Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Why don't you foster or adopt?

221 replies

Myguessis · 29/11/2022 07:49

Please, please stop asking this question to anyone that tells you they can't have children.

I promise you, they are already aware that adoption and fostering exists. You are not enlightening them.

Fostering and adoption are not solutions to infertility. They are huge undertakings in themselves, and the focus is on providing an often traumatised child a loving, stable home. Not to 'fill a hole' in someone's life. Yes, this can be the route some have travelled but it's not an automatic Option B!!

It's also a huge emotional challenge in itself, with the training, visits, and checks often taking months and months - many couples are still raw from unsuccessful invasive and physically demanding treatment.

Just don't make this 'helpful' suggestion. It's so insensitive.

OP posts:
KimberleyClark · 29/11/2022 16:49

Myguessis · 29/11/2022 16:44

💐

You've hit on a good point; you are subject to immediate judgement - as if not wanting to foster or adopt means you can't quite want a child 'that badly'.

Yes this. As if anyone who gets pregnant easily is in any position to judge how much anyone who I can’t really wants a baby.

Changeyncchange · 29/11/2022 16:47

SirSidneyRuffDiamond · 29/11/2022 16:45

@Changeyncchange

I have no idea about the statistics but the statements that most adoptees are infertile and most infertile couples do not adopt may both be true.

Indeed, but there is a link.

Changeyncchange · 29/11/2022 16:46

The "why don't you just adopt" question really highlights the asker's naivety and lack of awareness

I know you think I have an agenda but I do have to clarify. I would never ask this.

I would ask "would you adopt?".

Small difference but I think I understand your point more now. In fairness you did phrase it that way in your OP, I suppose my brain didn't process it because I cannot imagine anybody being that insensitive.

SirSidneyRuffDiamond · 29/11/2022 16:45

@Changeyncchange

I have no idea about the statistics but the statements that most adoptees are infertile and most infertile couples do not adopt may both be true.

Myguessis · 29/11/2022 16:44

justgettingthroughtheday · 29/11/2022 16:33

I have endometrial cancer and due to have a hysterectomy very soon. Al attempts to save my womb have failed.
I'm sick of hearing suggestions that I adopt- I don't want to and I don't think I'd be approved for many reasons.
It's not going to get better.
I got a huge amount of grief on a Facebook support group for endometrial cancer when I asked people not to suggest adoption. They accused me of all sorts and one even told me that if I wasn't prepared to adopt then it was a good thing I wasn't able to be a mother!

💐

You've hit on a good point; you are subject to immediate judgement - as if not wanting to foster or adopt means you can't quite want a child 'that badly'.

OP posts:
MRSDoos · 29/11/2022 16:43

@Myguessis Yes the question should never be asked

I think you are totally right. A lot of people are so uneducated that they think adoption is like going to Tesco. In reality it’s possibly years of paperwork, meetings, panels. It can be heartbreaking as some adoptions fall through. I’ve looked into it as personally I want to adopt in the future but I think it is such a personal choice and I hate that people think it is an answer to miscarriages or infertility

Possiblynotever · 29/11/2022 16:40

There is nothing that you can say to an infertile woman, unless you have been infertile yourself.
Both my DH and I have been declared 100% infertile and then, after 5 years of marriage, I got naturally pregnant ( when I called my gynecologist to give him the news he said: Eva Braun thought the same). I usually keep this for myself.
It is bereavement every month.

Myguessis · 29/11/2022 16:39

MRSDoos · 29/11/2022 16:28

I haven’t struggled with infertility but I cringe at the comments I see online from people “Just adopt!”

I totally agree that adoption and infertility are two separate things.

Funnily enough it’s usually woman who are able to have bio children easily who make these sorts of comments. A couple of weeks ago I saw a post on Facebook from a celeb that used IVF to get pregnant. A woman commented “Just adopt, so many children need to be adopted! Why would you put yourself through that?” Ironically had 3 bio kids herself and stated she didn’t need IVF. A lot of people bashed her, why didn’t she “just adopt” if she says there is children who need to be adopted!!

The "why don't you just adopt" question really highlights the asker's naivety and lack of awareness. Without exception.

As if you simply pick out a child from a fancy catalogue, kit out the nursery, get it dropped off via Amazon Prime and bam, instant happy family.

It's easy, just don't ask anyone if they've thought of it. Everyone knows adoption and fostering exists, it won't be a foreign notion.

If someone is close to you, they'll inevitably talk about it- but on their terms.

OP posts:
Changeyncchange · 29/11/2022 16:37

MRSDoos · 29/11/2022 16:34

@Changeyncchange Yes they are completely separate issues. I am sure I saw statistics that most infertile couples do not adopt.

In the US its the most common reason for adoption. Can't find the figures for the UK but would be surprised if they were different.

rippleraspberry · 29/11/2022 16:37

Changeyncchange · 29/11/2022 16:27

You are talking as if it is an identity.

I don't think that's healthy for anybody. The people close to me did/do not see it like this.

Now obviously you are going to tell me I wrong and they secretly do because you are so seem so committed to this identity you feel perfectly comfortable telling me you understand complete strangers better than their own family.

