Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think China is still locking down

179 replies

mumofgirl1 · 28/11/2022 21:19

Sorry if this has already be posted about I was just watching the local news and they where covering recent lockdowns in China I'm shocked they are still implementing lockdowns and wondered how there economy is coping nearly 3yrs down the line of lockdowns and what has happened to the vaccines over there have they not worked. It seems so strange when the rest of the world are coming out the other side of this and they are still putting local lockdowns in place surely they can't do this forever

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
mumofgirl1 · 30/11/2022 21:35

@LizTrusssPA I managed a care home throughout the first lockdown and the start of the pandemic up until I went on mat leave nov 20. I locked down the home before bojo told us to. Rightly or wrongly I didn't admitted any new residents both from the community and coming from the hospital yes we were told to take pressure off the hospitals and admit people where we could. I had 4 empty rooms so could of taken 4 potential new residents in however I weighed up the risk of filling these empty rooms with new people who could or couldn't potentially have covid and decided that risk was to great to people that already lived in the home, my staff and also myself who was pregnant at the time. when the hospital discharge team and social services did there daily ring round to find out how many beds we had I told them 4 but we wasn't admitting every now and again I was asked why I'd explain and that was that. We had some residents that had to go in hospital prior to the testing becoming available yes I did allow them to come home and we isolated that person in there room for 10 days and staff would barrier nurse. This worked for us and I'm proud to say that both the home and the staff remained covid free. At no point was I forced to take people in. Those homes that did take people in was because they was either council, nhs places or had the owners of the homes putting pressure on the managers to take people in from hospital and (I term that I hate but widely used in the care sector by care home owners) get bums in beds. My point to this post is yes the government said we should take untested people in but at no point was it forced upon us to take untested people in.

OP posts:
SirMingeALot · 30/11/2022 12:47

LizTrusssPA · 30/11/2022 12:32

China locking people in their homes is causing them harm.
UK Govt Health officials sending carehome residents back to carehomes to infect others who were effectively locked down also caused harm.
One isn't better than the other in that regard.

Again, your value judgement has no bearing on whether the tweet was a defence or justification of China's behaviour. Why are you conflating the two?

LizTrusssPA · 30/11/2022 12:32

SirMingeALot · 30/11/2022 12:27

You also said that the tweet wasn't justifying or defending China's behaviour, which is the part we were discussing. So your question about care homes has no bearing at all on that.

China locking people in their homes is causing them harm.
UK Govt Health officials sending carehome residents back to carehomes to infect others who were effectively locked down also caused harm.
One isn't better than the other in that regard.

justasking111 · 30/11/2022 12:31

Brazil took the attitude, you'll live or you'll die from the beginning. www.worldometers.info/coronavirus/country/brazil/

To think China is still locking down
SirMingeALot · 30/11/2022 12:27

LizTrusssPA · 30/11/2022 12:22

I didn't agree with the tweet. I said both approaches to covid whether China's or the UKs are causing harm.

You also said that the tweet wasn't justifying or defending China's behaviour, which is the part we were discussing. So your question about care homes has no bearing at all on that.

LizTrusssPA · 30/11/2022 12:22

SirMingeALot · 30/11/2022 11:55

How is that relevant to the issue of whether the tweet was an attempt at justifying the Chinese state's actions? You agreeing with the tweet has zero bearing on that.

I didn't agree with the tweet. I said both approaches to covid whether China's or the UKs are causing harm.

LizTrusssPA · 30/11/2022 12:20

paintitallover · 30/11/2022 12:13

I see the link you are trying to make, @LizTrusssPA . You're saying it's hypocritical. Fair point, I suppose, although the Chinese government are more brutal by far. We just starve our population these days!

Thankyou.

paintitallover · 30/11/2022 12:13

I see the link you are trying to make, @LizTrusssPA . You're saying it's hypocritical. Fair point, I suppose, although the Chinese government are more brutal by far. We just starve our population these days!

