Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

14 yo DS wants to play Grand Theft Auto- I've said no

55 replies

MrsJThornton · 28/11/2022 18:34

He tells me all of his mates have it (I know a lot of them do so it's not a fib) I said I wasn't keen but I'd have a read up about it. Common Sense Media rates it as an 18+ and this seems justified based on the content it states it has. Just wondering if I'm in the minority saying no? He has instagram but it's linked to my account and uses Snapchat/TikTok etc. so I'm probably being hypocritical as I know he has access to more grown up stuff on those apps anyway, but he's very open about talking to me about anything he's seen which he thinks is inappropriate or doesn't understand.

OP posts:
Dinnerdate1 · 28/11/2022 19:51

We all played it when it first came out. My brothers have grown up fine as have I. Think we was probably younger when it came out. Not saying it's right but it's never made us want to run over sex workers or shoot random drug dealers. It's just a game for the most.

Keyansier · 28/11/2022 19:43

I know somebody who refuses to let their kids play GTA in part because of the violence but happily buys them the God of War games because they're more 'educational' Shock

BewareTheBeardedDragon · 28/11/2022 19:41

I never understand on these threads why some people are seemingly so invested in kids being allowed to play this game and it being totally fine.

If you are not comfortable with it and/or don't think your kid could handle it then go with your instincts and stick with no. That is the decision I have personally made, based on my own moral code and my knowledge of my child.

For me, yes I know he will be/prob already has been exposed to stuff I don't agree with because we live in a world where the online sphere is impossible to control and other kids show people stuff, but I don't want my children to see me accepting things that I find morally repugnant. For me, that is part of teaching them and arming them with another viewpoint so that whenever they inevitably do run up against such stuff they have that viewpoint in their awareness.

I've explained to my ds why I disagree with some of the content of the game, and why I will not have it played in my house even when he is 18. He may not agree but at least he understands that this content is not just 'ok'.

Kindofcrunchy · 28/11/2022 19:38

OP I've played the recent gta games (4 & 5) since I was that age and the only part I'd be concerned about is the sexual content. But that in itself isnt that bad, nowhere near as explicit as porn or even a TV show like Game of Thrones. I also didn't turn out to be a hooligan. :D

itsgettingweird · 28/11/2022 19:34

My da was playing it at 14.

He got a job in software development at 17!

He loves computers and is great in them and can manage them for gaming and being sensible.

And in this day and age refusing a game that's reasonable for a teen is the same as refusing them to hang out at the park - it's socially excluding.

CruCru · 28/11/2022 19:29

I enjoy playing on computer games and have played both GTA IV and GTA V (must admit that I haven’t finished GTA V - it’s a massive game and I got busy doing other things).

I think of computer games as a new art form. Some are utterly beautiful and are some children’s only exposure to orchestral music (the games have their own soundtrack playing throughout).

I would hesitate before letting a 14 year old play on the GTA games - they often become very dark without a lot of warning. However, obviously only you can know how mature your child is.

Keyansier · 28/11/2022 19:28

TulipCat · 28/11/2022 19:25

ODFOD, it's nothing to do with my parenting. It's a violent, grim game that I don't want in my house. I don't want my teenage boys presented with the "option" to murder a prostitute. They can play one of the multitude of other games that don't have this vile element.

I didn't say it was Hmm If you read my post properly, I said if you have a problem with it and if your sons did it then it would have been 100% their decision. They are moot points because they rely on if you bought the game. So no, I wasn't criticising your parenting actually.

TulipCat · 28/11/2022 19:25

Keyansier · 28/11/2022 19:12

Using prostitutes and murdering them in the first person does not form part of the plot, it is a part of the open world element. So if your sons chose to do that and you have such a problem with it, you'd have to look towards your own parenting and the ways you raised them as to why they made that decision.

Or, just accept it's a game like most normal people.

ODFOD, it's nothing to do with my parenting. It's a violent, grim game that I don't want in my house. I don't want my teenage boys presented with the "option" to murder a prostitute. They can play one of the multitude of other games that don't have this vile element.

