Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Adult Step Daughter Advice

111 replies

lemonmeranguepie · 29/11/2022 10:13

My adult step daughter is 32. Her Dad and I have been married for 14 years (he had long since been divorced from her Mum) my Step daughter doesn't have a particularly close relationship with her Mother, but amicable . I've just felt from day 1 that she doesn't like me. I've tried (without overly trying) to be friends/nice etc. I thought it would be lovely if we got along- shopping trips/Spa days etc, but nothing. I get absolutely nothing. A cold shoulder. The bare minimum. She has a daughter and kindly allowed for me to be called Nana, which I really appreciated, but it's just weird to me that I'm Nana to a beautiful little girl, yet I have zero relationship with the Mother.
Even down to silly trivial things like FB. She will like or comment on every family members post except mine, or last year's Christmas card said 'to Grandad and Nannie' (I've never heard it said that way around - seemed a passive aggressive way of making DH appear more important) I'm good with my grandchild I think and love seeing her, buying little gifts etc, I just wish she and I had a closer relationship.

I have spoken to my DH, I think he sees it too and feels sad but is helpless to it all. As she's doing nothing overtly obviously it's hard to address and tbh I don't want any issues caused.
She rarely visits and only lives very locally to us. We visit her, but the conversation is always forced and uncomfortable. If he leaves the room she turns stony silent (DH has also noticed) yet when she calls him daily I hear her chattering away. Its obviously me, but I haven't done anything that I'm aware of. I'm fun and friendly and good with my Grandchild. Maybe it's just something I can't do anything about, it's sad really.

Anyone have any experiences?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
WhoKnows2346 · 02/12/2022 12:18

It sounds like for whatever reason your DSD is reserved in her affections, you say her relationship with her own mother is amicable but you don't mention loving or close. It took along time for me to let my MIL be close to me.

What I would do is stop trying, please.
When your DH isn't in the room, either turn your attentions to the grandchild or ask impersonal questions such as, have you managed to finish your Christmas shopping? Or the weather. And instead of forcing yourself on her to help out, say 'well, you know where we are if you need me.' I have a very nice relationship with my MIL now and regularly speak on the phone for an hour at a time but it was a very bumpy road to begin with. Good luck xx

cypresstree · 01/12/2022 00:15

@Caplin she is your husband’s daughter who was an adult when you arrived.

I completely agree and her daughter is not your granddaughter. Of course you can be someone special in this child's life, but your need to take ownership over these people really comes across in your posts and if it comes across here, I can only imagine what it presents itself as in real life. Just calm it down a bit.

Caplin · 30/11/2022 22:20

If I were you I would be grateful she allowed you to be called nanny. My mum remarried when I was an adult. She was with her partner before I had my children, married when they were tiny. I don’t let my kids call her husband Grampa or Papa (he might want that but he is not), he is known by his name. I don’t like him much, I tolerate him because I have to. I don’t stop my kids seeing him (although it is rare due to him, not them). He likes my kids, gets on with them fine, buys them gifts for birthdays etc.

Your husband’s daughter is an adult, capable of choosing her own friends and you can’t be foisted on her, you had no hand in her upbringing, she is not your step daughter, she is your husband’s daughter who was an adult when you arrived.

Would it be nice to do spa days and so on? For you, yes. For her, you are fine, but she isn’t interested in spending her time with you beyond her dad. She doesn’t dislike you, but you came along when she she didn’t need you in her life, she was leaving. You need to accept that.

randomusername666 · 30/11/2022 19:23

lemonmeranguepie · 29/11/2022 10:13

My adult step daughter is 32. Her Dad and I have been married for 14 years (he had long since been divorced from her Mum) my Step daughter doesn't have a particularly close relationship with her Mother, but amicable . I've just felt from day 1 that she doesn't like me. I've tried (without overly trying) to be friends/nice etc. I thought it would be lovely if we got along- shopping trips/Spa days etc, but nothing. I get absolutely nothing. A cold shoulder. The bare minimum. She has a daughter and kindly allowed for me to be called Nana, which I really appreciated, but it's just weird to me that I'm Nana to a beautiful little girl, yet I have zero relationship with the Mother.
Even down to silly trivial things like FB. She will like or comment on every family members post except mine, or last year's Christmas card said 'to Grandad and Nannie' (I've never heard it said that way around - seemed a passive aggressive way of making DH appear more important) I'm good with my grandchild I think and love seeing her, buying little gifts etc, I just wish she and I had a closer relationship.

I have spoken to my DH, I think he sees it too and feels sad but is helpless to it all. As she's doing nothing overtly obviously it's hard to address and tbh I don't want any issues caused.
She rarely visits and only lives very locally to us. We visit her, but the conversation is always forced and uncomfortable. If he leaves the room she turns stony silent (DH has also noticed) yet when she calls him daily I hear her chattering away. Its obviously me, but I haven't done anything that I'm aware of. I'm fun and friendly and good with my Grandchild. Maybe it's just something I can't do anything about, it's sad really.

Anyone have any experiences?