SirMingeALot · 30/11/2022 11:55

LizTrusssPA · 30/11/2022 11:52

So how could the carehome residents sent back to their deaths have avoided risks?

How is that relevant to the issue of whether the tweet was an attempt at justifying the Chinese state's actions? You agreeing with the tweet has zero bearing on that.

LizTrusssPA · 30/11/2022 11:52

SirMingeALot · 30/11/2022 11:40

Yes, it's absolutely justifying. That's what the claim it has saved lives is in there for.

What you are saying here is that you don't think some other people or perhaps institutions, it isn't quite clear, have any room to criticise. Which is not the same issue at all, albeit the tweet does attempt to conflate them.

So how could the carehome residents sent back to their deaths have avoided risks?

SirMingeALot · 30/11/2022 11:40

LizTrusssPA · 30/11/2022 11:35

It's not justifying it is it? I just don't think a country that has sent thousands of people to their deaths by ignoring covid has the right to decide what they deem as where the bar of decency in public health is.
China's policy is tyrannical. But so was sending positive covid patients back to carehomes. They couldn't escape risk either.

Yes, it's absolutely justifying. That's what the claim it has saved lives is in there for.

What you are saying here is that you don't think some other people or perhaps institutions, it isn't quite clear, have any room to criticise. Which is not the same issue at all, albeit the tweet does attempt to conflate them.

LizTrusssPA · 30/11/2022 11:35

It's not justifying it is it? I just don't think a country that has sent thousands of people to their deaths by ignoring covid has the right to decide what they deem as where the bar of decency in public health is.
China's policy is tyrannical. But so was sending positive covid patients back to carehomes. They couldn't escape risk either.

SirMingeALot · 30/11/2022 10:10

I can't see how it could possibly be read as anything other than defence of China.

He's ackowledging that their policy 'has problems' by which I presume he's referring to things like people burning to death because they've been welded into quarantine, but claims it has saved an enormous number of lives. How isn't that justifying it? It's a piss poor attempt at justification, obviously, because the figures provided by the Chinese state mean absolutely nothing and also because he's completely failed to consider what happens next, but he clearly thinks that their way has led to fewer deaths thus far and that this is something in its favour.

It also appears to be what he's attempting with his attempt at an unfavourable comparison with the UK, as though there's a rule that one of the approaches must have been correct and this is binary. And lastly, there's a clear attempt to delegitimise criticism of a regime for a little thing like causing people to burn alive in forced quarantine by calling it 'bashing'.

LizTrusssPA · 30/11/2022 09:54

Buzzinwithbez · 30/11/2022 09:44

People still defending China. This is quite scary, really.
They believe the number of deaths and don't take a minute to think about any none covid deaths or the trails of being fastened in to your home or feeling like you or your loved ones could be snatched from it in a heartbeat.

Perhaps I'm looking at it wrong but I don't see that twitter post as necessarily defending China. He's pointing out that our own current failed herd immunity experiment isn't going too well either. Aren't both causing harm?

Buzzinwithbez · 30/11/2022 09:44

People still defending China. This is quite scary, really.
They believe the number of deaths and don't take a minute to think about any none covid deaths or the trails of being fastened in to your home or feeling like you or your loved ones could be snatched from it in a heartbeat.

To think China is still locking down
LizTrusssPA · 30/11/2022 09:38

SoupDragon · 30/11/2022 07:57

OTOH there are TV programmes like Strictly where they are all close together and hugging and one confirmed case of covid doesn't seem to have spread like wildfire through the cast...

