Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Adult Step Daughter Advice

111 replies

lemonmeranguepie · 29/11/2022 10:13

My adult step daughter is 32. Her Dad and I have been married for 14 years (he had long since been divorced from her Mum) my Step daughter doesn't have a particularly close relationship with her Mother, but amicable . I've just felt from day 1 that she doesn't like me. I've tried (without overly trying) to be friends/nice etc. I thought it would be lovely if we got along- shopping trips/Spa days etc, but nothing. I get absolutely nothing. A cold shoulder. The bare minimum. She has a daughter and kindly allowed for me to be called Nana, which I really appreciated, but it's just weird to me that I'm Nana to a beautiful little girl, yet I have zero relationship with the Mother.
Even down to silly trivial things like FB. She will like or comment on every family members post except mine, or last year's Christmas card said 'to Grandad and Nannie' (I've never heard it said that way around - seemed a passive aggressive way of making DH appear more important) I'm good with my grandchild I think and love seeing her, buying little gifts etc, I just wish she and I had a closer relationship.

I have spoken to my DH, I think he sees it too and feels sad but is helpless to it all. As she's doing nothing overtly obviously it's hard to address and tbh I don't want any issues caused.
She rarely visits and only lives very locally to us. We visit her, but the conversation is always forced and uncomfortable. If he leaves the room she turns stony silent (DH has also noticed) yet when she calls him daily I hear her chattering away. Its obviously me, but I haven't done anything that I'm aware of. I'm fun and friendly and good with my Grandchild. Maybe it's just something I can't do anything about, it's sad really.

Anyone have any experiences?

OP posts:
LearnerCook · 30/11/2022 12:37

Stepmothers usually get treated like crap on here, OP.

I don't think that hoping for a chatty, easy going relationship with your stepdaughter is asking too much. You know you're not her mother and that you'll never be best friends, but I do believe there is a happy medium and it seems you've tried to find that with her. Just keep on being your normal self with her. At least you can say you've tried. Enjoy time with your granddaughter.

YellowTreeHouse · 30/11/2022 12:11

YABU.

TheWomanTheyCallJayne · 30/11/2022 12:07

Snnowflake · 30/11/2022 11:38

OMG they've been married FOURTEEN YEARS - 14 years folks, and she won't continue a conversation with you if you are in a room together FFS - she is taking out her sadness over her parents failed marriage on you.

I would step right back - you might want a relationship with the DGD but it's going to be at the SD's behest so will always be akward.
Do you have no other young relatives who appreciate you or the time you spend on them?
Sadly it looks like this situation is not going to change after 14 years - I would say sod them tell DH you prefer to give up and just keep your distance - he is a selfish fool to continue his very close relationship whilst you are rudely ignored. That's his choice - make it a bit more uncomfortable for him - that's the least he deserves for not supporting you.

This
She sounds rude. It’s one thing to not want a relationship but to blank someone is mean.
I would step away and not make any effort at all.

kateandme · 30/11/2022 11:59

Has she ever in all the years openly said anything to give you reasons to believe as you do.
I do think giving you nan status is pretty brilliant and has to show trust.do you have a close one with her?

Georgieporgie29 · 30/11/2022 11:54

Not the point of the thread I know but it baffles me why mumsnetters post and then name change pretty much straight away 🤯

anyway, I think you are just expecting a closer relationship than she wants, although going stony silent when your dh leaves the room is rude in my opinion

Snnowflake · 30/11/2022 11:52

ivykaty44 · 30/11/2022 11:49

my dd addresses her cards to dad and Hilary, not Nana and Granny and Grandma - she uses her name.

If you think putting Grandad and Nannie is passive aggressive then you are the problem in the relationship - sorry to tell you

Does she also blank Hilary, cold shoulder her, deliberately exclude her Fb posts from liking etc because if not your post is a waste of time.

ivykaty44 · 30/11/2022 11:49

my dd addresses her cards to dad and Hilary, not Nana and Granny and Grandma - she uses her name.

If you think putting Grandad and Nannie is passive aggressive then you are the problem in the relationship - sorry to tell you

Mamma2017 · 30/11/2022 11:45

2bazookas · 29/11/2022 13:44

Girly shopping trips and spa days would be my idea of hell. With ANYONE.

Her father takes precedence over you in her feelings and social behaviour. Of course he does.

You want her to fit in to your emotional/social/imaginary fantasy of what a daughter of yours could/should be. She is not your daughter, or a substitute for the daughter you never had. She already has a mother and their relationship is private between them; none of your business.

You probably see yourself as being "too sensitive".

Your post suggests you have the hide of an elephant.

what a hideous reply. You are everything I hate about mumsnet. Seriously OP is hurting and you come up with this bull?

OP. I understand what some of the -more constructive- posters are saying: acceptance is needed- she’s showing you that she doesn’t want a relationship & of course you can’t force one.
But you know I will say this- she’s a grown woman in her thirties and sorry it’s just plain rude to go stony silent on someone in the room as you described. she’s being a bit difficult when you’ve not given her reason. I’m the grown up daughter in my situation and yep- me and step mother are not super close (mainly distance but we are quite different as people) but you know what? I care about my dads happiness, I’m not so self involved and unempathetic as to give the cold shoulder to a significant person in my dads life who like it or not is part of the family, albeit not by blood.
If your behaviour was a thing ie if you were shitty with her, her dad or child-different story altogether! If you’ve done nothing wrong do not beat yourself up or keep trying to force it. I would just be polite, civil, smile. Maybe in time as she learns you can be trusted she might come round and you can be there for her as you clearly care, but don’t hold out on this. And yep great that she’s happy for you to be nana to her daughter.
Look after yourself 💐

Feef83 · 30/11/2022 11:45

Sorry if missed

op - do you have any children?

