Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Adult Step Daughter Advice

111 replies

lemonmeranguepie · 29/11/2022 10:13

My adult step daughter is 32. Her Dad and I have been married for 14 years (he had long since been divorced from her Mum) my Step daughter doesn't have a particularly close relationship with her Mother, but amicable . I've just felt from day 1 that she doesn't like me. I've tried (without overly trying) to be friends/nice etc. I thought it would be lovely if we got along- shopping trips/Spa days etc, but nothing. I get absolutely nothing. A cold shoulder. The bare minimum. She has a daughter and kindly allowed for me to be called Nana, which I really appreciated, but it's just weird to me that I'm Nana to a beautiful little girl, yet I have zero relationship with the Mother.
Even down to silly trivial things like FB. She will like or comment on every family members post except mine, or last year's Christmas card said 'to Grandad and Nannie' (I've never heard it said that way around - seemed a passive aggressive way of making DH appear more important) I'm good with my grandchild I think and love seeing her, buying little gifts etc, I just wish she and I had a closer relationship.

I have spoken to my DH, I think he sees it too and feels sad but is helpless to it all. As she's doing nothing overtly obviously it's hard to address and tbh I don't want any issues caused.
She rarely visits and only lives very locally to us. We visit her, but the conversation is always forced and uncomfortable. If he leaves the room she turns stony silent (DH has also noticed) yet when she calls him daily I hear her chattering away. Its obviously me, but I haven't done anything that I'm aware of. I'm fun and friendly and good with my Grandchild. Maybe it's just something I can't do anything about, it's sad really.

Anyone have any experiences?

OP posts:
LosingTheWill2022 · 29/11/2022 13:29

Would it help to liken into an 'in-law' relationship?
I have 2 brothers and have known their wives for decades. I am aware that some people have a close family like relationship with their siblings' spouses but many don't.

I get on with my sils but would never think to have days out just me and them (singly or together).
I am very happy to see them at family occasions etc and I care about them, but it's a relationship that exists purely because my dbs chose to marry them. Just like a step relationship.

Aprilx · 29/11/2022 13:16

winterywonder · 29/11/2022 13:02

Thankyou, I think you're right. Hopefully I will have a lovely relationship with my grandchild throughout future years, but I'll just concentrate on that.

I am not saying this to be mean, but she is not your grandchild, I am only saying that because if your relationship breaks down you are not going to see that child again. I think with the whole Nannie / Grandad think and wanting spa days, you are maybe not really appreciating the different relationships.

MrsSkylerWhite · 29/11/2022 13:06

We can’t all like everyone. She’s polite and civil in person?

fwiw, if anyone invited me to spa days/shopping trips I’d say no, would be my idea of hell on earth, whoever was inviting me and however much I liked them. May just not be her idea of fun.

winterywonder · 29/11/2022 13:02

cookiesbeforepookies · 29/11/2022 12:52

I see you're getting all the usual anti-stepmother posts OP.

I don't know why people are assuming you are asking for advice on how to force a closer relationship, it sounds to me like you're asking for advice on how to accept that your step-daughter wants a distant relationship.

My own advice would be to stop trying with DSD, just be friendly when you see her but stop the texts etc. Continue to focus on your lovely DSGD. You may find that when you stop trying, DD will come round.

Thankyou, I think you're right. Hopefully I will have a lovely relationship with my grandchild throughout future years, but I'll just concentrate on that.

cookiesbeforepookies · 29/11/2022 12:52

I see you're getting all the usual anti-stepmother posts OP.

I don't know why people are assuming you are asking for advice on how to force a closer relationship, it sounds to me like you're asking for advice on how to accept that your step-daughter wants a distant relationship.

My own advice would be to stop trying with DSD, just be friendly when you see her but stop the texts etc. Continue to focus on your lovely DSGD. You may find that when you stop trying, DD will come round.

Newwardrobe · 29/11/2022 12:46

I agree with a pp , you came into her life when she was a young adult, so you have never had the role of caregiver or stepmother, you just happen to be married to her dad.
You need to give up the hope that things will be any different to how they are .

PeekAtYou · 29/11/2022 12:42

I think that you need to find a way to accept that she only wants to be on polite terms with you. It's a shame that she doesn't want to be as friendly as you'd hoped but trying to change things could end up with you being in a worse situation. I suspect that you've done nothing wrong and she'd be like this with any woman that your dh picked as his wife.
FWIW I think it's fine that she says Grandad and Grannie since your h is her dad.

Catflapping · 29/11/2022 12:36

You don’t get to decide what your relationship
is with her. She was already an adult when you married. My Dad remarried when I was 19 and I wouldn’t even call her my step-mum, she’s my dads new wife, to me it would be weird to call her my step mum when we had no mother daughter relationship? We get on perfectly well, probably more so than you and your husbands daughter, she pops in for cups of tea and we enjoy days out with my dad, my children in tow. But it would be odd for me to go on shopping or spa days with her, any attempt to force these would have just made me pull further away. All cards are addressed to Dad and her name. I think you are over thinking it and should enjoy the relationship you have with your grandchild.

pjani · 29/11/2022 12:31

I think it’s because it’s wishing for something when the facts show it’s just not going to happen.

Like wishing for a pony when you’re a kid, or to meet your favourite pop star. It wouldn’t be immature to wish for that before you met her the first time, it would be hopeful.