No, once again, you are putting words into my mouth.

I did not say that I see it as an identity - I actively work hard to prevent that and ensure I have a life outside of it.

However, the fact that you are judgmental about the idea of it being an 'identity' also shows your lack of understanding. For some people, it does become an identity, and it's not one that anybody would ever want. It's extremely dismissive to just say 'that's not healthy'. No it's not - but that is how it goes for some people.

It can be all consuming, and that is why it can be helpful to have a support network. People who share an experience have a commonality in understanding that experience.

KimberleyClark · 29/11/2022 16:37

Changeyncchange · 29/11/2022 16:30

I totally agree that adoption and infertility are two separate things

Is it? The majority of people I know who fostered or adopted (outside of kinship care) don't have their own children due to difficulty conceiving.

Adoption does not exist to provide children for would be parents. It’s about finding homes and families for children who need them. Infertile couples are not automatically the best people to provide this (though some undoubtedly are). You do not need to be infertile to adopt.

MRSDoos · 29/11/2022 16:34

@Changeyncchange Yes they are completely separate issues. I am sure I saw statistics that most infertile couples do not adopt.

Changeyncchange · 29/11/2022 16:33

DuchessofSandwich · 29/11/2022 16:32

Most infertile couples don't adopt or foster.

Do you know how many adopters (outside of family) are infertile? I don't know btw, just wondered. I appreciate my experience is anecdotal.

justgettingthroughtheday · 29/11/2022 16:33

I have endometrial cancer and due to have a hysterectomy very soon. Al attempts to save my womb have failed.
I'm sick of hearing suggestions that I adopt- I don't want to and I don't think I'd be approved for many reasons.
It's not going to get better.
I got a huge amount of grief on a Facebook support group for endometrial cancer when I asked people not to suggest adoption. They accused me of all sorts and one even told me that if I wasn't prepared to adopt then it was a good thing I wasn't able to be a mother!

DuchessofSandwich · 29/11/2022 16:32

Changeyncchange · 29/11/2022 16:30

I totally agree that adoption and infertility are two separate things

Is it? The majority of people I know who fostered or adopted (outside of kinship care) don't have their own children due to difficulty conceiving.

Most infertile couples don't adopt or foster.

Changeyncchange · 29/11/2022 16:30

I totally agree that adoption and infertility are two separate things

Is it? The majority of people I know who fostered or adopted (outside of kinship care) don't have their own children due to difficulty conceiving.

Changeyncchange · 29/11/2022 16:28

And perhaps listening to the view of someone with experience of infertility might give you an insight into how it can feel, underneath what they will share with you

Again. I have. That's what we are discussing.

MRSDoos · 29/11/2022 16:28

I haven’t struggled with infertility but I cringe at the comments I see online from people “Just adopt!”

I totally agree that adoption and infertility are two separate things.

Funnily enough it’s usually woman who are able to have bio children easily who make these sorts of comments. A couple of weeks ago I saw a post on Facebook from a celeb that used IVF to get pregnant. A woman commented “Just adopt, so many children need to be adopted! Why would you put yourself through that?” Ironically had 3 bio kids herself and stated she didn’t need IVF. A lot of people bashed her, why didn’t she “just adopt” if she says there is children who need to be adopted!!

Changeyncchange · 29/11/2022 16:27

rippleraspberry · 29/11/2022 16:21

Infertility is not a defining characteristic that confers you superior knowledge of complete strangers feelings and relationships because they share that characteristic.

People going through infertility do have a kind of knowledge of each other's experience which is not shared by other friends and family members in their day to day lives.

Many people seek out community support from others who are going through similar - you only need to look at the IVF/ Infertility forums on here to see that. It is the same with people going through other challenging life experiences who seek out a community, because they can relate to each others' experiences and feelings, even though they are strangers.

There is value in shared experience and yes, there actually are commonalities in the experience of infertility. That is obviously not to say that everyone is the same, but of course there are going to be feelings and emotions which one can understand when going through a similar experience.

You are talking as if it is an identity.

I don't think that's healthy for anybody. The people close to me did/do not see it like this.

Now obviously you are going to tell me I wrong and they secretly do because you are so seem so committed to this identity you feel perfectly comfortable telling me you understand complete strangers better than their own family.

rippleraspberry · 29/11/2022 16:23

Changeyncchange · 29/11/2022 16:15

I'm astounded that you continue to insist you are an authority on other peoples feelings.

You are not.

There is nothing unique about infertility that makes it a unifying condition/experience. I wouldn't dream of sitting here and telling people I have universal knowledge of the feelings of everybody who shares my trauma and challenges. Why do you insist that you do?

OK, well, just to clarify in the most obvious way I can - I am not an authority on other people's feelings.

However, neither are you. Not even those of your closest family and friends.

And perhaps listening to the view of someone with experience of infertility might give you an insight into how it can feel, underneath what they will share with you.

Or perhaps not. You can take from it what you like, however I think I'm done now.

rippleraspberry · 29/11/2022 16:21

Infertility is not a defining characteristic that confers you superior knowledge of complete strangers feelings and relationships because they share that characteristic.