Feef83 · 30/11/2022 11:44

Her father fell in love with you.

She didn’t

As long as she’s at least civil, accept the situation.

Theskyisfallingdown · 30/11/2022 11:41

OP changing your name means no one will see your replies highlighted.

Meh. There’s no ‘mumming’ to be done, sounds like she sees you just as her fathers wife, and there’s nothing wrong with that.

Alice786 · 30/11/2022 11:40

Your husband could have a word with her to find out why she is so cold towards you as it's bothering you as much. He doesn't have to say you said anything, just say he's notice, it may help get a better understanding and help improve the relationship.

In an ideal world she would make an effort with you for the sake of her dad especially as you have tried so hard but unfortunately it's not always like this in reality.

It sounds like she doesn't like you and just tolerates you. I think stepmother has negative connotations attached and she might not be able to help the way she feels about you, so you may need to accept her feelings might not ever change.

I think you need to back off a bit and give her some space. Just be there if she needs you but stop trying to be her friend and don't put so much effort in and you won't feel so hurt and disappointed in return.

Coyoacan · 30/11/2022 11:40

It sounds like you are a nice person and she recognises that you are nice, but personally I would have nothing in common with someone who wanted to go shopping and on Spa days. It is just not my thing.

Only little gold coins are loved by everyone.

CheeseIsMyPatronus · 30/11/2022 11:40

You're thinking you should matter to her, but you don't. You are just the woman her dad married. You're technically a step parent, I guess, but it's not like you did any actual parenting, she was 18 when you got married.

She's clearly not got a problem with you if she's letting you be called Nannie and not your name (which is more usual) by her daughter. But it would be more sensible to accept shen isn't that into you, and doesn't have to justify it.

I'm sorry if that sounds harsh but you clearly are not accepting what she's made blindingly obvious for fourteen years.

She's just not that into you.

Snnowflake · 30/11/2022 11:38

OMG they've been married FOURTEEN YEARS - 14 years folks, and she won't continue a conversation with you if you are in a room together FFS - she is taking out her sadness over her parents failed marriage on you.

I would step right back - you might want a relationship with the DGD but it's going to be at the SD's behest so will always be akward.
Do you have no other young relatives who appreciate you or the time you spend on them?
Sadly it looks like this situation is not going to change after 14 years - I would say sod them tell DH you prefer to give up and just keep your distance - he is a selfish fool to continue his very close relationship whilst you are rudely ignored. That's his choice - make it a bit more uncomfortable for him - that's the least he deserves for not supporting you.

Spanielsarepainless · 30/11/2022 11:33

Ha! Thirty years with DH, and I'm not even called Nan. Just my Christian name. I have ceased to let it bother me as my DSGD is pure gold. You can't force her to like you and I didn't try very hard, just welcoming, polite, interested when we saw DSD but no bond to speak of.

Viviennemary · 30/11/2022 11:33

You replaced her mother. That is enough for many adults to feel the same way as your SD. People can't help how they feel. It is good of her to let you have a relationship with her child.

AliceOlive · 30/11/2022 11:32

You can request that this be moved this to step parents topic.

Beamur · 30/11/2022 11:29

I am both the adult step child and the step mother in my life.
I have zero relationship with my Dad's wife. She's been hostile to me from day 1 and I have long been resigned to that!
My SC have been in my life since small and are now adults. We get on very well but I would be surprised if my DSD wanted to go shopping with me! My DSS did come and meet me for lunch when I was visiting the town he lived in, which I was quite touched by as I wouldn't have expected it.
OP - I think that you just have to accept this is how it is. There could be any number of reasons why your husband's daughter is civil rather than friendly, it might not be about you, or it might. The fact that she's facilitating a relationship with her daughter for you is a good indicator that she likes and trusts you enough for that, but she doesn't want to be your personal friend.

kateandme · 30/11/2022 11:28

For whatever reason she doesn’t want this.
have you ever sat down just you and her and asked if there is a problem or what else can you do because you feel as if there is a barrier there between the two of you.
is it openly hostile or just not as close as you’d like? Is it making thing difficult?
and I think it’s ok and sweet to want to have a special relationship with your step child. It can and does happen as much as we don’t like to say it on here.

User359472111111 · 30/11/2022 11:18

You sound like you want to be a great stepmum, but my advice is that these things run deep and to focus on being an amazing Nana.

FatimaHatima · 30/11/2022 11:17

Can you imagine spending FIFTEEN YEARS being polite (but clear that you have no desire for a familial relationship) to your fathers wife, and her STILL banging on about spa days and complaining you're not warm enough with her?
She must have the patience of a saint!

Feef83 · 30/11/2022 11:12

To me it reads that you’re just not her cup of tea. Her dad loves you but that doesn’t mean that you’re someone she would ever be close to.

She is civil and thoughtful. So just respect that

RoachPussy · 30/11/2022 11:12

Sounds a bit like you’ve been trying too hard. Some people in life we get on better with and others we take against.

Lostatsea10 · 30/11/2022 11:11

I’m the adult stepdaughter in my own scenario and in fact my father got married after I did, though she was at my wedding. I’m polite to her and friendly enough when I see her but genuinely, with no malice meant, she is nothing to me other than my dads wife.

Her adult children (who I might have seen 5 times in total over 15 years) are nothing other than my dads wife’s children. That’s just how they’re thought of in my mind.

It’s not personal, she’s just not important in my life. My dad and her called her Nanny X which we went along with as they choose to be largely absent grandparents and only see us/DC once or twice a year. We refer to her as X when talking about her in front of the DC.

We’re all grown ups and there’s no ill will in it but she’s not someone I’d choose to be friends with, I’m too old and don’t need a ‘step mum’ and so she is just my dad’s wife.