Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Motability car use…

138 replies

TheSecondMrsMoorcroft · 28/11/2022 20:03

Posting here for traffic.

I have a 22yr old son who’s in receipt of PIP. We have a Motability car FOR HIS USE.

I have applied for a nursing post (community based) and need use of a vehicle. It’s part time and so, work use will be strictly limited to around 10-12hrs a week only. However, I’m thinking I can’t use this car for this purpose. It will not affect my using the car for my son. It is his vehicle (he doesn’t drive and has difficulty crossing the road, even) and my hours must work around him.

Does anyone know? AIBU to even consider using “his” car for my work use?

OP posts:
Sidge · 29/11/2022 09:21

Punxsutawney · 29/11/2022 09:09

"Most councils provide transport for SEN students, and once they’re in post-16 education it isn’t free"

DS is 18 and in our LA, transport for post 18 students is completely free. I am very grateful for his taxi, as otherwise it would take up about 3hrs of our day driving him there and back.

@Punxsutawney thats really good, ours is subsidised so we make a means tested contribution. It’s still hundreds of pounds but admittedly a better deal than trying to do it myself. She’s now at college an hour away so 4 hours a day in the car for me is not remotely possible!

vivainsomnia · 29/11/2022 09:20

Funny how all posters think it's absolute fine yet 56% of voters says you are being unreasonable!

Punxsutawney · 29/11/2022 09:09

"Most councils provide transport for SEN students, and once they’re in post-16 education it isn’t free"

DS is 18 and in our LA, transport for post 18 students is completely free. I am very grateful for his taxi, as otherwise it would take up about 3hrs of our day driving him there and back.

x2boys · 29/11/2022 09:07

caringcarer · 29/11/2022 09:00

Motability say the disabled person must be in the car or you are doing an errand for their benefit example they give on their literature you are collecting food for disabled person. I don't think you using it for work if your son is not in car would be allowed. You could hire one for yourself from your salary. Most people expect to have to get themselves to work. I also have a foster son with PIP but only use his car if he is in vehicle. I keep an old one for my personal use so as not in to break rules and I could not risk him losing it.

What notability actually say is that the car .must be being used for the disabled child/ adult or for their benefit ,it benefits my child having a parent that works so my dh uses it to get to and from work and it's our family car.

caringcarer · 29/11/2022 09:00

Motability say the disabled person must be in the car or you are doing an errand for their benefit example they give on their literature you are collecting food for disabled person. I don't think you using it for work if your son is not in car would be allowed. You could hire one for yourself from your salary. Most people expect to have to get themselves to work. I also have a foster son with PIP but only use his car if he is in vehicle. I keep an old one for my personal use so as not in to break rules and I could not risk him losing it.

Thatsnotmycar · 29/11/2022 08:59

@SidTwaddell Thank you. I’m going to try to help the 3 people I know who this would really help but who have been told it isn’t possible.

So not only did they have a fully funded car, they were laughingly making use of a free taxi too.

Hmm motability cars aren’t fully funded. Their DC are legally entitled to such school transport. You would have a heart attack if you knew some families get mileage instead of a taxi.

Underhisi · 29/11/2022 08:50

"So not only did they have a fully funded car, they were laughingly making use of a free taxi too."

We could have a motability car (but use the money to buy our own) and ds gets a taxi to school. I'm not spending 5 hours a day driving after being up for hours during the night. The car is used for meeting the family's needs including currently taking dh to his chemo sessions. Do you have a problem with that? Would you like to swap situations?

Sidge · 29/11/2022 08:45

So not only did they have a fully funded car, they were laughingly making use of a free taxi too.

Oh @CloverCoolCalm stop for a moment and have a think - you obviously have no idea what you’re talking about.

The car isn’t fully funded, it’s paid for out of a non means tested benefit. Many cars also have a hefty down payment. To have a car big enough to carry my daughters wheelchair and big enough to transport 4-5 fully grown people means I needed a larger vehicle requiring a £2500 down payment.

Most councils provide transport for SEN students, and once they’re in post-16 education it isn’t free. My daughters school was 12 miles away (and that’s close! We’re in a large mainly rural county and some students were 1.5 hours away) and there was no way I could have taken her to school and back twice a day, as well as get her sibling to school for the same sort of time, and get to work. ALL students at her school came by taxi/minibus - school grounds don’t allow for 150 disabled children to arrive at once in 150 cars… we’re not “laughingly making use of a free taxi” - it’s the councils stipulation as to how our children attend school.

I use our Motability car to get to work, whilst she gets transport to school and then college. This is fully permitted - they don’t expect you to have a second family car. I am still using the car for her benefit, y’know to earn money to pay the rent and bills and buy food, as well as drive her to her many hospital appointments, pick up her meds, take her to her disabled kids club.

