Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

It is not natural for men to look after babies and possibly young children.

246 replies

TheYChromosome · 29/11/2022 05:01

I shall start by saying I’m not asking for advice. Also before people pile in and either start bashing men or suggesting solutions this thread is not actually for that.

I have a baby 9m and DH has been looking after her since she was 8 weeks. I’m back at work.

So he is really the main care giver and spends with DC most of the time. Despite of that, she in general settles better with me and now we hit the separation anxiety it’s me that she clings to.

Really ideally there would be men on here and I would be interested to hear their take on it l. But as there aren’t many men perhaps the army of women can share their observations and experiences how there DHs find being around babies.

Really the point of this thread is to get a window into how men feel when they look after young children.

I find DH although he loves our DC he finds it difficult to look after her. As an extension of that when ever I’m not working he prefers me taking care of her as I think he finds it draining more than I do.

So again, point of this thread is to get some more insights into how easy or difficult men find it too look after babies. If there are men reading this please do comment.

I know, I know - we are a modern society and generally quite forward thinking, but…. Are there some natural biological inclinations that just will never fully change. All we can do is try to understand better and facilitate better.

OP posts:
freyamay74 · 29/11/2022 22:19

@Onnabugeisha well said.

ReallyDarling · 29/11/2022 22:09

Sorry to derail but I'd love an AMA from a man working in the baby room of a nursery @Mysterian ...

p.s. that is incredible role modeling for the little ones. I would absolutely pay more to send my kids somewhere with male/female caregivers. It sincerely troubles me that my preschool aged youngest has never seen a female builder or male caregiver at pre school.

TheGuv1982 · 29/11/2022 22:04

For me personally, I found caring for the kids as babies and toddlers very easy and natural.

As they’ve got older, especially as my daughter approaches her teens, things become much more challenging as a bloke - I don’t understand the hormones, how I should handle the moods and what I should and shouldn’t say.

Abouttimemum · 29/11/2022 22:03

Onnabugeisha · 29/11/2022 21:59

That’s not the point. Of course I wouldn’t be fine handing my baby off to a stranger. The point is there is no special, mystical bond between mother and baby. We make those bonds. It’s not automatic, or instinct, or whatever higher power you want to give credit for what is literally a labour of love.

The special, natural mother baby bond that develops in the womb is an ancient patriarchy mythos to keep a woman in her place, as the primary caregiver of her children. Along with the view that it’s “unnatural” if a mother isn’t primary carer for her baby/toddler because that defies the mystical, special bond and harms the baby. So sick of this mythos and it seems to be having a resurgence with the 4th trimester BS going around these days.

Bang on! Also just gives the useless men another excuse to not pull their weight really.

Abouttimemum · 29/11/2022 22:02

DH is much better with babies than I am. That’s just a fact. I just don’t find them at all interesting! However I think we both bring different skills to the raising a child party, which is a good thing for our son.

Onnabugeisha · 29/11/2022 21:59

Anymanyall · 29/11/2022 21:49

@Onnabugeisha so you would be fine with handing over your baby to someone else and raising a random baby? If it’s ‘only’ that baby recognises voices but no other links and everything is built after birth as you say

That’s not the point. Of course I wouldn’t be fine handing my baby off to a stranger. The point is there is no special, mystical bond between mother and baby. We make those bonds. It’s not automatic, or instinct, or whatever higher power you want to give credit for what is literally a labour of love.

The special, natural mother baby bond that develops in the womb is an ancient patriarchy mythos to keep a woman in her place, as the primary caregiver of her children. Along with the view that it’s “unnatural” if a mother isn’t primary carer for her baby/toddler because that defies the mystical, special bond and harms the baby. So sick of this mythos and it seems to be having a resurgence with the 4th trimester BS going around these days.

MugginsOverEre · 29/11/2022 21:53

I was a SAHM, I breastfed all three kids and their dad worked full time.

And I still think he maybe changed more nappies than I did!

Our eldest is almost 16 now and DH is just as much a parent as me. He settled the babies better than I could (daddy's magic hands could get wind out in a heartbeat whereas I would be patting backs of screaming babes for ages.) They settled is his arms in an instant but I can't blame them cos one minute snuggled up with him and I'm fast asleep too.

Kids, particularly toddlers of even strangers gravitate towards him. I recall we were at a swimming lesson once and a wee girl, maybe a year and a half old kept coming up to say hello and hand her Peppa Pig toys to him. When it was time to go, she brought DH her coat and he ended up holding it for her to put on. He just acted on instinct and did it with a big smile for her. He's a natural with children of all ages.

