

528 replies

Sonervousimgonnathrowup · 29/11/2022 10:13

I am that person.
It suits me.
But fucking hell do I get comments, questions and often it seems like I’m treated like a second-class citizen.

Do people still today look down on single / childfree people?

OP posts:
Crumpleton · 29/11/2022 14:57

Until I read your post it isn't something that I ever think about even when out with child free friends.
It's as much a person's choice to not want to have children as it is a person's choice to have them.

AuntieAunt · 29/11/2022 14:56

I think this is really interesting and in a hundred years this mindset (hopefully) will be gone. I do think this mindset currently differs between what social circles you’re in. I’m in my late twenties and nobody in my core friendship groups have started having kids yet (but we’re all skint either trying to get onto the property ladder/just got our first mortgages/still working on careers etc). We’re all getting pressure from grandparents/parents but I think it’s only our singletons in my circle take offence to these comments as I did before I was in a LTR.

My neighbours are in their late 40s without kids. They have a great relationship, lots of holidays/hobbies, really in love with each other, really lovely people and madly in love with their dog. I have wondered if they’re childless by choice or if it was infertility just because I hope they’ve not gone through the pain of infertility as they’re such lovely people.

Why I find this mindset most interesting is because there’s quite a lot of adults who shouldn’t have kids. I know people who hate kids and go on to have kids just because it’s the done thing. While they love their kids (I’ve never heard someone say they don’t love their kids but that’s because that’s pretty socially unacceptable) they don’t particularly like them. I have a lot of respect for adults who are honest enough and have thought about having kids and decide it’s not for them.

I have a family member (I lived with her for quite a few months so I know the behind the scenes) who hates kids, had kids because she didn’t want to miss out/regret not having them so found the first guy who would go along with it and is now a pretty shitty mum just meeting the basic needs of the kids. She had a great life beforehand, top career, loved travelling and very materialistic. She honestly hates spending time with her kids, she’s never baked/cooked/arts and crafts with them, she’s never played a game with them, she only goes on holiday once a year now but never with the kids (she needs a break apparently), she works away quite a few nights of the week and has one day to herself at the weekend to unwind. She hates that the kids are messy (kids can’t colour in the house incase it damages the furniture), she hates that she doesn’t get a moment peace, she hates the company of children, she hates how she doesn’t live her normal life as the kids are expensive. I was pretty shocked when I found out that she was planning on having a baby but everyone said it would be the making of her. Her life beforehand wasn’t selfish, she worked and played hard.

I don’t particularly like dogs, I know a lot of people who love having dogs and understand the pros. I know even if I wanted a dog I don’t have the lifestyle for a dog nor want to give up my lifestyle to be a responsible dog owner. I could possibly hire a dog Walker during the day and I’d probably meet the minimum requirements to require a dog. Overtime I’d probably fall in love with the dog and I know sometimes I’d enjoy walking it. I have a happy life and like my current lifestyle therefore I don’t feel the need to get a dog. But most importantly I don’t want one and I’d probably not be the greatest dog owner in the world as I don’t really like them.

I never judge people who are childfree. I judge people who choose to have kids who wouldn’t even meet the minimum requirements to rescue a dog. Children aren’t therapy tools nor accessories.

Hopefully sooner than later it will become the social norm for people to be childfree. Society would greatly improve for starters. Same for people who are in unhappy relationships just because they think it’s better than being single.

just remember OP, everyone is judged in this world, some for not having kids, some for having too many kids, some for not having careers, some for being young, some for being too old, some for not being financially independent… if you’re happy so should everyone around you.

SallyWD · 29/11/2022 14:56

No! No way! Much as I love my DH and family sometimes u really envy single, child free people. Really there are so many ways to be happy in life. Marriage and kids isn't the be all and end all and it isn't for everyone.

psychomath · 29/11/2022 14:52

To be honest I don't have a problem with the 'no love like it' stuff because I think it's probably true (for the most part, there are some tragic exceptions ofc) - if I did have a child I'd probably love them more and in a deeper way than I've ever loved anyone before, because that seems to be how biology works for most people. But on balance, I don't think that would make up for the downsides of having children, for me - one of which would be the constant anxiety of loving someone so fiercely and yet not being able to guarantee that they'd always be safe and have a good life. I don't feel like I'm missing out because, as a PP said, I've never experienced it, so I may as well continue living my comparatively lower stress life.

Where it grates on me is when people phrase it along the lines of 'you don't know real love until you've had a child'. It always makes me think so what, if my partner or best friend or relative dies or something then it doesn't matter because I didn't really love them?