Take a step back and give yourself a break from the chill. Continue to be civil and friendly but stop trying to force a relationship with someone who clearly doesn't want to have one with you. you're probably better off without getting too close as the step daughter doesn't sound very pleasant.

Feef83 · 30/11/2022 19:19

Grumpusaurus · 30/11/2022 19:18

You sound a bit unhinged OP

There is definitely a whiff of that

Grumpusaurus · 30/11/2022 19:18

You sound a bit unhinged OP

Feef83 · 30/11/2022 19:16

Alice786 · 30/11/2022 18:01

We can only go by what she told us of course and not make assumptions.

Indeed

and on the basis of

I've never heard it said that way around - seemed a passive aggressive way of making DH appear more important… I can imagine there is perhaps very much a different side to the story here if we heard from the SD

Alice786 · 30/11/2022 18:01

We can only go by what she told us of course and not make assumptions.

FatimaHatima · 30/11/2022 17:32

Alice786 · 30/11/2022 16:51

You don't have to like them but as an adult you don't have to be rude to them either. It is quite selfish and self absorbed. Most parents make an effort with their children's partners even if they don't necessarily like them for the sake of their kids and I think it's not too much to ask to be polite to their dad's life partner especially one who is making such an effort. I think as a step parent you can't win, if you care and put effort it you're trying to replace their parent, if you don't put effort in you're the wicked stepmother.

You're taking OP's word as gospel, as if she doesn't have a massive chip on her shoulder and a specfic viewpoint....

Maybe the woman has just had enough of being polite and has had enough of OP after so many years?> It's clear OP is pushing for a relationship that isn't there, quite selfishly, its entirely possible the woman spent years being nice and friendly enough but not what Op wanted, and has just given up now.

She's not a step parent. She's just the fathers wife.

Alice786 · 30/11/2022 16:51

You don't have to like them but as an adult you don't have to be rude to them either. It is quite selfish and self absorbed. Most parents make an effort with their children's partners even if they don't necessarily like them for the sake of their kids and I think it's not too much to ask to be polite to their dad's life partner especially one who is making such an effort. I think as a step parent you can't win, if you care and put effort it you're trying to replace their parent, if you don't put effort in you're the wicked stepmother.

thecatsthecats · 30/11/2022 15:46

AdelineLou · 30/11/2022 13:26

Desensitise!

Be a little more objective. I could write most of what you have written....and that is about my relationship with my mum.

Perhaps this is how your step daughter is in most relationships. It seems her model of a close relationship, from her mum is different to what you except too.

I agree.

I'm not particularly close to many people at all.

An adult who only came into my life when I was already an adult wanting spa trips with me just wouldn't work. Partly because spa and shopping trips are the last thing I want.

She's got her ILs plus two sets of parent relationships. Those all come after the needs of her immediate family. Then she'll also have friends.

BungleandGeorge · 30/11/2022 15:40

I presume she doesn’t dislike you or you wouldn’t be a Nannie to her daughter. I think this is fairly normal for new partners introduced to adult children, don’t take it personally. If you split up you would probably both happily go your own ways, it’s usual not to have a close relationship. Perhaps you don’t have much in common? I don’t think I know anyone in similar circumstances who has spa days and shopping trips.

Ellessdee · 30/11/2022 15:25

If you were in her life since childhood it would be entirely different because she'd have formed an attachment to you. She's an adult, you can't force an adult to like and want to spend time with another adult. You're her dad's partner, she likely doesn't see that you have much in common, she's got shit to do and probably doesn't want to go on shopping trips and spa days with someone just because they're married to her father. I'm not close at all to my mum's partner, and am very close to my dad's partner. Neither are called grandad or grandma by my son, just their names. My mother and father definitely come first in Christmas cards. Just get on with your life OP and enjoy you'd time with your step-GC when you see them.

Feef83 · 30/11/2022 15:16

Snnowflake · 30/11/2022 11:52

Does she also blank Hilary, cold shoulder her, deliberately exclude her Fb posts from liking etc because if not your post is a waste of time.

And yet in more than 12 years it would seem no one has thought to raise this. The DH has seen the hundreds of times the Op has been cold shouldered, and… watched? The OP has never said anything?
very baffling

fdgdfgdfgdfg · 30/11/2022 15:08

I think you're looking for a relationship that isn't there OP.

My mum remarried when I was around 20. My stepdad is a good man, he made my Mum very happy for 15 years until she died. I like the man, but he's not my father, and he's not my friend.

You don't seem to be hung up on being Mum, but you do seem to be hung up on the fact that you're not friends. But friends are people you choose. You choose them because you have shared interests, because you have personalities that click well.

I don't click with my stepdad. I like him, I respect him, I trust him with my daughter, I wish him nothing but the best, and if he asked for a favour, I'd want to help. But chuck the two of us in a room by ourselves and conversation dries up very quickly.

My daughter has a much closer relationship with him. He's been "Bampi" to her since she's been born. They have their own in jokes, their own stories.

You are "Nana" to your step granddaughter. That in itself shows that your stepdaughter respects you, trusts you. You wouldn't be Nana if she hated you. Accept the relationship for what it is. You're two people forced together by someone you both love, that doesn't have to make you friends

Merry05 · 30/11/2022 13:44

It could be that she’s battling with the lack of relationship she has with her mum. I wouldn’t take it too personal, there could be something going on she’s struggling with. Wanting a relationship with her mother but not having it might be making her feel insecure about the relationship with you, worried about comments from her mum if she posts on your Facebook etc.

KimberleyClark · 30/11/2022 13:36

I agree the blanking when her father leaves the room is really rude and immature. Even if you don’t want to be friends with someone you can still be civil. I wonder if her mother has remarried and if so how she treats her mother’s husband.

AdelineLou · 30/11/2022 13:26

lemonmeranguepie · 29/11/2022 10:13

My adult step daughter is 32. Her Dad and I have been married for 14 years (he had long since been divorced from her Mum) my Step daughter doesn't have a particularly close relationship with her Mother, but amicable . I've just felt from day 1 that she doesn't like me. I've tried (without overly trying) to be friends/nice etc. I thought it would be lovely if we got along- shopping trips/Spa days etc, but nothing. I get absolutely nothing. A cold shoulder. The bare minimum. She has a daughter and kindly allowed for me to be called Nana, which I really appreciated, but it's just weird to me that I'm Nana to a beautiful little girl, yet I have zero relationship with the Mother.
Even down to silly trivial things like FB. She will like or comment on every family members post except mine, or last year's Christmas card said 'to Grandad and Nannie' (I've never heard it said that way around - seemed a passive aggressive way of making DH appear more important) I'm good with my grandchild I think and love seeing her, buying little gifts etc, I just wish she and I had a closer relationship.

I have spoken to my DH, I think he sees it too and feels sad but is helpless to it all. As she's doing nothing overtly obviously it's hard to address and tbh I don't want any issues caused.
She rarely visits and only lives very locally to us. We visit her, but the conversation is always forced and uncomfortable. If he leaves the room she turns stony silent (DH has also noticed) yet when she calls him daily I hear her chattering away. Its obviously me, but I haven't done anything that I'm aware of. I'm fun and friendly and good with my Grandchild. Maybe it's just something I can't do anything about, it's sad really.

Anyone have any experiences?

Desensitise!

Be a little more objective. I could write most of what you have written....and that is about my relationship with my mum.

Perhaps this is how your step daughter is in most relationships. It seems her model of a close relationship, from her mum is different to what you except too.

FatimaHatima · 30/11/2022 13:20

A lot of people projecting here and inventing details that aren't there.

It's simple. Just because your parent marries someone, that doesn't make them your family. You don't have to like them or make an effort with them, if you don't want to.

silverclock222 · 30/11/2022 13:02

FatimaHatima · 29/11/2022 10:16

'to Grandad and Nannie' (I've never heard it said that way around - seemed a passive aggressive way of making DH appear more important)

He IS more important! He is her father. You are not her mother. If this is your attitude, that might be why she is cold with you.
She doesn't particularly like you or want to be close with you, that's ok. She has no problem with you being a grandmother to her daughter though, which is nice, so why not just focus on that and stop flogging the dead horse?

Sorry but yes, this

PeekAtYou · 30/11/2022 12:59

I noticed this on a second reading "my Step daughter doesn't have a particularly close relationship with her Mother, but amicable"

Maybe this is part of the reason why your relationship with her is also not close but amicable too?

xJ0y · 30/11/2022 12:51

You can't force it though. So long as she's civil and doesn't ruin days out I'd just accept it. It is a ''blended'' family. I know the answer to a lot of life's problems is to just care a bit less and it's advice I could take myself (plenty of things have hurt me and I wish I'd cared less as after five years of hurt feelings on both sides I just don't care anymore and if I'd felt this little investment to begin with then we could have had the facade of a family relationship talking about the weather and the dog and the lunch. But no, I was HURT and they were angry I was hurt. And they gave me the silent treatment for being hurt. Which hurt me more. So, to cut a long story short, I think you should be really kind to yourself and dialogue with yourself very kindly but privately.

Lollypop701 · 30/11/2022 12:45

Not wanting a relationship is fine, being rude to you in your own home is not and dh should have a word. I know you love the dgc but do you feel used? because you provide care and that’s only why you are Nannie? If so it’s up to you what you do. I’d back off and leave sd alone, be polite but that’s all and personally have relationship with dgc on my own terms

stuntbubbles · 30/11/2022 12:43

last year's Christmas card said 'to Grandad and Nannie' (I've never heard it said that way around - seemed a passive aggressive way of making DH appear more important)
This is one of the most bonkers things I’ve ever read on MN! I always address things to Grandfather and Stepmother’sname and of course my father is more important to me than his wife is. Thankfully she’s a wonderful and sane human who wouldn’t bat an eye at this. Even the fact your stepdaughter has let you be Nannie rather than Name is generous, imo, she doesn’t have to at all.

Boohisspiss · 30/11/2022 12:37

You keep saying your husband agrees with you. I wouldn’t talk to him about it so much, it puts him in an awkward position and your step daughter may feel it. Not
everyone clicks and it’s okay, just be yourself, and if she’s silent, act like your comfortably silent yourself and hopefully she leads.