Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

A secondhand gifts ONLY Christmas

109 replies

SweetRascal · 29/11/2022 08:35

For cost and the environment, I've decided to do a secondhand gifts only Christmas, with the obvious exception of food items.

But some people can be a bit funny about things that aren't new. I'm wondering what some members of my family will really think (although I'm sure they'll be polite and gracious).

I look carefully round charity shops, boot sales and Facebook marketplace. I wouldn't buy just anything but love a spontaneous find that I think someone would like.

My children couldn't care less if something is new but adults can be a bit different. Having said that, I'm still going to do secondhand only despite what they may think. It will save money and I feel like it's one way forward for the environment.

However, I am interested what people think about this?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
hattie43 · 01/12/2022 19:09

Personally I wouldn't . My recipients wouldn't appreciate second hand gifts or home made for that matter .
Fine for yourself if that's what you choose but I wouldn't for others .

Bluevases · 01/12/2022 18:56

I wouldn't want a secondhand gift but tbh it's because I really don't want more stuff, new or old! My close family buy me something and I always treasure it as they know me really well and choose something that I always end up treasuring (because it's from them as much as for the thing itself). From my friends, I'd rather have their company or have them buy me a drink on an occasion that we are together. Second hand tat is better for the planet than giving new tat, but I just prefer not to have more tat! Books and gardening vouchers are the exceptions for those really wanting to gift a 'thing'.

AgathaMystery · 01/12/2022 13:24

Pleasebeafleabite · 29/11/2022 22:09

I know someone who is still trying to get rid of bedbugs from his house as a result of acquiring a secondhand laundry basket six years ago.

Secondhand furniture? No thanks

He’s not doing a very good job of getting rid of them is he 😂 bloody hell…

I’ve tried not to buy much new stuff this year. We are making a conscious effort and it does make a difference financially. As for gifts I have got:

~mens Rapha cycling to £12 vinted (RRP £98)
~DM Leonore boots £80 Vinted (RRP £160)
~ childrens Barbour with Liberty lining £8 (RRP £??) eBay BNWT
~3 Georg Jensen serving bowls £50 for 3 (£90 odd each new) charity shop
~cashmere jumper from the secondhand cashmere company £38
~bordallo pinhero jug £6 charity shop
~Joseph Joseph rice cooker BNIB £3 charity shop
~Mens OnRunning trainers BNIB £19 vinted

all look new, so I’m really happy.

Pleasebeafleabite · 29/11/2022 22:09

I know someone who is still trying to get rid of bedbugs from his house as a result of acquiring a secondhand laundry basket six years ago.

Secondhand furniture? No thanks

Divebar2021 · 29/11/2022 21:53

Sounds like a fun challenge OP although I don’t know why it would be limited to charity shops. I’ve bought and had gifted lots of items for my house which were vintage which let’s face it are just used. ( original angelpoise lamps, Bakelite phones etc… all design classics). I’ve also gifted Atomic style tea sets, embroidered linens, old patchwork quilts, prints etc. Clothes are a bit trickier but band T shirts or US college T’s would be great for a teenager for example. Books are also good and certainly wouldn’t be out of print editions in my neck of the woods.
Maybe you’d like to look at Re-found objects for some inspiration

www.re-foundobjects.com/category/view/2ndhand

704703hey · 29/11/2022 21:52

FourChimneys · 29/11/2022 14:40

We don't really do Christmas presents here but secondhand gifts are the norm. Books are the most popular.

I found a beautiful and warm jumper recently so have washed it and given it to DH to stash away for my birthday.

That's really great, I know what I like and my face must be a picture when I'm presented with some tat like keyrings or stone bracelets. That could have been spent on a bottle of EVOO for the same price. I need no more tat. Unless it's useful tat like a baking tray 🤣

You'll have a lovely jumper which you will use and get pleasure from.

LolaSmiles · 29/11/2022 21:31

I would like second hand gifts as long as they were personal to me and not a random cookbook or ornament.

With people who are invested in everything being new, I'd probably suggest cutting all gifts for adults rather than try to get them to be open to second hand.

TheDogAteMyHousework · 29/11/2022 21:26

I try to avoid buying new generally. I don't really have adults to buy for because we stopped adult gifts, but family is fine with second-hand. My DC understand that I can afford to get them more books/games if I don't buy new and that it is more responsible to reuse than constantly produce more goods.

I clicked on this thread hoping to get some more ideas for sustainable gifts.

My DC (tween/teen) will be getting preloved clothes from Father Christmas, along with rechargeable batteries, preloved books, things they can eat (branded cereal they don't get the rest of the year), second-hand board games and one is getting a vintage egg cup.

We're getting an experience from my parents.

I recently discovered some preloved book subscription gifts which are great if you have a bookworm.

Memberships (museums, galleries, English Heritage), experiences, theatre, nice food and drink... There are lots of options if you want to avoid new but also don't want to do second-hand.

Personally, I'd rather have second-hand if available. When I think about the sheer volume of stuff in the world, I feel slightly sick. I wouldn't gift something that didn't look new unless I knew the recipient would be OK with it. But so many books (for example) look untouched. And I have some lovely clothes that you would never guess weren't new when I got them and better quality than I could afford new.

Most of my friends are the same. I've been really surprised by some of the comments on this thread. It just goes to show that we often live in our own little echo chambers.