Also, whoever said they assume no child dreams of being completely alone when they grow up, I did! I fully intended to be some kind of forest witch living in the middle of nowhere, performing rituals involving toadstools and talking to birds or something Grin Probably not the most common childhood fantasy but I don't think it's completely unheard of. I don't remember any of my friends at primary school talking about how they wanted to get married and have babies, although we'd play 'house' sometimes because children tend to copy the adults around them.

Goldenbear · 29/11/2022 14:48

I work with lots of people and honestly only know three people that I categorically know have DC. There must be more but they don't bring it up.

VladmirsPoutine · 29/11/2022 14:44

@antelopevalley - No. I just don't talk about my personal life like that. Although having said that, the ones who do have kids will often say something like over the weekend they took their kids etc to a party, football, whatever which I guess I've never said. And it's sometimes obvious because they've said they're leaving early to pick up their kids so I can see how it comes out.

Badnewsoracle · 29/11/2022 14:38

I don't understand why anyone would feel like that.

Goldenbear · 29/11/2022 14:37

But if having children is being delayed then it is not particularly unusual to come across child free people in their 30s so It is contextual but as above,the judgement is not really abound! In our circles we found judgement the other way as my DH is 40 and we have a 15 year old, in the Architect world he works in, he has been asked loads about that especially as he is at director level. It is not the 'done' thing. When I became pregnant with my first I was asked by my boss, 'why?' And that was in 2007!

antelopevalley · 29/11/2022 14:36

I have sadly known people who appear to love their dog more than their children.

whumpthereitis · 29/11/2022 14:32

Googlecanthelpme · 29/11/2022 14:12

No I dont think any lifestyles are better / worse.

I think it’s a difficult one because the only people to have experienced having children are those who have had them and once you’ve had them, you’re in the opposite camp. People without kids do not experience both.

example - when people without kids talk about loving their pets like children I just think well yes, I thought that too. But then I had kids and realised it was an entirely different level. Looking after dogs is not the same as looking after a child. But some people without kids will believe it is (I know a few of my friends certainly believe so and I did also equate them at one point).

Ultimately we can’t know if our life choices were right for us until we’re at the end of our lives, what served us at 30/40/50 might not turn out to be the path we should have taken. And that includes people who have kids too because plenty of people regret them (loving your kids but disliking being a parent is very common).

But this is the problem with thinking experiences are universal. You have experienced both, but you can only compare with yourself. A different level for you is just that - for you.

It may very well be your friend’s reality that they love their pet in the same way you love your child, but neither one of you will truly know because you’ll never actually experience each other’s emotions.

antelopevalley · 29/11/2022 14:32

@VladmirsPoutine do your work colleagues really not know if you have kids or not! I find that extraordinary.

antelopevalley · 29/11/2022 14:30

Googlecanthelpme · 29/11/2022 14:12

No I dont think any lifestyles are better / worse.

I think it’s a difficult one because the only people to have experienced having children are those who have had them and once you’ve had them, you’re in the opposite camp. People without kids do not experience both.

example - when people without kids talk about loving their pets like children I just think well yes, I thought that too. But then I had kids and realised it was an entirely different level. Looking after dogs is not the same as looking after a child. But some people without kids will believe it is (I know a few of my friends certainly believe so and I did also equate them at one point).

Ultimately we can’t know if our life choices were right for us until we’re at the end of our lives, what served us at 30/40/50 might not turn out to be the path we should have taken. And that includes people who have kids too because plenty of people regret them (loving your kids but disliking being a parent is very common).

Of course looking after kids is not the same as looking after pets. But it is still about love and caring for another being and I think that is what people mean about pets.

I don't think if you have children you do know what being childfree is like. Everyone is childfree at some point in their lives. But life changes as you get older whether you have children or not.

The women I know who treat pets like babies are those with grown up kids. They also tend to be the women who most loved being a mother and are replacing a void.

Ted27 · 29/11/2022 14:29

@AntsGoMarchingOneByOne

I’ve rarely seen anything quite so patronising and judgemental.

Perhaps you would like to tell us more about your free from failure perfect life where nothing has ever gone wrong?

VladmirsPoutine · 29/11/2022 14:28

I'm not sure if I've ever been on the receiving end of this attitude because my colleagues etc just don't have this information about me. Who is all this judgement coming from? How do they know your child/less status?

KimberleyClark · 29/11/2022 14:23

I think it’s a difficult one because the only people to have experienced having children are those who have had them and once you’ve had them, you’re in the opposite camp. People without kids do not experience both.

Life before children is not the same as life without children.