Honestly posts like yours make me so angry, you have no idea as to the reality but like to make snarky comments about all the free stuff and easy life us parents of those disabled kids have.

bigbluebus · 29/11/2022 08:39

The type of work you propose would require business use on the insurance as it isn't just the usual "to and from normal place of work" type cover that comes with SDP standard cover.

Those who are spouting all sorts of alleged Motability rules aren't being helpful.

You do need to speak to Motability. Where will you son (the beneficiary of the vehicle) be whilst you intend to work? If he's at a college/day centre which you either drop him off at or they collect him (so he has no need for use of the car) then that is totally different to him being stuck at home with carers because there's no vehicle to use.

I used my DDs Motability car as my main vehicle until she became an adult and we had carers at home who were added to the insurance (Motability arranged this at no cost to us) so the carers could use the car to take DD out. I then had to find another vehicle to use otherwise I couldn't go anywhere during my respite hours.

ScroogeMcDuckling · 29/11/2022 08:16

I worked with a lady whose daughter has serious medical issues, which allowed the lady/mother to have a car.

I was listening (we all were) to her talking to “the car people”, that hopefully she will be working part time, over five days, at different sites, sometimes going to more than one site a day, within a 25 miles radius of her home, she really, really wanted the job, could she do it with her daughters car.

She was ecstatic at the end of that call, they said yes.

BakedTattie · 29/11/2022 07:51

So not only did they have a fully funded car, they were laughingly making use of a free taxi too

and what exactly is wrong with that?

people are so ignorant about motability cars. For a start, they aren’t free!!

SheldontheWonderSchlong · 29/11/2022 07:49

So not only did they have a fully funded car, they were laughingly making use of a free taxi too

Yes, so true - when I watched my son go off in a taxi to his special school miles away and then rushed to get my daughter (also SEN but in mainstream) to her school in our 'fully funded car' I would have such a laugh about how good I had it and what mugs the government were and how I was getting one over on everyone else.

🙄 There aren't enough eye rolls.....

x2boys · 29/11/2022 07:46

CloverCoolCalm · 28/11/2022 23:43

Just use it.

This brings to mind a local TV news story, the husbands car and tools and ladders for his work were stolen, it made the local news. Much was made of the fact that this was their child’s Mobility paid for car.
Then the Mum was interviewed explaining that the child had already left for school, that morning, when her husband’s vehicle was stolen, the child travelled in the Council paid for taxi, which they were collected in every** school day.
So not only did they have a fully funded car, they were laughingly making use of a free taxi too.

However, your case is different, I would use the car, in your case, you need the job.

Yep my child gets transport to and from his special school and s have a mobility car that is our family car ,and???

Afterfire · 29/11/2022 07:42

CloverCoolCalm · 28/11/2022 23:43

Just use it.

This brings to mind a local TV news story, the husbands car and tools and ladders for his work were stolen, it made the local news. Much was made of the fact that this was their child’s Mobility paid for car.
Then the Mum was interviewed explaining that the child had already left for school, that morning, when her husband’s vehicle was stolen, the child travelled in the Council paid for taxi, which they were collected in every** school day.
So not only did they have a fully funded car, they were laughingly making use of a free taxi too.

However, your case is different, I would use the car, in your case, you need the job.

Free taxi comment 😡🙄

My son travels to his complex needs school in a taxi everyday. He needs an escort. For most children with severe sen they will need someone sitting in the car next to them as well as someone driving. Lots of parents cannot use the mobility car for school runs for this reason, not to mention if they have other children to get to local schools at the same time - many children with sen travel miles to get to their specialist school (my sons journey last year was a 23 mile trip each way). It’s much more complex than getting a “free taxi”.

Ericaequites · 29/11/2022 04:54

Keeping a roof over his head, meals on the table, and clean clothes are definitely in your son’s best interest.

WiddlinDiddlin · 29/11/2022 04:42

Just ring and ask them.

I had to as I was being driven to work, which would be fine but it wasn't a fixed work address, I was being driven to clients homes and at the time (it may have changed) that needed specific permission.

I also had some drama on setting off home from a 3 day training course, ringing them to switch drivers last minute and the person I spoke to on the phone (incorrectly!) told me I couldn't do that, that they couldn't insure someone as it was business related...

I asked how she thought me and my two wheelchairs were getting back from a soggy wet field the far end of Hertfordshire to Worcestershire minus the car, and what was the point of the Motability scheme if I can't attend a mandatory training event... she found a supervisor who had a brain and it was fine, but that was a sticky moment, so its always best to check things beforehand!

transformandriseup · 29/11/2022 02:07

Growing up we had a disability car for my disabled mum and it was used for everything including my dad to get to work. There was no way we could have afforded two cars.