People going through infertility do have a kind of knowledge of each other's experience which is not shared by other friends and family members in their day to day lives.

Many people seek out community support from others who are going through similar - you only need to look at the IVF/ Infertility forums on here to see that. It is the same with people going through other challenging life experiences who seek out a community, because they can relate to each others' experiences and feelings, even though they are strangers.

There is value in shared experience and yes, there actually are commonalities in the experience of infertility. That is obviously not to say that everyone is the same, but of course there are going to be feelings and emotions which one can understand when going through a similar experience.

Changeyncchange · 29/11/2022 16:15

rippleraspberry · 29/11/2022 16:07

@Changeyncchange I am simply giving you a suggestion based on my own experience about how your friends/ family going through infertility might actually be feeling, underneath their polite responses to you. There is no need to take such offence.

When people ask me these questions, I do talk to them, and I'm grateful for their interest and I know that it comes from a good place. They would have no idea that I secretly wish they were not asking me these questions, because I'm a pretty open person and I appreciate people caring and being interested.

I would of course have been 'perfectly capable' of telling them that it hurt to think about adoption, but I probably wouldn't do that, because they were trying to be supportive to me and they are people I like and care about.

You actually don't know about the internal worlds of your friends and family going through infertility - and I probably actually do have a pretty good insight in terms of that. In my 3 years of struggling with this, I have spoken to countless other people going through the same or similar, and I have never heard anyone say they were pleased when adoption/ fostering was raised and they were made to talk about it.

It just bloody hurts. Every time you say 'have you thought about adoption?' you are reminding that person that they might not be successful in having a biological child. That's not something they want to think about.

Anyway, if you really want to know the truth of it, go to your friend/ family member or whoever it is, and ask them if it hurt to think about adoption back when they were going through infertility and trying to have a biological child. See what they say.

I'm astounded that you continue to insist you are an authority on other peoples feelings.

You are not.

There is nothing unique about infertility that makes it a unifying condition/experience. I wouldn't dream of sitting here and telling people I have universal knowledge of the feelings of everybody who shares my trauma and challenges. Why do you insist that you do?

Changeyncchange · 29/11/2022 16:10

Flapjackquack · 29/11/2022 16:06

The only small subsection of dissension here is you.

That was my point.

Mumsnet is not a bastion of diversity, even if you put that aside it's called selection bias.

A thread saying "I don't like this thing" is far more likely to attract people who agree rather than people who disagree or don't care.

Also Internet communities are echo chambers by nature.

Finally lots of people just don't do online discussion and support at all.

rippleraspberry · 29/11/2022 16:07

@Changeyncchange I am simply giving you a suggestion based on my own experience about how your friends/ family going through infertility might actually be feeling, underneath their polite responses to you. There is no need to take such offence.

When people ask me these questions, I do talk to them, and I'm grateful for their interest and I know that it comes from a good place. They would have no idea that I secretly wish they were not asking me these questions, because I'm a pretty open person and I appreciate people caring and being interested.

I would of course have been 'perfectly capable' of telling them that it hurt to think about adoption, but I probably wouldn't do that, because they were trying to be supportive to me and they are people I like and care about.

You actually don't know about the internal worlds of your friends and family going through infertility - and I probably actually do have a pretty good insight in terms of that. In my 3 years of struggling with this, I have spoken to countless other people going through the same or similar, and I have never heard anyone say they were pleased when adoption/ fostering was raised and they were made to talk about it.

It just bloody hurts. Every time you say 'have you thought about adoption?' you are reminding that person that they might not be successful in having a biological child. That's not something they want to think about.

Anyway, if you really want to know the truth of it, go to your friend/ family member or whoever it is, and ask them if it hurt to think about adoption back when they were going through infertility and trying to have a biological child. See what they say.

Flapjackquack · 29/11/2022 16:06

Changeyncchange · 29/11/2022 15:58

If you know very little about infertility, I recommend that you listen to the lived experiences of people who do, before spouting opinions about what they need

Firstly I have.

Secondly I hate the term people with lived experience, it's the most condescending phrase in the world and also implies that there is consensus among groups when actually there is almost always a diversity of opinion.

Finally you are not asking me to "listen to PwLE" but to listen to the ones you agree with. The very small subsection of those people who you engage with who are likely very similar to yourself.

Just because you friend and family members answer your questions politely, does not that your questions are in any way helpful or pleasant for them

It's really grating that you feel the need to patronise my friends and family by implying that they cannot tell me how they feel themselves. They are perfectly capable of telling me and anybody else if they are hurt. Again it goes back to projection and assuming because you and your particular echo chamber feel a certain way you can speak on behalf of everybody.

If you want to support someone going through it, just listen and empathise. Dont try to suggest solutions - because they are the expert. They know 100 times more than you and it only increases the frustration to go round the houses again and again

Again, stop telling me how to engage with my friends and family. You don't know them. Infertility is not a defining characteristic that confers you superior knowledge of complete strangers feelings and relationships because they share that characteristic.

It's the equivalent of asking a professional plumber fixing a leak if they've tried turning off the tap. Of course they bloody have.

Indeed, and I wouldn't take offence.

The only small subsection of dissension here is you.