Keyansier · 28/11/2022 19:24

For balance, here's some of the other activities you can do in the game, purely off the top of my head, there will be loads more:

Yoga lessons
Tennis lessons
Flying lessons
Parachute jumps
Triathlons
Visiting fairgrounds
Being a taxi driver
Being a policeman
Being an ambulance driver
Cleaning up water pollution

Keyansier · 28/11/2022 19:21

tellmewhentheLangshiplandscoz · 28/11/2022 19:16

Jesus Christ that's grim.

I have no intention of playing it or allowing DD to either and I'm not sure doing so and "experiencing " the game would make what previous poster described, not that bad.

Seriously, if you get your kicks actively playing at that I think your a little fucked in the head

If you've never played it you have no room to make statements like that.

The latest instalment is the second biggest selling video game of all time. That's an awful lot of people you're flinging accusations about.

Florenz · 28/11/2022 19:18

I would let him play Grand Theft Auto. The original game, released 25 years ago.

tellmewhentheLangshiplandscoz · 28/11/2022 19:16

BecauseICan22 · 28/11/2022 18:42

Actually, this is the content of the latest game.

A segment in the latest instalment caused controversy for scenes containing player-initiated torture. The mission "By the Book" features graphic depictions of kneecapping, electrocution, dental extraction and waterboarding, and the player is required to perform an act of torture in order to progress in the game.

UK-based charity Freedom from Torture publicly condemned the use of torture scenes in Grand Theft Auto V. The organisation, who works to rehabilitate survivors of torture, joined other human rights charities who were outraged at a torture scene in the game in which the players have to pull teeth and electrocute an unarmed man in order to extract information. The charity's CEO Keith Best stated: “Rockstar North has crossed a line by effectively forcing people to take on the role of a torturer and perform a series of unspeakable acts if they want to achieve success in the game."[95]

The game has also been accused of sexism. The Los Angeles Times considered the game's satirical portrayals of women uncreative, and added that violent and sexist themes hurt the game experience. Edge noted that while "every female in the game exists solely to be sneered, leered or laughed at", it treated its all-male lead characters in a similar vein through their stereotyped tendencies towards violence.

Please don't let him play this.

Jesus Christ that's grim.

I have no intention of playing it or allowing DD to either and I'm not sure doing so and "experiencing " the game would make what previous poster described, not that bad.

Seriously, if you get your kicks actively playing at that I think your a little fucked in the head

Proudofitbabe · 28/11/2022 19:15

Oh i remember GTA, great game. My kids are too young but I remember my brother must have been about 14 playing it with me and is a totally normal, nice, successful person today. But I do get why you're steering clear.

Forever42 · 28/11/2022 19:13

I don't get the argument "they will see worse in the real world". I can happily say that I have gone 45 years without seeing any gratuitous violence, murdering of prostitutes or gun warfare. These are not things that you routinely see.

Keyansier · 28/11/2022 19:12

TulipCat · 28/11/2022 19:08

My sons are not allowed GTA and never will be under my roof. There are so many great games out there, there is absolutely no need to play one where they, in the first person, use prostitutes and then murder them. I am not concerned that they would do this in real life, but that still doesn't mean I want them emulating it in fantasy.

Using prostitutes and murdering them in the first person does not form part of the plot, it is a part of the open world element. So if your sons chose to do that and you have such a problem with it, you'd have to look towards your own parenting and the ways you raised them as to why they made that decision.

Or, just accept it's a game like most normal people.

LatteLady · 28/11/2022 19:11

You may not wish to buy it for him and that is fine, but do not think he will not have seen it or played it. Our Year 6s were asked if they had played GTA... about 25% had their own copy the rest had used their siblings devices or played on their peers devices or at friend's houses. When we discussed this with parents, most of them thought their children had never seen it... and were shocked to see the stats that our adviser shared with them. Although, very interesting how many complained that their children were very aggressive when being asked to leave online games

Rather than just stopping him having a copy, check where he is going for sleepovers, that they do not have a copy. I am afraid that like Pandora's box, this one is already in the wind and travelling.