But now it’s been years and you’re still wishing and feeling hurt when - you just can’t afford the pony. It’s about meeting the reality of the situation.

winterywonder · 29/11/2022 12:26

ThreeblackCats · 29/11/2022 10:55

You can’t force your adult sc to become your best friend. My adult sd doesn’t even talk to me! In fact she actively makes a point of ignoring me on the very rare occasions we are in the same room.
(Her dad was widowed and I was not the ow) so consider yourself lucky that you have any sort of relationship with her.
I doubt she will ever put your name first on Christmas cards etc, as her dad is obviously much more important to her.
You seem to have a very romantic view of what being a stepmum is, shopping and spa days, really? Are you very much younger than her dad?
sorry op, but in the kindest way, you sound immature.

Why is hoping for a nice friendship immature? I thought it would be nice if we could do things together occasionally and have a friendly relationship. My DH also wishes it was mire this way, but obviously you can't force these things. I find the immature comment a bit strange, as surely its the opposite.

Aprilx · 29/11/2022 12:14

If you hadn’t have made that comment about Grandad and Nannie, I would have maybe thought she was being unnecessarily cold to you. But honestly, I would absolutely expect Grandad to come first because he is her grandad!

We don’t have children but my FIL is a grandad through his other son, I don’t believe the grandchildren call his second wife Nannie or anything, I believe they use her name.

I think overall you need to accept that this is the relationship you have and it isn’t going to change now.

SleeplessInEngland · 29/11/2022 12:05

I say this constructively: she's just not that into you, get over it. It's ok not to be best buds with your step children, especially adult ones. If it's cordial, then fine.

charabang · 29/11/2022 12:03

It's likely in your SD's eyes that your role is Dad's GF or wife. She has a mum of her own. I think she is accepting of you if she is allowing you to be called Nannie and that's great. Don't force a relationship that isn't there.

KIW · 29/11/2022 11:53

You have answered your own dilemma.

“maybe it’s something I can’t do anything about”

Acceptance is best in this situation.

FatimaHatima · 29/11/2022 11:50

winterywonder · 29/11/2022 10:24

I do appreciate that sounds picky, I guess I just notice these little things more because she feels cold toward me. I've not mentioned the card thing to anyone, it's just something I noticed and not a big issue in itself

It's not an issue at all though, its totally normal and expected!

She isn't obligated to be your friend. You're just the woman her father married, you're not her family unless she wants you to be.

Shinyandnew1 · 29/11/2022 11:39

I’m confused, has @lemonmeranguepie changed names to @winterywonder ??

ast year's Christmas card said 'to Grandad and Nannie' (I've never heard it said that way around - seemed a passive aggressive way of making DH appear more important

This really undermines anything in your post as it’s bizarre and makes people question everything else. Of course her dad is ‘more important’ to her!?

When writing cards, I would always tend to write them to the person I know most written first, eg To uncle Dave and Auntie Sue if he’s always been my uncle but they’ve not long been married, but to Karen and Pete-if she’s my friend from school and he’s her husband. That’s just what she’s done.

Soontobe60 · 29/11/2022 11:33

The thing is, she may just not like you. It is possible to be civil to someone without having ‘spa days’ and putting their name first in a card!
If you’re friendly enough then thats OK. You can’t force her to like you.

Pebbledashery · 29/11/2022 11:27

The Grandad and Nannie thing is really clutching at straws. I'm sorry OP, you're really fabricating issues out of nothing. I appreciate you may feel hurt not to have a close relationship with her. But as long as she's civil to you, accepts you being with her father and hasn't actually caused you any issues, then I'm afraid you can't force her to like you. Perhaps where she's not so close to her mother she just doesn't want a maternal figure in her life. I would just enjoy the relationship with her daughter/your granddaughter and not try to force the matter. She doesn't sound like she's actually done anything to you except just not want a close relationship, which is her right

DrinkFeckArseBrick · 29/11/2022 11:16

It's sad as it would make family occasions easier if you were close but it's time to accept that you're not. Likely not because of anything you've done, more likely she just sees you as 'dads partner' rather than 'my family'. If she can't even chat when her dad leaves the room then I'd just give up, let her dad have the relationship with her separately to you. I think it will be a relief not to be rejected any more. Just concentrate on the relationship with your grandchild

MeMyBooksAndMyCats · 29/11/2022 11:11

You just need to accept that she doesn't want a close relationship with you. She wants one with her dad clearly, but yours will always be a polite relationship for your husbands sake.

KatherineJaneway · 29/11/2022 11:05

I think you need to change your ideas of what the relationship should be or you want it to be. She clearly does not want to be close to you for whatever reason, you have to accept that I'm afraid. If you push, she may back off even more.

CatByDay · 29/11/2022 11:01

Rogley · 29/11/2022 10:56

Is @winterywonder also the op with a different name?

I think so

pjani · 29/11/2022 11:00

I agree with the PP that I think you’re forcing this unnecessarily and that pressure might be part of what she is reacting to. I think she wants to spend time with her dad, not you so much, and that should be totally ok.

As with anything that causes hurt, I think it’s important to try and develop other passions and relationships to help this be less of a focus for you. What else is going on in your life? Are there other relationships you can deepen?

SwimInTheRain · 29/11/2022 10:58

This probably isn't about you. She's lost her original family of her mum dad together and that can not be fixed, no matter how delightful you may be. Try not to take it personally. She hasn't chosen to have you in here life, her dad has. If I were you I'd reduce my effort and contact with her since it isn't really wanted and it doesn't sound like you get much out of it aside from hurt feelings. Maybe let DH and his daughter catch up and have their own relationship and you can go have a spa outing with a friend. Or if you want to be a hands-on Nanna offer to care for step-grandchild while DH and daughter go out for coffee.

Rogley · 29/11/2022 10:56

Is @winterywonder also the op with a different name?