Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Woman flying along with newborn in the front

209 replies

Ithastobeacbeebiesday · 28/11/2022 16:18

Can’t get this out of my head.
Yesterday, Dh, Dd and I were on the motorway and a woman joining onto our lane on the left, nearly crashed into us. She didn’t slow down or stop, so Dh had to slow right down, she came flying past and we saw she was talking/arguing? On her phone, gesticulating madly and that there was a buggy in the back and baby in a baby seat in the passenger seat.
We were in such shock at first at the way she was driving and thought she’d crash into us, then saw, she was on the phone, then the baby. It was one of those tiny smart cars, so no seats in the back, is this legal?
Dh was beeping loudly at her and said after that he wanted to follow her (we had to turn off)
Not sure regarding laws (we’re in another country) but surely this isn’t legal, cannot get over how she could drive like that with a baby in the car, such a strange sight to see.

OP posts:
saffy2 · 30/11/2022 11:15

When you are taught to drive you are taught to always let people merge on a motorway, by whatever means necessary moving lanes or adjusting your speed so that the car merging can accelerate to the safe speed needed to merge with the motorway. That’s what is taught. because that’s how it is supposed to happen. The onus is on the people already going dangerously high speeds to allow others to join, not for a car joining to stop. That would cause an accident and would be severely stupid and dangerous. Which is why, when you learn to drive you are taught to ensure that doesn’t happen.

Shade17 · 30/11/2022 10:15

mam0918 · 30/11/2022 09:40

The warning marker lines are to ADJUST speed to relative to the traffic there not to STOP... if theres a traffic jam crawling they obviously cant fly out at 60mph but in full free flow its still other cars job to move, you can't join a flowing 50-70mph road from a stand still.

Theres also a blind spot looking back at an angle and no where else to move when joining from a slip road while OP DH has full visual and another lane.

Do you not understand basic physics?

If you can’t join you must stop. It shouldn’t happen on a free flowing motorway unless you’re a terrible driver who can’t match your speed to a suitable gap and I’ve never seen it happen but the fact remains, you WILL give way to traffic that’s already in lane one.

mam0918 · 30/11/2022 09:40

Shade17 · 30/11/2022 09:05

You couldn’t be more wrong. You stated that the person going up the slip road has priority - they don’t! The lines at the top of the slip road mean give way. You must stop there if you can’t join. There is no responsibility on the part of drivers in lane one to to move over or take any kind of action. It is common courtesy of course to be mindful of people joining and to make it easier for them and on the whole I think most drivers do that.

The warning marker lines are to ADJUST speed to relative to the traffic there not to STOP... if theres a traffic jam crawling they obviously cant fly out at 60mph but in full free flow its still other cars job to move, you can't join a flowing 50-70mph road from a stand still.

Theres also a blind spot looking back at an angle and no where else to move when joining from a slip road while OP DH has full visual and another lane.

Do you not understand basic physics?

PeterRabbitHadACarrot · 30/11/2022 09:31

He wanted to follow her? That really jumped out.
What the fuck?
Your husband sounds disturbed.

Shade17 · 30/11/2022 09:05

saffy2 · 30/11/2022 08:01

And are you suggesting that’s not how it works in the uk?!?! 😂 when have you ever seen someone at a standstill while on the slip road to join a motorway 🙈 you haven’t, because the other road users on the motorway know how to drive and allow the joiners to merge safely. If they don’t, they are in the wrong and would be the ones to have caused a crash, not the merger.

You couldn’t be more wrong. You stated that the person going up the slip road has priority - they don’t! The lines at the top of the slip road mean give way. You must stop there if you can’t join. There is no responsibility on the part of drivers in lane one to to move over or take any kind of action. It is common courtesy of course to be mindful of people joining and to make it easier for them and on the whole I think most drivers do that.

saffy2 · 30/11/2022 08:01

saffy2 · 30/11/2022 07:59

I hadn’t seen it was in Portugal before responding so I’m talking about UK. However, it being in Portugal doesn’t change my answer, physically you can’t join 70mph traffic from a standstill. That is dangerous. Common courtesy and common driving etiquette (in every country I have driven in) would mean that the driver driving at 70mph already would adjust, or move over to allow those approaching to merge. That IS just basic driving knowledge. Wherever you’re driving. It’s common knowledge that joining a motorway driving 70mph starting from a standstill will cause a crash, because people will be approaching you at 70mph and you would be going at 10mph…it’s just physics that that is not safe. At all.

