Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Advise with a 'white' fib apparently

90 replies

nc4this111 · 29/11/2022 01:25

Background, newly married having been together 6 yrs.

Dh put his house on the market several months ago and it sold quickly, however it's been a long 6 mths with the solicitors and buyers .. one thing after another ... he had a call last week to say they will be arranging a completion date soon , so Friday I ask if he'd heard anything 'no nothing' this evening I saw a email when it came through while he was holding his phone from the estate agent.. I didn't say anything.. an hr or so later I asked if he had heard anything from them 'no nothing but I'm sure I will soon, that's what they said'

I stewed on it for an hour... i was quiet , he asked what was wrong , I said I didn't want an argument but I had ask if you had heard anything and you said no but I saw you had an email from them , he didn't know what to do raised his voice , so I did I said you have lied to me and what was it, he then admitted it was a proposed exchange date and he was to call them tomorrow to confirm , he then showed me the email.

Why did he not tell me ? Hes saying he wanted to have it confirmed tomorrow and surprise me , I'm not buying that one bit, if the shoe was on the other foot I'd have told him straight away , I gave him the opportunity to tell me when I asked if he heard from them and he said he hadn't .. he apologised and said he should have said.. I'm not buying it , I feel hurt , he tried to turn it round , said if I don't trust him then what's the point of being married , I pinged that back and said in a marriage surely you would tell your wife if your house has a completion date. What else has he or could he lie about , he said it was only a white lie , it's really thrown me. He got all shitty and said well if you don't trust me I may as well go back to the house , I said you'd best think about pulling out the sale then .. I don't get it one bit, he then goes on to say that because it's been so tough with all the hassle which we have both been in it together , why when he gets this news he keeps it to himself .. I'm I making a mountain out of a miles hill here ? He knows how much I value trust in a relationship

OP posts:
LindseyHoyleSpeaks · 29/11/2022 07:46

All these people defending a liar. And then you wonder why so many women get stuck with useless wankers…? He’s a liar - like it or not, he lied. Big or small in your judgement, he lied. I don’t do lies.

user1471447924 · 29/11/2022 07:43

Goodness me what a drama queen you are.

winteriscoming2022 · 29/11/2022 07:40

This is exactly how my Exh started with the 'white lies' near the beginning of our marriage. A lie is a lie, if your h did not want to discuss it with you he could easily have said ' Yes. I've had an email but I'm not getting my hopes up and tbh don't want to talk about it anymore until it's done and dusted'
When I look back I think it gave my ex a feeling of power that he knew something I didn't if that makes sense, like he was 'one up'. In the end lying was just second nature, 'Have you eaten?' 'No I wasn't hungry earlier' Then I see pots in sink from him cooking....... It made no sense, I think some people just lie
Sorry if that sounds a lot of projection but I will never since go near anyone who I know tells lies

SquishyGloopyBum · 29/11/2022 07:39

I don't get the responses on here.

It's such a stupid/weird thing to lie about why do it. I'm not surprised you feel how you do. His reaction to be defensive is also not good.

I was brought up and told little white lies all my life. It's a form of gaslighting to me and I hate any form of lying now.

JayJayYoYo · 29/11/2022 07:33

You sound hard work. Why didn’t you tell him you saw the email? Trying to trap someone isn’t an attractive quality. Maybe he thinks the same and is planning on leaving you once the sale goes through?

Crazyinlove123 · 29/11/2022 07:32

are there trust issues? I would find it annoying especially if you both have been waiting a while for the sale to be completed and the lying to your face. But his reaction of “I will just move back in” says a lot. Perhaps he didn’t want to talk about it because he is sad about selling.

Anniegetyourgun · 29/11/2022 07:29

I don't understand any of these replies. Not one of them. Why lie? There's no need for it. He could say well I've had an email but I'm not getting my hopes up, or some other honest way of managing the OP's expectation. Lying is completely unnecessary and as far as I can see in this situation it does nobody any good - ergo, honesty should be the first choice, even if it doesn't do any particular harm either. Ex was a terrible one for "I didn't want to upset you" when either it wouldn't have upset me so what the heck was he on about, or if I actually gave a fuck about the thing it was because it was something I did actually need to know and would eventually find out anyway. I think he just liked to keep me in ignorance for some weird power game I didn't even know we were playing.

Lying to your spouse should NEVER be the default reaction IMO. There may be cases when it's justified but this really doesn't sound like one of them.

Peasepuddingbloodycold · 29/11/2022 07:27

There's trust and then there's paranoia.

I can’t make this sentence make sense.

704703hey · 29/11/2022 07:27

Sometimes you just want to finish something before you say.

Don't give him a hard time.

ApolloandDaphne · 29/11/2022 07:25

I have things I sometimes don't tell my DH for a while because I just can't be bothered with the effort of going over old ground again. It's not lying, it's just waiting and gathering the energy to face whatever it is. Your DH is probably fed up with having to talk about the situation with his house every day and was just waiting to have some concrete information to give you.

moleeye · 29/11/2022 07:24

Drama Llama much 😂

Sprouttreesareamazing · 29/11/2022 07:24

Keeping it to himself was fine initially but once asked, and asked again and the lying to your face isn't great. My dh would have said he had been going to wait until he knew for sure but because I asked he would tell me... Lying regardless is insulting and deceitful...

