Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Motability car use…

138 replies

TheSecondMrsMoorcroft · 28/11/2022 20:03

Posting here for traffic.

I have a 22yr old son who’s in receipt of PIP. We have a Motability car FOR HIS USE.

I have applied for a nursing post (community based) and need use of a vehicle. It’s part time and so, work use will be strictly limited to around 10-12hrs a week only. However, I’m thinking I can’t use this car for this purpose. It will not affect my using the car for my son. It is his vehicle (he doesn’t drive and has difficulty crossing the road, even) and my hours must work around him.

Does anyone know? AIBU to even consider using “his” car for my work use?

OP posts:
SusanPerbCallMeSue · 29/11/2022 10:32

vivainsomnia · 29/11/2022 10:08

Oh stop acting like the bloody benefit police. You clearly have no fucking idea and are merely bitter because someone has use of a motability car. How sad for you
No, just like the majority, I don't think it's right but benefiting directly from the adult disability.

The whole 'if I earn more, they benefit' is just about cutting for a child, but not an adult. They are entitled to benefits of their own accord, just like other adults, not for the benefit of their family.

Would parents feel the same if they just took the money each month to pay for their own transport to work, only giving them £10 of it there and then for their use of a taxi? Why does a car somehow mae it all different?

And give up the whole 'you are bitter', there is nothing to be bitter about. I have massive admiration for parents of disabled children an know how immensely hard it it to look after disabled children. I fully support taxes going for extra support and respite care. I still believe that using a vulnerable adult assets for one own needs to be wrong.

You obviously know absolutely fuck all about life with a disabled adult, and how having a motability car as a family car is fine. I'd much rather have the money, but we need a car. I'd much rather not need the car or the PIP my son gets and that he could be independent and have a job etc, instead of being a 20 year old that can't be left alone or go out alone and doesn't understand why he can't do the things his younger brothers are doing.

softpilllow · 29/11/2022 10:15

@vivainsomnia

Oh stop acting like the bloody benefit police. You clearly have no fucking idea and are merely bitter because someone has use of a motability car. How sad for you

No, just like the majority, I don't think it's right but benefiting directly from the adult disability.

You are not the majority. Fat from it. You are also being stupid if you think a parent who is supporting their ADULT child through life because they have a disability is benefiting from that. The cost of financially supporting another adult far outweighs any benefits that may be received, including the bloody car.

x2boys · 29/11/2022 10:13

vivainsomnia · 29/11/2022 10:08

Oh stop acting like the bloody benefit police. You clearly have no fucking idea and are merely bitter because someone has use of a motability car. How sad for you
No, just like the majority, I don't think it's right but benefiting directly from the adult disability.

The whole 'if I earn more, they benefit' is just about cutting for a child, but not an adult. They are entitled to benefits of their own accord, just like other adults, not for the benefit of their family.

Would parents feel the same if they just took the money each month to pay for their own transport to work, only giving them £10 of it there and then for their use of a taxi? Why does a car somehow mae it all different?

And give up the whole 'you are bitter', there is nothing to be bitter about. I have massive admiration for parents of disabled children an know how immensely hard it it to look after disabled children. I fully support taxes going for extra support and respite care. I still believe that using a vulnerable adult assets for one own needs to be wrong.

It doesn't matter what you or the majority think Is right as you don't make other he rules up

Swingwhenyourewinning · 29/11/2022 10:12

tillytoodles1 · 28/11/2022 20:06

My husband had one. It could only be used if he was either driving or a passenger. The rules are very strict.

You know this isn’t true my partners dad has a motorbility car that his mum uses as she is bed bound. But he needs to go shopping for her pick up prescriptions. Work as this financially benefit's his dad

vivainsomnia · 29/11/2022 10:08

Oh stop acting like the bloody benefit police. You clearly have no fucking idea and are merely bitter because someone has use of a motability car. How sad for you
No, just like the majority, I don't think it's right but benefiting directly from the adult disability.

The whole 'if I earn more, they benefit' is just about cutting for a child, but not an adult. They are entitled to benefits of their own accord, just like other adults, not for the benefit of their family.

Would parents feel the same if they just took the money each month to pay for their own transport to work, only giving them £10 of it there and then for their use of a taxi? Why does a car somehow mae it all different?

And give up the whole 'you are bitter', there is nothing to be bitter about. I have massive admiration for parents of disabled children an know how immensely hard it it to look after disabled children. I fully support taxes going for extra support and respite care. I still believe that using a vulnerable adult assets for one own needs to be wrong.

ginghamstarfish · 29/11/2022 10:05

I can't imagine anyone monitors these things, there is certainly no monitoring of who uses (and abuses) blue badges which are much more widespread, so can't think anyone is looking at motability cars. You need to get to work to support him, so I would say use it.

