Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Ofsted and Pre school

58 replies

wowmummy · 28/11/2022 21:11

Ok trying to keep this brief...

Ofsted were at my twins Pre school. They were speaking to parents and asked me about staff. I named staff my children talk about at home but one particular member of staff that I've never really got on with I said was unapproachable and she split the twins up without consulting me first and that pissed my husband and both off and said that one speaks much better without the other. At home she never shuts up, she's the quieter child but there's nothing wrong with that. Everyone is different and that's her. My son is a quiet child with the other twin being a louder child. I see no NEED either, they have a twin bond without a doubt and are still in the nurturing phase of their lives. She isn't there key worker either. She also tries to pull the comforter out of one of my twins mouths - sucking its ear 🤢 and that annoys me as they go two days out of 7 in their young lives and it doesn't do anyone any harm for the bunny to be there even if it's just on the peg. Anyway staff have found out, really frosty this morning - no professionalism but ok they are obviously annoyed and then this afternoon I went and one of them was dry in pants - hasn't been in weeks and I said 'same trousers? Yayyy' and they just ignored me. And I said 'did XXXX go themselves?' And they said 'yes but more interested in playing with the sink' so I said 'oh ok, thanks bye'

I previously told them that we were not happy to be met with 'we've split them up today' and they said they wouldn't do it again and I did say to Ofsted they are now in the same room but it was the way that particular member of staff went about it

I told Ofsted WHY I didn't like that member of staff and that is the truth and now feel I shouldn't have said anything? What is the point if you are met with that and is that being filtered down to my children and their care? Will it blow over? This was the first day they had seen me since the inspection so maybe they were wondering how I was going to be? They didn't even said 'they've been fine, had a great day'

Im sure that my comments wouldn't have affected their score?

I don't want to move them, it's all people that are clicky with the area too. However I didn't mention that in over a year I've seen no reports, nothing. Just one settling in meeting after 4 weeks. I don't even know their next steps

I'm so anxious it's unreal!

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Noname99 · 02/12/2022 20:08

‘Theguiltyfeminist’
No there is a middle ground. At worst, staff made a mistake, a minor mistake. It wax rectified. Are you so perfect that you make no mistake ever at work and if you do it’s ok that the regulator is involved. And everyone is surprised that nursery staff, teachers and TAs are leaving in droves.
‘Katapolts’
Thank you!!!

Katapolts · 30/11/2022 16:53

@Theguiltyfeminist no, the scenario is the OP had a fairly minor disagreement with the staff, which she raised with the manager and it was resolved to her satisfaction.
Then, she used an Ofsted inspection to moan about a particular member of staff she dislikes.

These kind of disputes - parent disagrees with the group her child is put in, wants them put with/separated from a friend, doesn't like what's offered for snack, wants child to have more naps/less naps, clothes got dirty, too much TV, not enough photos on the app and so on - are not Ofsted issues, they're things that should be resolved with setting manager.

LondonElle · 30/11/2022 16:04

Not sure either of the issues discussed would be classed as safeguarding issues both were dealt with. Both wouldn't have been a concern to ofsted.

OmiOmy · 30/11/2022 15:27

Theguiltyfeminist · 30/11/2022 14:25

Hang on a second. There are two alternative scenarios here:

  1. that the nursery did nothing wrong and acted in a completely appropriate manner. This is being implied by a number of posters. In which case, there is no problem - the inspector will agree with the staff that they behaved in a completely appropriate manner and will presumably mark them up, not down.
  2. that the staff have not acted in a completely appropriate manner. In which case, are PPs seriously suggesting that the OP and all the other parents should have closed ranks around the staff and given an inaccurate picture in order to protect the staff? Wtaf? You can’t be serious? The purpose of an inspection is surely to check whether a setting is safe for the kids - you know, the kids who may in some nursery settings be pre verbal and cannot speak up for themselves or tell anyone what’s happening? I am genuinely horrified that there is at least one childcare professional on here that thinks it is ok for the kids to have to suck up wrongdoing in order to protect the adults who are meant to be looking after them. That has massive implications for safeguarding. I appreciate it isn’t much fun being inspected, but it isn’t about the adults - it’s about the kids. If the parents aren’t allowed to answer questions about their experience of the nursery then why have inspections at all - why not just let the nursery self certify that they are absolutely wonderful? Thank God you people aren’t looking after my kids - if you think that protecting the adults is more important than making sure a setting is appropriate for children then you don’t sound very trustworthy at all. Would you say the same about carers looking after elderly or vulnerable people? Again, I’ll reiterate that if there has been no wrongdoing, then the inspector will agree and there will be no negative impact on the Ofsted report.