BeautifulWar · 29/11/2022 07:20

I agree with pps.

Selling a house is so frustrating and fraught. Unless there's some massive back story about your DH lying, I don't get your reaction.

I do think your reaction explains your husband's omission, somewhat. You sound intense.

Flavabobble · 29/11/2022 07:15

he apologised and said he should have said.. I'm not buying it , I feel hurt

I don't understand why you couldn't have just accepted his apology over something so minor - (unless you're going to drip-feed a backstory.)

He's probably had more than one similar email that has amounted to nothing, you massively overreacted.

Dragonskin · 29/11/2022 07:14

But a proposed exchange date means absolutely nothing, as we all know that even on the day things can change. It isn't really good news until exchange has happened and the completion date is fixed.

Personally I think you are being a bit weird about this

Scepticalwotsits · 29/11/2022 07:07

DDivaStar · 29/11/2022 05:44

Maybe he's fed up.of this daily conversation. Its a long drawn.out process and delays are likely, he was waiting fir something more concrete before telling you.

You must have been stood next to him staring at his phone to see who that email was from.

It sounds like you have trust issues and he is finding the constant monitoring of him too much.

Pretty much my view on it here. If you monitor someone to the nth degree they feel invaded and as such will often hide what they are doing even when it’s not an issue, which then feeds into the trust cycle and things get worse.

it sounds like OP is very paranoid about what her husband is doing.

Scepticalwotsits · 29/11/2022 07:05

Billybagpuss · 29/11/2022 05:18

I think his reaction to the lie is the telling thing here. If he’s been keeping quiet to surprise you when he was called out he would have got all excited and said yes I was waiting until it was confirmed but things are finally moving and you could dance around the hous le a bit.

but he got arsy and defensive why? Is he not happy. I think there is definitely a conversation to be had today.

Tbh when people get called out on many things they don’t always act rationally.

while it’s easy to say if they were this they would do that from the sidelines it’s not always as easy as that. People are messy complex creatures.

MichelleScarn · 29/11/2022 07:03

this evening I saw a email when it came through while he was holding his phone from the estate agent..
Where did you see this email? On the phone he was holding (you must have been on top of each other!) or another device?

Shemovesshemoves21 · 29/11/2022 06:48

I don't understand, to me you're being completely over the top.

You say you've talked about this every day - that's a lot. It's quite possible he's exhausted by the whole thing and wanted to make sure it went ahead before telling you.

Why do you think there's another motive to him not telling you?

As for him shouting at you and throwing our things like "Maybe I'll go back to the house" - people say stupid shit when they're angry.

Quite honestly, unless there's some huge backstory, you're being ridiculous.

Zanatdy · 29/11/2022 06:33

Pictograph · 29/11/2022 05:34

OP, I feel like I'm missing something. You say that you're "not buying" his explanation that he wanted to tell you tomorrow when it was confirmed. But I can't think of any other possible explanation? What are you accusing him of - do you suspect him of another motive, and if so what?

Agree. What other reason is there for not telling you? Do you think he is getting cold feet? Unless there is a back story I can’t imagine that there’s any other reason

chikp · 29/11/2022 06:31

Did he keep bringing up the house sale or was it you bringing it up every day? It's possible he is feeling a bit sad about it so just didn't want to chat about it?

KangarooKenny · 29/11/2022 06:27

There’s no such thing as a white lie, there’s the truth or a lie. He lied. You’ll never trust him again.

DDivaStar · 29/11/2022 05:44

nc4this111 · 29/11/2022 01:54

I'm just shocked that it's been a daily conversation and when he gets the green light he don't say anything, I find it really odd. We normally tell each other everything, we are normally so close so I feel floored that such a big thing he felt the need not to tell me , and the way he went off on one , I was calm until he started shouting so I raised my voice to him , I then left the room he then came to me and said so what do you want to do , if you don't trust me we can be together, I felt he tried to curve ball it to make me feel bad. He's obviously not at upset as me as I can hear him snoring through the ceiling!! I'm just pissed off that he didn't say , I'd have been whooohooo to him 'look what we have' yes we are all different but he soon discussed with me when we were hitting barriers , a bit of good news and is all hush hush .. part of me wishes to see what tomorrow what would have happened but too late for that now

Maybe he's fed up.of this daily conversation. Its a long drawn.out process and delays are likely, he was waiting fir something more concrete before telling you.

You must have been stood next to him staring at his phone to see who that email was from.

It sounds like you have trust issues and he is finding the constant monitoring of him too much.

DDivaStar · 29/11/2022 05:35

I think you're reaction to this says more than his.

Yes he could have said about the email, but I imagine over 6 months there have been lots of emails that have come to nothing, so no need to update you each time.

Why are you concerned hes not telling you? Do you not think he wants to share finances ?

Pictograph · 29/11/2022 05:34

OP, I feel like I'm missing something. You say that you're "not buying" his explanation that he wanted to tell you tomorrow when it was confirmed. But I can't think of any other possible explanation? What are you accusing him of - do you suspect him of another motive, and if so what?