And are you suggesting that’s not how it works in the uk?!?! 😂 when have you ever seen someone at a standstill while on the slip road to join a motorway 🙈 you haven’t, because the other road users on the motorway know how to drive and allow the joiners to merge safely. If they don’t, they are in the wrong and would be the ones to have caused a crash, not the merger.

saffy2 · 30/11/2022 07:59

Shade17 · 29/11/2022 19:33

This. She has right of way here, she can’t stop while trying to join a motorway, because then she’s trying to join 70mph traffic from a standstill. In that scenario it’s your husbands responsibility to move over the another lane and let her in or adjust his speed so she doesn’t have to slow down but can speed up in fact to join the motorway at 70mph. That’s basic driving knowledge I thought!!

Are you suggesting that’s the case in Portugal or you think that’s how it works in the UK?

I hadn’t seen it was in Portugal before responding so I’m talking about UK. However, it being in Portugal doesn’t change my answer, physically you can’t join 70mph traffic from a standstill. That is dangerous. Common courtesy and common driving etiquette (in every country I have driven in) would mean that the driver driving at 70mph already would adjust, or move over to allow those approaching to merge. That IS just basic driving knowledge. Wherever you’re driving. It’s common knowledge that joining a motorway driving 70mph starting from a standstill will cause a crash, because people will be approaching you at 70mph and you would be going at 10mph…it’s just physics that that is not safe. At all.

Merryweather80 · 30/11/2022 05:46

You’re so contradictory in the details.

Have a cuppa and try to put it from you mind.

ellyeth · 29/11/2022 23:02

On the face of it, that sounds crazy.

Is there a possibility, though, that she was trying to deal with some sort of emergency situation? That doesn't, of course, justify her dangerous driving, especially with a baby in the car, but perhaps it does explain why she was driving so badly.

Your husband beeping couldn't have helped the situation.

Shade17 · 29/11/2022 20:38

SofiaSoFar · 29/11/2022 20:31

Yes Yes Yes - you do treat a slip road as a give way!

The vehicles on the carriageway have priority and you must give way to them. If you can't merge you have to stop.

Have you passed your test?

This!

SofiaSoFar · 29/11/2022 20:31

HeraldicBlazoning · 28/11/2022 17:00

No No No - you do not treat a slip road to a motorway as a give way! Do you have a driving licence?

Yes Yes Yes - you do treat a slip road as a give way!

The vehicles on the carriageway have priority and you must give way to them. If you can't merge you have to stop.

Have you passed your test?

SirGawain · 29/11/2022 20:13

Onnabugeisha · 28/11/2022 16:21

Yes some countries you

  • can drive and use your mobile phone
  • put the baby in car seat in the front passenger seat so long as you have disabled the airbag.

The fact that it’s legal doesn’t make it sensible or an excuse for bad driving.

supersop60 · 29/11/2022 19:38

Fluffygreenslippers · 28/11/2022 16:22

Man, don’t go to india. I was shocked by the amount of women I saw holding babies in the back of cars, no car seat whatsoever.

I've seen that in the UK too. How do they not get caught?

Shade17 · 29/11/2022 19:33

This. She has right of way here, she can’t stop while trying to join a motorway, because then she’s trying to join 70mph traffic from a standstill. In that scenario it’s your husbands responsibility to move over the another lane and let her in or adjust his speed so she doesn’t have to slow down but can speed up in fact to join the motorway at 70mph. That’s basic driving knowledge I thought!!

Are you suggesting that’s the case in Portugal or you think that’s how it works in the UK?

nannykatherine · 29/11/2022 19:33

Oh dear you are one of those 🙄

Changechangychange · 29/11/2022 19:20

Ithastobeacbeebiesday · 28/11/2022 16:24

@Fluffygreenslippers I know, I’ve been, worst place and Morocco, I mean there are worst places and I’ve seen worse…maybe because I was younger then and without a child, she really was driving so fast like a mad person

Maybe her husband or mother is dying and she is racing to the hospital? Or maybe she’s a shit driver. Either way, the baby in the front seat is neither here nor there.

mam0918 · 29/11/2022 19:07

nannykatherine · 29/11/2022 19:01

As the OP has pointed out the rules in Portugal are different re merging
and it is only a Two lane motorway ….