Yes, a poor Ofsted can obviously impact on a setting’s commercial success. That’s the case with any regulatory inspection of any business- like environmental health and food safety inspections, for example. If people want to play the purely commercial card, then most businesses know they have to keep their customers or service users happy in order to avoid poor public reviews. If you are unfriendly or unapproachable or unhelpful then that information quickly makes its way into the public domain and makes people vote with their feet. That’s the deal with running a business.

I am genuinely a bit disturbed by the number of people on this thread who think that in principle it would be more acceptable for the service users of a nursery- the children- to be thrown under the bus than the nursery workers. If the kids are not in fact being thrown under the bus in any given situation, then I refer back to point 1 above.

Not sure about the others but for me it was the fact that the OP said the issue had been already resolved by the time ofsted inspector had asked the question. If it's been resolved, why bring it up? She could have said yes, we had an issue but it was sorted, why bring in a personal dislike of someone?

The OP has sent an older child there before and, presumably, had no issues before so she obviously likes the pre-school.

Plus what other parents? I don't think the OP mentioned any one else.

Theguiltyfeminist · 30/11/2022 14:25

Hang on a second. There are two alternative scenarios here:

  1. that the nursery did nothing wrong and acted in a completely appropriate manner. This is being implied by a number of posters. In which case, there is no problem - the inspector will agree with the staff that they behaved in a completely appropriate manner and will presumably mark them up, not down.
  2. that the staff have not acted in a completely appropriate manner. In which case, are PPs seriously suggesting that the OP and all the other parents should have closed ranks around the staff and given an inaccurate picture in order to protect the staff? Wtaf? You can’t be serious? The purpose of an inspection is surely to check whether a setting is safe for the kids - you know, the kids who may in some nursery settings be pre verbal and cannot speak up for themselves or tell anyone what’s happening? I am genuinely horrified that there is at least one childcare professional on here that thinks it is ok for the kids to have to suck up wrongdoing in order to protect the adults who are meant to be looking after them. That has massive implications for safeguarding. I appreciate it isn’t much fun being inspected, but it isn’t about the adults - it’s about the kids. If the parents aren’t allowed to answer questions about their experience of the nursery then why have inspections at all - why not just let the nursery self certify that they are absolutely wonderful? Thank God you people aren’t looking after my kids - if you think that protecting the adults is more important than making sure a setting is appropriate for children then you don’t sound very trustworthy at all. Would you say the same about carers looking after elderly or vulnerable people? Again, I’ll reiterate that if there has been no wrongdoing, then the inspector will agree and there will be no negative impact on the Ofsted report.

Yes, a poor Ofsted can obviously impact on a setting’s commercial success. That’s the case with any regulatory inspection of any business- like environmental health and food safety inspections, for example. If people want to play the purely commercial card, then most businesses know they have to keep their customers or service users happy in order to avoid poor public reviews. If you are unfriendly or unapproachable or unhelpful then that information quickly makes its way into the public domain and makes people vote with their feet. That’s the deal with running a business.

I am genuinely a bit disturbed by the number of people on this thread who think that in principle it would be more acceptable for the service users of a nursery- the children- to be thrown under the bus than the nursery workers. If the kids are not in fact being thrown under the bus in any given situation, then I refer back to point 1 above.

EverybodyDance · 29/11/2022 21:26

Maybe that member of staff doesn't like you either.

There's no maybe now.

PyjamaFan · 29/11/2022 21:13

You told an Ofsted inspector that you don't like a member of staff?

Unbelievable.