Whatatimetobealivetoday · 29/11/2022 20:51

SkylightSkylight · 29/11/2022 13:19

I acquired a HappyLand ebay addiction when the girls were little. Trying to find the unusual sets etc. loved it!! I loved winning the auctions as much as wethey loved playing with it!!

have fun 🎄

@SkylightSkylight 😂😂 I can feel the addiction beginning…

skyeisthelimit · 29/11/2022 14:45

I have bought items from charity shop that are brand new and untouched , but I wouldn't give anything that looked used or tatty in any way.

DD wants an expensive camera for Christmas, I have been offered one for £100 that cost £300 new, and I have discussed with her about buying it and whether she is happy to have a 2nd hand item for a Christmas present.

One friend gave DD a load of her kids Lego Friends stuff one year, around 5-6 sets that would have cost a fortune new. We very much appreciated it.

FourChimneys · 29/11/2022 14:40

We don't really do Christmas presents here but secondhand gifts are the norm. Books are the most popular.

I found a beautiful and warm jumper recently so have washed it and given it to DH to stash away for my birthday.

strawberriesarenot · 29/11/2022 14:31

I'd rather have a bunch of flowers, or a handful of bulbs, or nothing at all.

PoquitaAmiga · 29/11/2022 14:21

I'd rather no adult gifts. I've received some great second hand gifts from people who know me well so I'm not against second hand. I'm against compulsory gifts - i.e. Christmas, birthdays, etc

frozengoose · 29/11/2022 14:19

I am delighted with antique jewelry, furniture and art. I also love antiquarian books.
I would be much less thrilled with a charity shop pj set if I'm being honest.

Nevermind31 · 29/11/2022 14:17

It would very much depend what it is. A lovely piece of jewellery? Why not. But I don’t need or want bric-a-brac.
so if you see something that you know someone will like - sure. Going through all the charity shops and picking from what is there for the sake of it - no thank you, it’s the same as people wanting to offload their stuff onto others to feel good.

704703hey · 29/11/2022 14:09

If the thought had gone into what people would like I'd be delighted if you gave me something I'd like/which was useful at higher quality than retail full price.

I am fully supportive of this, currently wearing a black cashmere skirt bought secondhand for £6 perfect condition!

surreygirl1987 · 29/11/2022 14:03

I think it's great. Practically all my kids' Christmas presents are second hand. I don't really tend to buy adult ones these days but I would have no issue with receiving a second hand present.

AntsGoMarchingOneByOne · 29/11/2022 13:59

I'd rather get a box of chocolates or cookies than a second hand gift. I don't like other people's used stuff.

Buzzinwithbez · 29/11/2022 13:49

I've given people worthy gifts in the past and often regretted it when I came to realise it was more about me than the recipient.
If your inlaws like new, buy new, unless you're 200 percent sure they're going to live y what you get them.

cupofdecaf · 29/11/2022 13:43

I find second hand adds so many more possibilities.

Furniture for example I've found some lovely pieces on Facebook. People downsizing have been a good source of lovely furniture. When we wanted two matching very large sideboards we were realistic about finding them secondhand and bought new though.

Buying second hand has also saved us a huge amount on furniture but that's mostly come secondary to the reality of finding things I like.

I don't like all matching furniture and really don't like flimsy cardboard like furniture.

2 of the best prices of furniture we have are 2 chest of drawers refurbished by a local business. They are lovely and the drawers run so smoothly. Another piece of furniture I have that is very old just has so much more character than you could ever get in a new piece. I take great pleasure in finding/ placing and living with lovely furniture that has history and does a good job.

SkylightSkylight · 29/11/2022 13:19

Whatatimetobealivetoday · 29/11/2022 11:38

I have pretty much bought all our toddlers Christmas pressies from Vinted this year. He’s into Happyland which is overpriced plastic. Got some amazing sets for a fraction of the price in very good condition!
Also some brand new toys that he will love!

I can afford the full price I just hate buying more plastic first hand. We’ll pass it on again if it’s still in good condition when he’s finished.

I acquired a HappyLand ebay addiction when the girls were little. Trying to find the unusual sets etc. loved it!! I loved winning the auctions as much as wethey loved playing with it!!

have fun 🎄

Mousicles · 29/11/2022 13:02

I often do this without thinking as we buy most things 2nd hand, wouldn't occur to me to warn people in advance. But for gifts I make sure what I've found is better than what I could afford new: cashmere, silk, luxury brands and designer labels, and I would get it online from specific shops. It's how you frame it to people, picking stuff up from your local charity shop is quite different to sourcing an antique item or collector's edition to suit that person's interest. Most people have hobbies or tastes that mean they'd love a 2nd hand version of something high quality to fit that hobby. I buy all my SLR camera lenses online 2nd hand from specialist shops but if someone said they were picking up gifts from charity shops I'd not have high hopes.

Strictlyfanoftenyears · 29/11/2022 13:02

Secret santa for adults this year, I have asked for vintage china. (Love the bone china plates etc). So one present each and hopefully people will look at charity/ homemade stuff, but not compulsory). I think that maybe an odd poster might just be winding us all up!!!😂

Nowisthemonthofmaying · 29/11/2022 12:55

I buy everything second hand or in charity shops myself but wouldn't generally do it for presents - unless it's beautiful antique things like a nice leather-bound book or a crystal decanter or something. But you have to know someone's taste quite well if you're going down that route!

Needmorelego · 29/11/2022 12:53

@YellowTreeHouse I bought 2 paperback books recently. I am curious if you can tell from the picture which one I bought new and which one secondhand.

A secondhand gifts ONLY Christmas