Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think China is still locking down

179 replies

mumofgirl1 · 28/11/2022 21:19

Sorry if this has already be posted about I was just watching the local news and they where covering recent lockdowns in China I'm shocked they are still implementing lockdowns and wondered how there economy is coping nearly 3yrs down the line of lockdowns and what has happened to the vaccines over there have they not worked. It seems so strange when the rest of the world are coming out the other side of this and they are still putting local lockdowns in place surely they can't do this forever

OP posts:
DroppedLeaves · 29/11/2022 12:02

They have actually relaxed measures in recent weeks. Before they were taking covid cases, close contact AND second tier contact cases to centralised quarantine facilities. Now only covid cases and close contacts are removed. We have several teachers and pupils in centralised quarantine at the moment as they are close contacts.

DroppedLeaves · 29/11/2022 11:59

HeraldicBlazoning · 29/11/2022 11:56

That is horrendous, @DroppedLeaves . How long did they keep you locked in for? I just can't get my head around a society which thinks that potentially hundreds of people dying in a fire is better than a few of them getting covid.

We were locked down for 48 hours about 20th March, and could finally leave our compound in June. For a large tranche of that we were actually confined to our apartment, as my son picked up covid going down for our daily PCR. We were very lucky that he wasn’t taken away to a covid camp. We had been told he would be, but luckily they were overwhelmed with cases at the time and so they never came to pick him up.

DroppedLeaves · 29/11/2022 11:56

However, I’d also say that covid measures aside, I’ve been here for several years and Shanghai is a great place to live and work. The lifestyle is excellent. Everyone is hoping that the government further relax their covid policies soon.

HeraldicBlazoning · 29/11/2022 11:56

DroppedLeaves · 29/11/2022 11:48

I live in Shanghai and we had the most awful lock down earlier this year. We too were locked in to our 62 floor apartment block and had the fire escape welded and front door chained. My workplace had to provide food parcels! It was horrific. I am watching the figures slowly tick up and hoping that we don’t have lockdown #2 ahead of us.

That is horrendous, @DroppedLeaves . How long did they keep you locked in for? I just can't get my head around a society which thinks that potentially hundreds of people dying in a fire is better than a few of them getting covid.

DroppedLeaves · 29/11/2022 11:51

We are also still having frequent pcr tests. We were having them 5 times a week at school and once at weekends (we needed a 24 hour test to enter school - also a teacher), but now it’s more relaxed - we test Monday, Wednesday and Friday at school, and then once on Sundays. Most places require 48 hour pcr tests at the moment.

DroppedLeaves · 29/11/2022 11:48

I live in Shanghai and we had the most awful lock down earlier this year. We too were locked in to our 62 floor apartment block and had the fire escape welded and front door chained. My workplace had to provide food parcels! It was horrific. I am watching the figures slowly tick up and hoping that we don’t have lockdown #2 ahead of us.

Pikafee · 29/11/2022 11:46

In Shanghai right now - last summer (2021), you could get vaccines easily (Chinese nationals) but the older generation weren't getting them. The government was bribing people with free rice/oil etc to get a vaccine. However, nowadays it's pretty impossible with all the testing we have to do - if you get a vaccine, then you can't get tested for at least 24-48 hours or else you'll test positive. Not really worth being taken to quarantine just for getting a vaccine.

MilkyYay · 29/11/2022 11:39

Truffoiled good point. Although i think they'll culturally always struggle with western irreverence for state/leadership!

Truffoiled · 29/11/2022 11:36

HappinessAlley · 29/11/2022 11:34

The number of explanation marks can be a giveaway

Tbh I'm loathe to point out the propaganda flags, as it just helps them smooth their style for next time.

HappinessAlley · 29/11/2022 11:34

MilkyYay · 29/11/2022 11:29

The writing style of shasha to me just seems very obviously propagandistic, i assume the author is a social media employee of the Chinese state etc.

Also their attempts to show how well versed they were in mnetisms were crap Grin.

The number of explanation marks can be a giveaway

Roussette · 29/11/2022 11:33

Truffoiled · 29/11/2022 11:10

What do you think the protests against the government are about then?

And I don't believe you.

Neither do I

I imagine it's far far worse than we're being shown

which is why western reporters are being attacked and arrested

MilkyYay · 29/11/2022 11:29

The writing style of shasha to me just seems very obviously propagandistic, i assume the author is a social media employee of the Chinese state etc.

Also their attempts to show how well versed they were in mnetisms were crap Grin.

Puzzledandpissedoff · 29/11/2022 11:28

Tended to hear more about the principle rather than people actually coming out and saying they approved of the squeamish parts, iyswim

I can see exactly what you mean, SirMingeALot, and this is why so many of us write about the bigger picture - because while the principle can look pretty good in itself, the actual implementation raises issues which some (as you correctly say) prefer to gloss over

MrsMorrisey · 29/11/2022 11:23

TrixJax · 28/11/2022 21:39

They were showing a graph on news earlier and only 20% of over 80s and about 50% of over 60s have had at least 2 doses of the vaccine. The elderly are sceptical of modern medicine and ted to still use traditional Chinese medicine.