No wonder education staff are leaving in droves.

Maybe that member of staff doesn't like you either.

PatchworkElmer · 29/11/2022 21:09

I think you handled it badly. A general comment about concerns raised and how they were dealt with would’ve probably been fine. You’ve also brought up an issue that was dealt with promptly and to your satisfaction AGAIN. I’d be upset in their position too.

LondonElle · 29/11/2022 19:27

You don't sound sorry at all.

wowmummy · 29/11/2022 19:15

Rainbowcat99 · 29/11/2022 18:46

"It's not daily"

"and then this afternoon I went and one of them was dry in pants - hasn't been in weeks."

In your first post, this implies that the rest of the time they've been wet then?

And whether you agree with them splitting the twins, the fact was that in nursery one twin was quieter and they tried to help. Then when you complained they changed things back for you.

So they sound like they're trying their best... I'm beginning to see why they're a bit frosty tbh. They'll never be your best mates I wouldn't have thought.

But in answer to your first question, yes it'll blow over in all probability most of them will be polite and professional and treat your kids well, which is all you can ask for really.

In my first post I also say they are there 2 days out of 7. Yes they haven't been dry there in weeks

I never had anyone express anything about 'quiet' etc it was just told to me the day they split them up.

I haven't said I wanted them to help her not be quiet 😂😂😂 if that's who she is thats who she is, nothing wrong with being quiet

They put them back together yes after I emailed them

OP posts:
AdelineLou · 29/11/2022 18:50

I work alongside Ofsted inspectors during inspections. Ofsted will take a wider view, not the view of one parent. They will check out with other parents to find a wider picture. Only if a few parents are expressing the same concerning view will they accept and report. They will also want to know how the nursery takes parents views into account.

Like anyone leading in the education sector, Inspectors know there is always ‘that parent’ ( as everyone else was likely quite positive). In this case it is likely you are ‘that parent’.

Rainbowcat99 · 29/11/2022 18:46

"It's not daily"

"and then this afternoon I went and one of them was dry in pants - hasn't been in weeks."

In your first post, this implies that the rest of the time they've been wet then?

And whether you agree with them splitting the twins, the fact was that in nursery one twin was quieter and they tried to help. Then when you complained they changed things back for you.

So they sound like they're trying their best... I'm beginning to see why they're a bit frosty tbh. They'll never be your best mates I wouldn't have thought.

But in answer to your first question, yes it'll blow over in all probability most of them will be polite and professional and treat your kids well, which is all you can ask for really.

wowmummy · 29/11/2022 18:39

KatMcBundleFace · 29/11/2022 17:02

Expecting a child at nursery not to be sucking a comforter is appropriate. Splitting twins up is appropriate. Hopefully OFSTED will recognise that you were just having a bit of a petty moan.

But you've just given the equivalent of a shitty review without speaking to the management before hand about your "problems" and given them chance to explain. I should imagine the staff are deeply unimpressed with you.
Hope you've learned your lesson for the sake of your children.

Why is separating twins expected?

OP posts:
wowmummy · 29/11/2022 18:36

Rainbowcat99 · 29/11/2022 18:11

So the nursery looked after your older son well.
Then you sent the twins, they noticed that one was a lot quieter than the others and tried to help with that.
They've been dealing with their wet pants daily (presumably toilet training them for you then)
And "making a big fuss" of them when they do well.
They accepted your complaints about splitting the twins and changed things to accommodate you.

They've done all that and you repay them by moaning about them to OFSTed?

It's parents who moan, complain and find fault like this that make working with children (usually for a pittance) hard and a big part of the reason why nurseries struggle to recruit staff 🙄

No

They've haven't helped with a quieter twin. Nothing wrong with her

It's not daily

I would have expected a big fuss seeing as they are supposed to be praising achievements

OP posts:
Winterscomingagain · 29/11/2022 18:24

I'm sure the inspectors would be trained to disregard someone who says she dislikes a member of staff. You threw this member of staff under a bus and I'm not surprised the team are treating you like this.