DameHelena · 29/11/2022 14:19

Alaldlccmemsjzja · 29/11/2022 13:57

its so strange when people are like “gosh I wish I had the lie ins, holidays and boozy lunches”

like people work and have families and stuff too? It’s not like you just laze about all day, eating grapes

I know, baffling, isn't it? And the boring old trope that if you don't have kids you automatically have loads of disposable income.
Not when you and your DP are both self-employed in the arts! He doesn't even clear minimum wage and I'm not much better off.

DuchessofSandwich · 29/11/2022 14:14

I do think that age is a factor too, people treated me fine when I was in my twenties but childless late thirties I was definately treated differently (by some people, but it adds up to how it feels).

Googlecanthelpme · 29/11/2022 14:12

No I dont think any lifestyles are better / worse.

I think it’s a difficult one because the only people to have experienced having children are those who have had them and once you’ve had them, you’re in the opposite camp. People without kids do not experience both.

example - when people without kids talk about loving their pets like children I just think well yes, I thought that too. But then I had kids and realised it was an entirely different level. Looking after dogs is not the same as looking after a child. But some people without kids will believe it is (I know a few of my friends certainly believe so and I did also equate them at one point).

Ultimately we can’t know if our life choices were right for us until we’re at the end of our lives, what served us at 30/40/50 might not turn out to be the path we should have taken. And that includes people who have kids too because plenty of people regret them (loving your kids but disliking being a parent is very common).

DuchessofSandwich · 29/11/2022 14:12

EBearhug · 29/11/2022 10:24

Yes. The world is set up for couples and families. You're not quite safe enough for dinner parties etc. No one says it, but it's how things are.

My taxes are also paying for schools etc, so I am contributing to society, but you don't have to spend long out there before it's clear you're not quite good enough on your own.

I agree with this. I didn't have a child until I was 41 and I often felt that I lived outside of society or something like that. Now that I have a child there are plenty of people (other parents) that treat me as equal/ "you know how it is"/ smile on the street in passing. I'm now one of them apparantly.... I'm still the same person....

thejadefish · 29/11/2022 14:11

I got this a lot when single too. I'd hoped that society had moved on 😕

GloomyDarkness · 29/11/2022 14:05

Goldenbear · 29/11/2022 13:52

No because you are not really a minority and with the baby bust will continue to be part of an increasing number of people that are childfree. I l live I Brighton where the birth rate has fallen 27.2 % since 2010. They will have to a close a school eventually as there won't be enough children to fill the places, my DD's infant school won their fight to remain open for now but the choice you talk about is going to be so common place that 'childfree' around here is not going to be something people can't understand. I actually think DC are less toolerated because of it. My teenagers and his friends from example don't really have anywhere to go, things like the council leisure centre are astronomical. The cinemas are aimed at child free trendy couples around here. When I was a teenager in the 90s it was a cheap activity as was bowling, ice skating etc. Now these pursuits are all the domain of young adults.

www.ons.gov.uk/peoplepopulationandcommunity/birthsdeathsandmarriages/conceptionandfertilityrates/bulletins/childbearingforwomenbornindifferentyearsenglandandwales/2020#:~:text=The%20percentage%20of%20women%20who,rather%20than%20not%20having%20children.

According to ONS there been a fairly consistent18 - 20% of women since 1950s who at end of childbearing years ( they take 45 I think) who don't have children.

Of course that could increase with time - but does show it's not a new phenomenon or rare - 1 in 5 women not having children at all and been pretty close to that last 7 decades.

Most of the decline in fertility rates - here it is 1.49 - is due to smaller family sizes and many on here are equally opinionated about only children or more than two children.

Penguinsaregreat · 29/11/2022 14:04

No I absolutely do not.
I do judge those who keep having children with different partners when they are not in a stable relationship and not financially able to support their children.
Childless people, no it’s not my business. Neither is it my business if someone is single. I have single friends and understand completely why they stay single.

MrsDanversGlidesAgain · 29/11/2022 14:03

Since you asked for an honest opinion:
I won't say it to their face or make comments to them, but I do pity single and childless people over 40.
To me it means that something went wrong in their lives. They couldn't build a relationship with anyone, or maybe they are infertile, or something happened (e.g. their partner died).

Well here's my honest opinion. I pity someone who is so narrow minded and unimaginative that they can't even begin to think that someone might have chosen not to have children as a positive choice they made rather than something that was forced on them by circumstance.

ScotlandEuropa · 29/11/2022 14:00

No I truly do not care

antelopevalley · 29/11/2022 13:59

@Goldenbear what does that mean? Do you just mean your children are more important to you than any job you have had or any social life?