I'm surprised the Chinese Gov has not made vaccination compulsory in order to access lots of areas of society. Even some western democracies did that!

Australia did that. Bloody horrendous.

Truffoiled · 29/11/2022 11:10

shasha21 · 29/11/2022 04:44

Hi OP! I’m working in China at the moment. The news is quite exaggerated. There are lockdowns, but it’s not like it was in the UK. For example, in the cities people live in apartment complexes - loads of buildings inside a huge complex. If there are outbreaks, the one building where the outbreak is will be ‘locked down’ for 3 days while the people are tested each day. Once they are given the all clear they are free to go.

Legally, they must receive full pay for the time that they are locked down. (I got fully paid during the lockdown I experienced and so did my colleagues.)

If the outbreak gets out of control, they will lock down a bigger area (I.e the whole complex will be asked to stay in for 3 days - or the whole district when numbers start to spiral. They test daily and if no more positive cases they are freed asap).

There is an outbreak in the city I live in but we aren’t locked down. I’m a teacher and there will be covid tests done 2-3 times a week for all teachers and students so we know it’s safe to work and no cases in the school. People wear masks a lot still (not in schools though, just on public transport and in supermarkets. Free to use bars and restaurants as normal mask-free).

It is false that you aren’t allowed to travel between cities. It’s absolutely fine to travel as normal, but yes, you will be asked to download an app on your phone which shows that you haven’t been in any ‘high risk’ areas immediately before travel. If you have, you are just asked to take a test prior to departure. The results are all uploaded onto the app too, and there are small test centres scattered about everywhere so you can just pop in when you need to use one.

The news is obviously focussing on the very negative side but the news here does the same about the UK and USA! Watch the news at home and you think China is awful; watch the news here and it’s exactly the same about home. You have to be aware that the media very much picks and chooses what they report on to ensure that the country they aren’t so fond of doesn’t look great and their own country looks superior in whatever aspect!

Vaccine-wise, the general consensus (and official advice here) is that the mRNA technology used to make the vaccines abroad (like in the UK, Europe, etc) is very dangerous. It’s interesting because their own research says the same that those accused of being ‘anti-vaxxers’ say in the UK. Their vaccine is different. It seems to be just as effective in that it minimises symptoms but doesn’t make it impossible to get or transmit the virus (as with the vaccines back home).

In general, people here don’t really mind. The lockdowns are very few and far between, and they’re usually very short. The majority of the people I have spoken to feel that the irritation of occasional lockdowns are worth it to keep the vulnerable safe from covid. A few people think it’s stupid but I’d say that those people are very much outnumbered by those who feel it’s positive to be cautious in this way. (I’d say only about 15% of my friends and colleagues are negative about it, the rest feel it is positive.)

We feel sorry for them in the UK but they too feel sorry for us so it’s a really interesting experience to witness both sides!

Anyone has any questions feel free to ask! 😊

What do you think the protests against the government are about then?

And I don't believe you.

Justanotherlurker · 29/11/2022 11:10

I have relatives and friends in Shanghia and I recommend anyone in the west to look into what the Great Translation Movement have been highlighting over the past few years as they rely heavily on the language barrier in the west, and it punctures holes in the simplified narratives of lockdowns only lasting 3 days on full pay etc.

It is a combination of anti lockdown and anti CCP, what really started it was banner man

twitter.com/tgtm_official/status/1580475248176029696

He has obviously been 'dissapeared' but it hit a spot and was talked about a lot on WeChat, the CCP crushed any mention of it as they regularly do, so people was airdropping the message from the banner to others phones, the CCP put presure on apple to make a change to there phones to effectively disable airdropping to try and quash it

People neeed to realise that what does come out of china is from 1st tier cities (and the 3 day lock down is very generous boarding on 50 cent army rehotic), the 3rd tier cities and villages are a lot worse, people are scared of being put in the quarantine camps. All protesters had there QR code turned to red, they now can be 'legally' transferred to one of these camps and refused entry into certain districts/shops etc.

A good place to start for any westerner is The Great Translation Movement

twitter.com/TGTM_Official

ReadyForPumpkins · 29/11/2022 10:51

I'm hoping this isn't going to end like Tiananmen Square in 1989. Xi still has control of the military.

ReadyForPumpkins · 29/11/2022 10:51

My family is from Hong Kong so I might be biased. I think it's about President's Xi desire to control the population. Coronavirus gave him the perfect opportunity to grab more power to tightly control and surveillence the population, without resistance. The people embraced it in 2020 because they believed it's for the good for the community.

HappinessAlley · 29/11/2022 10:45

Indeed, it’s easy to not think through the consequences. Even the party in China didn’t really think it through

inamarina · 29/11/2022 10:45

shasha21 · 29/11/2022 04:44

Hi OP! I’m working in China at the moment. The news is quite exaggerated. There are lockdowns, but it’s not like it was in the UK. For example, in the cities people live in apartment complexes - loads of buildings inside a huge complex. If there are outbreaks, the one building where the outbreak is will be ‘locked down’ for 3 days while the people are tested each day. Once they are given the all clear they are free to go.