TinkyWinkyRainbowHead · 29/11/2022 10:03

I have a motability car and initially thought that DH could never take it to work. I can’t drive it as I have a medical condition which prevents driving so he would hardly be depriving me anyway and he’s the only registered driver on there. I digress, he has to go the the office once every 6 weeks and motability said it was absolutely fine as him working benefits me. It helps to pay the mortgage and bills as my salary alone wouldn’t cover it. Ring motability if unsure, they’re really helpful.

LoveBluey · 29/11/2022 09:59

wherearebeefandonioncrisps · 28/11/2022 20:35

No, you can't use his motability car for your commute to work. The rules are strict.

I don't think this is true and if it is it's ridiculous and it's not benefiting the family.

In practice this could mean driving a child to school in their motabilty car then driving home to swap to a separate car which has to be paid for and maintained out of the family budget, driving to work. Then driving home from work, swap cars to motability car to do school pick up. Would be absurd.

x2boys · 29/11/2022 09:58

vivainsomnia · 29/11/2022 09:51

You're obviously aware that many disabled adults can't legally drive? What would be the point of having 2 cars and one sitting not used often because the disabled person doesn't really go out? The OP working does benefit her son
Indeed, it would be pointless, so would make more sense for the disabled adult to get the cash rather than the car and pay for their transport, be it mum, dad, a carer or a taxi. This seems better use of their entitlement.

Why though?
I presume the disabled adult in this case needs a roof over their head ,so his mother going out to work he!ps provide that which benefits him ,if she was using the car leaving him stuck at home not being able to access activities I could see your point ,but that doesn't seem to be the case .

OnceAgainWithFeeling · 29/11/2022 09:56

Sidge · 28/11/2022 20:14

I was told I can use mine for commuting to work etc as me working is supporting my disabled daughter, who is financially dependent on me. However that’s when she’s a child/younger adult, I’m not sure how it works when they’re an adult.

I would guess if he’s living at home and financially dependent on you then it might be covered but worth asking Motability. It might also be different as you wouldn’t be just commuting but using it in the course of your work, so the RSA would also need to know for insurance purposes.

Community based nursing involves driving between sites. Which commuting cover usually doesn’t include.

softpilllow · 29/11/2022 09:54

vivainsomnia · 29/11/2022 09:49

Well in my sons case his disabilities are such that he won't ever have the cognitive ability to drive ,so will.still need a named driver
Well of course, but again, this should be for their own transport needs. Ultimately, whilst OP will be working, her DS wont be able to be transported in their car would they wish to.

If they have little need for transport, wouldn't they then benefit more from having the money rather than the car?

They have every need for their parent, who will be financially supporting them, to be able to work though.

softpilllow · 29/11/2022 09:54

vivainsomnia · 29/11/2022 09:51

You're obviously aware that many disabled adults can't legally drive? What would be the point of having 2 cars and one sitting not used often because the disabled person doesn't really go out? The OP working does benefit her son
Indeed, it would be pointless, so would make more sense for the disabled adult to get the cash rather than the car and pay for their transport, be it mum, dad, a carer or a taxi. This seems better use of their entitlement.

Oh stop acting like the bloody benefit police. You clearly have no fucking idea and are merely bitter because someone has use of a motability car. How sad for you.

Zebedee55 · 29/11/2022 09:53

"Do I have to be in the car when it is being used?
The car must be used by, or for the benefit of, the disabled person.

This does not mean that the disabled person needs to be in the car for every journey.

In practice, this means that other named drivers in the same household can use the car for shopping, visiting family and other routine activities, so long as the disabled customer will benefit.

Don't forget that only drivers listed under the permitted drivers section of your Certificate of Motor Insurance are covered to drive your Motability car."

www.motability.co.uk/contact/faqs/do-i-have-to-be-in-the-car-when-it-is-being-used

vivainsomnia · 29/11/2022 09:51

You're obviously aware that many disabled adults can't legally drive? What would be the point of having 2 cars and one sitting not used often because the disabled person doesn't really go out? The OP working does benefit her son
Indeed, it would be pointless, so would make more sense for the disabled adult to get the cash rather than the car and pay for their transport, be it mum, dad, a carer or a taxi. This seems better use of their entitlement.

vivainsomnia · 29/11/2022 09:49

Well in my sons case his disabilities are such that he won't ever have the cognitive ability to drive ,so will.still need a named driver
Well of course, but again, this should be for their own transport needs. Ultimately, whilst OP will be working, her DS wont be able to be transported in their car would they wish to.