Legallypinkish · 29/11/2022 01:58

SheldontheWonderSchlong · 29/11/2022 01:37

The registered keeper of the car doesn't have to live with the person who's PIP pays for it. The parents can keep the car to visit their child in supported accommodation, help them with shopping etc.
Also, as I've explained to social services who think I have the ability to be in two places at once dropping my son at an activity in one town and my daughter at school in an another, the motability car is paid for, not my services as a chauffeur!
Why shouldn't my son have a taxi as well?

As usual with these threads, this one is veering towards the narrative of people taking advantage of their 'free' car and ignoring that most of us parents who have a motability car would give anything for our children not to need it.

Exactly.

i suppose I should think myself “lucky” that my child is disabled so I can get a “free” car to use and thousands in benefits . 🙄. If he could speak and communicate I’d guess he feels lucky too!

Legallypinkish · 29/11/2022 01:53

CloverCoolCalm · 28/11/2022 23:43

Just use it.

This brings to mind a local TV news story, the husbands car and tools and ladders for his work were stolen, it made the local news. Much was made of the fact that this was their child’s Mobility paid for car.
Then the Mum was interviewed explaining that the child had already left for school, that morning, when her husband’s vehicle was stolen, the child travelled in the Council paid for taxi, which they were collected in every** school day.
So not only did they have a fully funded car, they were laughingly making use of a free taxi too.

However, your case is different, I would use the car, in your case, you need the job.

A motability car isn’t “free” or fully funded! . You pay for it using the mobility part of DLA or PIP. Over £250 per month. Motability accept that the car will be used by family and most children who get high/enhanced rate mobility will have complex needs and get transport for school. 99% of children at my sons special school goes to school on the bus or in a taxi. Parents aren’t “laughingly making use of a free taxi”. Most parents need to work so can’t take their children to school and most special schools don’t want or even allow 300 parents bringing their kids to school and causing absolute chaos in the mornings and afternoons.

Comments like this make me furious. Life is hard enough as it is with a child with complex needs and disabilities without people like you making ignorant comments. I can tell you I’d much rather have a child that doesn’t need and will need 24/7 care for the rest of their lives than a bloody motability car!

NewNovember · 29/11/2022 01:42

@tillytoodles1 that's simply not true, it has to benefit the disabled person. You can drive to work to provide an income but you can't use it as a taxi or delivery driver for example as then driving becomes part of your job.

SheldontheWonderSchlong · 29/11/2022 01:37

TippledPink · 28/11/2022 23:56

I have dealt with this issue a few times as a social worker in adult social care. We get a lot of parents who use the car for work, and then ask us to fund taxis to take the person to their activities as they state they need it for work. We have also had parents keep the Motability car to use even when the person has moved into supported living, leaving the person with no transport. Both are unacceptable! However in your situation, I would say that is fine. As long as if he did need it in the future for himself to get somewhere, you didn't prevent that by saying you need to use it to get to work.

The registered keeper of the car doesn't have to live with the person who's PIP pays for it. The parents can keep the car to visit their child in supported accommodation, help them with shopping etc.
Also, as I've explained to social services who think I have the ability to be in two places at once dropping my son at an activity in one town and my daughter at school in an another, the motability car is paid for, not my services as a chauffeur!
Why shouldn't my son have a taxi as well?

As usual with these threads, this one is veering towards the narrative of people taking advantage of their 'free' car and ignoring that most of us parents who have a motability car would give anything for our children not to need it.

Legallypinkish · 29/11/2022 01:34

Yes definitely contact motability. We had one for our son for years. Motability are really great when you contact them and really understanding. I don’t know one family that don’t use their child’s motability car as their normally family car, they told me when I phoned for something similar that they fully understand it will be used for normal family stuff and for work commutes and that’s fine.

WitchSharkadder · 29/11/2022 00:15

Hi, OP.

I am in the exact same position as you. Adult son has car on motability which I drive (because he can't- complex learning disability). I also work for the NHS and carry out community visits. All I had to do was call the insurance to update it to business insurance, which does not incur any extra charge, and renew that insurance annually/when I change vehicle.

It's fine, simple and easy. Motability have no issue with it, the NHS have no issue with it, nor do the insurance company.

The one thing is you can't upgrade your insurance until the actual start date of your job, but it's 24 hours max for your new policy to update in your online account and then forward your payroll dept and line manager the documentation.

TrixJax · 29/11/2022 00:03

I don't know insand outs of Motability but to use your car for work in the community (NHS) you must be insured for business use. And every year you must produce your renewal certificate.

Punxsutawney · 29/11/2022 00:02

'the child travelled in the Council paid for taxi, which they were collected in every school day.'

Ds gets enhanced mobility ( although does not have a car) and has a 'free' taxi to his specialist school and back everyday. No laughing here. In reality we would much rather he didn't actually get either and he was able to manage the same as his neurotypical peers.

Swipe left for the next trending thread