Anymanyall · 29/11/2022 21:49

@Onnabugeisha so you would be fine with handing over your baby to someone else and raising a random baby? If it’s ‘only’ that baby recognises voices but no other links and everything is built after birth as you say

Onnabugeisha · 29/11/2022 21:44

Anymanyall · 29/11/2022 21:36

@ChillysWaterBottle this is an utterly ridiculous view I don't think there's a biological or inherent component at all

if this was really the case then we could just pop all the babies into a common nursery and randomly hand them out to people as they leave the hospital. After all if there is no biological or inherent link between mother and baby , baby and mother then it wouldn’t matter who raises what child!

Babies recognise their mum and dads voices at birth. Beyond that there is no inherent bond between mother/father and baby at birth. It is all built after birth.

Thereisnolight · 29/11/2022 21:40

pollyglot · 29/11/2022 05:56

Nearly 50 years ago, DH and I swapped roles...he stayed home with DC and I returned to work when baby was 5 months. It was a pretty revolutionary thing to do back then...hard to explain to anyone under 60, but i earned a lot more, and had a more secure job. We switched baby's sleep times...DC slept during the day, and was raring to go when I got home after 5 pm. I spent all evening with baby, and then did the work I'd brought home after 11 pm. On weekends, husband reverted to "male role". That was his time - I did the cooking, laundry, housework he hadn't done during the week, and he sat with his mates for a beer while i did the catering. DC2 and 3, he worked, did no housework, no shopping, no night feeds, no brainwork. I worked p/t, and studied to make me more employable. He was fine with babies, and attending to their physical needs, so long as they didn't irritate him. But had no idea how to handle toddlers and resorted to smacking rather than taking the patient route. That was his role modelling from his own childhood, but there was nothing "instinctual" about how he parented. He was probably not typical of male parenting, even for those benighted times, but I would definitely agree that men do not find it so easy, in the majority of cases.

Crikey you literally did everything.

Anymanyall · 29/11/2022 21:36

@ChillysWaterBottle this is an utterly ridiculous view I don't think there's a biological or inherent component at all

if this was really the case then we could just pop all the babies into a common nursery and randomly hand them out to people as they leave the hospital. After all if there is no biological or inherent link between mother and baby , baby and mother then it wouldn’t matter who raises what child!

Paq · 29/11/2022 19:59

Babies bond with their mothers in the womb so men are at a disadvantage at birth. However, my DH was the main carer for all three of his children, two with his XW and one with me. He had energy, patience and responsiveness in spades.

Men can do it when they have to but I agree that evolution probably means more women than men are suited to caring for very tiny babies (excluding the breastfeeding factor).

lookslikeabombhitit · 29/11/2022 19:52

My husband is by far the most preferred parent by our kids. He's got far more patience than me, plays with them (I cannot for the life of me do imaginative play for more than 2 minutes without dying of boredom). He's done the bulk of the childcare for them all when I returned to work between 9-12 months until they were 2-3 yo. Our youngest is now at nursery full time and DH isn't a fan as he feels like he's lost his purpose a bit. Admittedly he's rubbish at the practical stuff so as soon as they're injured or sick or need something for school etc they all gravitate to me.

I think most people find parenting hard, especially full time. I, really naively, didn't expect having kids to be so utterly life changing in all aspects. I was the idiot who thought they'd just fit in around us. 😂🤦🏼‍♀️ He's taken to that disruption far better than I have!

ChillysWaterBottle · 29/11/2022 19:48

I don't think there's a biological or inherent component at all. I think it very, very much depends on the individual. There are plenty of nurturing men out there and plenty of non-maternal women!

5128gap · 29/11/2022 19:44

Like you, I worked, my DP stayed at home. Like you I felt DC settled better with me and that I coped better. With the wisdom of hindsight I can see he did a great job, and it was my own discomfort at breaking away from the role I was socialised to do that made me look for signs of his failings, and indications that I was the preferred and better parent. As we are taught as women we should be.

Mangolist · 29/11/2022 19:37

My dh looked after our son until he was 5 as I was the main earner. He was much much better at the childcare than me, and the 22 year old we have now is close to us both. Some women aren't 'natural' caregivers, difficult as that may be to admit.

Onnabugeisha · 29/11/2022 19:34

PuttingDownRoots · 29/11/2022 05:55

I think SAHD is more isolating than SAHM. Being the only male at baby or toddler group, less chance of a friend being off at the same time... just generally feeling the odd one out.