If they have little need for transport, wouldn't they then benefit more from having the money rather than the car?

TigerRag · 29/11/2022 09:44

vivainsomnia · 29/11/2022 09:31

Surely it applies the sane, disability or not. If your adult child bought a new car, would you just use it for yourself to go to work?

I totally get using as a family car when the child is indeed a child but once they are an adult and the claim is for them, why is it still ok? It's their car for their use. Saying that it benefits them seems more a case of stretching the truth to suit the convenience.

You're obviously aware that many disabled adults can't legally drive? What would be the point of having 2 cars and one sitting not used often because the disabled person doesn't really go out? The OP working does benefit her son.

Punxsutawney · 29/11/2022 09:42

Sidge, the policy in our LA is a bit strange. They charge about £500 for young people who are 16 and 17 in post 16 education. But once the young person reaches 18, there is no charge at all for those with EHCPs requiring transport. At the start of the academic year we waited for the invoice as we knew parents of a 17 year old that had paid. But it never arrived, so checked the policy and it didn't mention any charges at all for those over 18.

softpilllow · 29/11/2022 09:35

vivainsomnia · 29/11/2022 09:31

Surely it applies the sane, disability or not. If your adult child bought a new car, would you just use it for yourself to go to work?

I totally get using as a family car when the child is indeed a child but once they are an adult and the claim is for them, why is it still ok? It's their car for their use. Saying that it benefits them seems more a case of stretching the truth to suit the convenience.

Have you any idea that disabled children grow into disabled adults!

x2boys · 29/11/2022 09:34

vivainsomnia · 29/11/2022 09:31

Surely it applies the sane, disability or not. If your adult child bought a new car, would you just use it for yourself to go to work?

I totally get using as a family car when the child is indeed a child but once they are an adult and the claim is for them, why is it still ok? It's their car for their use. Saying that it benefits them seems more a case of stretching the truth to suit the convenience.

Well in my sons case his disabilities are such that he won't ever have the cognitive ability to drive ,so will.still need a named driver

x2boys · 29/11/2022 09:31

vivainsomnia · 29/11/2022 09:20

Funny how all posters think it's absolute fine yet 56% of voters says you are being unreasonable!

Probably because those commenting ,most will have experience with mobility care and those that think the Op is being unreasonable,will have deceided in their head what they think the rules SHOULD be ?

vivainsomnia · 29/11/2022 09:31

Surely it applies the sane, disability or not. If your adult child bought a new car, would you just use it for yourself to go to work?

I totally get using as a family car when the child is indeed a child but once they are an adult and the claim is for them, why is it still ok? It's their car for their use. Saying that it benefits them seems more a case of stretching the truth to suit the convenience.

POTC · 29/11/2022 09:28

Those saying yes haven't read the part where you say you're community based. The motability insurance won't cover business use and you won't be just commuting to a single place of work so I highly doubt you'd be insured.

Sidge · 29/11/2022 09:28

@Thatsnotmycar thanks I’ll check it out! There have been lots of issues with transport over the years, she finishes college in July so I’m not sure I’ve got the energy to challenge it now lol.

But I will find their policy.

softpilllow · 29/11/2022 09:26

caringcarer · 29/11/2022 09:00

Motability say the disabled person must be in the car or you are doing an errand for their benefit example they give on their literature you are collecting food for disabled person. I don't think you using it for work if your son is not in car would be allowed. You could hire one for yourself from your salary. Most people expect to have to get themselves to work. I also have a foster son with PIP but only use his car if he is in vehicle. I keep an old one for my personal use so as not in to break rules and I could not risk him losing it.

I think of you have a/nother/spare car it is an absolute waste of money having a mobility car too. (Unless adaptations are needed) Obviously different in the case of foster care but most of people have mentioned the possibility of OP having another car as well.

Thatsnotmycar · 29/11/2022 09:25

Sidge · 29/11/2022 09:21

@Punxsutawney thats really good, ours is subsidised so we make a means tested contribution. It’s still hundreds of pounds but admittedly a better deal than trying to do it myself. She’s now at college an hour away so 4 hours a day in the car for me is not remotely possible!

It is worth getting a copy of your LA’s post 16 transport policy and then checking with SENTAS whether it is lawful. Many LAs have unlawful post 16 transport policies and are charging when they shouldn’t or are charging too much (or refusing to provide transport completely).

Swipe left for the next trending thread