It doesn't spread in tv studios at the rate it does in schools etc because they have covid control measures in place still and stars and staff and audience who are testing positive are still required to isolate. A friend has visited several TV studios over the last year most recently only last month to a BBC one and got a whole list of TS&Cs on C19 measures including the stipulation that they would not be permitted entrance if they were covid positive. Is Kym Marsh the one case you were talking about or is this the second one? www.theguardian.com/tv-and-radio/2022/nov/22/kym-marsh-miss-strictly-come-dancing-covid-bbc

countrygirl99 · 30/11/2022 09:33

@shasha21 if you can get a visa for studying how come my friends son is currently in Singapore studying online in approx the right time zone instead of taking his place at Beijing University?

justasking111 · 30/11/2022 09:29

dementedma · 30/11/2022 09:23

My brother is out there. Still locked down. Allowed out once a day for a daily test. Food is delivered to the compound. Its horrific

My brother is in Kunming I hope it's better there. Still worry though

justasking111 · 30/11/2022 09:28

Buzzinwithbez · 30/11/2022 09:13

A good Twitter account coming out of China on what's happening.
There's one a little way down by a woman who described the scary levels of surveillance that enable it.

twitter.com/songpinganq?t=x0iBFjuSB-WVh5La2ZBGgg&s=09

That's bad

dementedma · 30/11/2022 09:23

My brother is out there. Still locked down. Allowed out once a day for a daily test. Food is delivered to the compound. Its horrific

Tirediam · 30/11/2022 09:19

My friend has recently moved from
Shanghai to Thailand. She wanted to get away. She said they’re locking down offices, so people go to work and then can’t leave. Same for schools, they’re told to take bags of stuff incase they can’t leave for a week once they’re there! Separating kids from parents etc. it’s awful.

Buzzinwithbez · 30/11/2022 09:17

A detailed thread on Chinese surveillance

"Example, when Wuhan residents in early 2020 went online to say that relatives were falling ill from a disease the govt had so far denied was contageous, some told me they were visited within hrs by police. In one case, police came to the hospital to order a family to remove posts"

"“But after all that, at least people will remember my protest” – not likely, a search on Weibo (China’s Twitter) today shows nothing is happening at all. Why? Each company has 1000s of censors. I wrote about one of these incredible censorship factories:"

twitter.com/catecadell/status/1597647634960818176?t=jaoU2M4vXbfQdo0EmuEd8g&s=19

MintyFreshOne · 30/11/2022 09:16

TrixJax · 28/11/2022 21:39

They were showing a graph on news earlier and only 20% of over 80s and about 50% of over 60s have had at least 2 doses of the vaccine. The elderly are sceptical of modern medicine and ted to still use traditional Chinese medicine.

I'm surprised the Chinese Gov has not made vaccination compulsory in order to access lots of areas of society. Even some western democracies did that!

It wouldn’t play well. Imagine leaked video of force vaccinating elderly people shared across social media, it’s too far even for the CCP. There is a real mistrust of Western medicine among older folks …

SexTrainGlue · 30/11/2022 09:15

a) achieving high enough vaccine cover is difficult
b) the vaccine wears off - all of them do
c) even with vaccine cover, people can still become unpleasantly ill , with knock on effects to society and the economy
d) long covid is taking a toll, and we still don’t fully understand it
e) we don’t know if the virus lodges in the body long term, or what it could do if it reactivated - maybe a covid shingles? (Or worse AIDS)
f) covid dampens immune response generally for a few months (at least) after infection regardless of mildness of initial illness - may perhaps have a role in all the other infectious diseases that we are being warned are in high (and sometimes severe) circulation this winter
g) definite role in increase in strokes and sudden adult death

worst case is that in 5 or 10 years time, the Chinese population - who are ‘living with it’ by having normality except when there’s an outbreak, this meaning most people never get it - are generally in similar good health to the population before 2019. Whilst countries who ‘live with it’ by ignoring it are building a ticking time bomb of long term detrimental effects (whist simultaneously making things like cancer care or anything else which can wipe immune system)

Buzzinwithbez · 30/11/2022 09:13

A good Twitter account coming out of China on what's happening.
There's one a little way down by a woman who described the scary levels of surveillance that enable it.

twitter.com/songpinganq?t=x0iBFjuSB-WVh5La2ZBGgg&s=09