Legally, they must receive full pay for the time that they are locked down. (I got fully paid during the lockdown I experienced and so did my colleagues.)

If the outbreak gets out of control, they will lock down a bigger area (I.e the whole complex will be asked to stay in for 3 days - or the whole district when numbers start to spiral. They test daily and if no more positive cases they are freed asap).

There is an outbreak in the city I live in but we aren’t locked down. I’m a teacher and there will be covid tests done 2-3 times a week for all teachers and students so we know it’s safe to work and no cases in the school. People wear masks a lot still (not in schools though, just on public transport and in supermarkets. Free to use bars and restaurants as normal mask-free).

It is false that you aren’t allowed to travel between cities. It’s absolutely fine to travel as normal, but yes, you will be asked to download an app on your phone which shows that you haven’t been in any ‘high risk’ areas immediately before travel. If you have, you are just asked to take a test prior to departure. The results are all uploaded onto the app too, and there are small test centres scattered about everywhere so you can just pop in when you need to use one.

The news is obviously focussing on the very negative side but the news here does the same about the UK and USA! Watch the news at home and you think China is awful; watch the news here and it’s exactly the same about home. You have to be aware that the media very much picks and chooses what they report on to ensure that the country they aren’t so fond of doesn’t look great and their own country looks superior in whatever aspect!

Vaccine-wise, the general consensus (and official advice here) is that the mRNA technology used to make the vaccines abroad (like in the UK, Europe, etc) is very dangerous. It’s interesting because their own research says the same that those accused of being ‘anti-vaxxers’ say in the UK. Their vaccine is different. It seems to be just as effective in that it minimises symptoms but doesn’t make it impossible to get or transmit the virus (as with the vaccines back home).

In general, people here don’t really mind. The lockdowns are very few and far between, and they’re usually very short. The majority of the people I have spoken to feel that the irritation of occasional lockdowns are worth it to keep the vulnerable safe from covid. A few people think it’s stupid but I’d say that those people are very much outnumbered by those who feel it’s positive to be cautious in this way. (I’d say only about 15% of my friends and colleagues are negative about it, the rest feel it is positive.)

We feel sorry for them in the UK but they too feel sorry for us so it’s a really interesting experience to witness both sides!

Anyone has any questions feel free to ask! 😊

the one building where the outbreak is will be ‘locked down’ for 3 days while the people are tested each day. Once they are given the all clear they are free to go.

So is it three days or until everyone gets the all clear? Because that could take considerably longer than three days. I can well imagine how the constant possibility of a spontaneous „3 day“ (in reality possibly longer) lockdown after nearly three years of Covid could affect people‘s mental health.

Legally, they must receive full pay for the time that they are locked down. (I got fully paid during the lockdown I experienced and so did my colleagues.)

Who is paying the full salaries for buildings/ building complexes full of people, never mind whole districts, again and again, for nearly three years? How long can an economy support that for?

SirMingeALot · 29/11/2022 09:53

I always had the impression it was more that pro restriction people liked the idea that a society could've had very strict restrictions initially that then meant the population could live more normally. Tended to hear more about the principle rather than people actually coming out and saying they approved of the squeamish parts, iyswim. More likely to gloss over it instead.

Puzzledandpissedoff · 29/11/2022 09:37

TokyoSushi · 28/11/2022 21:29

I think it's far more about political control of the population than it is about Covid.

Indeed - the irony being that for ages, we saw endless posts in favour of their overall approach

inamarina · 29/11/2022 09:29

saffy7 · 28/11/2022 21:54

A friend of mine from China has said that nothing has changed since the start of the pandemic out there, and she can't get back to see her family. It would take her more than a month to get home as no direct flights to the area she's from and each connecting flight would mean 2-3 weeks in isolation. Seeing as it would be 3 flights, she'd be in isolation up to 9 weeks and then coming back would be difficult as you run the risk of lockdown at any time.

That sounds awful.
I know someone who travelled to China recently. They had to stay in hotel quarantine for eight days and weren’t even allowed to go out on the balcony. It’s like it’s still the beginning of 2020.

SirMingeALot · 29/11/2022 09:27

If the outbreak gets out of control, they will lock down a bigger area (I.e the whole complex will be asked to stay in for 3 days - or the whole district when numbers start to spiral. They test daily and if no more positive cases they are freed asap).

'Asked'.

What would happen if people declined this request?

Usmbsr · 29/11/2022 09:13

I also think that some of the reports are incorrect and over exaggerated regarding China, the people are generally happy with the way the country is run, it is much safer than most countries around the world and little poverty.

Why are people protesting considering the ramifications for protesting in China if they are happy with it.

Safer for who?
sThoe in the unoffocial black jails?
Uyghurs?
North Korean escapees who either get sent back to NK or sex trafficked?
Human rights lawyers who have been tortured for standing up for basic rights?
Book sellers?
Protesters?

How are you defining poverty? The pretend ccp way where they claimed total victory over poverty and have a different figure from the world bank on how to define poverty? 13% of their population still fall below the world bank definition of poverty.

Swipe left for the next trending thread