TulipCat · 28/11/2022 19:08

My sons are not allowed GTA and never will be under my roof. There are so many great games out there, there is absolutely no need to play one where they, in the first person, use prostitutes and then murder them. I am not concerned that they would do this in real life, but that still doesn't mean I want them emulating it in fantasy.

Keyansier · 28/11/2022 19:03

BecauseICan22 · 28/11/2022 18:49

Yes, I can confirm that I don't know any teens that deal with the following in real life:

A segment in the latest instalment caused controversy for scenes containing player-initiated torture. The mission "By the Book" features graphic depictions of kneecapping, electrocution, dental extraction and waterboarding, and the player is required to perform an act of torture in order to progress in the game.

What a gormless mindset along with 'it didn't do me any harm'. I grew up not wearing a seat belt, I didn't die in an accident but thankfully we've evolved as a society and we KNOW different and better now. Age ratings are there for a reason.

But you can't die (in real life) from a computer game. Confused You can from not wearing a seatbelt in real life.

MrsJThornton · 28/11/2022 18:50

Thanks all, I'm going to stick with "No" I appreciate everyone has different ideas about this sort of thing but really appreciate people taking the time to respond. I'm going to go with my gut feeling and I've told him the answer and he understands so all good. Thanks again

OP posts:
BecauseICan22 · 28/11/2022 18:49

Yes, I can confirm that I don't know any teens that deal with the following in real life:

A segment in the latest instalment caused controversy for scenes containing player-initiated torture. The mission "By the Book" features graphic depictions of kneecapping, electrocution, dental extraction and waterboarding, and the player is required to perform an act of torture in order to progress in the game.

What a gormless mindset along with 'it didn't do me any harm'. I grew up not wearing a seat belt, I didn't die in an accident but thankfully we've evolved as a society and we KNOW different and better now. Age ratings are there for a reason.

SusanBland · 28/11/2022 18:48

Genuine question, what do you think will happen to him if he does play the game?

Keyansier · 28/11/2022 18:46

Lottsbiffandsmudge · 28/11/2022 18:44

I don't understand the mentality ' they will see worse in the real world'
The real world isn't a game. Awful shit happens to real people. I am not clear why treating such stuff as a 'game' is 'OK'.. at any age really.

Er...I think that is the point. The real world isn't a game. They will see worse in the real world. GTA is a game. It is pixels and fiction.

In case you need it pointing out, actors don't actually die for real in horror films either.

Lottsbiffandsmudge · 28/11/2022 18:44

I don't understand the mentality ' they will see worse in the real world'
The real world isn't a game. Awful shit happens to real people. I am not clear why treating such stuff as a 'game' is 'OK'.. at any age really.

BecauseICan22 · 28/11/2022 18:42

Actually, this is the content of the latest game.

A segment in the latest instalment caused controversy for scenes containing player-initiated torture. The mission "By the Book" features graphic depictions of kneecapping, electrocution, dental extraction and waterboarding, and the player is required to perform an act of torture in order to progress in the game.

UK-based charity Freedom from Torture publicly condemned the use of torture scenes in Grand Theft Auto V. The organisation, who works to rehabilitate survivors of torture, joined other human rights charities who were outraged at a torture scene in the game in which the players have to pull teeth and electrocute an unarmed man in order to extract information. The charity's CEO Keith Best stated: “Rockstar North has crossed a line by effectively forcing people to take on the role of a torturer and perform a series of unspeakable acts if they want to achieve success in the game."[95]

The game has also been accused of sexism. The Los Angeles Times considered the game's satirical portrayals of women uncreative, and added that violent and sexist themes hurt the game experience. Edge noted that while "every female in the game exists solely to be sneered, leered or laughed at", it treated its all-male lead characters in a similar vein through their stereotyped tendencies towards violence.

Please don't let him play this.

Beneficialchampion2 · 28/11/2022 18:42

I'm sure he's exposed to much worse in the real world.

I would let him play it if he were mine, I played it from the age of 13, I turned out fine. No criminal convictions or desires to murder prostitutes.

Maybe have an adult conversation with him and gauge it based on his maturity.