It is. When my DH was a SAHD he had some horrible experiences. Baby/toddler groups suddenly became “mum groups” with no men allowed. Neighbourhood playground dates he was made unwelcome. Mums would not let their toddlers play with our toddlers. Comments constantly about being a deadbeat dad with a sugar mama, or a kept man, etc.

Onnabugeisha · 29/11/2022 19:29

I haven’t read the thread yet, will do so after initial reply to the OP

It is not natural for men to look after babies and possibly young children.

I do not agree.

I have a baby 9m and DH has been looking after her since she was 8 weeks. I’m back at work. So he is really the main care giver and spends with DC most of the time. Despite of that, she in general settles better with me and now we hit the separation anxiety it’s me that she clings to.

Im sure she clings to him when you are at work. The thing is the working parent quickly becomes the favourite parent.

I find DH although he loves our DC he finds it difficult to look after her. As an extension of that when ever I’m not working he prefers me taking care of her as I think he finds it draining more than I do.

Well he has her all day M-F and that is difficult for anyone, mum or dad. As the working parent you get a daily escape. Yes work is work, but it has more variety.

My DH was the SAHD for our 4 DCs. I was back to work after 12 weeks with each of them.

neverbeenskiing · 29/11/2022 19:06

DH is a much more 'natural' parent than I am. I'm a good Mum, but that's because I work at it.

Kanaloa · 29/11/2022 18:40

And the night time waking was just an example. And I’m not suggesting men shouldn’t get up. It’s more ok, I agree it’s tougher for you but you still will have to do it, but maybe less nights than me, for example….

Oh darling, I know cleaning is harder for you, but you still need to have a little go sweetie pie, less than me of course! I’ll do the majority of it!!! I’ll lie down on the middle floor, just step on my back, it’s easier for meeeee!!!

No. why should men do less work raising their children? Why? What special natural abilities do men have that will result in less work for women?

EVERYONE finds it exhausting to have nights of broken sleep with a fussy baby. EVERY. ONE.

LSSG · 29/11/2022 18:28

I find that DH is very willing and able, doesn't find looking after children of any age daunting (appreciate many others aren't like this) however as far as the children are concerned, yes most of the time they just want their mum (for now)! 7y/o and baby.

CristinaNov182 · 29/11/2022 16:18

My DH is better with my DD then me, he has a calm and warm nature, he distracts her, makes her laugh when she gets in a mood, etc. I lose my patience faster, but I’ve learned from him, still learning tbh.

we both have had moments of stress or being fed up, but that happens rarely and then in that moment the one that is not that stressed picks up the slack

he’s not the only man I’ve seen being good with kids, his cousins are the same, my grandfather was great, etc

its just your husband and ofc other men too, it’s not something that it’s not in a “man’s nature”

Namenic · 29/11/2022 15:53

@TheYChromosome - it is 1 strategy - split tasks on what each person finds easier - so overall you get things done more efficiently. BUT make sure that if he is doing less childcare, he does more cleaning/cooking/laundry/life admin to make up for it (as you will then being working you job plus taking on some childcare).

another way of looking at it is that baby may need more time to get used to DH, so he should spend MORE time with her/him (while you take on more cleaning/cooking etc). This may initially be hard, but may get easier as baby adjusts. This has a benefit of it being easier for either of you to travel to events etc and leave baby with the other parent).

i don’t think it really matters what the pattern in the general population is. It matters more how it works for you and your DH personally - a split that is fair and works well.

Dervel · 29/11/2022 15:43

On the topic of night wakings as a man I did it because I HAD to do it. If I didn’t then it didn’t get done, and I obviously didn’t want my baby to suffer. The solution was having no safety net of Mum there picking up the slack!

If I was tired I’d make sure to catch zzzs when baby was asleep. I’m not historically an easy riser but being a sole carer focused the mind somewhat.

However I wouldn’t complain as the upside is that I didn’t need permission to make my own parenting decisions. I see a lot of blokes deferring to the mothers, rather than make parenting decisions equally as a team. I’ve been at liberty to really explore what parenting properly means and to do it to the best of my ability/vales.

GnomeDePlume · 29/11/2022 14:21

On the night time waking - when oldest was tiny (6 weeks onwards) and both DH and I were at work we took turns. One night on and one night off. We both remember how much we appreciated that approach. On the night on we would know we would get a decent night's sleep the next night. On nights off the bliss of thinking 'not my turn'.

Something which helped DH in being SAHP (he took on this role when youngest was born) was that his family is very warm and affectionate. They are definitely huggers.

My family is not like this. Quite formal and often quite remote. Also often quite critical.

DH took pride in being SAHP. He saw it as his job and did it well. All major housework was done during the day leaving weekends free for family activities.