2 lanes one too move over into, you cant merge from a stop onto a fast moving road in any country... physics doesn't change and the result crash would be equally as fatal in portugal as the UK.

OP has been wrong about litrally every single thing from carseats to road/car speed to other countries laws on phones... she is wrong about this too.

Milliejay · 29/11/2022 19:05

Hi, first pregnancy and dealing with bad anxiety over trying to conceive for so long but I was wondering if some of you supermoms could answer a few questions for me? Is it normal for the sensitivity in your boobs to go away and how long does cramping last? Thank you so much ☺️

nannykatherine · 29/11/2022 19:01

mam0918 · 29/11/2022 18:40

She wasnt driving erratically though... OPs husband doesnt know the rules (and common sense) of the road and was in the wrong lane.

HE flew through the merge point instead of moving over when she had right of way. His belief that she should have stopped is completely wrong and dangeous, you merge at the speed of the road and cars on the road move over to allow it.

As the OP has pointed out the rules in Portugal are different re merging
and it is only a Two lane motorway ….

celticprincess · 29/11/2022 18:48

Driving dangerously isn’t good. Having a rear facing car seat in the front is perfectly safe. I always had mine in the front so I could see them - reflux meant I often needed to stop!! In the uk using a phone is illegal and can lose you your lisence and is dangerous.

mam0918 · 29/11/2022 18:40

nannykatherine · 29/11/2022 17:59

I’m amazed that nearly everyone is not concerned that she was driving in such a distracted manner that she nearly crashed into you
!!!!
the point is not that she had a baby in the back
or if the country allows mobile phone
use
but that she was not driving with due care and attention
and could have caused an accident !!!
it says a lot about your lots driving and lack of concern for others if you think this is fine !!!!!!

She wasnt driving erratically though... OPs husband doesnt know the rules (and common sense) of the road and was in the wrong lane.

HE flew through the merge point instead of moving over when she had right of way. His belief that she should have stopped is completely wrong and dangeous, you merge at the speed of the road and cars on the road move over to allow it.

saffy2 · 29/11/2022 18:24

I’ve just seen the update with the speed 🤦🏽‍♀️ so not ‘flying’ or speeding out of control as op has described at all then 😂 just slightly over the generally accepted speed limit.

saffy2 · 29/11/2022 18:15

Onnabugeisha · 28/11/2022 16:26

Yesterday, Dh, Dd and I were on the motorway and a woman joining onto our lane on the left, nearly crashed into us. She didn’t slow down or stop

Some countries and regions of countries you can’t go up an on ramp and stop, you’re also told don’t slow down. It’s an acceleration lane to get up to speed. The traffic already on the motorway are supposed to adjust their speed or move ove a lane in order to let you merge on.

This. She has right of way here, she can’t stop while trying to join a motorway, because then she’s trying to join 70mph traffic from a standstill. In that scenario it’s your husbands responsibility to move over the another lane and let her in or adjust his speed so she doesn’t have to slow down but can speed up in fact to join the motorway at 70mph. That’s basic driving knowledge I thought!! So I’m really shocked that she ended up in a position where she didn’t have safe access to merge tbh.
yes it’s illegal to use a phone while driving and yes it’s illegal it’s speed.
its perfectly fine and safe (in fact sometimes the safest place in the car) to have a child in the front rear facing with the air bag off. I’m really surprised again that people don’t know that.
your husband didn’t behave appropriately afterwards either. He was in the wrong within all aspects of your interaction with her. She should not have been on the phone and should have been within the speed limit, but did nothing wrong at all during your interaction with her.
im questioning whether your husband should be driving to be honest, he could have caused a severe accident here by his lack of basic driving knowledge.

nannykatherine · 29/11/2022 17:59

I’m amazed that nearly everyone is not concerned that she was driving in such a distracted manner that she nearly crashed into you
!!!!
the point is not that she had a baby in the back
or if the country allows mobile phone
use
but that she was not driving with due care and attention
and could have caused an accident !!!
it says a lot about your lots driving and lack of concern for others if you think this is fine !!!!!!

Rosie22xx · 29/11/2022 17:53

The issue is with her unsafe driving, especially having a child in the car, she should be even more vigilant than normal. And also for others in the comments, a horn is used to make another driver aware that you're there and of a dangerous situation.