Idontgiveagriffindamn · 29/11/2022 18:24

Wow you made it way to personal about a member of staff and why you don’t like her. Of course they are going to be frosty with you.
You could have given feedback about your twins being split up without saying you didn’t like them.

LittleLadyCece · 29/11/2022 18:17

I’m not surprised they are annoyed with you whilst unprofessional it may be you’ve really stabbed them in the back to an Ofsted inspector.

A friend of mine is a teacher and I know the fear that is struck in them when they get a visit. Those reports are what parents assess nurseries and schools on for deciding where to send their children. There was no need to single one person out.

Your children won’t suffer at the nursery and I have no doubt they made a big thing of a dry day before you came to collect but I’m not surprised they were cold with you.

i think you were bang out of order

Rainbowcat99 · 29/11/2022 18:11

So the nursery looked after your older son well.
Then you sent the twins, they noticed that one was a lot quieter than the others and tried to help with that.
They've been dealing with their wet pants daily (presumably toilet training them for you then)
And "making a big fuss" of them when they do well.
They accepted your complaints about splitting the twins and changed things to accommodate you.

They've done all that and you repay them by moaning about them to OFSTed?

It's parents who moan, complain and find fault like this that make working with children (usually for a pittance) hard and a big part of the reason why nurseries struggle to recruit staff 🙄

cansu · 29/11/2022 17:49

I am sure the staff will continue to care well for your children, but I don't think they will like you much or go out of their way to be friendly to you. If this is important to you, then you might prefer to move. I am interested though that you don't want to move and like most of the staff. You have occasionally complained and they have accommodated what you have asked for. Yet, you still decided to give a critical review to an inspector. V odd.

cansu · 29/11/2022 17:42

You made it personal. You targeted one member of staff. I think that had you said ' In general I am happy about XYZ, but I did raise some concerns about keeping my children together' that would be different. You used it as an opportunity to raise everything you have ever moaned about or disliked. You said some quite unpleasant things about one member of staff. I think if I was a member of staff, I would not be too keen on you either. Lesson learnt I guess.

LondonElle · 29/11/2022 17:11

I don't think you should have mentioned you didn't like a member of staff, you brought your own opinion/feelings in to it.
Nursery workers work very hard for comparatively little pay and your comment would have deeply upset her.
You could have mentioned the issues you have had without saying how much you dislike someone but if you were happy with the setting generally then I don't get why would have said what you did!!!
It will feel like a betrayal!
I can't comment on the twin issue but at the setting I manage we don't allow soft comfort toys due to hygiene reasons.

KatMcBundleFace · 29/11/2022 17:02

Expecting a child at nursery not to be sucking a comforter is appropriate. Splitting twins up is appropriate. Hopefully OFSTED will recognise that you were just having a bit of a petty moan.

But you've just given the equivalent of a shitty review without speaking to the management before hand about your "problems" and given them chance to explain. I should imagine the staff are deeply unimpressed with you.
Hope you've learned your lesson for the sake of your children.

janglealltheway · 29/11/2022 16:47

As the issues had been dealt with there was no need to bring them up. I also think that mentioning that you dislike a particular member of staff is unfair.

Lots of nurseries are only just managing to keep their doors open at the moment, a poor OFSTED report could potentially push them to the edge. That leaves all those staff without jobs and parents without childcare!

Prettyinpink22 · 29/11/2022 16:27

wowmummy · 29/11/2022 16:23

Stressing again, I was mentioning it as WHY I don't like that member of staff. I can't just say I don't like such and such for no reason. I didn't make a complaint, ring them for an inspection or anything it was part of talking about her as a member of staff

But why bring up that you didn’t like a certain member we of staff to begin with? Why not just talk about the ones your children mention? You had no need to say you didn’t like a member of staff. Sounds like you are holding a grudge to be honest.

Your issues were dealt with there was no need to mention them. I can understand why they are annoyed.

wowmummy · 29/11/2022 16:23

Stressing again, I was mentioning it as WHY I don't like that member of staff. I can't just say I don't like such and such for no reason. I didn't make a complaint, ring them for an inspection or anything it was part of talking about her as a member of staff

OP posts: