Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

It is not natural for men to look after babies and possibly young children.

246 replies

TheYChromosome · 29/11/2022 05:01

I shall start by saying I’m not asking for advice. Also before people pile in and either start bashing men or suggesting solutions this thread is not actually for that.

I have a baby 9m and DH has been looking after her since she was 8 weeks. I’m back at work.

So he is really the main care giver and spends with DC most of the time. Despite of that, she in general settles better with me and now we hit the separation anxiety it’s me that she clings to.

Really ideally there would be men on here and I would be interested to hear their take on it l. But as there aren’t many men perhaps the army of women can share their observations and experiences how there DHs find being around babies.

Really the point of this thread is to get a window into how men feel when they look after young children.

I find DH although he loves our DC he finds it difficult to look after her. As an extension of that when ever I’m not working he prefers me taking care of her as I think he finds it draining more than I do.

So again, point of this thread is to get some more insights into how easy or difficult men find it too look after babies. If there are men reading this please do comment.

I know, I know - we are a modern society and generally quite forward thinking, but…. Are there some natural biological inclinations that just will never fully change. All we can do is try to understand better and facilitate better.

OP posts:
talkingmorenonsense · 29/11/2022 07:44

Research papers clearly show that men can care for children, just as well as women. It’s not gender that makes a difference.

Flabbers · 29/11/2022 07:44

Pictograph · 29/11/2022 05:10

Yes, it is tiring looking after a small baby and I'm not surprised that he likes to hand her to you when you're not working. I think many women would agree with that. Perhaps the issue is more that working men are less likely to agree to that, and more assertive at protecting their free time?

Exactly this

FancyFanny · 29/11/2022 07:42

I do think that there is a biological difference between men and women and an innate instinct in women to care for and take on that role. That's not to say that women find it easier or that men can't do that role just as well, or that there aren't women and men that don't possess a typical reaction to children.

IWantToBeACat · 29/11/2022 07:42

I'm not maternal at all. I was a SAHM and an able and competent caregiver for my daughter. My husband on the other hand, total and utterly fabulous, loving and 100% hands-on, natural daddy... He would come in from work and take over, do the night shift on the weekends. Get up early and have breakfast with her so I could get some sleep until he went to work. WE decided to have a child, so WE have raised her. Luckily he was of the same opinion, but there's no way I would tolerate what some of the women on MN accept.

SleeplessInEngland · 29/11/2022 07:39

I suspect most dads feel the same as mums - if the baby’s ‘easy’ then it’s nice, if the baby’s ‘tough’ then it’s a sleep-deprived hell. Breastfeeding notwithstanding it’s pure luck of the draw who the baby will respond better to.

badbaduncle · 29/11/2022 07:36

DH was much better than me. I cannot cope with no sleep and DS had severe reflux, I swear I can still hear the relentless screaming 18 years later!
I was much better with tweens and teenagers.

user564576 · 29/11/2022 07:35

DH definitely found it hard and didn't enjoy it, but cracked on with it, and I was exactly the same. I wasn't the "natural mother" I was supposed to be. We muddled along until they got to a more manageable age, we both much preferred it when they could talk and explain what they needed!

Bestcatmum · 29/11/2022 07:35

Simonjt · 29/11/2022 05:05

We’re both men, our daughter has been home since she was around two months old, it isn’t at all difficult caring for her (obviously tiring at times). Babies and children often go through phases of having a favourite, at the moment I seem to be the favourite despite being the one at work while my husband has been on leave for the past five months.

Is one of you the biological dad Simonjt. Do you think that makes a difference?

PurpleBananaSmoothie · 29/11/2022 07:34

Looking after a baby all day, everyday is draining. The dynamic when there’s two of you at weekends is completely different and taking a day off to look after DC just isn’t going to give you an idea of the relentlessness as it’s actually novel. To see how draining it is, take a week off work and send DH out without you for the time you’d be at work. You will almost certainly want to hand DC over when he comes home. It has nothing to do with you handling it better, it’s that you haven’t done it. When you do it, you might have a personality that can deal with the relentlessness more because some people do deal with it better but it’s not related to you being a woman.

DD was equally attached to me and DH when she was born. Even in the early days DH was the one who could settle her because I smelt of breast milk. Babies have their favourites and that changes regularly.

Bestcatmum · 29/11/2022 07:33

I have a savage maternal instinct that I've always had and I don't want to share by baby. I was a single mum so I didn't have to. Luckily he hasn't grown up to be Norman Bates haha.
Out of my friends I know two dad's who are patient and kind with their small children andook after them equally. The rest don't and don't have much patience with them.

Brefugee · 29/11/2022 07:31

not RTFT but: i didn't find it at all easy to look after babies, never played with dolls and ignored younger siblings.
DH has lots of siblings with children and grew up in a big messy family.

It came very easy to him and hugely difficult to me.

It's not down to biology. And while you're not looking for solutions: until everyone stops shoving all things baby/child on women and making men out to be heroes if they do a millionth of the work things will nver change.

ReneBumsWombats · 29/11/2022 07:29

I think he finds it draining more than I do.

You aren't the main carer so of course you're less drained by it.

It's exhausting for everyone. Stop promoting this nonsense that women aren't also exhausted by sleep deprivation, noise and constant attention.

MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 29/11/2022 07:28

It's a personality thing. Some people are more nurturing than others. It isn't about their sex.

PinkPomeranian · 29/11/2022 07:24

My husband is a fully functioning parent. We were quite keen for one of us to stay at home with the kids before they started school and he would have been very happy to have done that had he not been the one with higher earning potential. I've breastfed the kids but other than that he definitely doesn't need any input from me to meet their needs (although the scheduling that comes with older kids isn't his forte). He doesn't consider it part of helping me out, just something he needs and wants to do so maybe he's more willing to take initiative.

VestaTilley · 29/11/2022 07:24

@Guiltycat I agree with you - particularly on surrogacy.

VestaTilley · 29/11/2022 07:22

YABU. I’m a woman and I found looking after my newborn hard, exhausting, relentless and I was, quite frankly, regretful. (I’m not now).

DH wasn’t great either - but it’s not because women are naturally better at being with children, it’s because thousands of years of socialization have raised us in the caring role, and we are basically groomed from being young girls in to being more nurturing and gentle.

There are female hormones that are supposed to help us wake up more to feed a baby, but I never found them particularly useful at making me more able to cope with wakings!

electricmoccasins · 29/11/2022 07:19

In terms of personality traits, women are more likely to score highly on ‘agreeableness’. For this reason, women are sometimes better suited to childcare as it is linked with altruism. However, some men are highly ‘agreeable’ and some women not, so it isn’t that simple.

RambamThankyouMam · 29/11/2022 07:18

Purely anecdotal here, but DH is much better with Dd than me. He has qualifications in childcare, and way more patience!

SnoozyLucy7 · 29/11/2022 07:18

There are no different biological inclinations when it comes to men looking after children. Looking after babies is completely life changing and often completely exhausting. If you had been the parent staying at home you might observe your self to behave and feel exactly the same way your partner does.

I know that the moment my husband would come home from work, I would hand him the baby as I was exhausted.

I think often, still, there is this assumed supposed difference between how men and women look after their children, e.g assuming the woman is always the nurturing one - often she’s not, which in turn gives the man the excuse to be less involved. Which in turn is a complete cop out. And so these negative gender roles get perpetuated.

MushMonster · 29/11/2022 07:17

I am a woman. I found looking after a baby difficult. I loved it, but it is very tiring and challenging, worrying, scary at times...
I think babies get clingy with their mothers because they carry the food.
Otherwise, mine loved her father, he was her favourite and I am her "slave" lol

CoalCraft · 29/11/2022 07:17

RampantIvy · 29/11/2022 07:03

I don't think there's any biological reason why a man can't be just as good a parent as a woman. It's clearly socialisation.

Except for breastfeeding.

Implying women who can't or don't want to breastfeed are inherently worse parents that those who can and do.

maddiemookins16mum · 29/11/2022 07:15

DH was better at feeding (bottle fed), dressing, poonami nappies and was the 100% choice for bedtime stories (it was the voices I think).
I was the best at getting her to sleep in her cot.

However, DH was pretty useless at toilet training (he never ‘saw’ the pulling at clothes or the moment they freeze when having a poo in their pants).

Lcb123 · 29/11/2022 07:13

I think it totally depends on the individual (parents and children). No one is naturally a parent - we learn as and when it happens.

Dervel · 29/11/2022 07:12

I’m a man, and a separated parent. I had care of my son on my own for stretches up until 5 months when overnights started from there we rapidly reached a shared care arrangement. I also did all the day care for long stretches whilst Mum was working.

He’d look to me for comfort most of the time, and I could settle him very quickly. I for my part really enjoyed caring for him. We have a very strong bond now, which I credit very much to how present I’ve been in his life.

Perhaps you might be right in that across averages Mums do nurture incredibly well. However there are outliers like me. Wether that’s down to something intrinsic or cultural I have no idea.

In my own case two obvious points I can think of is a) my own father was absent and eventually left us which I remember acutely, I was NEVER going to have a child of mine grow up with an absent or emotionally detached Dad, b) I’m also something of a non-conformist and very much dance to my own tune. Fatherhood, was always something I was going to commit to and to the best of my ability.

Another caveat is my son was remarkably easy as a baby, I found I could sleep when he slept. He settled pretty quickly, took a bottle well, keeping him fed, rested and clean wasn’t all that challenging to be honest. However I appreciate babies can vary, wether I would have done quite so well with a more challenging baby I honestly don’t know. I remember those times as a pure joy. I also think because of the shared care situation I got plenty of down time to myself. So he really got a fully recharged and alert version of me too. Although I did miss him terribly when he wasn’t with me.

Maybe the take home is what is unnatural is “one” person being primary. I could see how being solely responsible as much as you love your child could grind you down wether you are a man or woman. I think childcare is best done as a team effort. It sounds like despite working full time you have probably prioritised the time you have had with yours to preserve a strong bond. Maybe that’s a quality of what you have done more so than just being a female. Also I’ve seen setups where the child had favoured the father more, but maybe in those instances mothers presence was a relied upon constant, and child was fully secure, and the separation anxiety is more reserved for the parent who is away more if you see what I mean?

Anyway if you have any questions feel free.

OhForDuckSake · 29/11/2022 07:11

"an extension of that when ever I’m not working he prefers me taking care of her as I think he finds it draining more than"

I'm a woman and I also expected dh to take over when he got home. it's not less draining for Person B. But person A is already totally drained

Swipe left for the next trending thread